Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make my DD play with other neighbours child.

32 replies

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 10:15

We live on a cul de sac, so my dd (9) plays outside on the street with the other girl (8) neighbour. They are best friends and come into and out of each other's houses to play/ hang out etc.

On the road there is also another child a boy who is 7- 2 school years below mine (but a lot 'younger' due to additional needs, though the 2 girls are immature). When they were all a bit younger 2 years ago, they all use to play outside but as the girls have got older they no longer want to play with him when they are outside!

My dp says I shouldn't make them play with him if he comes out to join them but I feel that is excluding him and as there is only 3, it's mean not to. (Though both my dd and the girl are only children) and the boy has a brother a couple of years younger than him, but doesn't play out. The boy is sporty and wants to play football, bikes etc where the girls are more lol dolls and make up.

Aibu to say she/ they should make an effort to all play together or should my dd say I don't want to play with him and that be ok.

My dd has a small circle of friends and she prefers it that way. But I think if the situation was reverse, I wouldn't want my child to feel left out and that happened when dd was 4/5 and the older children on the street were 9,10! Which I got but it still wasn't nice. We are also going through an ASC diagnosis, and as she gets older teenager there might be more times when she is excluded socially!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
itispersonal · 03/09/2022 15:59

Thank you @wibblywobblybits That's my issue and also with the child having Additional needs it seems even more mean to exclude him when playing outside.

I wouldn't want/ like it if it was my child being left out. If they are in private back garden it would be different. But as it's on the front, all should be included.

OP posts:
wibblywobblybits · 03/09/2022 13:28

OP, ignore the miserable people who are giving you a hard time. Essentially all you're doing is trying to be kind to another child who is potentially feeling left out. And you're simply asking if you're being unreasonable by trying to facilitate it. Which I absolutely don't think you are.

No, maybe don't force it, but have a quiet work and say to her maybe it would be nice to let X boy play with you sometimes. There's absolutely nothing wrong with that, and if my child was in a situation where they were possible being left out of playing with others, then I'd like to think the parents of the other children would encourage them to play nicely together. I hate the idea of children being left out.

FlorettaB · 03/09/2022 13:20

’I just feel it is exclusive as if they were all girls and the same age range between them all and one of them was left out of the 'gang' it would be mean’

But they’re not. You are seriously overthinking this. They’re being polite, that’s enough. Children are going to split off into groups by age and interest.

Goldbar · 03/09/2022 13:18

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:45

I think this is it, they let him play with them/ chat with them for a little while but they then go into either our house or hers and the boy is then excluded. Or if one of the girls goes in for dinner etc, the other girl will go in 5 minutes later, if not sooner.

I just feel it is exclusive as if they were all girls and the same age range between them all and one of them was left out of the 'gang' it would be mean. He wants to be their friend still, as I said a couple of years ago they all played out for hours together! But I also get the girls are pre teens now and the interests/ play habits are different!

I'll probably let her carry on as she's been doing then and letting him join in for a bit and stopping when she's had enough!

Your DD's behaviour sounds fine. At her age, you don't get to choose who is in her 'gang' unfortunately and so long as she's polite and considerate of the younger boy's feelings, that's really all you can ask.

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 13:17

itsgettingweird · 03/09/2022 13:01

I think if he comes over when they are playing to chat they should be told to be polite and allow him to join in. As long as he isn't unkind and hurting there's no reason not to.

I always hear people say "no one has to interact and socialise with someone they don't like".

Well no they don't. But I also don't know anyone who is socially adapted who would get up and leave a coffee shop, the staff room at work, a seat on a bus because someone they know but don't particularly want to talk to sits there.

That sounds like what they are doing. He comes over, they have a polite chat and play, and then they go in.

itsgettingweird · 03/09/2022 13:03

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:45

I think this is it, they let him play with them/ chat with them for a little while but they then go into either our house or hers and the boy is then excluded. Or if one of the girls goes in for dinner etc, the other girl will go in 5 minutes later, if not sooner.

I just feel it is exclusive as if they were all girls and the same age range between them all and one of them was left out of the 'gang' it would be mean. He wants to be their friend still, as I said a couple of years ago they all played out for hours together! But I also get the girls are pre teens now and the interests/ play habits are different!

I'll probably let her carry on as she's been doing then and letting him join in for a bit and stopping when she's had enough!

This sounds like a good set up.

What I would discourage is an immediate withdrawal and dismissal of his company. Being polite to someone for a short period of time is a good life skill!

itsgettingweird · 03/09/2022 13:01

I think if he comes over when they are playing to chat they should be told to be polite and allow him to join in. As long as he isn't unkind and hurting there's no reason not to.

I always hear people say "no one has to interact and socialise with someone they don't like".

Well no they don't. But I also don't know anyone who is socially adapted who would get up and leave a coffee shop, the staff room at work, a seat on a bus because someone they know but don't particularly want to talk to sits there.

Georgeskitchen · 03/09/2022 13:00

No wish to be harsh but this child is not your problem and not your DD and friends problem. I know that at the age of 9 I would not really be wanting to to play with a 7 year old boy, unless it was a group playing chase etc. Leave the kids to form their own friendship groups

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 12:59

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:45

I think this is it, they let him play with them/ chat with them for a little while but they then go into either our house or hers and the boy is then excluded. Or if one of the girls goes in for dinner etc, the other girl will go in 5 minutes later, if not sooner.

I just feel it is exclusive as if they were all girls and the same age range between them all and one of them was left out of the 'gang' it would be mean. He wants to be their friend still, as I said a couple of years ago they all played out for hours together! But I also get the girls are pre teens now and the interests/ play habits are different!

I'll probably let her carry on as she's been doing then and letting him join in for a bit and stopping when she's had enough!

But friendships are exclusive, by their nature. Are you equally friends with everyone because they happen to exist within your proximity?

Having closer friendships/choosing to spend more time with certain people does not mean you’re being ‘unkind’ to acquaintances. It’s entirely natural for different relationships to have different dynamics and levels of closeness. Your daughter and her friend wouldn’t be unreasonable even if he were a girl.

Forcing her is likely to to damage your relationship with her, not improve her interactions with this boy.

dottiedodah · 03/09/2022 12:56

I think that your DD is fine to just play with the other little girl .Theres an age gap and different interests here.As others have said no way would 2 older boys be including a younger girl! This is 2 little girls playing together ,how would we feel if out with our friend asked to include a random male!

mountainsunsets · 03/09/2022 12:54

I think this is it, they let him play with them/ chat with them for a little while but they then go into either our house or hers and the boy is then excluded. Or if one of the girls goes in for dinner etc, the other girl will go in 5 minutes later, if not sooner.

What's wrong with that, though? He's not their friend. They're being nice to him but ultimately it's not their job to entertain him.

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:52

MichelleScarn · 03/09/2022 12:50

I'll probably let her carry on as she's been doing then and letting him join in for a bit and stopping when she's had enough!

You'll probably let her and if she doesn't want to do this?

Then I'll let her decide!

Just didn't want her and the friend to be the mean ones!

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 03/09/2022 12:50

I'll probably let her carry on as she's been doing then and letting him join in for a bit and stopping when she's had enough!

You'll probably let her and if she doesn't want to do this?

O11 · 03/09/2022 12:46

Penguinfeather781 · 03/09/2022 12:36

I think you’re too hung up on this lovely ideal of all the children in the street playing together and I just don’t think it’s realistic. They aren’t preschoolers and they are at an age where they get to pick their own friends. In the context of two girls who are best friends that happen to live next door to each other, playing just the pair of them, no I don’t think they should have to play with a child significantly younger and with very different interests just because he also lives on your street. That’s not excluding or leaving out, anymore than me having a 1:1 conversation in the park with my best friend while watching our kids is leaving out the other vague acquaintances I see there after school most days. If there’s a large group playing football at the park and he wants to also play football then of course that’s different and I’d tell my child to let him join in.

I can almost guarantee if it was two older boys no one would expect them to play with a girl significantly younger and into different things. It’s always girls expected to bend socially to accommodate others, especially younger ones - the whole “be nice” “be kind” thing and actually I don’t think it’s healthy or fair. Your daughter is allowed to prefer to play 1:1 and hold her boundaries on that.

Exactly what I was thinking. Nobody would expect older boys to include a younger girl.

Although it's nice to teach inclusivity, it's also important that girls aren't brought up to be people pleasers. They should be allowed to say no.

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:45

I think this is it, they let him play with them/ chat with them for a little while but they then go into either our house or hers and the boy is then excluded. Or if one of the girls goes in for dinner etc, the other girl will go in 5 minutes later, if not sooner.

I just feel it is exclusive as if they were all girls and the same age range between them all and one of them was left out of the 'gang' it would be mean. He wants to be their friend still, as I said a couple of years ago they all played out for hours together! But I also get the girls are pre teens now and the interests/ play habits are different!

I'll probably let her carry on as she's been doing then and letting him join in for a bit and stopping when she's had enough!

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 03/09/2022 12:43

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:19

@MichelleScarn
Why the girls and the boy don't always want to play out together.

@FlorettaB if there's a mixture of ages and playing ball games/ scooters etc why wouldn't they play out with older children. Though when my dd was small there was her and the friend. A boy a year older and the 9/10 year olds.

I realise my street isn't the norm, with kids playing out on the front street and it is something I love about where I live as we have really small gardens.

So you love the idea of all the kids playing together, but what if they just don't want to? Would you like someone coming along to dictate your free time? 'Oh there's some parents in the next street who want to come and hang out with you, no you gave nothing in common and don't like each other, but hey, you really need to do this as you live in same village'?

mountainsunsets · 03/09/2022 12:41

YABU. You can't force children to be friends and to play together - and doing so will just cause upset and make your DD resentful.

As an adult, you wouldn't force yourself to hang around with people you dislike, so why force that onto your DD?

godmum56 · 03/09/2022 12:38

how are you thinking you can "make" your child play with other children?

Penguinfeather781 · 03/09/2022 12:36

I think you’re too hung up on this lovely ideal of all the children in the street playing together and I just don’t think it’s realistic. They aren’t preschoolers and they are at an age where they get to pick their own friends. In the context of two girls who are best friends that happen to live next door to each other, playing just the pair of them, no I don’t think they should have to play with a child significantly younger and with very different interests just because he also lives on your street. That’s not excluding or leaving out, anymore than me having a 1:1 conversation in the park with my best friend while watching our kids is leaving out the other vague acquaintances I see there after school most days. If there’s a large group playing football at the park and he wants to also play football then of course that’s different and I’d tell my child to let him join in.

I can almost guarantee if it was two older boys no one would expect them to play with a girl significantly younger and into different things. It’s always girls expected to bend socially to accommodate others, especially younger ones - the whole “be nice” “be kind” thing and actually I don’t think it’s healthy or fair. Your daughter is allowed to prefer to play 1:1 and hold her boundaries on that.

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 12:36

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:00

The boy doesn't want to change the game, just they have very different interests! Which I think it part of the problem.

You risk your daughter becoming increasingly resentful and unhappy with you, and taking it out on this boy tbh. Or she’ll just stop playing out altogether. Forcing interaction rarely results in the outcome you desire.

You’re also teaching her that her wants don’t matter.

Goldbar · 03/09/2022 12:19

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:00

The boy doesn't want to change the game, just they have very different interests! Which I think it part of the problem.

Would it not make sense for his parents to help him develop friendships with other children who share his interests?

I'm struggling to see precisely what you want your DD and the other 9yo to do in this situation? Say the older two are playing outside with their lol dolls, boy comes to join them but isn't interested... surely the girls could just say a friendly hello and then go back to their game, while the 7yo finds something he is interested in to do?

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:19

@MichelleScarn
Why the girls and the boy don't always want to play out together.

@FlorettaB if there's a mixture of ages and playing ball games/ scooters etc why wouldn't they play out with older children. Though when my dd was small there was her and the friend. A boy a year older and the 9/10 year olds.

I realise my street isn't the norm, with kids playing out on the front street and it is something I love about where I live as we have really small gardens.

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 03/09/2022 12:08

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:00

The boy doesn't want to change the game, just they have very different interests! Which I think it part of the problem.

I don't understand why this is a 'problem' unless he wants to change their play?

FlorettaB · 03/09/2022 12:04

’they have very different interests’

That’s why they don’t want to play with him. Equally, I would have been surprised and worried if a group of unrelated 9/10 year olds had wanted to play with your DD when she was 4/5.

itispersonal · 03/09/2022 12:00

The boy doesn't want to change the game, just they have very different interests! Which I think it part of the problem.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread