Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think soft play is old school and not eco or progressive

142 replies

sheparo · 03/09/2022 16:29

We have the v v exciting opportunity to make a building that will house some sort of large play/event/task zones for children, that will have to meet the council's loan interest of 100k a year. The building is part of a city-wide facelift on being more green, community focused and cheerful and is the only focus on making money in this venture. The rest is building bridges, creating community hubs, cycle paths and green spaces (yay!).

Thing is, I want this space to be eco friendly and an opportunity for kids to try new things like barefoot trails, climbing and bouldering, maybe a small skate park, small library area, sensory room, running and soft area, maybe even a circus bit, a little indoor garden... sort of where kids can develop skills, talk to each other, learn things, run around but also have it as somewhere to chill and have a milkshake.

My (kind but elder, male, grown up kids yada yada) colleague says he wants soft play. His wife is a childminder and wants soft play. I really think soft play would cheapen and degrade everything this building is meant to stand for... but I agree we need to make money... AIBU to want to push for something different? Or is there something about soft play that I am being snobby about? (I have three kids btw, they adore soft play tbh... but, but... garish and loud and plastic and aircon! And can be rough and not exactly community...)

Am just wondering if I am being a snob and really, soft play is fine and am just over it, personally, when others would really love it.

TIA ladies, I await judgement... !

OP posts:
BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 03/09/2022 17:16

My son is 3.5 and autistic he couldn't do any of those things you've listed except the sensory room which I wish there was more of. But soft play has taught him a lot about coordination and it allows him to be near other children but still find his own space.

So depends if you want to space to be inclusive of some kids that can't access those things

sheparo · 03/09/2022 17:15

FYN - 100k is not the budget, is what it needs to make per annum, roughly. Am not involved in budgets, am a mixture of promotion, research and community engagement :)

OP posts:
RayneDance · 03/09/2022 17:13

Our soft play was more for the parents and childminders. The children had Amazing fun they moved and contorted themselves into many different body moves, climbing, jumping, hanging etc..
But I could sit and take a breather. Knowing they were safe

Eco , something beautiful is great but it was fhe easing of my mental load that was the key.
Helped me tap into some quiet time and patience!
Personally I could create something really beautiful with Amazon forests layer's, the canopy etc,then an artic area...

Goldbar · 03/09/2022 17:13

Soft play is where I take my child when I don't particularly want to engage with them but don't want them sitting in front of a screen for the whole afternoon either.

Its merits are that it is soft, relatively safe, enclosed, DC is challenged physically and comes back exhausted and (at least at the one we go to) I can get a decent coffee and supervise from a distance. I usually dress DC in neon yellow or bright red so I can keep track of them in the frame without having to move from my table. It is not entirely risk free but generally I only intervene if DC is being silly or reckless around smaller children, strays into the baby zone or there are much larger kids being a PITA.

What you're describing sounds lovely but a bit more parent-intensive. I would definitely use something like this but more on a "Things to do WITH your children" basis than a "Trying to forget I have children" one (i.e. less frequently and more as a family trip out than a frequent wet weather/cba option).

fyn · 03/09/2022 17:12

Do you have a realistic understanding of how far £100,000 is going to go for play equipment. We recently built a very small skatepark for £60,000. Costs of play equipment have risen so much in the past year that there is no way we’d manage it now. The small (not full sized) MUGA we are installing is £70,000.

There is some great play equipment about, lots of recycled materials. Natural water play (maintenance costs a lot though). Wood is lovely but the lifespan of it is incredibly limited. We are building a very small fully inclusive play area at the moment and are looking at £50,000, just waiting on the quotes to come in.

AnnaBegins · 03/09/2022 17:11

Have a look at this place for market research www.riversidehub.com/ The toddler play village is fab and could be made eco focused with e.g. a kitchen garden area, repair shop, recycling station (the Think Tank in Birmingham used to have a great recycling station on a conveyor belt but they recently replaced it). The soft play has a climbing wall too, and a really nice sensory room. I can send you photos if you'd like ideas.

sheparo · 03/09/2022 17:10

Yes! I wanted a massive slide from high up that twirls down for ages... or a zipwire or something up high that older kids and tourists might be attracted to as well as a soft play for younger, more regular visitors.

I've heard of little brum! thanks so much for references and links to help hone ideas.

The project is vast and this building is meant for indoor play for children, and needs to make 100k a year to fund the rest of the social, eco and communal uplift our city is getting. Is fantastic and we don't want to fuck it up :)

OP posts:
mountainsunsets · 03/09/2022 17:08

Mercerly · 03/09/2022 16:47

You can do eco indoor play. I've seen a play in a huge barn with trees to climb, planks to walk on, slides, all eco themed to learn about the world. Maybe something like that?

So like... everything you can do in the woods for free but without the fresh air, the daylight, the learning about the ACTUAL world and the freeness?

Sorry but I really don't understand this. Might as well switch "eco" for "middle class virtue signalling".

But "actual woods" aren't always accessible.

For example, to access our local woods, you need to be able to drive, otherwise it's a 3 mile walk along an NSL road with no pavement or lighting - hardly ideal for children. And OP says she lives in a city, so there's every chance the local woods is 15 miles away.

Our local woods also has no toilet, no café, nowhere to change a baby or toddler, nowhere to warm up milk for a baby - it does't even have a bin!

An indoor play area is much more accessible - it's available year-round, it's safe, you're not restricted by daylight hours or good weather. It'll have a café, a toilet and a changing area and it'll be clean, so you don't come home caked in mud and soaking wet. It's also fully enclosed so children can run around without parents needing to worry as much.

Surely you must be able to see the appeal of safe, enclosed, clean indoor space for young children?

NameChange30 · 03/09/2022 17:06

We visited this place once (on a weekend away) and it was brilliant:
www.churchfarmstowbardolph.co.uk/activity/indoor-play-area/

habibihabibi · 03/09/2022 17:05

In Dubai there is a great place that has a soft play and adventure park combined. There are higher wooden climbing structures and ziplines plus soft play. It is all nature toned and not garish and it is incredibly CLEAN.
We were once at a place in London where my then 10month child uncovered a chicken drumstick in the ball pit......

sheparo · 03/09/2022 17:05

Just to say, am definitely doing lots of market research, with children of different ages, random sampling with questionnaires and unstructured interviews in town and at the site, in schools, nurseries and community organisations. And having a variety of activities for kids to engage in and we watch who goes to what and for how long. Then if they all say brightly coloured loud soft play that is what we will do, for sure! Am just trying to see if soft play is really still a thing. Seems it definitely is ;)

OP posts:
Hardbackwriter · 03/09/2022 17:05

In addition to my point above about consultation - it also depends on what the point of the public investment is, which isn't clear to me but hopefully is to you. If this venture needs to make money to subsidize the rest of the project then you need to whatever will be most commercially successful, which is probably more likely to be the softplay (there's a reason that there's lots of them, and not many of the kind of thing you want). If the point of the investment is to provide something more 'worthy', that it's a cultural/community investment, then doing something like your idea, which might well not be commercially viable without the subsidy, is more appropriate. In that case it might be actively inappropriate to open a softplay if it would undercut local businesses because you have council money and they don't.

NameChange30 · 03/09/2022 17:02

I agree with PPs that you need to do a consultation. Not just with parents but also people like children's occupational therapists and educational play experts.

I think you can do an eco indoor play area with good quality play equipment, wooden etc, and some things to encourage imaginative play, but have some climbing and slides etc, kids enjoy and arguably need that stuff.

I also agree with PPs that music is not necessary, I also think that things like natural light and comfortable seating areas (for the adults) can make a huge different to a place that people want to spend time in or not.

abovedecknotbelow · 03/09/2022 17:02

Can't you do a mix. Soft play really is perfect for little ones and who is going to be using the building during term time - small kids not in education yet.

Your ideas are great but not so much money making or practical for day to day.

MumDadBingoBlueyy · 03/09/2022 17:02

Have a look at little brum (think tank museum), it’s a small world sort of idea with little science bits and soft play built in. My kids (2&4) love it, but also there’s things for older kids too 😊 I think it sounds like a compromise between what you’re both looking at and it would be easy enough to tie in the eco side, and expand the soft play

SweetSakura · 03/09/2022 17:01

Surely you are doing some surveys /focus groups etc ? I would imagine what would suit an area will vary widely depending on the catchment?

And does it need to be all one or the other? We have a climbing centre near us that is a mix of soft play and bouldering, it's really well designed

Lostmyway86 · 03/09/2022 17:01

Near to where I live they have opened a small soft play all in white and grey. There is a cafe area for the adults. They only allow 10 children max at a time for a 1.5 hour session and you can order food and coffee. It is very calm, not all the bright colours and sensory overload as pp said. It's far less 'stuff' but a ki h more enjoyable experience for me and my children (age 3 and nearly 2).

SBAM · 03/09/2022 17:00

The tumbling bay play area in the Olympic park is also great, the climbing frames can be accessed by a wide range of ages. Westfield Stratford also has the biodiversity playground which is lovely for children up to around 10 but I’m not sure how much the average child actually engages with the educational display there. Something like the tumbling bay set-up but indoors would appeal to a wide age range, and you could perhaps create a cafe, with a sensory garden outside too.

TeenDivided · 03/09/2022 16:59

The thing about soft play is it is soft. It is pretty much safe as safe. Your child can run, climb, slide as much as they want with limited chance to get seriously hurt. They can burn off energy to their heart's content whilst you as a parent sit and chat or read or whatever.

I agree they can be sensory overload, though that could be mitigated for in design, and possibly also by having 'quiet' sessions (no music, more gentle lighting etc).

OP. Your ideas sound very 'worthy', but maybe not great money makers, and serving a different age group. You absolutely need to do proper market research.

sheparo · 03/09/2022 16:59

Thanks guys!

Hehe virtue signalling to other adults! :)

We have an outdoor area that is being developed with (hopefully) safe access to the river, and definitely big pitches for all weather team games and is by a lovely river with ducks and trees and a playground. So that's all great, just needs to be funded by this building.

I really like the idea of marrying my preferences with what soft play can provide. I am doing a weekend talking to the people and getting their views and providing some play stuff and seeing what the kids like. Am also asking schools and children (I work at a school and have 3 children of my own). And you guys! LOVE the idea of having wood to play on and around and areas about insects etc. We could even possibly change up the themes so it stays fresh?

Am really keen to push at least a sensory room for SEND kids, this would be a great investment. was thinking of having it accessed by a side door with a corridor leading to the main bit, so kids with sensory processing issues don't have to go into the main bit which will be loud and (hopefully) busy with kids.

Really want a climbing wall/bouldering area for older kids. And definitely a cafe for parents/carers.

:)

OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 03/09/2022 16:59

While your idea does sound good, it also sounds like it's going to be more expensive to maintain all the different elements and have all the right insurances and supervisors/training videos for climbing walls etc.

So it'll end up costing the parents more money to visit turning it into more of an occasional visit place rather than a rainy day/bored kids/cheap and cheerful place

SproutsAtChristmas · 03/09/2022 16:57

I think the best soft plays are the smaller ones with café and predominantly in term time it's used by under 5s so it's targeted at that age. You'll earn more money from it that way and can always put some smaller role play equipment in if you want it to double as a learning zone. The community can also use the café as a learning hub base too e.g. antenatal classes, baby groups, weaning support, parenting courses. That way it's more of a community space than just a soft play business.

Tonkerbea · 03/09/2022 16:57

Hardbackwriter · 03/09/2022 16:46

I don't think it should be decided on the whims of either you, your colleague or MN randoms, especially as there seems to be some public investment here. You need to do some research on what people in your area actually want, not what either of you think they should want or what you'd want them to want.

So much this! Have the community been engaged? What consultations are taking place? You need to give the local people a place they feel they belong, not what you think they need.

It's an exciting project, good luck.

Holidaydreamingagain · 03/09/2022 16:57

You need to do a proper community engagement consultation to find out what the local community want. You need to reach as many people as possible so need to have some market research groups, surveys, polls and get it out to as many people as possible and then decide from there. It’s what meets the actually needs of the community not what you think they should want.

SBAM · 03/09/2022 16:55

I agree that something billed as softplay or an indoor play area might be more appealing to parents as they understand what they’re likely to get when they arrive, and typically it’s designed as an age appropriate secure place for children to burn off energy.

ive recently visited the science museum in Kensington and they have a play area in the basement called the garden which is fantastic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread