Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask what your next move would be if you were Putin?

313 replies

Chowbellow · 03/09/2022 13:01

So. You're Putin. You rule a massive amount of people. You're ex KGB. You want to take over the world perhaps (or maybe just want to play!).
What is your next move now that the West is in crisis as you won't supply them with oil/gas?
Your people are dying but you've loads of people. You've invaded a non NATO country so you know they won't touch you.

OP posts:
PerkingFaintly · 04/09/2022 19:22

Chowbellow, do you feel able to say which country you're in/from when talking about "here" and "we"?

You said earlier that you're not from the UK, and it is making your posts quite confusing. Eg you talked earlier about "us" killing Russians, however the UK is not killing Russians.

Similarly, there's plenty of coverage in the UK mainstream media of eg Maganov's "fall from a window", and none I've seen suggests any acceptance of the official Russian line.

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 19:00

Is there a media blackout or something which prevents mainstream media outlets in the Uk from surmising?

OP posts:
Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 18:56

@whumpthereitis Thanks for that. I think that we all know that Russia issues warnings along with every cartel in Mexico etc. He will deny it while also knowing that everyone else knows that it's a warning. The suicides are typical of him (KGB), of MI6, of the CIA. We can't pretend that any of our countries are beyond reproach in that regard. It's interesting though that he managed to corale the mercenaries to take the gangs off the streets. Over here, we don't hear their history, we don't get their news. You have to read between lines. I mean seriously, who believes that an oil magnate in Russia falls out of his window accidentally? Our media never questions it though - they simply report that he fell out of a fucking window? That's what flabbergasts me! Why, are we, who have free press (allegedly) not reporting on anything but the facts? I don't get it.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 18:37

In terms of Russia and Democracy, Russia is a country with no real democratic tradition, and no democratic infrastructure. There was an appetite for it when the Soviet Union collapsed, but it was horribly mismanaged to the point that the experience put people off it in favour of the devil they knew: the strong autocrat.

I’m copying and pasting what I wrote in the Russian windows thread about what the oligarch assassinations mean, as well as context as to what the Oligarchs actually are:

it’s hard to explain just how bad Russia was in the 90s. We’re talking massive homelessness, severe food shortages, people walking up to cars in rush hour traffic and blowing up a car, dead bodies with their heads shot off washing up on river banks daily, rival bratva members suddenly appearing in a busy street and shooting at each other with AKs. Good luck if you were just going about your business and trying to scrape together a semblance of living. What little you had you were required to pay protection fees with, lest you and your family become a target (as opposed to just merely being caught in the crossfire). Meanwhile, the Oligarchs are building their wealth off that. Is the average Russian going to spare sympathy or tears for an oligarch? Of course not, why on earth would they?


When Putin came along, he cut deals and took it off the streets. Of course it still existed, but the average person can accept that if the alternative is what they already lived through.

——————
To get where they were, in Russia, means they have their own share of blood on their hands, and lots of it. It’s one branch of the mafia targeting the other in order to assert dominance. Shit versus shit.

——————
Lukoil was the only energy company in Russia that spoke out against the war. The former President, Alekperov, resigned a week after sanctions were announced. I have no idea where he is currently but you can bet his security are on hyper alert currently.


No one was genuinely supposed to believe this was an accident. It’s a warning shot, aimed at Alekperov and/or any other Oligarchs that have any notions of deposing him.


Long story short is that the Oligarchs collected their wealth in the 90s, following the fall of the Soviet Union and during a period of free-for-all gangster capitalism under Yeltsin. This essentially put them in control of the newly born Russian Federation, although they were loathed within the country. They were a problem for Putin, so he cut a deal with them. They could keep what they had, they just had to bend the proverbial knee and know their place. Abramovich, for example, agreed to this. Berezovsky (you may know the name in regards to Aleksandr Litvinenko) did not. Berezovsky ‘committed suicide’.


Even bought to heel as they were, they still have enormous influence. The western press openly pondered the possibility of the Oligarchs, angry at the sanctions of the seizure of their assets, getting rid of Putin (I suspect this may have been, at least in part, motivation for the sanctions on the first place). If the western press thought it, you can bet your ass Putin did.


Maganov is the tenth ‘mystery death’ of prominent Russian Oligarchs this year, the second from Lukoil. Most have been from Gazprom. He’s cleaning house in regards to the energy sector. It may be that a plot was uncovered, and it may be to send a message to remind them to watch their step. It may be both.

whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 18:24

*Nation

whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 18:23

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 18:19

Cornwall were Celts I think. The rest of England were Angla-Saxon and invaded by Romans but Cornwall held strong somehow? I may be wrong on this.

I’d have to do some more reading on that area of history but yes, Cornwall is one of the Celtic nations, whereas the English are Anglo Saxon.

Basically Russians and Ukrainians are both Slavic nations with a long shared history that dates back to Kievan Rus’. Ukraine spent many centuries as part of other countries rather than a national in it’s own right, and the country it was part of for the longest period was Russia and then the Soviet Union. Ukraine as we know it now emerged following the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 18:19

Cornwall were Celts I think. The rest of England were Angla-Saxon and invaded by Romans but Cornwall held strong somehow? I may be wrong on this.

OP posts:
Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 18:18

whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 18:17

I’m trying to think of a parallel. Imagine if Cornwall was an independent nation, and the rest of England opposed that.

I believe that happened!

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 18:17

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 18:12

Ok, so in terms that I understand it's like the UK conquering Ireland and not understanding why the Irish people wanted to be independent?

I’m trying to think of a parallel. Imagine if Cornwall was an independent nation, and the rest of England opposed that.

whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 18:14

And yes, Ukraine has its own shady ties with Oligarchs behind the scenes, it has issues when it comes to corruption. And Putin is correct when he speaks of a Nazism problem there. He is also correct when he says that Ukraine have committed war crimes against civilians in Donetsk and Donbas. What he’s overlooking is a Nazism problem within the borders of Russia. What he’s overlooking is the war crimes Russia has committed against Ukraine.

www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2014/10/eastern-ukraine-conflict-summary-killings-misrecorded-and-misreported/

I do think there is a problem with reducing conflicts to absolute good versus absolute evil, and to either pretend there are no issues with the side you happen to support, or to find excuses for them. Unfortunately you end up with both sides doing that, becoming entrenched in their viewpoints while civilians pay the price.

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 18:12

Ok, so in terms that I understand it's like the UK conquering Ireland and not understanding why the Irish people wanted to be independent?

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 18:02

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:56

Thank you for that interpretation. I suppose it's like the Commonwealth then? If you've conquered a place previously, then it's yours? Mind you I don't think Russia conquered nations all over the world, just neighbouring territiories. Sincere thanks though for fact-checking it.

Hmm. I'm not sure what to think now.
I'm from a nation that the UK conquered and I don't like it so I understand how Ukraine feels pissed off. However, my nation was never part of the indigenous people of the UK if you get me?

Those parts that he talks about, were they 'indigenous' to Russia?

It’s hard to say what’s indigenous to Russia, because Russia is made up of so many different people and cultures. It’s also made up of lands that have changed hands so many times. The first proto Slavic state though was Kievan Rus’, and that is what Putin is basing his claim on.

whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 17:58

He’s not a toddler. A psychopath and toddler may be alike in that they both lack empathy, but there is where the comparisons end. A toddler is driven by emotion and instinct. A successful psychopath is rational, he can outthink and outmaneuver. I think this is where respect comes in. If you don’t respect someone you invariably end up underestimating them, and there is a danger in that. A huge one. I do not like Putin. My father is Russian, and my grandmother Ukrainian. My father will not return to Russia, and neither will I. Respecting someone for the power they hold and the threat they pose does not mean you like, approve of, or admire them.

Putin miscalculates, but he isn’t stupid. At all. He’s a former lieutenant colonel of the KGB, so he knows all the tricks of that trade. He also knows countermeasures and ways to ensure his own security. Not foolproof of course, but close enough.

He’s a typical strongman of the Russian tradition. I don’t think he wants to rule the world, but he does want power over his sphere of influence (I.e Warsaw Pact countries). He wants Russia to be a power in the world, and he wants a legacy.

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:56

whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 17:47

In part, but some of it comes down to pragmatism. He needs a back up plan in order to shore up the Russian economy, in light of damaged trade relations with the west. It comes down to not keeping all your eggs in one basket.

From skim reading his rant, I don’t see any glaring historical error. The conclusions he draws are sympathetic to Russian interests, but the history itself seems correct. Ukraine was born from Kievan Rus’, which was destroyed by the Mongol horde. It re-emerged as territory divided and exchanged between Russia, the Polish-Lithuanian commonwealth, the Austrian and Ottoman Empires. Next came the Cossack Hetmanate, following an uprising against the Polish-Lithuanian commonwealth by the Zaporizhian host. The Cossacks historically originated from around the river Don and the Steppe. Poland and Russia fought over the area and it eventually became part of the Russian Empire. It was briefly independent in 1917, but became part of the Soviet Union and one of the founding SSR states. Following the end of WW2 part of Poland was indeed given to the Ukraine, and you see this divide between the western catholic areas, and the Eastern Orthodox ones. Similarly the Crimea, taken and settled by Russia in a war against the Ottomans, was gifted to Ukraine by Khrushchev.

^that’s a lot of simplification, but an overview.

There is a lot of of overlap when it comes to the Russian and Ukrainian. A lot of shared history and blood. Putin’s belief is that this means Russia has a right to Ukraine, rather than it having a right to self determination. So while his history seems correct, the issue is the conclusions he draws from it.

Thank you for that interpretation. I suppose it's like the Commonwealth then? If you've conquered a place previously, then it's yours? Mind you I don't think Russia conquered nations all over the world, just neighbouring territiories. Sincere thanks though for fact-checking it.

Hmm. I'm not sure what to think now.
I'm from a nation that the UK conquered and I don't like it so I understand how Ukraine feels pissed off. However, my nation was never part of the indigenous people of the UK if you get me?

Those parts that he talks about, were they 'indigenous' to Russia?

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 04/09/2022 17:47

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 16:42

I think his allegiance with China is because 'my enemy's enemy is my friend'.

China hates the West. He doesn't like China I suspect. But they have a common enemy. Us.

In part, but some of it comes down to pragmatism. He needs a back up plan in order to shore up the Russian economy, in light of damaged trade relations with the west. It comes down to not keeping all your eggs in one basket.

From skim reading his rant, I don’t see any glaring historical error. The conclusions he draws are sympathetic to Russian interests, but the history itself seems correct. Ukraine was born from Kievan Rus’, which was destroyed by the Mongol horde. It re-emerged as territory divided and exchanged between Russia, the Polish-Lithuanian commonwealth, the Austrian and Ottoman Empires. Next came the Cossack Hetmanate, following an uprising against the Polish-Lithuanian commonwealth by the Zaporizhian host. The Cossacks historically originated from around the river Don and the Steppe. Poland and Russia fought over the area and it eventually became part of the Russian Empire. It was briefly independent in 1917, but became part of the Soviet Union and one of the founding SSR states. Following the end of WW2 part of Poland was indeed given to the Ukraine, and you see this divide between the western catholic areas, and the Eastern Orthodox ones. Similarly the Crimea, taken and settled by Russia in a war against the Ottomans, was gifted to Ukraine by Khrushchev.

^that’s a lot of simplification, but an overview.

There is a lot of of overlap when it comes to the Russian and Ukrainian. A lot of shared history and blood. Putin’s belief is that this means Russia has a right to Ukraine, rather than it having a right to self determination. So while his history seems correct, the issue is the conclusions he draws from it.

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:45

Cooperation with keeping Putin in time-out might work?

OP posts:
Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:39

I'm under no illusions. He's very definitely a psychopath (I'm now waiting to fall out of my balcony lol). But if we can't understand the cunt, how can we defeat him? How can we cooperate with him? Cooperation doesn't appear to be something he does well. It's the equivalent of trying to manage a defiant toddler. You can put them in the bold corner but if they refuse to apologise, what the fuck do you do then? Toddlers are little psychopaths. Teenagers incidentally 'profile' as psychopaths. Lol. I think we need Supernanny or something.

OP posts:
PerkingFaintly · 04/09/2022 17:33

We've held the shield between two hostile powers—
Old Europe and the barbarous Mongol horde.”

Yes, absolutely. This is a part of the Russian mythos that Putin has tapped into extremely effectively.

He's gained great leverage out of the rise of Islamist violence and playing "your enemy's enemy is your friend". It's been extremely effective for him, particularly marked by his successes with US National Security Advisor Director Mike Flynn (later pardoned by Trump).

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Flynn

(The sheer brutality of Putin's war against Chechnya has long been a recruiting point for violent Islamists, of course, but that's too long to go into here.)

Of course the whole narrative involves Putin portraying himself as the bulwark against “those barbaric monsters who torture men, rape women, kill children and take over your country”.

Bit awkward for him to keep up when his forces – official Russian military, Wagner Group, and Kadyrovites – are the barbaric monsters who have tried to take over another country and have horrifically raped, tortured and murdered its citizens, not least in the Bucha atrocities.

Ukraine launches hunt for Russian soldiers accused of Bucha war crimes
www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-61269480

Bucha killings: Satellite image of bodies site contradicts Russian claims
www.bbc.co.uk/news/60981238

en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bucha_massacre&oldid=1108363393

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kadyrovites

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:32

The UK left the EU. We're not into unions either. Can we really blame him for being the same?

OP posts:
Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:29

I think Winter will change our stance on things as every government will be under severe political pressure from their citizens to at least be able to afford to live.

OP posts:
Liebig · 04/09/2022 17:22

The EU is the biggest proponent of neoliberalism outside the US. It’s very existence is a “we will rule just as every major economic power has”: thru our markets and economic clout. They have a commanding share of the global order, so this is no different to people saying the USA isn’t an empire as they don’t call themselves such. But they are most assuredly an imperial power to contend with.

The UK simply cannot rule, even if it had plans. The resources required were frittered away as the empire declined, and it’s much easier to takeover territories to service the imperial core when everyone is barely out of agrarian society. Little trickier when the likes of Pakistan have nukes.

As for Putin, I would definitely be focusing on getting the BRICs basket of currencies or single currency system up and running ASAP and nudging such nations towards exports being in such currency. For the Ukraine situation, it’s looking like more attrition is going to happen, so mobilisation may be the political poison pill to swallow now and get done with it.

Going into winter, it will be a better time to press an advantage against the NATO resolve and make sure the civilians appreciate how precarious their lifestyles are without cheap energy.

Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:17

We have to recognise how he views the West, how he views democracy, how he views imperialism etc. etc. British are Imperialist. It's a strange one. If I wasn't facing into a winter of discontent, I would find the psychology fascinating. It's more pressing though.

OP posts:
Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:13

I think essentially that some styles of governance want to rule the world. The EU, the US. Union is the common word. United States. European Union.

Putin doesn't seem to like that world order. In his mind, I think, you need someone who understands your history to be a leader. Cooperation is not his MO. The US and the EU and NATO all rely on cooperation. Putin appears to view this with disdain. I think that when you've been a proud people, cooperation is fine, so long as it doesn't weaken your status. I think we've never understood him. Does the US want to rule the world? Yes. Does China? Yes. Does Russia? Yes. Does the EU? No. Does the UK? Yes.

OP posts:
Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:04

Close Menu
Podcasts
Newsletters
Articles
Events
Store
About
Bulwark+
Search

The Bulwark
JOIN BULWARK+
PODCASTS NEWSLETTERS ARTICLES EVENTS STORE ABOUT BULWARK+

SEARCH FOLLOW THE BULWARK ON TWITTER THE BULWARK ON SNAPCHAT THE BULWARK FACEBOOK THE BULWARK INSTAGRAMTHE BULWARK YOUTUBE
RUSSIA
Putin Announced His Manifesto Against the West Fifteen Years Ago. His Story Hasn’t Changed.
Even after a decade and a half of consideration and reassurance, Putin still complains that his interests are being ignored.
by DANIEL FATA
FEBRUARY 7, 2022 5:30 AM
Putin Announced His Manifesto Against the West Fifteen Years Ago. His Story Hasn’t Changed.
(Photo by Adam Berry/Getty Images)
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email Print
Fifteen years ago this week, Russian President Vladimir Putin delivered a vitriolic speech at the Munich Security Conference in which he denounced the United States as a hyperbolic superpower, challenged Europe to reexamine security institutions across the continent, and questioned the rationale for expanding NATO. Sound familiar? On the fifteenth anniversary of his manifesto, as the world sits on the precipice of yet another conflict in Ukraine, Putin has dusted off the same talking points and the same demands, announcing last week that once again “fundamental Russian interests were ignored.” And just as the Bush administration did a decade and a half ago, the Biden administration is engaging in a series of talks which, while likely leading nowhere, are validating Putin’s bad behavior and giving him a bigger presence on the world stage than he deserves.

Founded more than fifty years ago, the Munich Security Conference has grown into a major annual event attended by world leaders, American and European defense ministers, parliamentarians from both sides of the Atlantic, journalists, policy experts, and more. The conference was, for decades, the place where U.S. defense secretaries reinforced America’s security commitment to Europe and occasionally chided their counterparts about contributing more to transatlantic security.

But on February 10, 2007, Putin’s litany of grievances disrupted this pattern, transforming the conference into a launch party for a resurgent Russia. The blockbuster tirade led to a series of diplomatic discussions and high-level “strategic framework” meetings that were, while interesting, ultimately fruitless—the same kind of meetings which are being repeated now to address the Ukraine crisis.

U.S. and European policies leading up to the February 2007 conference provided Putin useful material for his rant. In the months preceding the conference, the Bush administration in concert with America’s European allies was pursuing multiple, concurrent policies intended to strengthen transatlantic security. Bulgaria and Romania had agreed to host U.S. forces. NATO was close to extending membership invitations to Albania, Croatia, and Macedonia, having invited seven nations of Central and Eastern Europe to join in 2002. NATO had also made the decision to take over responsibility for the entirety of Afghanistan via the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) mission. As the Alliance began preparations for its April 2008 summit in Bucharest, its members were discussing whether and how to draw Georgia and Ukraine closer. And, the month before the conference, newly minted Secretary of Defense Robert Gates had made the decision to place the “third site” of the nation’s missile defense system on the territory of some of NATO’s newest members in Central and Eastern Europe.

To Putin, these policies provided a way to portray Moscow as the victim of U.S.-led dominion in Europe with scant regard for Russia’s interests. Another Russian leader might have smiled on developments that brought democracy, rule of law, and free markets closer to a Russia struggling with long-term economic stresses, crumbling infrastructure, and declining demographics. Putin saw them are threats to his rule. Instead of seeing NATO’s ISAF mission as an opportunity for cooperation against the common threat of Islamic extremism, Putin portrayed it as NATO destabilizing his “near abroad.”

Podcast episode cover image
PODCAST · SEPTEMBER 02 2022
Mitch Daniels: Raised Four Wonderful Daughters and Fixed the BMV
Purdue President Mitch Daniels joins guest host Mona Charen to talk about loan forgiveness, negative…
No one in the U.S. delegation or the international audience was prepared for what Putin would unload over nearly 45 minutes. The strident Russian president spent the majority of his speech and the following Q&A period railing against the Bush administration, staring down Gates and the U.S. congressional delegation led by Sen. John McCain throughout. He criticized the United States for being arrogant, for its “uncontained hyper use of force,” for having “overstepped its national borders in every way,” and for not adhering to the rule of law. He called America out for its policies on missile defense. He criticized NATO actions in Kosovo.

For the first two-thirds of the speech, which focused on castigating the United States, many of the Europeans in the audience were disturbingly open to Putin’s message. I remember sitting with the rest of the American delegation, seeing agreeable expressions and nods of approval from our European friends and allies.

But the Europeans’ trance broke when Putin redirected his ire toward the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE). He claimed the organization was being transformed into a “vulgar instrument designed to promote the foreign policy interests of one or a group of countries,” paying insufficient attention to “relations between the spheres,” and making states “dependent and, as a consequence, politically and economically unstable.” This naked paranoia startled the Europeans. It made them concerned that Putin had bigger ambitions about transforming Europe, and that his rant was not only about President Bush and his policies, but about Europe and the institutions that keep it free and peaceful. The unease was palpable—the Europeans were happy to criticize American leadership, but deeply suspicious of any plan to replace the institutions it supported.

Putin’s remarks and Gates’s response—“one Cold War was quite enough”—led to a yearlong effort known as the “2+2 talks,” with Gates and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and their Russian counterparts trying to define areas of cooperation, such as counterterrorism and nonproliferation, and trying to soothe areas of contention, such as missile defense and military deployments in Europe. Yet despite honest attempts at good relations, the issue of NATO membership for Ukraine and Georgia loomed over the discussions as neither side was willing to accept the other’s position.

Putin’s Munich speech was a watershed moment in Russia’s relations with the free world. It made many in Europe aware of the danger Putin represented, but it also created division among them (and among Americans) about how to respond to Moscow. It put the United States in the lead position for engagement with Putin about his concerns and grievances. And it served as the manifesto for the revanchism Putin has pursued ever since. Perhaps the biggest and most lasting effect of Putin’s speech was the reaction it generated from the West, which sought to engage him and reason away his concerns. This helped to legitimate his grievances and his desire to be treated as the leader of a great power.

Since 2007, Putin has remained intent on shaping political and security developments in Russia’s periphery. He wants to be seen as a necessary player on the world stage. He wants Russia to be seen as global power whose approval must be sought. As he said at Munich and many times thereafter, he seeks to reestablish Russian influence in the world.

Successive U.S. administrations and European governments have failed to convince Putin that he could have more influence by playing a constructive, cooperative role than a destructive, antagonistic one. His country’s forces wreaked havoc in Georgia in 2008 and Ukraine since 2014, splintering the territory of both nations and launching disinformation campaigns which have degraded their democratic processes (and those of other democracies as well). Putin and his cronies have paid relatively little compared to what damage they have been able to inflict militarily, psychologically, and diplomatically on millions of people.

With potential violence and devastation an order of magnitude greater than anything Europe has seen since World War II awaiting only Putin’s order, the Biden administration is again engaging in strategic framework talks with Russia, entertaining Moscow’s grievances and revisionist fantasies. Thankfully, United States and Europe have rejected Putin’s proposals, which essentially amount to a do-over of the Cold War. No doubt, talking is better than fighting, but the cost of talking is legitimizing Putin’s quest for dominion over Russia’s neighbors, as if that were the kind of thing about which the United States could or should negotiate.

For the most part, the collective position the transatlantic community has taken has been the right one: There needs to be an unambiguous message to Putin that any hostile actions by Russia against Ukraine will be met with consequences. For this threat to be seen as real and enforceable, NATO, the European Union, and individual European nations must be unified in their willingness to impose penalties on Russia for yet another attempt at disrupting peace and redrawing borders in Europe.

The United States and Europe have an opportunity to learn from past ineffective engagements with Putin and have this round turn out differently. Ideally, American and Europe’s leaders would adopt a stronger position of deterrence regarding Russia’s new offensive in Ukraine so as to make the penalties so severe that they force those around Putin to calculate the cost and benefits.

Putin told the world at Munich fifteen years ago that he has a narrative of how the West wronged his country, and he has used that story to appeal to the Russian people and to satisfy his need for validation, legitimacy, and special treatment. Taking his insecurities and Cold War nostalgia seriously gives him what he wants. By making clear that the consequences of aggressive action in Ukraine will be severe international political, economic, and military isolation would hit Putin where it matters.

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share via email
Print
Daniel Fata
Daniel Fata is the former deputy assistant secretary of defense for Europe and NATO policy under President George W. Bush. He is currently a non-resident senior advisor at the Center for International and Security Studies (CSIS) in Washington, D.C. The views expressed are entirely his own.
MORE IN RUSSIA
Featured Image
The Dugina Killing Aftermath
CATHY YOUNG
Featured Image
The Death of Dugina
CATHY YOUNG
Featured Image
Putin’s Crackdown on Anti-War Protesters
CATHY YOUNG
TRENDING ARTICLES
Featured Image
Reflections on My Mom’s Eviction
BILL LUEDERS
Featured Image
White Christian Nationalism, Out in the Open
ANNIKA BROCKSCHMIDT AND THOMAS LECAQUE
Featured Image
How Team Trump Breached the Election System
AMANDA CARPENTER

Sample products from The Bulwark's store
The Bulwark Store is OPEN!
Who is always right? Sarah? JVL? Or do you Beg to Differ? Show your support with Bulwark merchandise. Whichever side you choose, we’ll be back tomorrow, and we’ll do this all over again.

SHOP NOW →
COPYRIGHT 2022, BULWARK MEDIA. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. PRIVACY POLICY

OP posts:
Chowbellow · 04/09/2022 17:02

blueshoes · 04/09/2022 17:01

Ok, 'understand' is a better word. We definitely 'understand' Putin. It is clear what his motives are. He hisses and blasts it out often enough.

So what are his motives?

OP posts: