Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest cyclists need to be licensed

242 replies

savethebeesandthecees · 04/09/2022 08:59

And also pay Road Tax and risk having their licence revoked for misuse.

I'm saying this as a pedestrian. Nearly hit again by a cyclist going through a red light. Others routinely mount the pavement to swerve red lights. I'm sick of it. If I film them as evidence, so what? What are the consequences?

Something needs to change.

OP posts:
Towcester · 04/09/2022 21:12

ivykaty44 · 04/09/2022 21:07

Don't forget cars parked in them. Is that legal btw? Genuine question

it depends

if it’s a painted line and dashed - yes it’s legal to park in cycle lane

if solid white line then it’s not legal

Thanks!

ivykaty44 · 04/09/2022 21:10

How are the police going to trace a bike from video? That's the point, at least identification on them would help there.

whenever, and it’s rare so usually makes media attention, a pedestrian has been killed - cyclists have been identified if they left scean

MaybeThisIsntForYou · 04/09/2022 21:09

In the last month (yes, month!) I've had two vehicles hit, while parked, by licence holding, insured and taxed car drivers.

One car was a write off and has now been scrapped, thankfully the other just seems to be a minor paintwork scuff.

Both were legally parked midway down the street in a marked bay, in broad daylight, on 20mph residential roads.

A month before that I very nearly had a lorry driver drive up my rear on the motorway - he came within about a metre of the back of my vehicle, blaring his horn and doing an emergency stop. Broad daylight, and an unusually conspicuous vehicle. Terrifying.

Weirdly insurance, tax and licences didn't stop any of the above.

We regulate things in proportion to the capacity they have for causing damage to others. The capacity that cyclists have for causing damage is very, very low in comparison to those who drive one-two tonne lumps of metal around at 70mph. It's also invariably the cyclist who gets hurt first when they screw up, unlike when drivers screw up.

ivykaty44 · 04/09/2022 21:07

Don't forget cars parked in them. Is that legal btw? Genuine question

it depends

if it’s a painted line and dashed - yes it’s legal to park in cycle lane

if solid white line then it’s not legal

Towcester · 04/09/2022 21:04

DdraigGoch · 04/09/2022 20:57

When anyone whinges about cyclists not using a cycle path, I ask for a Google Maps link to the location. Inevitably the cycle lane is really poorly designed; stops every 100yds to give way to a side road; is difficult to access without stopping, dismounting, crossing and restarting; doesn't actually go where you need to go; is shared with kamikaze pedestrians (usually without so much as the solid white line which just gets ignored anyway)...

Don't forget cars parked in them. Is that legal btw? Genuine question

DdraigGoch · 04/09/2022 20:57

When anyone whinges about cyclists not using a cycle path, I ask for a Google Maps link to the location. Inevitably the cycle lane is really poorly designed; stops every 100yds to give way to a side road; is difficult to access without stopping, dismounting, crossing and restarting; doesn't actually go where you need to go; is shared with kamikaze pedestrians (usually without so much as the solid white line which just gets ignored anyway)...

LimboLass · 04/09/2022 20:53

Cycle paths are generally mixed with pedestrians, have roadside furniture such as signposts & trees, let alone lack of maintenance etc

I have been cycling 9 years and cannot recall more than a handful of cycle paths being suitable for a road bike even at low speeds. They are usually full of cracks or lumps from tree roots meaning that riding on anything with 70+ psi tyres is too uncomfortable to bare!

LaurelGrove · 04/09/2022 20:51

This line of thinking is so depressing.

All it does is put people off cycling.

We need way more people cycling, with much better infrastructure. It's better for health, the environment and safety. A tiny number of people are injured by cyclists each year and yes of course cyclists shouldn't ride on pavements, ignore red lights and hit pedestrians. But I cycle every day and usually have at least one near miss with a car. The last time I nearly hit a pedestrian was when one decided to step in front of a stationary bus at a bus stop into traffic while looking at his phone.

And of course we shouldn't pay vehicle tax - we don't emit any pollutants. That's a stupid idea. I'm actually supportive of voluntary insurance. But I pay taxes via plenty of other routes and I promise you it isn't my bike wearing out the infrastructure.

I speak as an urban cyclist. I can only see good outcomes from increasing urban cycling. Perhaps I would feel differently if I lived in narrow country roads.

There is interesting research on drivers seeing cyclists as "other", and which makes them drive more aggressively. It's one of the reasons I wear normal clothes while cycling. That plus trying to show people that you don't need to wrap yourself in lycra to get on a bike.

theemmadilemma · 04/09/2022 20:47

GeekyThings · 04/09/2022 09:07

No such thing as road tax. Also going through a red light incurs a fine, whether you're cycling or driving a car, so filming them and giving it to the police can get them fined.

I also don't drive, the main problem isn't cyclists, it's car drivers.

How are the police going to trace a bike from video? That's the point, at least identification on them would help there.

Tomikka · 04/09/2022 20:43

BishyBarnyBee · 04/09/2022 17:12

But I think there is a very targeted campaign from the tabloids at the moment which is whipping up anti cycling feeling. I don't see anything like that aimed at drivers. There was a video showing a cyclist riding on the road next to an empty cycle lane and headlines about how outrageous it was. That's one example of inconsiderate cycling - and not actually illegal. When will we see the videos of car drivers cutting up cyclists with the same level of tabloid indignation?

What type of cycle, what speed were they cycling and what type of cycle path was it?

Cycle paths are generally mixed with pedestrians, have roadside furniture such as signposts & trees, let alone lack of maintenance etc

It is also recommended that cyclists riding at at 18mph should not be on cycle paths

webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/+/www.dft.gov.uk/consultations/archive/2004/ltnwc/annexdcodeofconductnoticefor1688

ivykaty44 · 04/09/2022 20:40

@OneTC North Korea, and when this comes up I think do we really want to follow there lead? Is that what people want to emulate?

LimboLass · 04/09/2022 20:37

As a pedestrian, cyclist and car user I think all cyclist should need insurance. However cars will always cause a lot more damage than a bike and I honestly think all car users need to spend at least a few miles cycling on British roads at they might develop a bit more empathy and understanding for cyclists. Then they might start to realise the dangers that we face daily be that cars cutting us up, potholes the size of moon crates, smashed glass and accident debris that we need to avoid, pedestrians stepping out into the road without looking because they assume no noise = safe to cross and much more!

Alexandra2001 · 04/09/2022 20:37

Whiskeypowers · 04/09/2022 20:31

I don’t disagree it doesn’t stop Road deaths caused by cars
but if a cyclist causes an accident that results in life changing injuries for someone then why should they not be held to account?

in any event because there’s an opportunity to raid the public’s coffers yet again this “government” will do something I’ll conceived and far too hasty

If a cyclist does cause such injuries, then likely as not they will also crash and then be held to account.

BUT we need to look at where the danger to us & our children all lies and it is with car drivers,
So driving, for most people is the most dangerous thing they will ever do, 10s of 1000s of people end up with severe injuries as a result of road collisions with cars... not bicycles.

I'd like to see a far harder driving test, such as in most of europe and 10 year retests

Whiskeypowers · 04/09/2022 20:31

Alexandra2001 · 04/09/2022 20:28

there should be far more regulation

Whether you think cyclists should be taxed, licensed or insured or not, the evidence is, in regard to cars, it doesn't stop 1800 people on average, being killed by cars every year or around 1m uninsured car drivers on the roads.

With increasing obesity rates, very bad air quality, poor public health and a cost of living crisis, i'd have thought we need to encourage more cycling and walking... but apparently the Govt should rid the roads of cyclists, because thats what theses sorts of measures would do..

However, i would like cyclists to be encouraged to be insured, if only for their own good when run of the road by some crazed car driver.

Schapps should look at a study done by his own department just a few months ago, which showed licencing etc is unworkable before attempting to appease the angary 'Mail Boomer lot.

I don’t disagree it doesn’t stop Road deaths caused by cars
but if a cyclist causes an accident that results in life changing injuries for someone then why should they not be held to account?

in any event because there’s an opportunity to raid the public’s coffers yet again this “government” will do something I’ll conceived and far too hasty

Tessasanderson · 04/09/2022 20:31

I find this debate so amusing.

Ever increasing obesity issues
Ever increasing traffic issues
Ever increasing pollution issues
Ever increasing cost of living crisis

Wow, let’s pick on one of the greenest, low cost, healthy modes of transport. Unbelievable.

I have just come back from a city break in Madrid. The place was full of bikes, electric bikes, electric scooters. You name it, they used it to get around. Roads flowed, air was clean and people smiled.

Just as a matter of interest are we going to target youths too? Kids who use bikes to have a social life. Get to school, maybe even their first job. Possibly quite a proportion of Mumsnet members DC who don’t drive their kids everywhere.

shocking

Alexandra2001 · 04/09/2022 20:28

there should be far more regulation

Whether you think cyclists should be taxed, licensed or insured or not, the evidence is, in regard to cars, it doesn't stop 1800 people on average, being killed by cars every year or around 1m uninsured car drivers on the roads.

With increasing obesity rates, very bad air quality, poor public health and a cost of living crisis, i'd have thought we need to encourage more cycling and walking... but apparently the Govt should rid the roads of cyclists, because thats what theses sorts of measures would do..

However, i would like cyclists to be encouraged to be insured, if only for their own good when run of the road by some crazed car driver.

Schapps should look at a study done by his own department just a few months ago, which showed licencing etc is unworkable before attempting to appease the angary 'Mail Boomer lot.

Lonelycrab · 04/09/2022 20:27

As a cyclist, i would like to see the following rules implemented: 1. All bike helmets should be white or fluorescent yellow or green . 2. All bike shoes should be fluorescent yellow or green. 3. All bikes should have fluorescent features (wheels or tyres or frames) as a matter of course. 4. Max size of a group of cyclist should be 4. No two groups should be closer than 4 car lengths apart. 5. In towns/cities it should be illegal for a cyclist or motorcyclist or moped to pass stationery cars on the left unless there is a dedicated cycle lane on the road. It should also be illegal for motorists to move to the left to stop cyclists doing this

As a cyclist I ask you who’s going to enforce this, the green cross code man?
Remind me what the conviction rate for burglary is again.

chilliesandspices · 04/09/2022 20:26

Oh and my DH is a road cyclist who occasionally goes out training and does charity rides twice a year. When I asked him about third party insurance after we met, he honestly had no idea it existed. He'd been cycling on the road for 10 years at that point and had only ever insured his bike for theft. It never occurred to him that he could cause an accident because it's normally all about what a danger cars are to cyclists, never the other way round.

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 04/09/2022 20:25

Angelinflipflops · 04/09/2022 20:21

How exactly?

Please don't be wilfully ignorant

Angelinflipflops · 04/09/2022 20:22

Nobetter, I wasn't trying to be witty, you genuinely seem angry, swearing at strangers on the Internet and all that

chilliesandspices · 04/09/2022 20:21

I think they should at the very least be insured. I worked on a personal injury case where a negligent cyclist crashed into another cyclist on a pedestrian crossing. He heard the beeping and rushed onto the road despite bushes blocking his view. The other cyclist was left with a fractured pelvis, two broken legs, a dislocated shoulder and broken ribs. He was our client and was devastated by what happened but it didn't help the woman he hit. He lost his house paying damages but it barely scratched the surface of what that woman needed to live the rest of her life.

Angelinflipflops · 04/09/2022 20:21

How exactly?

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 04/09/2022 20:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/09/2022 20:20

Having a licence won’t stop bad cyclists

Very true but at least you'd know their identity, instead of watching the idiot who just ran into you disappear in the knowledge nobody would ever catch them

I also agree with the need for proper insurance (but not that they need to be taxed)

And FWIW I'm a cyclist too

Whiskeypowers · 04/09/2022 20:15

There exists an opportunity to make
money/ revenue and make something more expensive.
it’s just a question of time and for once I don’t think that’s a bad thing .
I know people who’ve been knocked down at crossing by cyclists when they were pregnant. I know people who’ve been knocked down by cyclists who stopped to see if they’d see on and had clearly been drinking. If they’d been in a car the consequences would rightly haven been severe.
why should they not be for cyclists? Is it because it’s environmentally friendly? Then what about drivers of electric vehicles ?

on a regular basis I see cyclists running red lights mounting pavements ad hoc at considerable speed. Of the they have headphones in so their awareness is compromised. Many of the bikes are powerful and high performance and would kill an elderly or very young / small pedestrian if they hit them at speed.

there should be far more regulation