Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still live my best life even though I’m fat

403 replies

Whatyagonnadokatie · 03/09/2022 22:26

Many mnetters hate fat people. They dress it up as concern for health. But I think it’s something deeper than that. Something about us letting ourselves lose self discipline or something. Some people even seem to think that we shouldn’t have nice clothes (let me tell you, no one purposely gains weight to wear some lovely plus size clothes).

reading some threads on here break my heart when women dread going to social events because they are fat.

aibu to say, fuck that, get on with your life and be happy even if you are fat. Wear the nice clothes, go to all the social events. And hey, eat the biscuit if you really want to

OP posts:
ButtOutBobsMum · 05/09/2022 06:58

stopitleaveitgetdown · 04/09/2022 00:21

I'm trying to love myself at 105kg (the biggest I have ever been) but then someone takes a picture or I see a Facebook memory of me from 5 years ago and feel absolutely horrible about how I look now.
I'm in awe of anyone who can truly love themselves how they are so if you can then enjoy yourself love.

Snap. I've gained a lot of weight due to health issues over the last couple of years. I don't let it stop me doing anything. I still go out with friends, went on holiday and wore a bikini etc. But I see photos of myself and I cringe. I HATE how I look and have to constantly resist the temptation to hide away. I'm very envious of those who are happy with themselves regardless of size!

Maverickess · 05/09/2022 02:07

When personal responsibility, choices and lifestyle are talked about, around being overweight, it's like there's no outside factors affecting these things at all, like the only priority should be to not being fat, and anything else is an excuse.
There's lifestyle's that aren't necessarily of someone's choosing that make it harder to be as healthy as you otherwise would be without that lifestyle - shift working and especially night shifts are known to increase risk factors for things like diabetes, cancer and obesity ( www.webmd.com/sleep-disorders/features/shift-work) - I didn't choose shift work because I thought I quite fancied a bit of that, I did it initially through necessity around other factors in my life and no, I didn't pay that much attention to my health because my priority was keeping a roof over our heads and keeping all the plates spinning. I ate the wrong things, went hours with nothing to eat and often to drink because of the demands of the job and ended up eating quick and easy convenience food that is shit for you because sleeping to go back and do it all again the next day was my priority.
I put weight on steadily over about 10 years of permanent nights, which are the shittiest end of the shift working stick, I didn't have the energy nor will to address the issues quite frankly. The weight is coming off, slowly now I no longer work nights, everything is better, I eat better, I am more hydrated, I exercise more, my mental health is much better.
Everyone wants hospitals, care homes and the like staffed 24/7 but will then be scathing and tell you all about your excuses when you try to talk about stuff like this.
Is it impossible to do? No, it's not but if you have other, more pressing priorities in your life going on, self care drops further and further down the list.
I talked about this a couple of years ago and the responses (likely from people who had only ever worked Mon to Fri, 9-5) were bitchy, sarcastic, and downright nasty.
I'm not saying they're the absolute reason for me being overweight, but as the changes that I have experienced since changing one thing, working through the night, it was definitely a contributing factor.

Jourdain11 · 05/09/2022 00:00

Whatyagonnadokatie · 04/09/2022 21:41

Jeeze, you sound bitter.
many of my friends are really slim (well, what would have been “normal sized”back in the day). I don’t spend time hating them.

I'm not talking about hating, I'm talking about constant comments and getting accused of gloating if you ever dare to say something like "I couldn't find any jeans that fit properly at the shopping centre this week".

TeapotTitties · 04/09/2022 23:01

I was recently diagnosed with a very underactive thyroid but I'm not overweight because I make sure I eat sensibly and remain active.

I'm going on an all inclusive holiday soon and I'll eat and drink whatever I want, and then if I gain weight I'll just be more sensible for a few weeks when I get home.

Having an underactive thyroid does not mean you'll inevitably become overweight and I wouldn't want anyone reading this thread, having had a recent diagnosis, to think that's the case.

KimberleyClark · 04/09/2022 22:53

I have had an underactive thyroid for years and the medication stabilises it but it is still hard to actually lose weight on it.

Same here. Medication eases the symptoms but it doesn’t cure the condition. The thyroid still doesn’t behave normally with regard to regulating metabolism.

Whatyagonnadokatie · 04/09/2022 21:41

hittheroadjackk · 04/09/2022 20:54

@Jourdain11

Totally agree. Fat people are so quick to call out and shame skinnier people.

But are so victimy when it comes to them when they're only 'living their best life!'

Well, no.. you're living your life heading into much higher risks of cancers, strokes and heart attacks and whatever else. If that's living your best life then fine. But don't push your insecurities onto slimmer people!

Jeeze, you sound bitter.
many of my friends are really slim (well, what would have been “normal sized”back in the day). I don’t spend time hating them.

OP posts:
Violinist64 · 04/09/2022 21:35

Wouldloveanother · 04/09/2022 11:39

I genuinely cannot reconcile how few people in, for instance, the 1920s there were compared to now, given they presumably had similarish levels of thyroid problems/MH issues etc?

I would imagine a lot of people that had thyroid problems 100 years ago might well have died from them. Not everyone was thin then, whatever people might believe - my great-grandmother was a case in point judging by the photos. The point is that weight problems are massively misunderstood and doctors only have a very small amount of time devoted to them during their training which, with the knowledge we have of the conditions that are exacerbated by obesity, is not a very good state of affairs. It really is not as simple as the eat less, move more mantra we have been patronisingly told all this time. There are many reasons for putting on weight, including emotional eating. I have had an underactive thyroid for years and the medication stabilises it but it is still hard to actually lose weight on it. I also have another medical condition, lipodoema, a hormonal condition which affects around 10% of the female population and a few men. It starts in the legs and can progress to most parts of the body in unlucky people (l am one of these) and the parts of the body that are affected cannot be reduced by diet or exercise. I am most around a size 14. Many ladies that have this condition are far larger. We will never have a normal BMI but surely nobody would begrudge us the chance to look and feel the best we can. The same goes for overweight people in general, whatever the reasons behind being larger than they would perhaps like.

hittheroadjackk · 04/09/2022 20:54

@Jourdain11

Totally agree. Fat people are so quick to call out and shame skinnier people.

But are so victimy when it comes to them when they're only 'living their best life!'

Well, no.. you're living your life heading into much higher risks of cancers, strokes and heart attacks and whatever else. If that's living your best life then fine. But don't push your insecurities onto slimmer people!

Paq · 04/09/2022 20:35

@Carpy88999 people only have so much capacity to take in information. And UPF companies are excellent at putting out biased research, e.g. www.bmj.com/content/371/bmj.m4601

^One common corporate scientific activity is to fund nutrition studies designed to generate favourable scientific evidence for a company’s products.2 These studies have an inherent financial conflict of interest. Systematic evaluations of industry funded nutrition studies have—perhaps not surprisingly— found a funding bias effect, whereby study findings are more likely to favour the interests of their industry sponsors.2
However, food corporations are also able to influence nutrition research through the types of nutrition studies they choose not to fund, producing what we might call “not funding” bias. Manufacturers of ultra-processed foods have had little interest in funding research that measures the detrimental effects of their products, and this may partly explain the neglect of such research over the past 50 years.^

Carpy88999 · 04/09/2022 19:41

Paq · 04/09/2022 16:04

As a global population we are all getting fatter. You can either conclude that humans are getting stupider, more weak willed and morally degenerate as a species or you can think that maybe something else is going on. I.e. increased refined sugars and UPFs, increased sedentary lifestyles, relentless marketing by processed food companies who push their addictive products on unsuspecting people (Frosties as "part of a healthy breakfast" really, Kellogg?).

It's not surprising people get fat, it is surprising that people deny that their lifestyle is irrelevant to their fatness.

If anyone thinks frosties are a healthy breakfast they can't be helped.

Goatinthegarden · 04/09/2022 19:19

30 years old, not 30 BMI

Goatinthegarden · 04/09/2022 19:18

MsTSwift · 04/09/2022 18:14

Same goat. Only when I properly educated myself did I realise why I was two stone overweight. Exercise needs to be full on pretty much every day not 20 mins 3 times a week. I only eat two meals a day now and on small plates. Eat about half of what I used to and I’m still not super slim but am in my healthy bmi and just about a size 10.

Silly question, but were you aware that you were overweight?

I was about two stone and a half stone over my healthy BMI at 30 and because so many people around me were also overweight, I didn’t actually realise it was that bad. I was a slim teenager and my weight just slowly crept up through my twenties. I knew I wanted to be a ‘bit thinner’ but was horrified to find I wasn’t healthy. It’s only now I’ve lost close to three and a half stone that I can see how big I was. I’m still not super slim, but I can see huge progress.

It’s not just cosmetic, I feel so much better, more energetic, strong and capable. I know people don’t like to hear it, I don’t want to fat shame, but I just want others to feel how I feel. I didn’t realise how sluggish or tired my extra weight was making me.

Jourdain11 · 04/09/2022 19:00

hittheroadjackk · 04/09/2022 15:36

I'm just under 9 stone. I eat 3 meals a day and my husband isn't cheating on me with a slim PT at the gym. I'm happy and healthy. Not every slim person rations lettuce leaves.

Do you also think that fat people cry into their box of donuts as their husbands cheat on them with someone who's not fat and a lot more attractive according to society? Probably not. But the fat ones are so quick to project their own feelings on the slim.

Assuming skinny people are unhealthy won't make the fat ones any healthier.

There is absolutely no reason to glamourise being fat. None at all.

I'm just under 7 stone. I eat a pretty regular diet and I exercise a few times a week (usually a 45' evening swim). I'm neither starving myself nor swanning around feeling superior, nor do I look skeletal. I have energy (most of the time) and I sleep well. But it's amazing the number of people who feel entitled to make disparaging remarks, will accuse me of gloating or that I must be anorexic!

PeloDramatic · 04/09/2022 18:39

@Goatinthegarden I manage to hit it. My job means I'm at a desk all day (and I can't get up and walk/wander off) so I really am sat down for 40hrs a week
That doesn't help my weight but I'm fat and still hit the NHS exercise guidelines. I think... spin classes are vigorous I'm guessing and I do 4 of those, 30-60 min classes plus stretching, yoga, barre but it definitely takes effort

MsTSwift · 04/09/2022 18:14

Same goat. Only when I properly educated myself did I realise why I was two stone overweight. Exercise needs to be full on pretty much every day not 20 mins 3 times a week. I only eat two meals a day now and on small plates. Eat about half of what I used to and I’m still not super slim but am in my healthy bmi and just about a size 10.

Doingprettywellthanks · 04/09/2022 18:11

Goatinthegarden · 04/09/2022 17:53

This was me. I genuinely thought I was healthy because I walked everywhere and bounced about at the gym now and again. I genuinely thought I had a good diet because I ate lots of nutritious food, I seemed to casually not notice the other things I was eating.

It’s only now that I have a rigorous daily fitness regime (that has taken time to build up to) that I realise how little energy and fitness I really had before. Very few people hit the NHS guidelines of a MINIMUM of 150 minutes of exercise - 75mins should be moderate intensity and 75mins should be vigorous intensity. A walk rarely counts as moderate.

It’s only now that I have spent time counting calories that I truly understand how much I was overeating and how very easy it is to overeat. I have to restrict what I WANT to eat because it is very far removed from what I NEED to eat. I speak as someone who regularly cycles 100-200km in one go and actively have to consume calories whilst working out.

I’m sure plenty of people have medical conditions that prevent diet and exercise in the way that I’ve described, but there certainly is a large number of people who are ignorant of what our bodies require to stay fit and healthy. The modern lifestyle doesn’t make it easy for us.

Good on you

you were honest with yourself and now completely reaping the benefit

Quincythequince · 04/09/2022 18:11

Goatinthegarden · 04/09/2022 18:01

Interesting that someone said bariatric surgery is the only guarantee to losing weight. I have a friend who has just had this surgery and my understanding is that it just makes it physically impossible for her to eat (she’s eating her ‘meals’ out of baby food Tupperware) so the weight is falling off.

However, because she is not able to get enough nutrition, her hair is falling out and her skin has changed. Surely, not the best solution?

Very common after bariatric surgery. Can also happen after normal dieting too.

It’s to do with the growth phase of hair - it does come back and isn’t that unusual with rapid weight loss.

Bariatric surgery works to help regulate the hormones so it’s success rate is generally good.

The new GLP-1 agonist drugs (Ozempic is one) also work well. They act centrally to reduce hunger.

Same longer term issues with keeping it odd though.

That’s where the hard work really is.

I’ve known people blend up chocolate and cream and drink it - it’s sad. Significant behavioural therapy is needed here too.

Interestingly, data shows that people who have bariatric surgery, replace their focus on food with something else (alcohol, exercise etc) It’s not uncommon at all.

FlimsySteve · 04/09/2022 18:07

It takes perseverance and dedication in today’s environment to keep it off.

It's way more than that - you have to beat your own biology - being obese affects your body at a molecular level and means that your body works harder to stay fat. So even normal healthy dietary changes and 150mins of exercise weekly will not have the same effect as on a non obese person.

Goatinthegarden · 04/09/2022 18:01

Quincythequince · 04/09/2022 17:55

So yes, when a doctor recommends a diet or weight loss programme to an overweight person, they are knowingly recommending something that is very unlikely to work (even if the 95% stat is inflated)

So Clinicians should never suggest a diet is what you’re saying?

That’s it - dont try to help fat people?

Or should they all get gastric sleeves? Because we can afford that can’t we.

Interesting that someone said bariatric surgery is the only guarantee to losing weight. I have a friend who has just had this surgery and my understanding is that it just makes it physically impossible for her to eat (she’s eating her ‘meals’ out of baby food Tupperware) so the weight is falling off.

However, because she is not able to get enough nutrition, her hair is falling out and her skin has changed. Surely, not the best solution?

Quincythequince · 04/09/2022 17:55

So yes, when a doctor recommends a diet or weight loss programme to an overweight person, they are knowingly recommending something that is very unlikely to work (even if the 95% stat is inflated)

So Clinicians should never suggest a diet is what you’re saying?

That’s it - dont try to help fat people?

Or should they all get gastric sleeves? Because we can afford that can’t we.

Goatinthegarden · 04/09/2022 17:53

Doingprettywellthanks · 04/09/2022 15:25

But loads of overweight people on threads always wax lyrical about how very moderate and healthy their diets are “, and they always seem to walk everywhere

But then the ones that have lost weight and kept it off say that when they were obese - they ate shit but denied it to themselves and did measley movement

This was me. I genuinely thought I was healthy because I walked everywhere and bounced about at the gym now and again. I genuinely thought I had a good diet because I ate lots of nutritious food, I seemed to casually not notice the other things I was eating.

It’s only now that I have a rigorous daily fitness regime (that has taken time to build up to) that I realise how little energy and fitness I really had before. Very few people hit the NHS guidelines of a MINIMUM of 150 minutes of exercise - 75mins should be moderate intensity and 75mins should be vigorous intensity. A walk rarely counts as moderate.

It’s only now that I have spent time counting calories that I truly understand how much I was overeating and how very easy it is to overeat. I have to restrict what I WANT to eat because it is very far removed from what I NEED to eat. I speak as someone who regularly cycles 100-200km in one go and actively have to consume calories whilst working out.

I’m sure plenty of people have medical conditions that prevent diet and exercise in the way that I’ve described, but there certainly is a large number of people who are ignorant of what our bodies require to stay fit and healthy. The modern lifestyle doesn’t make it easy for us.

Quincythequince · 04/09/2022 17:48

Fairislefandango · 04/09/2022 17:29

It’s not until 60 that you see metabolic changes that really really start to make it harder (published last year).

It’s hard work keeping weight off, it’s hard work over time being fat and it becomes even harder as we age. It’s a cliche but people need to choose their hard.

But whether it's metabolic changes, psychological issues, upbringing, habit or an obesogenic environment, or a lack of willpower that makes it hard for people to stick to weight loss programmes - the fact is they still fail and will continue to do so, however much people tell them to 'choose their hard'. So yes, when a doctor recommends a diet or weight loss programme to an overweight person, they are knowingly recommending something that is very unlikely to work (even if the 95% stat is inflated).

Implying that the the decision to remain fat (which in fact requires no decision or effort) remotely compares in 'hardness' with having to make the decision every waking hour of every day for the rest of your life to resist eating what you want to eat is very disingenuous, however neat a catchphrase 'choose your hard' might be.

But with the right programme for them (there is no magic bullet, what works for you won’t work for me) - they won’t fail.

That is rather the point.

It takes perseverance and dedication in today’s environment to keep it off.

It is hard - no doubt. But you can do it.

People spend so much time and effort on nails, hair, nice clothes, outings (Inc eating out) mindfulness and ‘loving themselves’

All hugely important. And so is a healthy body.

An Obese or overweight body is by definition, metabolically dysregulated.

Nobody makes you eat what you eat.

For those poor souls who live in food deserts and have no transport, fair enough they have little mobility to make healthy choices and I get that.

But here’s the thing - most of us do.

How many takeaways, ready meals, multi bags crisps, shop bought pizzas etc do people buy for convenience and use far more often than they should?

Loads - the market is booming because we buy it.

Look at this ‘eat well for less’ show on TV. Utter crap being bought - mostly feom
supermarkets too where there risk planet od other Choice.

People also eat Willy nilly now ans never let themselves feel hunger! Ever. This is bad. Being hungry on occasion is not.

I have four kids, and I am very careful with their diets. Takes me ages to prep food and cooks suppers- I hate it sometimes, but I do it because I have to to keep them (and me) healthy.

If that doesn’t motivate you - nothing will.

And the decision to remain fat does require effort, don’t be so disingenuous. How many calories does a female need to eat to maintain a size 24? A lot. That’s a lot of eating of healthy food ( eat less) and less eating of shit (buy better food).

Fairislefandango · 04/09/2022 17:29

It’s not until 60 that you see metabolic changes that really really start to make it harder (published last year).

It’s hard work keeping weight off, it’s hard work over time being fat and it becomes even harder as we age. It’s a cliche but people need to choose their hard.

But whether it's metabolic changes, psychological issues, upbringing, habit or an obesogenic environment, or a lack of willpower that makes it hard for people to stick to weight loss programmes - the fact is they still fail and will continue to do so, however much people tell them to 'choose their hard'. So yes, when a doctor recommends a diet or weight loss programme to an overweight person, they are knowingly recommending something that is very unlikely to work (even if the 95% stat is inflated).

Implying that the the decision to remain fat (which in fact requires no decision or effort) remotely compares in 'hardness' with having to make the decision every waking hour of every day for the rest of your life to resist eating what you want to eat is very disingenuous, however neat a catchphrase 'choose your hard' might be.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 04/09/2022 17:21

VladmirsPoutine · 04/09/2022 08:10

I think people hate fat people being unapologetically happy because of the lies we were sold. Fat women are supposed to be unhappy, miserable, unloved, unkempt and so forth so when people who've hitherto been keeping themselves thin at the price of unhappiness and being strict with everything it seems so worthless when they see that a fat woman can have all the good things and still be fat.

I agree with this very much.

Also, why do so many people need to correct and provide information to others, when it was never asked for? So what if somebody posts that they can't lose weight? What's it to anybody else? They've presumably discussed this in real life, with or without professional advice, and that's the conclusion they've come to. Why launch into a lecture that nobody needs?

People posting what you may believe to be nonsense, on a chatboard is par for the course. Some posts are not nonsensical but, if you don't agree with them, still no need to challenge and correct. It's a waste of time, usually comes across as patronising and really, it's just unnecessary.

My view is that women need to stick together to be a voice louder than those moronic men who call us names when we run, walk, do any bloody thing in public that isn't centreing them. That abuse happens at every size and it's insidious. It affects so many women and it needs to stop.

Heckling what's somebody's said about their weight/body/lifestyle and reasons for it? Not useful.

Doingprettywellthanks · 04/09/2022 17:18

It would be fascinating to know the weight and height of the posters on these threads.

i strongly suspect the reasoning behind certain viewpoints would be very clear!

Swipe left for the next trending thread