Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to just let DD go to school with earrings in.

306 replies

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:29

School starts tomorrow and DD is saying that she will go to school her earrings in (not allowed). Now i dont agree that earrings shouldnt be allowed however they are the school rules. Ive said to her health and safety but she says that 1) my earrings are small and screw on- there is no chance of them falling off or getting caught on something. Tbh shes right- shes worn these earring from nursery right through primary school and there has never been an issue. 2) if its health and safety concerns why are the teachers wearing earrings. Shes right on this to- in events and parents evenings ive seen the teachers wear earrings/jewellery. Shes gotten phone calls home about this and got shouted at by the school but she says to me ' its a bit hard to take them seriously about the danger of earrings when they have like 5 earrings as well'. I cant get hett up about her wearing the earrings to school. Shes doing amazing in all other areas of school so far and this seems like a pointless rule
AIBU?

OP posts:
PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 10:22

Forgot to add she removes them for pe

OP posts:
MissingNashville · 04/09/2022 10:22

It’s the schools rule, if you don’t like it, send her to another school.

It’s all very well saying let the school deal with it, but so much time is wasted on this sort of thing. A teacher may only spend a minute in conversation with your daughter about this, but multiply that with however many other kids they have to talk to about earrings or the wrong shoes or other incorrect uniform and that time soon adds up. It’s really fucking annoying for teachers who have to enforce the rules and for kids that just want to learn. Tell her to grow the fuck up and abide by the rules. It’s your job as parent, stop wasting the schools time. She really doesn’t need her ears to ‘look pretty’ for school, and the excuse of the deceased grandmother, I’ve heard it all now....the teachers eyes will just be rolling back in heir heads so far if she uses that one. Ridiculous.

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 10:21

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 04/09/2022 10:15

If they are her lucky earrings & have such a sentimental meaning attached to them, surely the best thing to do would be to take them out & keep them at home where they would be safe?

Her teachers have far bigger issues (especially around the cost of living crisis) to try & help their students navigate & support this term than one student who is stamping their feet about a pair of ruddy earrings. She’ll just be asked to remove them (risking her then losing them), or be sanctioned with other penalties. Detentions, demerits, whatever her school chose to use. They won’t give a fig if they’re lucky, sentimental, or we’re personally given to her by The Pope. It doesn’t matter.

It’s a school rule, no matter how absurd, she has to suck it up. She can wear them before school, after, at the weekends. But not in school. If she wants to change the rules, join the school council.

I wore a subtle helix piercing stud as a teacher, but then I wasn’t likely to fiddle with it, lose it, take it in & out depending on if I was going into PE, science or whatever, and wouldn’t pitch a shit fit if the backing fell off which then disrupts the bloody lesson.

Trust me, ive explained this all to her. Shes agreed that if teachers tell her to take it out, she will take it out with no argument and will accept any punishments. To PPs saying that i should take them out, i cannot do that unless I actually rip them out, shes 15

OP posts:
MenopauseSucks · 04/09/2022 10:21

Where I went to school, the rules were that it was plain studs only, one piercing per ear & they should be removed for PE.
If the pupil refused to remove them for PE then it was not the school's responsibility if something happened...

neverbeenskiing · 04/09/2022 10:18

Ok, I don't know what went wrong with the formatting on my post but you get my point!

neverbeenskiing · 04/09/2022 10:18

if its health and safety concerns why are the teachers wearing earrings

This is a daft argument. Teachers and other school staff generally do not

-Take part in PE

  • Take part in extra-curricular sport
  • Do Dance or Drama which can also be very physical
  • Need adult help if they get their hair tangled around an earring, lose an earring, or their earrings gets caught on something resulting in injury.
-Fight with each other (play fighting or actual fighting, which can happen on occasion) -Get their parents to call up and complain if they lose something valuable like jewellery at school
  • Wear a uniform and therefore have to comply with the school uniform policy

If your DD can't accept that rules are different for children than they are for adult staff members then secondary school is going to be tough for her, and for you. I wouldn't be getting into protracted negotiations about this to be honest.

bellac11 · 04/09/2022 10:17

Goldenbear · 04/09/2022 10:03

Some rules are irrational though and the school needs to listen and respond accordingly to the world we live in. At my DS's secondary school they have been having issues getting those who wear the school tartan skirt to keep it a the regulatory length - children just fold it at the top, ironically the tartan skirt was brought in to avoid this issue as the school skirt used to be any black one from high street shops. A teacher was pulling mainly girls aside and measuring it from the knees to where it fell and would give a detention if it was more than 3cm. There was outcry from parents about this and children with brightly coloured dyed hair being put in detention etc. So they did a parent survey and consulted with mental health professionals as many parents were arguing it was affecting there child's mental health which was particularly bad after the damage done to teenagers during the pandemic. As a result of these steps and listening to the parents loads of the rules have changed so any colour hair is allowed, shoes with logos on are allowed if they are black, earrings were always allowed but you can have another stud on the same ear or in your nose and the skirt is going to come in three different lengths.

Ive already said that these rules are petty and shouldnt really be in place but please please, 'mental health'?

Its affecting a child's mental health to be told not to dye their hair or have the wrong length skirt? Please do not undermine the seriousness of genuine mental health disorders with muddling up 'being pissed off that miss told me off' to depression, anxiety or psychosis.

Honestly is this where we've got to with trying to take seriously and recognise illness, its now turning into a parody.

And as an aside in respect to the rest of the thread, Im wondering where the narrative came from that if an adult isnt or is doing something, that is relevant to what a child is allowed to do

Adults are grown ups, they do have different rules and allowances, because,,,, erm, thats what it means to be an adult.

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 04/09/2022 10:15

If they are her lucky earrings & have such a sentimental meaning attached to them, surely the best thing to do would be to take them out & keep them at home where they would be safe?

Her teachers have far bigger issues (especially around the cost of living crisis) to try & help their students navigate & support this term than one student who is stamping their feet about a pair of ruddy earrings. She’ll just be asked to remove them (risking her then losing them), or be sanctioned with other penalties. Detentions, demerits, whatever her school chose to use. They won’t give a fig if they’re lucky, sentimental, or we’re personally given to her by The Pope. It doesn’t matter.

It’s a school rule, no matter how absurd, she has to suck it up. She can wear them before school, after, at the weekends. But not in school. If she wants to change the rules, join the school council.

I wore a subtle helix piercing stud as a teacher, but then I wasn’t likely to fiddle with it, lose it, take it in & out depending on if I was going into PE, science or whatever, and wouldn’t pitch a shit fit if the backing fell off which then disrupts the bloody lesson.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 04/09/2022 10:15

bellac11 · 04/09/2022 09:47

Are they just plain gold studs, I thought screw on earrings were quite a modern thing I didnt realise that they had been around when her grandmother would have worn them, which Im assuming is many years ago but perhaps not

I dont really like uniform rules but equally if you dont like the rules of a certain school then change school, or home educate. You signed up to accepting the school rules when you signed her up at the school so you have to accept it

She said they were given from her Grandmother, not that they were Grandmother's .

RiftGibbon · 04/09/2022 10:15

Comtesse · 04/09/2022 09:40

I hate petty rules like this. I’m kind of with your daughter.

Me too.
If it is genuine H&S, for example, no earrings to be worn for PE, then I can accept that.
Likewise, no dangly earrings, because they could get caught on clothing, etc.
No earrings at all = rules for the sake of rules.

I'm the sort of arsey person that would absolutely challenge these petty rules and ask exactly what purpose they serve.

I also agree about teachers. If the pupils they instructors can't have earrings/dyed hair, then neither should teaching staff. They may be older and more responsible but of earrings and dyed hair are distracting, then they are putting the focus on the teacher and not their teaching, surely? 😁

Georgeandzippyzoo · 04/09/2022 10:14

She is y10. It's her battle to do. You have warned her of the consequences and it's now her decision to accept the consequences. Obviously if she keeps pushing the consequences could be more and, if repeatedly breaks it , could lead to detentions/exclusions.
My son wears trainers at school. I send him out in appropriate shoes and he swaps them on the way to school. He does have other issues but uniform brings him detentions etc, hes totally not bothered, and as long as it stays at school then I don't bring anything at home. If he gets excluded then we also have a home consequence.

Personally I do generally agree with those who've posted that if you don't like a rule send them elsewhere but you don't have that issue.

Teachers and pupils don't have the same rules . Does your child get the same rules as the adult at home? Generally not. It's the same for school. However when I was teaching we did have to tell a student teacher 5 pairs of creole earrings was a safety issue incase a child grabbed them (primary) so rules are sometimes applied.

For those saying it's a stupid rule, many secondary schools do allow a pair of studs, however when I was at school (y9) a couple of friends were being daft (not being rough) and one had her stud earring caught and pulled down through her lobe. The level of blood was scary! she needed some form of 'surgery' to fix it.

iwishiwasafish · 04/09/2022 10:13

In an ideal world teachers wouldn’t be at breaking point, and so children should be able to make a stand against pointless bureaucracy and engage in debate.

Unfortunately, in the real world, teachers are understandably far beyond breaking point, are leaving the profession in droves, and a great number of them are personally suffering with huge amounts of stress.

It doesn’t feel fair to add to that strain for something so trivial.

VioletCharlotte · 04/09/2022 10:10

It's not worth arguing with teenagers over things like this. Let the school tell her to take them out if they have a problem with them. Are these just studs? No earrings seems like a bit of a pointless rule, what's wrong with studs? My opinion is that if schools make silly rules then they have to police them. At my DS school they introduced a rule saying hair counts be shorter than a grade 3 - ridiculous!

MsSquiz · 04/09/2022 10:09

Does she realise that if she's made to take them out and she loses them, there's nothing she can do about it?
School wont be responsible because she shouldn't have been wearing them in the first place and she'll have lost something seemingly so special to her due to her stubbornness

JanePrentiss · 04/09/2022 10:09

YellowTreeHouse · 04/09/2022 10:03

It IS up to you. You’re the parent. You’re the adult.

If you want her to take them out you tell her that and she does so.

This. All this thread reads is someone who daren'"t tell their dc to take their earrings out and handing the hassle over to school. As though schools don't have enough problems (genuine concerns and shit they don't need like this) to deal with...

PantyMcPantFace · 04/09/2022 10:07

W0tnow · 04/09/2022 09:31

Take them out. Honestly teachers do not need to be dealing with this. Just take them out. If you don’t like the school rules, send her somewhere else.

This is the only response needed.

Teachers do not do PE.
Students do.

OstrichFeet · 04/09/2022 10:07

Christ , as if schools haven’t got enough on their plate
you are the parent , bloody parent her however hard that is
consequences can happen at home too

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 04/09/2022 10:05

At Y10 I'd let her do what she wants and face the consequences.

DS's school is similarly strictly on jewellery, hair, uniform, shoes.... he was considering not getting his haircut before the start of term, because he liked how long and curly it had got. My approach was "fine, but you know the rules and the consequences". He went to the barbers yesterday afternoon.

luxxlisbon · 04/09/2022 10:04

You sound like a nightmare parent to be honest.

raindon · 04/09/2022 10:04

YellowTreeHouse · 04/09/2022 10:03

It IS up to you. You’re the parent. You’re the adult.

If you want her to take them out you tell her that and she does so.

What's she going to do if she says no? Rip them out?

raindon · 04/09/2022 10:03

maddiemookins16mum · 04/09/2022 10:01

I get what she’s saying tbf. However, if she chooses to disobey the rules, let her face the consequences. But please don’t go running to the local paper with sad faces (there will be a few of those in APILN this week no doubt).

Oh I forgot about those. Sad face why can't my child wear Nike Airs

YellowTreeHouse · 04/09/2022 10:03

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 09:45

Honestly if it were up to me the earrings would be out. However i think its good for her to learn the consequences of her actions and will be backing school if she gets in trouble

It IS up to you. You’re the parent. You’re the adult.

If you want her to take them out you tell her that and she does so.

Goldenbear · 04/09/2022 10:03

Some rules are irrational though and the school needs to listen and respond accordingly to the world we live in. At my DS's secondary school they have been having issues getting those who wear the school tartan skirt to keep it a the regulatory length - children just fold it at the top, ironically the tartan skirt was brought in to avoid this issue as the school skirt used to be any black one from high street shops. A teacher was pulling mainly girls aside and measuring it from the knees to where it fell and would give a detention if it was more than 3cm. There was outcry from parents about this and children with brightly coloured dyed hair being put in detention etc. So they did a parent survey and consulted with mental health professionals as many parents were arguing it was affecting there child's mental health which was particularly bad after the damage done to teenagers during the pandemic. As a result of these steps and listening to the parents loads of the rules have changed so any colour hair is allowed, shoes with logos on are allowed if they are black, earrings were always allowed but you can have another stud on the same ear or in your nose and the skirt is going to come in three different lengths.

raindon · 04/09/2022 10:02

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 10:02

Ive decided she can face the consequences as shes being extremely stubborn. I shall be backing the school. I really dont want them to get lost but given shes very careful and hasnt gotten them lost in 8+ years i dont think very will. Problem is that she will likely not get into trouble as she will hide them with her hair or she will get told to take them out- they dont even ensure that she does!

If she loses them she loses them. That's her choice.

PinkChaires · 04/09/2022 10:02

Ive decided she can face the consequences as shes being extremely stubborn. I shall be backing the school. I really dont want them to get lost but given shes very careful and hasnt gotten them lost in 8+ years i dont think very will. Problem is that she will likely not get into trouble as she will hide them with her hair or she will get told to take them out- they dont even ensure that she does!

OP posts: