Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask what your next move would be if you were Putin?

313 replies

Chowbellow · 03/09/2022 13:01

So. You're Putin. You rule a massive amount of people. You're ex KGB. You want to take over the world perhaps (or maybe just want to play!).
What is your next move now that the West is in crisis as you won't supply them with oil/gas?
Your people are dying but you've loads of people. You've invaded a non NATO country so you know they won't touch you.

OP posts:
blueshoes · 04/09/2022 14:28

PerkingFaintly · 04/09/2022 13:48

So to answer the OP's question: if I were Putin, I would be doing that. ^

Oh look, I already am.

@PerkingFaintly good one. I forgot Kaja Kallas' explanation of Putin's tactics at the start of the war, so thanks for reminding.

Yes, Putin has done just that. Straight out of the Russian playbook.

Lots of people have already fallen for Putin's manipulation and insidious misinformation campaign (including on mn) going by the victim blaming and ignoring the totally illegal and unspeakable suffering he has forced on Ukraine as a result of his tactics and holding the world to ransom on energy, food and nuclear threat.

itsgettingweird · 04/09/2022 14:21

PerkingFaintly · 03/09/2022 20:58

BTW, re another of the lines being spammed round by Putinists...

In case folk hadn't noticed, we're already in a multi-polar world.

With the growth of the BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) in addition to the powerful countries of the Middle East, the globe is already very much multi-polar.

What's wrong with this picture, for Putin, is that none of those poles is Russia.

He misses the old bi-polar days when there were only 2 superpowers, and Russia was one of them.

But again, this is something he can't really sell to aforementioned multiple poles. They don't need him in order to become powerful. But he needs them.
Hence all his cosying up to them and whataboutery.

That's interesting.

Thank you for those facts.

This thread is teaching me lots and I've always believed that whatever your views on someone's actions you have to understand their motivations to solve it.

Nolongerteaching · 04/09/2022 14:11

@PerkingFaintly

yes, absolutely about the Vasilov seed bank and the brave scientists who stayed with it but out of interest, we have surely replicated the contents of the seed bank somewhere?

Also, in terms of WW2 I don’t think we did recognise Russia’s contribution at the end of the war and this is so significant, isn’t it? I agree about the original motivation of Russia at the start but the country lost so many on the front, then was brutalised again under Stalin. I think we have to recognise that your analysis is one that we can recognise in the West but is removed from the experiences of the populace who saw the old eastern countries seemingly integrated into the west whilst they were still viewed with suspicion (unless they were Uber rich).

I don’t know

PerkingFaintly · 04/09/2022 13:48

So to answer the OP's question: if I were Putin, I would be doing that. ^

Oh look, I already am.

PerkingFaintly · 04/09/2022 13:45

Transcription of Kaja Kallas, the Estonian Prime Minister:

Russia is making the demands. Russia is threatening. And now if we think: “Oh let’s offer them something, then they actually get something that they didn’t have before.”

And I’ve quoted this foreign minister, Alexei [should be Andrei] Gromyko, a Soviet-time foreign minister, several times, who said about the negotiation tactics of the Soviet Union, three things:

First, demand the maximum. Do not ask, but demand something that has never been yours.

Second, present ultimatums. You know, threaten.

And third, do not give one inch in negotiations, because there will always be people in the West who offer you something.

And then in the end, you will have one-third or even one half of something you didn’t have before. So we have to keep that in mind all the time.

twitter.com/munsecconf/status/1512451999622643714

PerkingFaintly · 04/09/2022 13:29

Shortly before Putin's invasion of Ukraine, Estonian prime minister Kaja Kallas described perfectly the Russians' classic negotiation technique:
twitter.com/munsecconf/status/1512451999622643714

PerkingFaintly · 04/09/2022 13:19

Good lord there's some ahistorical nonsense on this thread.

I've never forgotten the Soviet Union were our allies in WW2 – and I've never forgotten the rest of it, either.

The Soviet Union wasn't fighting for us by any stretch of the imagination. It was fighting for itself, and that only after Nazi Germany invaded it.

Before then, in 1939, Stalin's Soviet Union signed a non-aggression pact with Nazi Germany. The pact wasn't just "don't invade us and we won't invade you", it included "and we Nazis won't mind if you, Stalin, annex some of your neighbours". And by 1940 the Stalinist Soviet Union had done just that: annexing Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Finland, parts of Romania and parts of Poland, including carrying out the Katyn Massacre (which decapitated Polish society because it targeted the most educated).

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molotov–Ribbentrop_Pact
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katyn_massacre

Of course the pact wasn't worth the paper it was written on. Hitler just used it to keep Stalin off his back while he was overstretched elsewhere – then invaded the Soviet Union at a time of his convenience in 1941.

At the end of WW2, Stalin cemented Soviet control of the annexed neighbouring countries to create a communist superpower. When the population voted with its feet and left, the state machine gunned them. The Soviets built the Berlin Wall to keep Soviet Bloc citizens in, not to keep foreigners out.

The people of the Soviet Union suffered unspeakably during WWII. They then suffered unspeakably after WWII. More than 14 million people were sent to gulags (forced labour camps) over the decades before and after the war.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Stalin#Post-war_era_and_death
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulag

One of the things (among many) that's really upset me about Putin's invasion of Ukraine has been the Russian shelling of the national seed bank (Yuriev Plant Production Institute), which is a global treasure.
www.euronews.com/green/2022/08/06/ukraines-national-seed-bank-is-still-standing-but-could-be-lost-forever-warn-scientists

It's a betrayal of the heroic dedication and sacrifice of the Russian scientists in WW2 who gave their lives to protect the Petersburg seed bank (Vavilov Institute of Plant Industry) during the Siege of Leningrad.

www.opindia.com/2022/01/the-siege-of-leningrad-russian-scientists-starved-themselves-to-death-to-preserve-vavilov-seed-bank/

The Russian people I could cry for, as for those of Ukraine. But rewriting history to make the pore lil Russian state a victim of those meanie westerners doesn't help the Russian people at all.

itsgettingweird · 04/09/2022 13:05

I think that there are perspectives in every argument and we don't hear their perspective so we can't understand their behaviour if we haven't even heard their side.

I'm a little shocked actually that I'm so ignorant of a lot of their history with the West.

This.

If I was Putin I'd want people to try and understand my motivations so we can meet in the middle.

I'd want people to realise my own propaganda is as valid as their own and realise all countries are using propaganda.

As an English person myself - writing as a MNer - I fear how much Russia use death as a weapon against those who deflect - and I don't agree with Putins actions because I'm against war - but I feel to understand his motives helps me rationalise it.

itsgettingweird · 04/09/2022 13:03

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 03/09/2022 19:18

I'd just carry on as is and settle in for a war of attrition.

Russia has the resources to outlast Ukraine but, more crucially if they keep access to their oil, gas, wheat, cooper, steel, etc restricted to allies/neutral nations, they will probably be able force Western Europe into backing down.

I think winter will be the turning point. Russians are far better equipped to deal with hardship than the spoiled soft populations of the West. The Ukrainians will continue to fight to the end but one difficult winter will be enough to erode support in Western Europe to the point there will be internal pressure to settle things.

At that poing I'd look to negotiate for Ukraine to become a Russian territory but would settle for the Donbas and Crimea becoming officially Russian instead. I'd also demand an agreement that there will be no more NATO expansion or that Russia be allowed to join NATO (which was previously denied).

Yes.

And Russia experiences freezing winters every year.

They have the infrastructure and resources.

The west don't.

We are walking blind into something we don't know the future of because of a long standing hatred between Russia and the west.

But we know Russia are militarily strong.

Without them the west wouldn't have won the war.

whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 12:13

Oh, it’s also salient to consider how Russia views herself. It’s hard to shorthand, but a country’s art is often illuminating. Here are a few stanzas from a translated poem by Aleksandr Blok. It’s not a great poem, Blok himself didn’t actually like it particularly, but it gives some insight as to self image and national myth:

“You are but millions. Our unnumbered nations
Are as the sands upon the sounding shore.
We are the Scythians!
Try to wage war with us—you'll try no more!

You've had whole centuries. We—a single hour.
Like serfs obedient to their feudal lord,
We've held the shield between two hostile powers—
Old Europe and the barbarous Mongol horde.”

allpoetry.com/The-Scythians

haven’t posted one of the racially wince-inducing lines from the excerpt, but FYI they are there in the poem if anyone wants to click on the link.

whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 11:51

I do not believe he wants to restore the Soviet Union. It was an economically stagnant monolith. I do think he wants to reestablish a sphere to influence. I don’t believe this will be achieved through military engagement, but corruption from within (the latter we see already). Conventional warfare is expensive, and an outside threat usually unites people against the aggressor. The way to break a country apart is to turn the people against one another and exploit this.

Ukraine is different to the Baltic states. Russia as it is now, was born from Kievan Rus’. There’s an idea that it is rightfully Russian, a region rather than a separate country. Outside of sentiment, it’s a buffer zone, was the breadbasket of the Soviet Union, is rich in natural resources, is a conduit for gas, and provides access to central and Western Europe as well as a warm water port.

Some of it is a restoration of national pride/Russia’s role as a power player on the world stage. He wants revenge on those that wrote Russia off and a non entity when the USSR collapsed.

i also don’t think it’s just Putin that should be looked at, but also what, or who, is behind him. Russia has been building and strengthening economic and political ties with China and India for quite a few years now. To what degree is he acting as a surrogate, distraction, and/or weapon?

Right now he’s doing something simple but effective in turning off the gas. People WILL start turning against supporting Ukraine as they suffer from this. They will start pressuring politicians to reverse course, and they will reverse course because they don’t want their own governments destabilized.

I think he will continue to dig in with the Ukraine war, and wait it out. I think there’s a lot of propaganda being shared in all presses, for reasons of shoring up support and morale, as such it’s hard to determine what the true picture is of how it’s playing out. Either way, in war, tides can and do turn. It’s early days.

LittleFluffyCloudz · 04/09/2022 10:10

With regards to the west - divide and conquer. I will threaten nuclear conflict but ultimately want to avoid it - that is a game with no winner. Why attack the west directly when don't need to? I can inflict economic damage, sow seeds of suspicion and dissention between allies, distract and divide without incurring any losses.

I've been watching / reading things with an East German theme recently. The Stasi were close comrades of the KGB. I've been watching / reading and thinking Putin.

Digita · 04/09/2022 10:09

SkirridHill · 03/09/2022 21:13

Do you know what Terry Pratchett said about people who use too many exclamation marks? Same rules apply with question marks.

That’s brilliant lol 😂

itsgettingweird · 04/09/2022 10:07

DrawingdowntheMoon · 03/09/2022 18:34

"I’d want Russia’s pride for our input in WW2 to be acknowledged. ThecWest could start by putting up memorials to Russia’s WW2 dead in our military cemeteries."

Now that isn't a bad idea.

As many as 27 million Soviets lost their lives, with as many as 11.4 million military deaths joined by up to 10 million civilian deaths due to military activity and an additional 8 million to 9 million deaths due to famine and disease.

People seem to forget that Russia was our ally in WW2

They do.

Any many analysis reports from WW2 actually state we only won because of their input.

And this is it isn't it? Our poor relationship with Russia goes back 75 odd years. Pretty much Putins lifetime.

He will have learnt a different history to us his whole life. Not different but obviously you learn your countries bias. By us always assuming he's wrong because of his actions we are part of the problem of resolution.

Great idea above by starting to offer memorials to those who lost their lives fighting for us - The west.

I don't agree with Putin or his actions but everyone knows behaviour is communication and if we ignore what he's saying there is no resolution that isn't military.

Digita · 04/09/2022 10:03

@LittleMissLaundry ”Internationally i shall do my best to forge closer bonds of friendship with my allies like China”

Such as war games events?

Apparently something that tends to happen anyway every 4 years. But still even more terrifying given what’s been happening in Ukraine.

Russia starts massive war games with China and other ally states

Putin Brings China and India to Russia for War Games Defying US

Putin to attend war games with China and other allied nations, expert warns of 'dangerous' time
Russia expert warns Moscow and Beijing could be planning a 'surprise' during drills like a simulated nuclear weapons release.

Maybe he only meant Ukraine when he started out, like how Hitler only meant Poland. But the backlash and sanctions from the Western powers leads to a more widespread war. And that’s scary.

I do think there’s a real potential for world war 3 and that one maybe the end game.

Isitsixoclockalready · 04/09/2022 09:59

What Putin really fears are functioning democracies - especially big ones - right on his doorstep.

LittleFluffyCloudz · 04/09/2022 09:56

SquirrelSoShiny · 03/09/2022 13:31

My fantasy is that he has a sudden attack of conscience, realises he's basically a low tech Dr Evil and gives himself one of those accidental falls his oil tycoons keep having.

My fantasy is that he has a sudden heart attack.

I'm on holiday in Portugal at the moment and their are loads of Russians here. I'm biting my tongue.

Isitsixoclockalready · 04/09/2022 09:56

This has already been played out in hundreds of articles online. You only have to Google 'Putin'.

itsgettingweird · 04/09/2022 09:53

PinkyU · 03/09/2022 13:51

If I’m Putin I want the same respect (through fear) that Russia had back in the glory days of the Cold War.

I want retribution for Russia being left behind after WW2 given the massive part played in helping the allied forces win and recognition of the substantial loses of life and economy. I want financial remuneration.

I would recognise that the only only way to achieve this is to firstly cripple Europe then threaten the world with nuclear war.

That's very interesting and o think your second paragraph is a fair enough wish.

But I think Putins mindset means his means outstrip what are acceptable gains.

itsgettingweird · 04/09/2022 09:51

Fallonangel · 03/09/2022 13:39

I watched a documentary about him a few months back. He has planned this since he was security for Gorbachev. He manipulated Gorbachev to back his presidency and then didn't even thank him. It was filmed live and if you watch you will see the expression on Gorbachevs face. He realised he had been played.
Putin is an absolute dictator. People are pawns not humans.
He has every trait of a true psychopath.

What documentary was this?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/09/2022 09:47

Thanks @blueshoes !

blueshoes · 04/09/2022 03:07

Chowbellow · 03/09/2022 20:33

The way Putin works is that he does something and then UTTERLY POINT BLANK DENIES IT.
What is to stop him accidentally sending a missile into London and then going WOOPSY - MY BAD!

OP, are you a one-trick pony?

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing I like the cut of your jib.

Chowbellow · 03/09/2022 23:30

MyMumSaysALot · 03/09/2022 23:18

You’ve got it wrong - as usual - as always.
It’s me - Merrick. And you’re in a heap of trouble.

Nah, these plebs haven't a clue what we're doing here..... mwahahahaha. *strokes fluffy white cat

OP posts:
MyMumSaysALot · 03/09/2022 23:18

Chowbellow · 03/09/2022 23:03

Yeay Vlad! How are you?

You’ve got it wrong - as usual - as always.
It’s me - Merrick. And you’re in a heap of trouble.

Chowbellow · 03/09/2022 23:03

MyMumSaysALot · 03/09/2022 22:49

Is that you, Donald?

Yeay Vlad! How are you?

OP posts: