Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest cyclists need to be licensed

242 replies

savethebeesandthecees · 04/09/2022 08:59

And also pay Road Tax and risk having their licence revoked for misuse.

I'm saying this as a pedestrian. Nearly hit again by a cyclist going through a red light. Others routinely mount the pavement to swerve red lights. I'm sick of it. If I film them as evidence, so what? What are the consequences?

Something needs to change.

OP posts:
Lockheart · 04/09/2022 09:51

No.

It would be too costly and difficult to administer for very little benefit.

Cyclists are not hazardous on the level that drivers are. There is a good reason that drivers need to have a licence and insurance before being permitted to take a vehicle onto a public highway.

OneTC · 04/09/2022 09:48

Research suggests that most crime overall is committed by people with feet.

I think people with feet should be identifiable at all times because it's only a matter of time before one of these befeeted mobile crime hotspots strikes again

TooBored1 · 04/09/2022 09:47

Let's get all the unlicensed drivers off the road first. They're the ones that cause the most injuries and deaths.

Lerouge · 04/09/2022 09:46

pointythings · 04/09/2022 09:36

It won't help. Far better to focus on investing in proper cycling infrastructure of the kind that exists in the Netherlands, that would improve safety for everyone and make cycling a realistic commuting option for many more people.

This, 100%. We already have rules in place that mean cyclists shouldn't run red lights etc. What would help is the rules actually being enforced.

Also, I see someone has mentioned the idea of cyclists having licence plates. How would these be effective? They would have to be pretty small to fit on a bike, so small you wouldn't actually be able to read it from any distance, so pointless.

WeeMadArthur1 · 04/09/2022 09:43

My 'exactly this' was supposed to be quoting @ThrallsWife post not agreeing with the OP but my quote didn't work!

OneTC · 04/09/2022 09:43

An idea so stupid that nowhere in the world has actually done it seriously, despite people moaning about bikes since their invention

Lemonyfuckit · 04/09/2022 09:42

TorviShieldMaiden · 04/09/2022 09:34

As a cyclist I was once almost seriously injured after a pedestrian stepped out in front of me. I was completely in the right, doing 20mph (ish) in a 30, and she just stepped off kerb in front of me. Luckily I had noticed her and started to prepare for swerving.

There are bad drivers, bad cyclists and bad pedestrians. Those need dealing with. A license won’t help, otherwise we wouldn’t have as many car accidents as we do.

Yes for all the pedestrians who complain on forums about the 'multiple' times they've nearly been hit by a cyclist (and I don't doubt there are bad cyclists, I know many jump lights, and I also know there are many many terrible drivers out there), there are also many terrible pedestrians who cause or nearly cause injury to cyclists too, who walk along, often on their phones not looking where they're going and just step into the road (not at a pedestrian crossing) without looking. Oblivious to the fact that in that scenario, a car might have to break very suddenly, it might manage to stop in time or it might not, and if it doesn't the pedestrian will be the one injured. If it's a cyclist however who has to break very suddenly in that scenario, the careless pedestrian may or may not be hit but the cyclist will almost certainly go over their handlebars and be very hurt.

WeeMadArthur1 · 04/09/2022 09:42

Exactly this. The current infrastructure isn't built for cyclists in this country, and with people starting to use electric bikes, electric scooters, etc there really needs to be proper planning so everyone can use roads and pavements together safely. We should be encouraging people to travel more sustainably and cheaply.

I'm a driver, cyclist and pedestrian, depending on where I'm traveling to, and cycling is by far the most difficult as cycle lanes just randomly stop, or you end up cycling in the gutter in potholes, etc. I do get annoyed about cyclists on pavements though. I think with the exception of younger children, if you aren't confident to cycle on the road you shouldn't really be cycling.

Lunar270 · 04/09/2022 09:40

And what about mobility scooters? The amount of times I've nearly been run over.

OneTC · 04/09/2022 09:38

It's an idea entirely without merit

Lunar270 · 04/09/2022 09:38

Skateboarders are gutter rats the lot of them. They're the ones who need a massive number plate on the back.

Then we need speed cameras in the pavement so we can catch the fuckers.

Tomikka · 04/09/2022 09:37

Getoff · 04/09/2022 09:23

I'm sure that in the last month or so I read that the law has been (or is being) changed so cyclists can receive much more severe sentences for injuring people.

Not the same thing as identifying them, but it seems government is on the case.

I think there was also an article quoting at least one government minister suggesting cyclists should have number plates.

You did read that recently.
But it was without substance by Grant Shapps

He suggested a number plates, tax, insurance - which have been previously considered and ruled out by the transport ministry

He also suggested new legislation with larger sentences / fines - but failed to point out that legislation already exists and therefore if he wanted greater sentences / fines then he should put that to parliament to increase the maximums

He also stated that cyclists should not be able to ‘get away with breaking laws that don’t apply to them’
If the law does not apply them they aren’t breaking the law.

This directly related to speed limits. A standard road speed limit does not apply to cyclists, but every council in the UK has the power to enable and enforce cyclist speed limits

Grant Shapps was getting his name out in the media with meaningless statements

pointythings · 04/09/2022 09:36

It won't help. Far better to focus on investing in proper cycling infrastructure of the kind that exists in the Netherlands, that would improve safety for everyone and make cycling a realistic commuting option for many more people.

Glittertwins · 04/09/2022 09:35

Goatinthegarden · 04/09/2022 09:08

I’m a cyclist and I agree that cyclists should have to follow rules of the road and be held accountable if they don’t.

I don’t agree that they should pay additional taxes to use the roads, although I do have insurance to cover me if I injure someone or cause damage to their vehicle/property.

This and also I agree with the French method where everyone has personal indemnity insurance.
We have two cars so already pay two lots of VED. The vast majority of cyclists are vehicle owners as well.

Lemonyfuckit · 04/09/2022 09:34

ThrallsWife · 04/09/2022 09:29

My biggest issue with this would be how this affects children. Learning to cycle is such a useful skill and many older children rely on their bikes to get to and from school. Would you have them wait until they are 17, like car drivers?

I would rather campaign to change the system.

British roads are not built for cyclists. Look at continental Europe, where cycling in general is far more common, but cyclists have their own path alongside roads, so they don't continuously risk their lives due to impatient drivers.
It also gets them out of the way and makes waiting at a traffic light far less dangerous (which contributes to the number of cyclists who change to pedestrian paths at traffic lights).
Cycle paths here are strange - I have seen them change lane from the pedestrian to the cycle side all of a sudden through bad road marking, I have seen them suddenly end after a few meters and most of the time they simply don't exist.

Where I am from, all children learn basic traffic rules in primary school - who has right of way, what traffic signs mean etc. and then take an exam similar to the car theory and practical test where they gain a "cycle licence". It's not a legal document and they'll never be asked to present it, but it does make them far safer on the roads. So why not throw out something less useful from the primary curriculum and look at road and cycle safety instead? It would help so many down the line with driving, too.

I would, however, make helmets and visible clothing mandatory, as well as what bikes themselves have as standard. Bikes sold over here are extrenely poor quality compared with continental Europe; they are almost just frames and everthing that should be standard - lights (why are they battery operated and not dynamo operated?), a stand, splash guards appear to be optional extras. And why do British bikes only have a hand brake, which is far more unreliable and dangerous to use than a back tread brake?

Compulsory licences are not the way forward, but much can be done to improve conditions for cyclists and make them safer to start with.

Completely agree.

TorviShieldMaiden · 04/09/2022 09:34

As a cyclist I was once almost seriously injured after a pedestrian stepped out in front of me. I was completely in the right, doing 20mph (ish) in a 30, and she just stepped off kerb in front of me. Luckily I had noticed her and started to prepare for swerving.

There are bad drivers, bad cyclists and bad pedestrians. Those need dealing with. A license won’t help, otherwise we wouldn’t have as many car accidents as we do.

lljkk · 04/09/2022 09:33

Cyclists were licensed in California in the 1980s. I know this because twice I got stopped for some other infringement and didn't have one, so went and got a license (was about $3 from a fire station). Does anyone think this legal requirement made cyclists more law-abiding in CA in the '80s?

If you're wanting cyclists to be insured (& qualified?) then presumably you want the same for all, no exclusions, even if it's a 5 year old riding with stabilisers on the pavement, and same for horseriders, and even pedestrians. What about electric scooters (the fast 2 wheel ones or the mobility ones): shouldn't their users be licensed & insured? To use any public bridleways or pavements, right?

Just now when it makes so much sense to put money into the administration to make these things happen. Great idea. #sarcasm

KosherDill · 04/09/2022 09:33

They should have to be licensed and carry insurance.

SirChenjins · 04/09/2022 09:32

I agree OP - something has to change. Of course having a licence won’t stop bad cycling but having some kind of insurance and ID would make it easier to trace the kind of cyclist you’re talking about and hold them to account. I doubt it will happen though - pedestrians are at the bottom of the pile, it seems.

Lemonyfuckit · 04/09/2022 09:32

@Tomikka when you say taxing cyclists though, what do you mean? (Licensing point aside). As we've established, vehicles pay tax according to emissions, so electric cars and cyclists don't pay VED. Cyclists being people who presumably live somewhere will pay council tax amongst any other taxes so they contribute to maintenance of the roads in exactly the same way that other road users do. What other tax would you have cyclists pay?

Ifailed · 04/09/2022 09:31

The authorities can't even manage to control motorists at the moment ( more than 600,000 unlicensed drivers on the road, 1 million uninsured, over 700,000 with unpaid VED), I'd rather they got that sorted out first.

Lunar270 · 04/09/2022 09:31

🤦 not this crap again.

OP, do some reading 🙄

MsTSwift · 04/09/2022 09:31

Here we go 🙄

watcherintherye · 04/09/2022 09:30

savethebeesandthecees · 04/09/2022 09:12

Oh I thought car/lorry drivers paid Road tax? I don't drive but was sure they did. Confused

All vehicle owners have to tax their vehicles or they can’t drive them on the road. Maybe that’s what you mean? If you Google ‘road tax’ you will be guided to the govt. website section dealing with taxing your vehicle. The posters picking you up on this are being deliberately obtuse.

mondaytosunday · 04/09/2022 09:30

Are you saying kids too?
How will having a license help?
How would you enforce this?
The government wants more people on bikes, not less (you know, pollution, traffic, physical health...)
Cyclists are already supposed to follow the Highway Code but many don't. If the police can't enforce that how will they be able to do as you suggest?
How much money do you think setting up a system would cost? Far more than any revenue.