Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend will only pay me back if I allow her to live with me

306 replies

losca · 03/09/2022 13:19

Two years ago I gave my friend a loan of £4k as she was in a precarious financial situation having not been able to break her lease when her MSc came to an end as she had anticipated (she was screwed over by landlord so I was very sympathetic as I experienced similar).

In contrast, I was living at home (moved back in during Covid) and was able to save so more than happy to help. My dad basically convinced me to give up a few years of my life in order to get on the property ladder in London.

My friend has known my plan has always been to buy a house and use rent from housemates to cover the rent (wish I had never shared my bloody life plan with her now). My friend also knows roughly what the mortgage will be -- foolishly shared Rightmove link with her.

I've lost a lot of respect for her as she has far exceeded the date we agreed that she would pay me back by. Anyway, I'm really shocked that she has essentially said she will only be able to afford to pay be back if she moves into my new house (rent is far below market rate).

There's no way I want to live with her due to the way she has conducted herself but I really feel like she is blackmailing me. She has slagged me off to anyone who will listen and shared my every detail of finances - savings, salary etc. to mutual friends.

I drafted a contract (independent witness also signed) but I'm worried it's meaningless. I cannot afford to walk away from the money as I need to set up home with it.

OP posts:
TattiePants · 03/09/2022 14:44

She owes you £4k now but just think how much she’ll owe you if she moves in then stops paying rent.

Jibbajabba1 · 03/09/2022 14:44

Don’t move her in

Rosscameasdoody · 03/09/2022 14:44

losca · 03/09/2022 14:42

I was really hoping to avoid small claims litigation. Maybe it was wishful thinking but I thought there could be something I had overlooked (mumsnet actually supported me massively in getting my security deposit back a few years ago)

Looks like I'm left with no other option, unfortunately. I really have tried my best.

In that case before you embark on small claims procedure, can you get some legal advice on the contract you drew up, to see if that can be enforced ?

losca · 03/09/2022 14:44

how long did you give her to repay?

I offered a number of installment plans which she wasn't able to agree to.

OP posts:
tonicwaters · 03/09/2022 14:43

Just write off the loan and let her move in. You don't seem to see any other solution do you, despite all the advice here. Some people just have too much of a conscience, which is not a bad thing, but not at the expense of your future and your well being.

So you have some choices. Write off loan (inevitable). Refuse to take her on as a lodger/tenant, dismiss the views of your friends they are not relevant and are damaging you.

or, you can sub her the money, let her move in and for sure she will do your head in with excuses for not paying rent etc. But your friends will clap you on the back hurrah.

I could not be friends with anyone who would criticise my approach to things, especially where my approach is from my hard earned savings/work etc. and I am judged for not bailing out every waif and stray. Such friends rarely put their hands in their own pockets, but are very good at spending other people's money for them.

Do try to divest yourself of this leech and your friends, it's not worth it. You will be far happier and you will make more friends in time. Best of luck.

Cailleachian · 03/09/2022 14:43

[quote]

I'm pretty distraught and reluctant to be too aggressive as our friend group is pretty progressive and many are socialist leaning.

I personally believe it is immoral to exploit the human need for shelter so am happy to set rent at mortgage + bills.

I was very much on the fence about allowing her to move in as I do feel for her as she is struggling massively and the only reason I'm not is 100% down to luck. But agree who knows if she would even pay me rent?
[/quote]

Socialists are very vulnerable to manipulative and toxic people in my experience.

There is a degree of performative socialism, where someone who is mildly better off than someone else is expected to personally address wealth inequality, by personally transferring handing over money to another.

Socialists rightly condemn charity, as its an exploitation vector which shunts the problem to one side, while not addressing the issue, but charity is what she is seeking here.

Working class people often borrow money from one another.
But solidarity is paying it back. She had a number of ways she could have dealt with the situation - She could have waled away and taken a hit to her credit rating,, she could have taken out a crediit card, she could have done a crowdfunder. But because she had a personal connection to someone that was in the position to loan her money without the intrusion, implications and strength of enforcement action that a credit company has, she used that route.

You are now offering a non-profit making place in a houseshare, she is nabbing that generous opportunity that could have been a massive boost for someone who didnt have a pal who could lend them £4k in an emergency and are now working their socks off to pay their credit card bill.

What she is demanding is your charity, for you to become her benefactor. This is not a socialist arrangement, and thats worth pointing out if anyone starts attacking you as a spoilt rich landlord profiting from a poor foreign student who is about to become homeless.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/09/2022 14:42

She is not your friend. A friend would appreciate you lending them money when they needed it, and would be eager to pay it back ASAP.

Take her to small claims court - it’s relatively easy and cheap to do in comparison with the amount you stand to lose. Then cut her loose. If you allow her to basically blackmail you into letting her to move in with you (which is what this is) she will be a pain in the arse, you’ll never get your rent on time (if at all) and she’ll be really difficult to evict.

losca · 03/09/2022 14:42

I was really hoping to avoid small claims litigation. Maybe it was wishful thinking but I thought there could be something I had overlooked (mumsnet actually supported me massively in getting my security deposit back a few years ago)

Looks like I'm left with no other option, unfortunately. I really have tried my best.

OP posts:
WallaceinAnderland · 03/09/2022 14:42

There's left leaning and then there's leaning so far you are on the floor with a 'please walk over me' sign.

Fraaahnces · 03/09/2022 14:41

Why don’t you call her bluff? “If you continue to attempt to blackmail me by dangling the money you OWE me, I will not only share all the messages you have sent me admitting to this, and the contract you signed, but I will have no other option than to take you to court.”

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 03/09/2022 14:40

Neither a borrower nor a lender be...
Take her to small claims court. Well done for having it writing, Judge Rinder would be very happy!

Teaandtoastedbiscuits · 03/09/2022 14:40

This has nothing to do with your parents. They gave you very sound advice. Your problem us is that you care too much about what people who don't matter think. You need to get your money back through the court and don't give out anymore loans

Xpologog · 03/09/2022 14:39

Go straight to small claims before she leaves the country.

Hopeandlove · 03/09/2022 14:36

Do not let her move in she won’t pay rent or bills and she has already disrespected you - post factually in the group dear x I lent you this money y amount on these dates - you promised to pay it back. I need this money back and I’ve asked for it the following dates and times instead you have agreed to repay only if you live with me.

thid is not acceptable the loan was given in good faith. Where is my interest?

Coyoacan · 03/09/2022 14:34

One thing is socialism, another thing entirely is theft and blackmail.

Hopeandlove · 03/09/2022 14:34

losca · 03/09/2022 13:25

I sent a letter which she shared in a whatsapp group we're both in. She dangles the fact she will have to return to her home country (EU) over my head if she cannot afford to be in London.

She characterizes me as being money obsessed/spoilt - not true!

Ok how long did you give her to repay? In your letter. Screen shot everything. Then just do it online it’s easy upload your letters and all your evidence etc if she has admittedly she has taken the money she hadn’t got a leg to stand on. Court gives her 28 days to respond

Glittertwins · 03/09/2022 14:32

@FlipFlopShopInHawaii has it spot on

Mardyface · 03/09/2022 14:32

You're feeling guilty about being better off within the system than she is. You're not long term though. She has an EU passport which is worth more than your house long term probably. It's great to have principles but you should expect principles from others (eg keeping their word and not being a twat) too.

losca · 03/09/2022 14:31

I'd pay way more taxes to stop this from happening

So would I!

OP posts:
losca · 03/09/2022 14:29

I personally believe it is immoral to exploit the human need for shelter so am happy to set rent at mortgage + bills

I was very much on the fence about allowing her to move in as I do feel for her as she is struggling massively and the only reason I'm not is 100% down to luck. But agree who knows if she would even pay me rent?

Honestly, this entire situation makes me regret listening to my parents. I would never have saved that money to lend had I not moved back home and my mental state would be far better!

OP posts:
Mardyface · 03/09/2022 14:28

I am very left leaning too. It's a real shitshow that the system works to ensure those without means get less and those with get more. I'd pay way more taxes to stop this from happening. What I wouldn't do is let a very well educated 'friend' who is in a position to hoik her own pants up to a place that lets her fight that system from the inside steal money from me and basically tell me it's my fault/responsibility she did it. No.

You don't have to be aggressive but you should be assertive. The law is on your side but what will probably work better with your friends is that SHE agreed to pay the money back. Start shall claims without telling her so she can't move away to where she can't be found but your messages on the group chat should just refer to what she promised. Of course she can't move in with you though. She would have to sign a contract and you know she doesn't stick to those.

Heronwatcher · 03/09/2022 14:24

Do not let her move in. She won’t pay you back and you’ll have to evict her which will cost much more than £4k.
I agree, small claims court. Your contract is probably fine, you can create contracts orally. Send one message to the WhatsApp group explaining the situation and then leave it- true friends won’t believe her.

If you really can’t bear your friends to possibly hear about this then write the 4K off, but still don’t let her move in. And stop lending money and over sharing with her or any other friend- establish some firm boundaries. Socialism is not an excuse for piss-taking.

GoneWithTheWine1 · 03/09/2022 14:24

Also once it's been to small claims court, show your mutual friends what a dazzling catch of a friend she really is.

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/09/2022 14:23

JudithHarper · 03/09/2022 13:22

Send her a letter before action and take her to the small claims court.

She isn't your friend so get your money and cut her loose.

Absolutely

CAB can advise. She is not your friend she is an appalling person

GoneWithTheWine1 · 03/09/2022 14:23

She's a scruffy little rat, say nothing and take her to a small claims court.

You can prove by messages etc. i take it if no contract.

Do not be blackmailed by this person. They'll probably move in and expect to live rent/bill free!