Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that you're really lucky if you enjoy exercise?!

194 replies

bumblebee1987 · 03/09/2022 22:06

I will preface this by saying that I'm really fed up because I've been dieting and exercising since March and lost a very minimal amount of weight despite really trying, and have now plateaued for weeks, so this is probably more of a vent 😆

I hate exercise. I always have, every since school, I am rubbish at it, am not remotely competitive, and I just don't enjoy it. I have tried many many different types of exercise, it's all the same, I don't enjoy any of it. I don't enjoy watching sport, hearing about sport or being involved in sport in any way.

I go to the gym 3 times a week because I feel like I have to, because I am overweight and I need to sort myself out, but I hate it. I know I need to do it, but I don't enjoy it, and I think this is really unfortunate. My DH on the other hand, LOVES sport, his entire career is based in sport, he loves nothing more than going for a 5 hour bike ride or spending an hour or two in the gym, it's his happy place. Which is great because obviously it's really good for him!

I keep seeing fitness influencers saying how important it is that you find the sport that you love so that you will keep it up, but I really don't think there is one for me?! So I think I am basically stuck with forcing myself to do something I hate a few times a week, despite hating every second of it.

So am I being unreasonable to suggest that it's actually really lucky if you enjoy sport and exercise?! I am not talking about being good at it, I appreciate that being good at it takes a huge amount of dedication and not luck etc, but if you really enjoy it regardless of whether you're good at it or not, then that's really fortunate, right?!

I appreciate that this is very much a first world problem and is meant in a light-hearted way!

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/09/2022 09:26

@bumblebee1987 I know you mentioned that your thyroid was checked though there has to be some medical reasons for this.
My Dsis has hashimoto's disorder and thyroid issues.
She is on a strict diet and has consistently lost 1 lbs per week since she started.
I think she is aiming for 1500 calories daily, no gym, brisk walking.
Go back to the gp or book a session with a nutritionist if you can afford it.

AquaticSewingMachine · 04/09/2022 09:20

Ps. I really love boxing. I'm tiny and I get a never-ending kick out of being massively underestimated by men who then have to revise their preconceptions right quick when I land a punch on them. There are so many options for exercise and different things to enjoy. And nothing gets your heart rate up like knowing someone will hit you if you don't move your feet!

I also know that exercise has a hugely beneficial effect on mental health, way more than most people think, and that helps me to make sure I get out there.

bumblebee1987 · 04/09/2022 09:20

summerinthebigcity · 04/09/2022 08:55

YANBU, it's great to enjoy physical activity, I used to hate it as a teenager.

Are you drinking alcohol? It has hidden calories, messes with your blood sugar, and can make you have less energy for physical activity. Fruit/ veg can have lots of carbs/ sugars especially when cooked or as a smoothie.
I think 16:8 or even 14:16 or 12:12 is a great way to regulate blood sugar, also to have energy/ motivation to move.

Do you enjoy your diet? Could you do it for the rest of your life? If not, up your calories and include something you really enjoy. It sounds like you are repeating your yo-yo dieting experience.

It sounds like you have some body shame and this stops you liking exercise, e.g. the sweating. I used to be like this as a teenager. In my case just thinking of myself as a healthy person who likes physical activity helped me get there. Fake it to make it.

You say you don't like the way your body hurts after the gym. This seems to be one of these mindset ones. When I took responsibility for my fitness (as opposed to my mum/ school telling me) I started to like this as it meant there was an impact. But it is true it is "pain" and so depends on how you interpret it.

Also, I think having a DH who is very into sport can't necessarily help. I'd hate that. Men respond so much quicker to exercise in terms of fitness AND weight loss. Maybe you are secretly competitive, or feel more body shame in comparison. I think I'd hate having someone very fit next to me. It would reduce the fun I get from exercise, sadly.

I haven't had alcohol since I was at University, which is longer ago than I care to remember 🤣 I haven't touched it since. I don't do anything with fruit other than eat it as it comes, and I try not to eat much because I'm a sucker for grapes and berries so if I don't restrict my intake then before I know it, I've eaten an entire punnet 🤣

I definitely don't enjoy my diet, but I have a weird relationship with food. It's either all or nothing, if that makes sense? I find it really hard to eat in moderation. It's easier for me to stick to really low calories and cut entire foods out, than it is to eat sensibly. So for example, if I eat a biscuit, then I can't stop myself eating half the pack, so it's easier for me to just stop those foods entirely. And I get immense food guilt if I eat outside of what my brain considers safe foods. I know that sounds weird!

I definitely have body shame, I hate how I look, and I hate that I let myself get like this!

Haha, having a fit DH definitely doesn't help 🤣 Although he is lovely and does not care one single bit what I look like or how much exercise I do etc. He doesn't expect me to share his passion! He would love it if I got into cycling and often gently says it would be nice to go for family bike rides, but in reality he knows this can't happen because I can't cycle on roads. (Well, physically I can, but mentally I can't!)

OP posts:
DragonsAndMoons · 04/09/2022 09:17

I only like exercise when I'm already fit. It's a boring hard slog to get fit but once I am fit enough I enjoy it. I then do more active things for fun like a 4hr bike ride or climbing up something like pen y fan. I love walks like pen y fan but only when I'm fit so it's not an effort.

AquaticSewingMachine · 04/09/2022 09:16

I am an exercise junkie. I'm benignly addicted to exercise. I hate not working out - it makes me feel sluggish, anxious and depressed. I wasn't always this way though - I got this way over time by sticking at it whenever it would have been easier to sit on my arse (and there are always times it would be easier to sit on your arse).

I think building movement into your life is important. I love to walk, I don't drive unless I have to. I think finding something that makes you feel good or at least makes it sustainable also helps. A PT, if you can afford it, is a great way to build some structure, see a difference, and make it impossible to punk out. Six months ago I fell madly in love with weight training and it is such a fucking kick to see your body change, to see muscle emerge under the skin and grow. I would hate to stop working out and see those hard-won gains disappear. I use a Fitbit to track my RHR, Vo2 max and you can use a body comp scale to track muscle and body fat percentages; a lot of people find it really motivational to see what you're gaining, especially since as PP is observed you seem kind of stuck in a mindset of punishing your body and yourself and a weight loss focus. What if you were pursuing a positive goal - that even if you didn't lose an ounce, your heart was stronger, your lungs worked better, a bit more of you was muscle than you used to be, and you have achieved a goal you set yourself?

Am I happy every single minute when I'm straining, gasping, sweating, bright red in the face? Nerp. But I know that I will regret quitting, and I'll never regret sticking with it, and if you can stick with it for long enough something magical happens.

stopitstopitnow · 04/09/2022 09:11

I have an inflatable punch bag (which is amazing for getting rid of any stress). I also put some tunes on a dance like no-one's watching. I started doing it in lockdown 1 and have kept at it. Yes, I end up a hot sweaty mess, but I'm at home so there is nobody to stare or judge me. There are better ways IMO opinion to exercise than gyms, bikes, running and all the other stuff that most people seem to do.

5128gap · 04/09/2022 09:11

I don't care for it and the heavier I was the worse I found it. Fortunately it has only minimal impact on my ability to lose weight, which I did through diet. I do try to walk daily, but even briskly and including hills it only uses about 200 calories, which it would be much easier simply not to eat. I make myself walk for the fresh air, weight baring and cardio, and can enjoy it if ive travelled to a nice location and the weather is pleasant. But if I drop it for a while I don't see any weight gain, as I find I'm less hungry without excercise. I probably should try to build some strength in my arms but I really don't have the motivation.

bumblebee1987 · 04/09/2022 09:09

coldcoldheartt · 04/09/2022 09:06

Ahhh OP I feel you I really do! Can't stand gyms. I came on to say try weight lifting but pleased to see you've got that booked for Tuesday. I LOVE it. I never thought I would but honestly it's great. And hopefully it'll shock your body out of its plateau. Good luck and let us know how Tuesday goes!

Thank you! Hoping Tuesday will be the kickstart that I need 😁

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 04/09/2022 09:07

I find it dull - so exercise bike in front of Netflix doing it now 70 mins each morning 500 calories burned watching box sets or listening to audible

Carpy88999 · 04/09/2022 09:06

bumblebee1987 · 04/09/2022 08:50

@Carpy88999 - You're right, it isn't enough, but it is what I have been doing, and I am not lying or miscalculating. I have been tested for medical conditions and the results showed nothing.

My DH has been working in the sports and fitness industry his entire life, and he has spent his career believing the 'eat less, move more' mantra. He sees what I am eating on a daily basis, he knows I am not cheating, and he finds it baffling because it goes against everything he thought he knew.

I've lost a stone and a half since March doing this (with a few weeks off in the middle because we moved house), and have now plateaued and lost nothing for 3 weeks, despite still having 3 stone to lose. 🤷🏻‍♀️

That's why you shouldn't drop your calories to an unmanageable level right from the off. You'll either have to keep going at this low level until your break through the plateau which will happen eventually, have a refeed period where you up your calories for a while then lower them again after. Or just introduce more cardio which I wouldn't recommend while only eating 1200 cals.

coldcoldheartt · 04/09/2022 09:06

Ahhh OP I feel you I really do! Can't stand gyms. I came on to say try weight lifting but pleased to see you've got that booked for Tuesday. I LOVE it. I never thought I would but honestly it's great. And hopefully it'll shock your body out of its plateau. Good luck and let us know how Tuesday goes!

summerinthebigcity · 04/09/2022 09:04

I think you have hit the nail on the head with disassociating it from weight loss!

bumblebee1987 · 04/09/2022 09:01

Sorry, finding it hard to reply to everyone individually!

I do love the idea of doing something a bit more unique. I'm going to look for an adult ballet class for sure. Some of the others, while they sound great, will just feed my anxiety, it's a nightmare 🤣 Open water terrifies me, as does cycling on roads, climbing is a no because I'm scared of heights. Horse riding I used to love, but I got thrown off a horse when I was 21 and ended up in hospital and I haven't got on a horse since because I then became terrified of that too 🤣 Honestly, I'm a walking nightmare! I'm pretty restricted with what I can mentally cope with, which is very frustrating!

Trail running sounds fun so I am going to have a look into that. I might try the c25k, although probably picked the wrong time of year to start it!

I wish I could exercise with DH, he used to be a PT, so he's great for motivation and usually knows what he's talking about, but we have young kids, so usually have to tag team doing exercise so one of us can stay with them.

I think the mindset argument is key here isn't it. I need to change how I view it. Maybe I will never enjoy it, but I CAN and SHOULD do it for my overall health. I just find it really hard to disassociate it with weight loss. I like the machines that tell me how many calories I have burned, because mentally for me, that's what it's mostly about. I know that's ultimately wrong though!

OP posts:
Musti · 04/09/2022 08:56

Hi op. Look at Team RH on Facebook. Basically calculate how many calories you burn a week and average that out and take off 500 calories. So if you burn 2300 cals you should be at a calorie deficit of 1800 to lose weight.

Get 10k steps in and make sure you eat enough protein and fibre and also include fats. There is an ideal ratio.

As long as you’re not sedentary then it doesn’t matter what you do - walking, mowing the lawn, whatever. Some quick weights workouts are really good.

I walk and the last year have been swimming a lot and love it. I have mp3 earphones so that helps. I often go with a friend and sit in the jacuzzi afterwards for a chat.

I also love playing badminton.

I would start with short workouts that are about 15-20 mins. But be consistent.

mountainsunsets · 04/09/2022 08:55

Having read back through your posts I would actually say you need to increase your calories and increase your exercise.

Three sessions at the gym per week isn't really very much if that's all you're doing. I know you feel sad about your dog getting old (I get it, I walk dogs for a living and seeing them struggle is heartbreaking) but could you borrow a dog from a friend or neighbour and take them instead? Or do your potter with your old boy, then stick some headphones in and really go for it for an hour?

How many steps a day are you doing on average (especially on days where you don't go to the gym)?

summerinthebigcity · 04/09/2022 08:55

YANBU, it's great to enjoy physical activity, I used to hate it as a teenager.

Are you drinking alcohol? It has hidden calories, messes with your blood sugar, and can make you have less energy for physical activity. Fruit/ veg can have lots of carbs/ sugars especially when cooked or as a smoothie.
I think 16:8 or even 14:16 or 12:12 is a great way to regulate blood sugar, also to have energy/ motivation to move.

Do you enjoy your diet? Could you do it for the rest of your life? If not, up your calories and include something you really enjoy. It sounds like you are repeating your yo-yo dieting experience.

It sounds like you have some body shame and this stops you liking exercise, e.g. the sweating. I used to be like this as a teenager. In my case just thinking of myself as a healthy person who likes physical activity helped me get there. Fake it to make it.

You say you don't like the way your body hurts after the gym. This seems to be one of these mindset ones. When I took responsibility for my fitness (as opposed to my mum/ school telling me) I started to like this as it meant there was an impact. But it is true it is "pain" and so depends on how you interpret it.

Also, I think having a DH who is very into sport can't necessarily help. I'd hate that. Men respond so much quicker to exercise in terms of fitness AND weight loss. Maybe you are secretly competitive, or feel more body shame in comparison. I think I'd hate having someone very fit next to me. It would reduce the fun I get from exercise, sadly.

Hyacinth2 · 04/09/2022 08:55

Walk listening to a good book or podcast

bumblebee1987 · 04/09/2022 08:53

EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/09/2022 08:48

Do slimming world where pasta is free.
You could have breakfast of poached eggs, bacon medallions, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes cooked frylite spray.

Weirdly, Slimming World never works for me! I have tried it so many times, and I do the food diaries etc, but I don't lose. I usually lose a little bit in the first week, and then nothing, then I get fed up because I get accused of not logging everything or cheating, so I leave 🤣

OP posts:
bumblebee1987 · 04/09/2022 08:50

Carpy88999 · 04/09/2022 08:42

1200 calories isn't enough to maintain for a 135lb 5ft woman with a sedentary lifestyle so you're either lying, miscalculating or you have an undiagnosed medical condition.

@Carpy88999 - You're right, it isn't enough, but it is what I have been doing, and I am not lying or miscalculating. I have been tested for medical conditions and the results showed nothing.

My DH has been working in the sports and fitness industry his entire life, and he has spent his career believing the 'eat less, move more' mantra. He sees what I am eating on a daily basis, he knows I am not cheating, and he finds it baffling because it goes against everything he thought he knew.

I've lost a stone and a half since March doing this (with a few weeks off in the middle because we moved house), and have now plateaued and lost nothing for 3 weeks, despite still having 3 stone to lose. 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/09/2022 08:48

Do slimming world where pasta is free.
You could have breakfast of poached eggs, bacon medallions, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes cooked frylite spray.

Nik2015 · 04/09/2022 08:47

I feel the same and am very jealous when I see PTs, etc who pretty much get paid to keep fit…

EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/09/2022 08:44

You must stop that diet. You'll collapse and your blood sugar levels will be impacted.

Carpy88999 · 04/09/2022 08:42

bumblebee1987 · 04/09/2022 08:31

@Carpy88999

I can 100% guarantee that I am.

I do not cook with any sort of oil or use any additional fat, so no need to measure them because they don't exist in my diet.

I don't eat carbs in the form of pasta/rice/potatoes etc, so no need to weigh those either.

A typical day for me looks like this.

Breakfast- 2 boiled eggs and a banana - 300 calories.

Lunch- An Itzu noodle pot - 200 calories

Dinner- Lettuce, cucumber, 30g reduced fat cheese (weighed, not estimated) half a tin of tuna or a chicken breast (cooked in the air fryer with no oil or sauce or anything). - Approximately 400 calories.

Snacks- If I snack, which I often don't because I don't get time at work, then I will eat 10 grapes/a pear/carrot and a little pot of reduced fat hummus/fat free yoghurt. - None of those are over 100 calories each, and I would typically only have one a day.

After dinner I sometimes have a mini lolly for something sweet- Maximum 80 calories.

If it goes in my mouth then it is logged on MFP. I eat food dry, I don't use condiments or sauces other than salt. The only foods I don't weigh are salad and veg (and I don't mean things like avocado, I mean typically very low cal salad and veg, like lettuce, cucumber, broccoli, cabbage etc, because overeating those is not the difference between me losing weight and not)

So if all of that if genuinely adding up to more than 1200 calories then I am clearly wrong, but I would be very surprised if it is.

1200 calories isn't enough to maintain for a 135lb 5ft woman with a sedentary lifestyle so you're either lying, miscalculating or you have an undiagnosed medical condition.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/09/2022 08:42

I think you have to try harder when it comes to your fitness level.

You'll eventually start releasing endorphins and become fitter, the buzz is addictive once you get into a routine, a healthier buzz than too little food and no results.

Convince yourself that your body needs it, assuming you're 34 by your username?

Ask yourself in ten years would you want to be fitter or fatter.

MintJulia · 04/09/2022 08:36

I was like you OP, I LOATHED sport at school, was utterly useless and binned my trainers the day I left. I did literally nothing until I was mid forties, but was getting to the point I didn't feel great. I couldn't afford a gym so I started running. It was hilarious, I could run about 40 paces before I turned purple. 😀

C25K was beyond me, so I did gateposts. Every time I went for a run, I tried to get to the next gateway before I stopped. It took me a year to be able to run 1k. Also like you, I didn't want others around, I wanted to do it alone.

That's 10 years ago and I can now run 10k fairly easily. I run parkrun and a mid-week 5k. I do a karate class as well to maintain flexibility. I don't exactly enjoy it but I like getting rid of the stress and I feel brilliant afterwards. Full of energy and much more positive and cheerful.

I'm not sure I'll ever have that 'joy of running' that others get but the feeling afterwards makes it worthwhile.