Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make my DD play with other neighbours child.

32 replies

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 10:15

We live on a cul de sac, so my dd (9) plays outside on the street with the other girl (8) neighbour. They are best friends and come into and out of each other's houses to play/ hang out etc.

On the road there is also another child a boy who is 7- 2 school years below mine (but a lot 'younger' due to additional needs, though the 2 girls are immature). When they were all a bit younger 2 years ago, they all use to play outside but as the girls have got older they no longer want to play with him when they are outside!

My dp says I shouldn't make them play with him if he comes out to join them but I feel that is excluding him and as there is only 3, it's mean not to. (Though both my dd and the girl are only children) and the boy has a brother a couple of years younger than him, but doesn't play out. The boy is sporty and wants to play football, bikes etc where the girls are more lol dolls and make up.

Aibu to say she/ they should make an effort to all play together or should my dd say I don't want to play with him and that be ok.

My dd has a small circle of friends and she prefers it that way. But I think if the situation was reverse, I wouldn't want my child to feel left out and that happened when dd was 4/5 and the older children on the street were 9,10! Which I got but it still wasn't nice. We are also going through an ASC diagnosis, and as she gets older teenager there might be more times when she is excluded socially!

OP posts:
Goldbar · 03/09/2022 11:10

No, I don't think your DD should be forced to play with him, especially if it means changing the game. Maybe have a conversation about how it would be nice to include him occasionally but that's as far as I would go.

I'm all for children learning to be kind and I think exclusion should be strongly discouraged in a school environment where the children are the same age and have to be in school, but this is different. It's outside school, in their social time when they should have some say over what they do and this boy is a lot younger. And your DD is not his 'free' entertainment. My almost 5yo would love to be able to bother and annoy our neighbours' children who are older and play out alone, but instead I organise playdates and activities for DC with their friends and similar-age children.

aSofaNearYou · 03/09/2022 10:33

No I don't think you should. There is a substantial difference between their age and interests, and it's not a given that all the kids on a street play with each other by any means. I know it might be a familiar idea to some but I would say most streets are not like this. Your DD and the other girl are genuinely friends. There is no "all the kids on the street" club.

SchoolInForeignLands · 03/09/2022 10:31

No, you shouldn't force them to play with him, but equally you should not allow them to be nasty to him or always exclude him because he's a boy.
We're playing this, would you like to join in? Then it's on him to decide.
Girls are playing something and change to something they know he won't like as soon as he comes out - not ok.

Can you get some games or equipment that they could all use together? Basketball, soft archery kit, chalks, skateboard etc.

Dadaya · 03/09/2022 10:25

The girls should play what they want to play. If the boy comes out they should let him join in, but not change their play to suit him. I wouldn’t make them play with him all the time though, it’s ok for them to play with him for a bit then go in the house.

Boxofsockss · 03/09/2022 10:23

I think you should encourage it but not force it. If she doesn’t want to play with him then she doesn’t want to.

stormywhethers321 · 03/09/2022 10:20

People have the right to decide who they want to interact with socially, and that includes children. Obviously, she shouldn't be cruel to him, but she's not obligated to play with him just because he's there. It's actually a really good lesson for children to learn as they enter the teenaged years that no one is entitled to their time and company just because they want it. And similarly, they aren't entitled to the same from others.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 03/09/2022 10:20

If they are playing out and he is there then I think they can ask him to play sometimes. Assuming that there isn't an issue with him other than they just prefer to play together. But they shouldn't change their game (eg they are on their scooters and he says no I want to play football, they should say no they are playing scooters but he is welcome to join in).