Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave my son in his cot

116 replies

ChatterCot · 03/09/2022 14:55

Sometimes in the afternoon I will put my son in his cot and close the curtains, put on some white noise and leave him. He often doesn't sleep but will instead just lie there playing with a teddy or quietly chatting to himself.

I use this time to have a brew or watch TV. Typically for around 40 mins - an hour before he stands up and starts whinging at which point I'll go and get him. Very occasionally he'll fall asleep and stay up there for longer but most of the time he just lies in his cot quietly.

A family member thinks this is mean if he's not actually asleep. Imo though if he's not crying then he's okay?

YABU - even if he's not crying, he shouldn't be left in his cot when not asleep.

YANBU - it's fine for you and he to have some downtime if he's not upset.

OP posts:
mountainsunsets · 03/09/2022 23:01

VestaTilley · 03/09/2022 22:57

And for all those of you praising “quiet time” for children - that’s meant to be for overstimulated 10 year olds who are always at school or extra curricular activities, FFS - not 18 month old babies who need interaction when awake for vital bonding, socialisation and speech and language development!

And nobody is saying they don't need those things.

But no child or baby needs constant interaction when they're awake. 40 minutes of quiet solo play doesn't mean they're never being socialised or talked to!

ElspethTascioni · 03/09/2022 23:01

I am completely anti-controlled crying etc, but I can’t see anything wrong with him lying in his cot having a bit of quiet time if he’s happy to do it.

I’d re-think the white noise though, and try an audiobook of music instead - there’s some research to suggest white noise isn’t great for their developing brains.

Discovereads · 03/09/2022 23:00

VestaTilley · 03/09/2022 22:55

I agree with you @Discovereads

I’m glad I’m not the only one seeing what’s wrong with this.

Discovereads · 03/09/2022 22:59

missintolerance · 03/09/2022 22:49

Good grief. What a knob head you are. The language you use is inflammatory and quite frankly you’re inventing a narrative to stir up a negative emotional response to support your own argument.

The child is playing HAPPILY in their cot so obviously not distressed. The OP REMOVES the child from the cot when the child indicates they are ready to be removed. A 40 minute rest in the afternoons for both mum and child does not equate to neglect.

Have another read, the word HAPPY or HAPPILY is not written by the OP once.
What were you saying about “inventing a narrative”?

VestaTilley · 03/09/2022 22:57

And for all those of you praising “quiet time” for children - that’s meant to be for overstimulated 10 year olds who are always at school or extra curricular activities, FFS - not 18 month old babies who need interaction when awake for vital bonding, socialisation and speech and language development!

VestaTilley · 03/09/2022 22:55

I agree with you @Discovereads

MarianneVos · 03/09/2022 22:53

bakewellbride · 03/09/2022 17:33

I did that with my son but when he was older - 2 or 2 and a half and with me in the room. Unsupervised would've been no more than 5 mins or 10 max and no younger than 2.

At 18 months I left him in his cot for literally a couple of mins while I went for a wee and when I came back he had somehow got his leg stuck in the bars (we just have a normal traditional cot with normal looking wooden bars and I'd in no way thought this was a real risk). It took 40 mins to free him and was terrifying. I was on the verge of dialling 999. It's a risk I'll never take again. It's not worth it op.

Surely you left an 18 month old in a cot for longer than five minutes very frequently if that's where he slept?! Not sure why it's suddenly dangerous if it's during the day.

VestaTilley · 03/09/2022 22:52

I never did this, and wouldn’t leave a child like that for ages, no. It’s lazy parenting. You can have them playing with you downstairs while you make a cup of tea!

At that age he should still be napping, so you put him down for naps, not random time so you get a break as well! I put my DS down in his Moses basket or cot whenever he was due a nap or took him for a walk in the park to sleep, but if he was awake I was talking to him, playing, reading, out at a baby group or had him in the high chair talking to him while I cooked or washed up.

I can’t believe what I read on here sometimes.

Discovereads · 03/09/2022 22:51

@Mummyoflittledragon
Your situation is entirely different. Your child was still sleeping her night time sleep in the bedroom with her Dad there when you went for a dog walk. She wasn’t being ferried off in the middle of the afternoon while wide awake and shut up alone in a dark room with white noise for being “grumpy” for the better part of an hour- sometimes longer.

whatshouldIdo2022 · 03/09/2022 22:50

Mine dropped naps at 18 months and I did this as well. Sometimes she would drop off,sometimes not. I tried everything to get her to nap, staying in there just stimulated her so I'd leave her about as long as you do then go and get her if not asleep. I wouldn't have done this if I'd still had a napper but it was essential for my sanity. The days are long and tough when they stop napping that young and its totally understandable IMO that you need a break. I've been advised and encouraged to do this by the health visitor and numerous baby friends.

missintolerance · 03/09/2022 22:49

Discovereads · 03/09/2022 22:02

Neglect is by far the most common type of child abuse, there is no “and abusing” as neglect by itself is a form of abuse. Over 26,335 children are on protection plans in England and Wales as of 2019 (that’s more than half those on a protection plan). And when you think about all the children not reported and not on protection plans…there are going to be many more of them.

So you’ll have to forgive me but the “majority” opinion means nothing to me. Not when you see the figures of how prevalent and insidious child neglect is. I personally would not do it, as I do think it is neglectful.

I don’t think it is serious life threatening neglect, but I don’t think it is healthy or positive for the child at all. How would you feel if a nanny you had hired took an long break like this? Is it really child care to stuff an awake and alert child in a dark room, in a wooden cage they cannot get out of and walk away to watch TV and sip tea? Sorry no, not something I can condone or praise.

Good grief. What a knob head you are. The language you use is inflammatory and quite frankly you’re inventing a narrative to stir up a negative emotional response to support your own argument.

The child is playing HAPPILY in their cot so obviously not distressed. The OP REMOVES the child from the cot when the child indicates they are ready to be removed. A 40 minute rest in the afternoons for both mum and child does not equate to neglect.

Discovereads · 03/09/2022 22:47

mountainsunsets · 03/09/2022 22:29

I don’t think it is serious life threatening neglect, but I don’t think it is healthy or positive for the child at all. How would you feel if a nanny you had hired took an long break like this? Is it really child care to stuff an awake and alert child in a dark room, in a wooden cage they cannot get out of and walk away to watch TV and sip tea? Sorry no, not something I can condone or praise.

You're being ridiculous and actually quite offensive to people who did suffer from genuine neglect as children.

Letting your child rest and recharge in a safe, quiet space is the opposite of neglect. OP also comes running as soon as her child fusses or cries.

And if a nanny or babysitter did this - I'd say bloody good for them. Caring for children all day is hard work and both adults and child need a break to rest and recharge.

I think you are being flippant by applauding what is clearly not a good or healthy practice. I’m not being offensive to victims of neglect by pointing out this isn’t good.

Im not going to agree with the OP putting her 18mo in a dark room, with white noise for 40mins to an hour because he’s “grumpy”. It’s clearly creating a mood-punishment cycle, as he already knows he has to be in a “better mood” afterwards. It’s not about independent play at all.

This also isn’t the only way to have a rest or a break when both awake. You can be together and do things independently.

I just can’t support it. You can call me ridiculous all you want. It’s not a good habit to have.

Mummyoflittledragon · 03/09/2022 22:42

My dd wouldn’t have been ok to lay quietly but napped until about 3 years old. I don’t think it’s neglectful. I think it’s giving the brain and body time to regenerate. If as suggested, you put your ds in his playpen, he would probably get too much stimulation and be overtired in the evening.

@Discovereads Does it make a difference as to why a person would leave their child in a cot whilst awake? Mine was to provide dd with breast milk as I didn’t have gallons of the stuff. Once dd got to about 5 months, I wasn’t coping and made a plan to have better sleep so got up at 6am to express milk then went for a quick dog walk and a second express. I then had enough milk to feed dd at about 11.30pm to get her through the night. I would then go to her at 7am and breastfeed. Dd woke up between 6.30 and 7am so was awake and happy. As she got older, she would sing and chatter to herself. She was in the bedroom with us until 1 year old so dh was around and in bed actually. I don’t see this as neglecting my dd. I was meeting my need for sleep, to have a calm dog and dd’s feeding needs.

Hugasauras · 03/09/2022 22:42

I'm convinced that poster is a parody account from their posts elsewhere too.

megletthesecond · 03/09/2022 22:40

"Wooden cage" 🤣

mountainsunsets · 03/09/2022 22:29

I don’t think it is serious life threatening neglect, but I don’t think it is healthy or positive for the child at all. How would you feel if a nanny you had hired took an long break like this? Is it really child care to stuff an awake and alert child in a dark room, in a wooden cage they cannot get out of and walk away to watch TV and sip tea? Sorry no, not something I can condone or praise.

You're being ridiculous and actually quite offensive to people who did suffer from genuine neglect as children.

Letting your child rest and recharge in a safe, quiet space is the opposite of neglect. OP also comes running as soon as her child fusses or cries.

And if a nanny or babysitter did this - I'd say bloody good for them. Caring for children all day is hard work and both adults and child need a break to rest and recharge.

WishingWell5 · 03/09/2022 22:20

I wish mine would do this!

MajorCarolDanvers · 03/09/2022 22:14

Discovereads · 03/09/2022 22:02

Neglect is by far the most common type of child abuse, there is no “and abusing” as neglect by itself is a form of abuse. Over 26,335 children are on protection plans in England and Wales as of 2019 (that’s more than half those on a protection plan). And when you think about all the children not reported and not on protection plans…there are going to be many more of them.

So you’ll have to forgive me but the “majority” opinion means nothing to me. Not when you see the figures of how prevalent and insidious child neglect is. I personally would not do it, as I do think it is neglectful.

I don’t think it is serious life threatening neglect, but I don’t think it is healthy or positive for the child at all. How would you feel if a nanny you had hired took an long break like this? Is it really child care to stuff an awake and alert child in a dark room, in a wooden cage they cannot get out of and walk away to watch TV and sip tea? Sorry no, not something I can condone or praise.

I think that you are being incredibly flippant to equate this with neglect.

Each of your posts is becoming more hyperbolic in turn and are really not to be taken at all seriously.

Give your head a wobble and stop playing games and trying to conflate a very serious issue with a toddler having a bit of quiet time and playing with a teddy.

Blondeshavemorefun · 03/09/2022 22:07

18mths is early to drop nap. Poor you

nothing wrong with quiet time. ESP if falls asleep

it’s not like you are leaving him screaming getting upset while you ignore and watch tv

Somethingsnappy · 03/09/2022 22:05

Discovereads · 03/09/2022 21:48

Neglectful parents never do describe it for what it is, are you that naive? No one’s going to go on a forum and make it blatantly obvious, there are definite red flags though in OPs description which if you’ve never worked with neglect you’d not pick up on.

Red flags? Plural? Could you expand please?

Discovereads · 03/09/2022 22:05

JenniferBarkley · 03/09/2022 21:50

I was thinking the opposite - I think it's really important that DC learn to play independently, enjoy their own company, feel comfortable and safe in their own rooms etc. Happy quiet play after lunch seems to me to be a great, gentle way to encourage that.

I would think that those who are horrified may in years to come regret not allowing their children to develop more independence in their play.

No regrets here as I have 4 DC and youngest just turned 18. You don’t have to shut them in a cot in a dark room when they’re 18 months old to teach them “independent play” what utter rot.

Discovereads · 03/09/2022 22:02

MajorCarolDanvers · 03/09/2022 21:50

Do you think then that the majority of posters who have agreed with OP are also neglecting and abusing their children?

Neglect is by far the most common type of child abuse, there is no “and abusing” as neglect by itself is a form of abuse. Over 26,335 children are on protection plans in England and Wales as of 2019 (that’s more than half those on a protection plan). And when you think about all the children not reported and not on protection plans…there are going to be many more of them.

So you’ll have to forgive me but the “majority” opinion means nothing to me. Not when you see the figures of how prevalent and insidious child neglect is. I personally would not do it, as I do think it is neglectful.

I don’t think it is serious life threatening neglect, but I don’t think it is healthy or positive for the child at all. How would you feel if a nanny you had hired took an long break like this? Is it really child care to stuff an awake and alert child in a dark room, in a wooden cage they cannot get out of and walk away to watch TV and sip tea? Sorry no, not something I can condone or praise.

MrsEG · 03/09/2022 22:00

Completely fine, I still do this some days with my twins (they’re 2.5) if they’re having a busy day. Frustratingly nursery still reliably get them to nap during their 2 days a week there (wizards!) but it’s down to ‘occasional’ for us at home!
Only difference is they’re in beds so they can have a play with some toys or grab a book from the bookshelf etc. Same as you some days they conk out for a sleep, others they just play happily in a quiet room for 45 mins and recharge their batteries!!
Some other days we all just go for a walk, but that’s not always the easy option with two haha.
My HV actually recommended the quiet time to me; sometimes we do it in the living room too on beanbags with a film on and again 50% of the time they zonk out there as well haha. Other times they lay very quietly for a bit. I dim all the lights etc.
Its hard work when they get in to the ‘some days I do, some days I don’t need a nap’ stage, it started at age 2 for us; I think having the quiet time is an excellent sort of ‘go-between’ especially to power you through to bed time!

TabithaTittlemouse · 03/09/2022 21:52

Sounds like it works for you and your little one.

That is all that matters.

JenniferBarkley · 03/09/2022 21:50

Creepymanonagoatfarm · 03/09/2022 21:31

Personally I think in years to come you will regret you did this.

I was thinking the opposite - I think it's really important that DC learn to play independently, enjoy their own company, feel comfortable and safe in their own rooms etc. Happy quiet play after lunch seems to me to be a great, gentle way to encourage that.

I would think that those who are horrified may in years to come regret not allowing their children to develop more independence in their play.