Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To answer questions this way?

218 replies

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 19:48

This is hard to explain but DH will ask me a question, and I give the information I have to hand that can be used to get to the answer but I don't work it out for him. This annoys him because 'Im not answering the question'. I feel I am! For context we have small kids and I am often already doing three things at once when the questions come in.

Examples
him - when do we need to leave to get to the party? me - it's a 40 minute drive and we need to get there at 10:30.
him - what time is the teddy bears picnic? me - it's on the calendar.
him - how many pieces of chicken is my share? me - I cooked 10 between 4 people.
him - do the children need sun hats? me - I checked the forecast earlier and it's going to be sunny all day.

Aibu to answer this way or would your partner answering like this annoy the crap out of you?

OP posts:
Sparklfairy · 03/09/2022 20:59

When people post on here that their Dh asks inane questions out of laziness and passing the mental load, the suggestions are always to reply as you do OP. I have no idea why you're getting a hard time on this thread!

MoveBitch · 03/09/2022 20:55

God....are you the riddler

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 03/09/2022 20:54

I'm amazed by the majority of answers here. Why should OP have to give him all this info?

Why is it a problem and annoying for him to have to work out the answer from the info given, but OP is just expected to have already done the annoying problematic working out so that she can present him with a nice simple answer?

For the leaving time one for eg - by giving him the relevant info (which he could have found out for himself) it makes them both responsible for arriving on time, so if they're then late he couldn't turn around and say 'you said we needed to leave at x time, we should of left earlier', and it makes them more likely to arrive on time.
Whereas if OP 'just answers the question' the responsibility of everything is purely on her.

I wonder what the broader context of responsibility sharing is within their relationship.

CornedBeef451 · 03/09/2022 20:53

I get it. DH always asks what time he needs to get somewhere. I don't know the answer, I just know what time he needs to be there.

Now I put everything on the calendar and direct him there, he has the same access to Google maps as me.

This avoids me being blamed if he is late or early as I can't predict traffic, weather or anything else.

With the hats I would answer the same way as if I just said no and then it was sunny, that would be my fault rather than unpredictable weather. Although he wouldn't think to pack hats so I always have them in a bag along with suncream, medicines, inhaler etc. and he complains I pack too much but also expects me to have everything on hand.

Can you tell we're not getting on at the moment?

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 20:53

Rosebel · 03/09/2022 20:46

You sound exhausting. It would drive me up the wall if my husband answered like this and I'm pretty sure he'd feel the same way if I answered like that.
Either answer the question or say you don't know and let him figure out the answer.

But if I just say 'I don't know' then he doesn't have the information to get to the answer. That seems much more annoying to me.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 03/09/2022 20:52

I think you're both as bad as eachother. Why is he asking you if the kids need sun hats? I couldn't live with a man who required that much hand-holding. Does he have to contact his boss at work to check what time he needs to leave for various meetings? Equally the way you answer questions would tip me over the edge. So I think you balance eachother out.

dizzydizzydizzy · 03/09/2022 20:51

DP used to be like this too. Every. Tiny. Thing. He had to ask me detailed questions when he could easily work it out himself. It's the mental load. I don't always want to be the one working out when we have to go out, whether we need to buy peas (look in the freezer) or whether we need snacks (yes, unless we are going out for less than 2 hours)

So, I'm with you OP. YANBU.

Limpshade · 03/09/2022 20:51

My husband does this, it's a bit like talking to a politician: I never get a straight answer Grin However for context, I don't treat him like a PA. It's just really hard to generally ask him about his plans and actually understand what he's doing and when. It's infuriating!

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 20:51

I have to say I don't know what the 'straightforward' answer to the chicken question is?

'2, 3, or 4' seems pretty unclear. Whereas by saying there's 10 pieces of chicken he can work out he gets at least two, and then judge from how the kids are eating whether he is likely to get more or not. (Is my logic, but I accept that many on here find it twattish).

OP posts:
getsomehelp · 03/09/2022 20:50

My husband is the same, he needs his dick holding for a pee I need to have all the info & all the answers, its utterly exhausting, & now it really annoys me.
Why am I the only one required to have & use my brain ?

What time are we leaving for the station? involves me working it backwards, & giving him a time, he will then contradict me, & tell me I'm wrong. (because I drive better & faster & know where to park possibly)
Also when I tell him something he will come back & ask me about it, as if he hasn't been able to understand (I have already discussed it, I don't need to do it again) or I didn't give him all the info necessary, or, he will say I never told him at all.

So I just say "I don't know" now, I don't tell him most stuff, I just give instructions.
& Yes our marriage is broken

Rosebel · 03/09/2022 20:46

You sound exhausting. It would drive me up the wall if my husband answered like this and I'm pretty sure he'd feel the same way if I answered like that.
Either answer the question or say you don't know and let him figure out the answer.

Scurryfunge12 · 03/09/2022 20:46

Why do you answer like this? Yes he could work the answer out from what you’ve said, but why do you do this? Just answer the bloody question. It sounds like you do it to be deliberately annoying 🤣

FOJN · 03/09/2022 20:45

Hmm yes it would drive me mad but then so would having a husband who needed me to wipe his arse for him.

You are both being unreasonable.

MyneighbourisTotoro · 03/09/2022 20:43

It sounds very PA imo. My DH would feel like I was being snarky to him.

Thoughtful2355 · 03/09/2022 20:42

Sorry but yabu and it would bug me, he just wants a simple answer not to have to do maths or potentially get the answer wrong because you havent just given him the answer to HIS question

BarbaraofSeville · 03/09/2022 20:37

YANBU.

He's expecting you to do all the thinking and working out and you're showing him its not that straightforward. Why should you be the only one with the mental load cluttering your head?

ofwarren · 03/09/2022 20:37

sidewayswalking · 03/09/2022 20:26

Urgh. Why though?

I genuinely couldn't live like this. I'm autistic and I just need a straight answer. I can't imagine many people would be happy with it though.

'How many pieces of chicken are for me?'

'I cooked 10 for 4 people'

WTAFF

This!
I feel anxious just reading those replies!

Serialcatmum · 03/09/2022 20:34

Although I find your questions infuriating 🤣 I also think it’s genius.

Why doesn’t he know if his own kids need sun hats?
Any reason he’s asked you sooner than check the calendar?

Why should you have to be the bearer of all knowledge?

CalishataFolkart · 03/09/2022 20:33

AtomicBlondeRose · 03/09/2022 20:26

I totally get it. He is outsourcing his thinking to the OP! Come on, a grown man can work out how much chicken is his share.

I agree. The thought processes are:

OP - Do the kids need sun hats today? I’ll check the forecast.
MrOP - Do the kids need sun hats today? I’ll ask Dances.

Information isn’t beamed directly into her brain. She has to find it, log it and store it.

The chicken could be an exception though because it might not have been totally obvious how many pieces there were.

LordEmsworth · 03/09/2022 20:33

You're both unreasonable. He shouldn't need you to make all the decisions. Your answers, I would assume if someone said them to me they were pissed off at me and couldn't be bothered to engage.

him - when do we need to leave to get to the party? me - it's a 40 minute drive and we need to get there at 10:30 - "so what time would you like to set off" / "so I think 9.45ish" / "so let me know what you decide".
him - what time is the teddy bears picnic? me - it's on the calendar "I can't remember, can you check".
him - how many pieces of chicken is my share? me - I cooked 10 between 4 people "so take 2 so there's enough" / "so can you cut a couple in half" / "because you said you were hungry so I did for you".
him - do the children need sun hats? me - I checked the forecast earlier and it's going to be sunny all day - ok this one I'd have just said "I'm not the king of sun hats, what do you think" or if he's completely ineffective "yes of course they do, look out the bloody window".

Talia99 · 03/09/2022 20:32

Just to say, by ‘want to stay married to’, I don’t mean that either you or your DH are doing anything divorce worthy, just that if the marriage isn’t on the way out anyway, being deliberately unpleasant to each other (which, even if that’s not what you intend, seems to be how the way you respond to his questions is coming across to your DH) doesn’t make for a nice atmosphere.

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 20:30

Mummadeze · 03/09/2022 19:53

My partner would hate this. He does need a lot of spoon feeding though. I would answer as fully as possible just to avoid the lengthy back and forth that would ensue.

I do think there is a bit of this, so if I just do the maths in my head and think it's 40 minute drive and we need to get there at 10:30, so I say 9:50, then inevitably the next question will be 'how long is the journey?' so (I'm thinking) it's better to give him all the information I have at the start, rather than just the 'result'.

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 03/09/2022 20:30

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 20:24

Not a reverse!

I'm not 'deliberately' answering that way to wind him up, (definitely not being passive aggressive!) I'm just saying the bit that's already in my head?

It wouldn't be quicker to give the 'short' answer because I'd have to work it out, so he'd have to stand there while I thought the bit that I'm saying out loud, then did the maths (or got out my phone to see the calendar etc), then gave the answer.

Obviously when I know the answer off the top of my head I just say it.

That's not true for the sun hat example. You knew the answer was 'yes', but chose not to say it.

mtld · 03/09/2022 20:29

Yeah, some people talk like this because they need to “think out loud” to get to the answer. It can be frustrating for people who don’t think that way, but I don’t think it can be helped.

Your post did sound a bit like you have the answer in your head and you’re just making him figure it out for himself.

girlmom21 · 03/09/2022 20:28

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 20:24

Not a reverse!

I'm not 'deliberately' answering that way to wind him up, (definitely not being passive aggressive!) I'm just saying the bit that's already in my head?

It wouldn't be quicker to give the 'short' answer because I'd have to work it out, so he'd have to stand there while I thought the bit that I'm saying out loud, then did the maths (or got out my phone to see the calendar etc), then gave the answer.

Obviously when I know the answer off the top of my head I just say it.

But surely if you've put 10 pieces of chicken in the oven you did that because you were giving people X amounts? Even if there were 10 in the pack you could say there's 2 each and 2 spare