Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cutting down on expenses. AIBU to take DS out of nursery for a year?

243 replies

SpicedAutumnPumpkin · 03/09/2022 13:38

Name changed for that.

With the cost of living crisis already taking a stroll on our household expenses I am getting concerned over what is about to come in the colder months ahead. We are not on a minimum wage by any chance but find that our balance is not looking good after all the deductions at the beginning of the month. We went though those and can't cut down on anything else. For example a deliveroo treat once in 2 weeks is an essential for our mental sanity as we dont go out much. Our rent is about 900 which is very good for the place we rent and we will not find anything cheaper. Everything else just adds up. We don't go on holidays nor do we have any expensive hobbies.

Dh works full time but its a hybrid work with some days from home and I do some part time work online plus studying for a new qualification. We got DD who is 9 and goes to a state school and DS been going to a really lovely nursery for the past year. He is turning 3 in a month time. The fees are quite high and even with the funding available the term after he turns 3 will still leave us with quite a lot of money to pay even for just a few days a week. Especially during holiday times when we do not really need the nursery but have to pay for it anyway and the funding won't be available for those days .

AIBU to be considering taking him out of the nursery for a year till he goes into a state pre school. We used to do that before when my dh and I would replace one another and it worked okish. I can then take him to activities like swimming and football or just playgroups around to meet with other kids.

My friends think that this should be an absolute last resort and I am being unreasonable. But then it won't be them telling my kids that we can't do presents for their upcoming birthdays and Christmas.

OP posts:
user1496146479 · 03/09/2022 23:05

sheepdogdelight · 03/09/2022 22:11

There is another thread at the moment, where an OP has been practically berated for not sending her child to nursery, and has disadvantaged them for starting school!!!!

That OP didn't send her DC to nursery at all before school.
OP is proposing that her DC goes to pre-school for the whole year before he starts school. Not remotely the same.

@sheepdogdelight
My comment was in response to comments on this thread saying why bother with nursery if you don't need it type comments etc!

allboysherebutme · 03/09/2022 23:03

Can't you just send him to nursery for the hours you will get free. X

Summerbreezee · 03/09/2022 23:01

Just here for solidarity OP on your takeaways!! Dh spending money goes on 1 takeaway EVERY week and until we can't afford ANYTHING he will never give it up, as it's his 'treat' 😄

Honestly, 2022 and a fortnightly takeaway is seen as living the high life 🙄

Swimmingpoolsally · 03/09/2022 22:49

Op I think your life is very, very different to most, with kids of nine and three and a part time working parent , most don’t feel they can only connect with their partner if they get takeaway. For some reason you and your partner cannot connect when the kids are in bed every night unless you get food delivered and if you d0jt it impacts your mental health.

it seems you don’t understand how unusual this is, and most others don’t understand how it’s possible takeaway is so critical to you for your mental Health and partner connection. Just you’ve an unusual thing going on really.

Change12345 · 03/09/2022 22:48

If people weren’t being serious this thread would funny! But it’s not, sorry you got so many ridiculous responses OP, especially on the deliveroo! I mean FFS, a take away twice a month is no biggie on the grand scheme of things and it’s nice to look forward to when you literally spend nothing else on luxuries for yourself. Half of the posters berating you for getting a deliveroo are probably half cut on their lambrini - with the expenditure vastly more than your two deliveroos.
I don’t think your DC would miss out developmentally but I know I personally couldn’t cope wfh with DC here for a full year. (Otherwise if need to up my deliveroos to weekly 😉)

ThinWomansBrain · 03/09/2022 22:44

everyone seems to have got very hung up on deliveroo - I don;t use them myself, but say £25-£30? Which presumably doesn't buy many hours of nussery,

MorganKitten · 03/09/2022 22:35

SpicedAutumnPumpkin · 03/09/2022 18:19

Did you not read a message? I share my takeaway addiction (sorry hahah) with my Dh . Who also loves having let's say a Nepalese or South African meal from his favourite family run place twice a month!. It is his wish and choice too or should I control what he does with his money as well and give him a lecture and show him how much he would save if he doesn't order it?? Surely that's awful.

It is also a support for those places as many of the restaurant closed down where we live in.

You know Deliveroo charges those businesses each order right? If you really want to support them order direct.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/09/2022 22:31

I think trying to juggle childcare, work and studying would eat into my sanity even more than no deliveroo.

This!

I think it’s absolutely miserable for children to be stuck in the background whilst parents are working. And I mean up to about year 5/6 - so age 10/11. It would be the very last thing I cut - way after deliveroo.

RayneDance · 03/09/2022 22:26

Take him out, keep your deliveroo...find local toddler groups and enjoy!!
For Xmas charity shop gifts for him....huge cheap pile and see what older DC wants and compromise a little...

RayneDance · 03/09/2022 22:21

Op if that's the only reason, to engage with other children then surely it's a no brainer?.
Toddler groups cost a few pounds £1.50 a few years ago for snacks, crafts... rotated toy's each week...lots of other DC to play with.

We had so many around here and each one had a different feel.

Then soft play, parks and so on.
My.dc were out mixing this way for a few hours nearly every day?

sheepdogdelight · 03/09/2022 22:11

There is another thread at the moment, where an OP has been practically berated for not sending her child to nursery, and has disadvantaged them for starting school!!!!

That OP didn't send her DC to nursery at all before school.
OP is proposing that her DC goes to pre-school for the whole year before he starts school. Not remotely the same.

longestlurkerever · 03/09/2022 22:01

My dd1 is 11 now so maybe things have changed but I seem to remember when she was small parents got chastised for "outsourcing parenting" and sending their children to nursery for "long days". Just seems like people are looking for any excuse to put the boot in really

user1496146479 · 03/09/2022 21:55

GhostFromTheOtherSide · 03/09/2022 15:30

Children don’t need to nursery, parents need their children to go to nursery for childcare reasons. This is why nurseries get away with charging parents extortionate amounts of money to look after their children.

Full time nursery is only a concept which has existed for the past generation, prior to that children managed perfectly well without, and let’s be honest we don’t have a generation of children who are so much more developed than the previous generation.

Children benefit from preschool when they turn 3, but if you don’t have to then I wouldn’t pay exorbitant nursery costs no.

As for the people criticising the OP for using deliveroo, I presume you never buy yourself anything which isn’t a necessity ever? You don’t buy makeup? A bottle of wine once a week? Have netflix? You just have the bear minimum and nothing else ever?

The only reason why OP is being criticised here is because she’s dared to name the treat she has. But I guarantee there is not a single person on this thread who never spends money on something they easily could go without.

There is another thread at the moment, where an OP has been practically berated for not sending her child to nursery, and has disadvantaged them for starting school!!!!

Lavender2021 · 03/09/2022 21:43

I would check your nursery contact as we have to give three months notice before we leave. So you may have to pay for a few more months anyway.

LuckySantangelo35 · 03/09/2022 21:27

Doingprettywellthanks · 03/09/2022 16:39

Such as seeing joy on your children’s faces on Christmas morning

having seen @LuckySantangelo35 multiple posts on parenting…. That is not going to be something that washes with her in the slightest

@Upsidedownagain

Haha

well actually I do think kids should have Christmas presents of course I do

so I think they should have hundreds of pounds spent on them for a birthday at the expense of their parents only treat? NOPE

Being a parent doesn’t mean you constantly have to come last all of the time

LuckySantangelo35 · 03/09/2022 20:53

People on here are just outraged youre not completely martyring and sacrificing yourself to give your kids everything they want OP

mathanxiety · 03/09/2022 20:36

Wrt DD's birthday party:

Make a cake. Invite a few of her closest friends to your home for a movie night. Provide popcorn in fancy popcorn bags and m&ms and lemonade. Everyone goes home at 9pm. Job done, very little spent. Kids of 10 don't need a partypalooza involving the whole class.

mathanxiety · 03/09/2022 20:20

Yes - take him out until you qualify for the funding. Order your fortnightly deliveroo.

Lol at people wringing hands at the idea of sacrificing his development for the sake of a takeaway. Seriously?

How do you think children develop in countries where there are no nurseries or child minders around every corner? Where it's full time day are or nothing?

My DCs were home with me until age 4, when they went to preschool for 2.5 hours, four days a week. Their 'development' did not suffer, and no, I didn't spend a fortune on activities or outings. They watched TV, dug in mud, drew with crayons, went to mom and me gym and swim in the YMCA, and played with couch cushions and blanket forts and their toys. They played in the local playground when the weather wasn't too hot or too cold.

LuckySantangelo35 · 03/09/2022 20:16

rainbowmilk · 03/09/2022 20:09

On a serious note, I’d only take your DC out of nursery if it’s not going to interfere with your work or place a burden on your or your DH’s colleagues. Those without kids made a ton of allowances during lockdowns (parents had their hours halved on full pay but the work still needed doing) but the mood is definitely different now that childcare settings are open, living crisis or not.

Totally agree with this

rainbowmilk · 03/09/2022 20:09

On a serious note, I’d only take your DC out of nursery if it’s not going to interfere with your work or place a burden on your or your DH’s colleagues. Those without kids made a ton of allowances during lockdowns (parents had their hours halved on full pay but the work still needed doing) but the mood is definitely different now that childcare settings are open, living crisis or not.

rainbowmilk · 03/09/2022 20:04

SpicedAutumnPumpkin · 03/09/2022 18:22

Each to their own. Some methods of contraception also cost quite a bit of money though. So if you use lets say condoms, imagine how much money your household could have saved in a year without this expense.

P.s its a sarcasm because that's what this thread has turned into .

The danger of course being that by not spending on condoms you end up with the much more expensive alternative: a child. Best to avoid sex altogether!

WannabeMathematician · 03/09/2022 19:42

@user1496146479 Yes but I’m my case my employer chose not enforce that contract to retain staff during lock downs. They did offer everyone the option to temporarily cut their hours while the lock downs were on going and the nurseries and childminders were shut.

But it was clear when childcare opened up again that they expected us to use it. I’m a software developer so the job requires deep concentration so I can see why they don’t want toddlers distracting us.

User287264 · 03/09/2022 19:36

I'd take ds out of nursery if you can manage it with work. I guess it's a false economy if you then can't work properly and get sacked.

And keep having your takeaway every 2 weeks. We're having a takeaway tonight and I'm looking forward to it for the same sorts of reasons.

Quveas · 03/09/2022 19:35

BecauseICan22 · 03/09/2022 14:01

You're choosing a fortnightly takeaway over your sons development.

You could recreate your favourite takeaway at home. You and DH could cook it together after the kids have gone to bed.

Sorry, son. Mummy and Daddy need a takeaway more than you need socialisation and an education.

Nursery fees round your way must be very cheap if a years nursery cost the same as 24 takeaways. And just think of all those centuries worth of deprived people who never got any socialisation or education because there weren't nurseries for them. However did they manage?

OP, there is no right answer to this. Everyone has to cut their cloth according to their own lights. You won't die without your takeaways. Your child won't be socially and educationally damaged by missing a year of nursery.

Your only unreasonable action was being daft enough to ask the question here...

user1496146479 · 03/09/2022 19:23

WannabeMathematician · 03/09/2022 13:44

I think trying to juggle childcare, work and studying would eat into my sanity even more than no deliveroo.

But in all seriousness check your contracts/company hand book. Mine explicitly forbids looking after a child in work hours when working from home (though the phrasing is better). Could you look for a childminder which might be cheaper rather than keeping him home altogether?

@WannabeMathematician
Isn't this what everyone was doing during lockdowns?

Swipe left for the next trending thread