Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Son needs a *delicate* operation and I need to lie

392 replies

LittlewhitelieLily136 · 03/09/2022 10:13

When my son was born he had one undescended testicle.

He is going to be 7 in October and it STILL hasn't come down by itself (consultant confirmed it is very stuck!) and with covid and everything his op to get it fixed kept getting pushed back and back. (Understandable but annoying for him too!)

Anyway.

He finally finally has an op date and he'll need time off school for it but, well, we haven't said that he's got an undescended testicle publicly.

  1. Because it's no-one elses business
  2. For his privacy because it might be considered embarrassing - no matter how common it is.

Now we haven't said to our friends and family that ds is having an op yet but we will have to as it won't be taking place in our local hospital and for the time off school.

AiBU to lie about the reason for his op to protect his privacy and self esteem? DS is mature enough to know that one lie leads to more - and I agree with him. I feel bad that I need to lie but I do need to lie for him if that makes sense. I can't stand the thought of him being bullied for this. He already gets bullied.

I also don't know what kind of op to replace it with.

Please advise

OP posts:
CharlotteRose90 · 04/09/2022 12:12

No one is going to bully or tease a small child about the fact he’s got a problem with one of his testicles . Just say he’s having a minor operation and that’s that. You don’t need to lie and say it’s something else. It’s an operation and that’s it. Don’t make a song and dance about it.

ancientgran · 04/09/2022 12:04

Iknowthis1 · 03/09/2022 22:11

Two of my sons had similar operations. I had the same concerns but they didn't care in the slightest who knew. Nobody teased them. You're over thinking it

You do realise that some children get teased for all sorts of things? One of mine wore glasses from age 3, he got teased, the favourite taunt in primary school was to call out "Fit the best, Fit Everest" which was a TV advert for double glaziing at the time and he got tired of it. My kids are mixed race DD got teased about her nose and lips. Some kids who look just like her or who wear glasses won't get teased, good for them but the OP knows more about the kids at the school her child goes to than you do.

ancientgran · 04/09/2022 12:00

PlutoCritter · 04/09/2022 11:19

Men need to feel comfortable about getting medical help if they have a problem, they don't need to feel that they have some obligation to tell anyone else.

Absolutely this.
I know some very private medical stuff about a male teen relative of mine which I think it's totally out of order that I know. Nothing dangerous or requiring my to know.

Yet his parents told the whole family details. Just gossiping mixed with no privacy boundaries, like children don't have a right to privacy and it's public knowledge.

It's completely ridiculous that I know his gynaecological medical situation. I wouldn't tell him the details of my contraceptive choices and I'm not ashamed about those.

Huge difference between shame and privacy.

Huge difference between shame and privacy is so true. I had horrendous piles after my youngest was born, I wasn't ashamed of them, why would I be? I didn't discuss them with anyone except DH (more moaning than discussing) and HCP. The fact that I didn't want to tell Fred and no 27 about my piles didn't stop me getting the right medical advice.

Someone else might feel fine discussing their piles with all and sundry and that' fine too.

PlutoCritter · 04/09/2022 11:19

Men need to feel comfortable about getting medical help if they have a problem, they don't need to feel that they have some obligation to tell anyone else.

Absolutely this.
I know some very private medical stuff about a male teen relative of mine which I think it's totally out of order that I know. Nothing dangerous or requiring my to know.

Yet his parents told the whole family details. Just gossiping mixed with no privacy boundaries, like children don't have a right to privacy and it's public knowledge.

It's completely ridiculous that I know his gynaecological medical situation. I wouldn't tell him the details of my contraceptive choices and I'm not ashamed about those.

Huge difference between shame and privacy.

KennAdams · 04/09/2022 11:17

Clicked post too soon.

My nephew had the same and the school were great. They made sure he took it easy and gave football a miss for a week or two.

I'd be inclined to agree with @Iknowthis1

I doubt he'd be teased at all.

KennAdams · 04/09/2022 11:15

My nephew had the same.

JaneBrowning · 04/09/2022 11:10

As so often gran speaks sense.It could equally be argued that the reason men do not get help as adults is because their parents embarrassed them as children by sharing private medical information and that it has taken 10 years to shake the nickname 'one ball Billy' so they'd rather not see a doctor as an adult

Don't be so silly. @ancientgran is not talking any sense.

The child in question is having his testicle sorted out not removed.

And the main point is that his mother is ashamed, emabrrassed, prudish, whatever, about telling his school teacher. The teacher will need to know for PE.

It is FAR more damaging to create shame and embarrassment about balls and willies than worry about some other school kids poking fun (and I've never come across this in 40 years of teaching. Most kids are matter of fact and don't make a fuss over this sort of thing- especially at 6!)

A child will be with his family for 18 years. Their attitudes to sex and body parts will have far more impact on the child's behaviour as an adult than a medical examination by a dr when at 6 years old. The examination is clinical in a clinical setting. The attitudes of the parents (this mother) are going to impact in a psychological way.

Children on the whole are very sensible about medical stuff especially before puberty.

The problem here is the mother is projecting her own embarrassment and unhealthy attitude to genitals onto her child.

Iknowthis1 · 03/09/2022 22:11

Two of my sons had similar operations. I had the same concerns but they didn't care in the slightest who knew. Nobody teased them. You're over thinking it

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 03/09/2022 22:05

HideTheCroissants · 03/09/2022 21:25

All my letters say what the appointment is for……

As I said,your employer doesn't have the right to know exactly what for. I suppose if that's the only proof of appt you have then you could photocopy the letter and block the details out.

ancientgran · 03/09/2022 21:33

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 03/09/2022 20:25

As so often gran speaks sense.

It could equally be argued that the reason men do not get help as adults is because their parents embarrassed them as children by sharing private medical information and that it has taken 10 years to shake the nickname 'one ball Billy' so they'd rather not see a doctor as an adult

Yes that sort of thing can be traumatising for a child, like the previous poster who was embarrassed about constipation.

HideTheCroissants · 03/09/2022 21:25

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 03/09/2022 14:05

You don't have to disclose what is wrong though, just appt letters. You are within your rights to keep things private and I know this for a fact as dh has done exactly that.

All my letters say what the appointment is for……

MrsLargeEmbodied · 03/09/2022 20:35

dont be silly,
the parents are not sharing the inforamtion with all and sundry
purely with the school
one ball billy indeed

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 03/09/2022 20:25

ancientgran · 03/09/2022 19:39

What rubbish. This child has been seen regularly by a doctor, you know one of the people he would need to go to for medical help and advice so no indication whatsoever that this would stop him seeing a doctor if he needed to. Men need to feel comfortable about getting medical help if they have a problem, they don't need to feel that they have some obligation to tell anyone else.

As so often gran speaks sense.

It could equally be argued that the reason men do not get help as adults is because their parents embarrassed them as children by sharing private medical information and that it has taken 10 years to shake the nickname 'one ball Billy' so they'd rather not see a doctor as an adult

ancientgran · 03/09/2022 19:39

ZeroFuchsGiven · 03/09/2022 17:09

Howay man, please read upthread to the poster who put this perfectly. THIS IS THE REASON MEN DO NOT GET MEDICAL HELP WHEN THEY NEED IT. Its ingrained by parents like you needing to keep things 'private'.

What rubbish. This child has been seen regularly by a doctor, you know one of the people he would need to go to for medical help and advice so no indication whatsoever that this would stop him seeing a doctor if he needed to. Men need to feel comfortable about getting medical help if they have a problem, they don't need to feel that they have some obligation to tell anyone else.

schoolmum101 · 03/09/2022 19:11

School needs to know. Everyone else it's just medical absence. No-one else apart from the school has any need to know diagnosis or treatment. None of their business. Don't feel you need to account to people you don't need to account to.

Sirzy · 03/09/2022 17:50

ZeroFuchsGiven · 03/09/2022 17:09

Howay man, please read upthread to the poster who put this perfectly. THIS IS THE REASON MEN DO NOT GET MEDICAL HELP WHEN THEY NEED IT. Its ingrained by parents like you needing to keep things 'private'.

slightly off topic but I was impressed that Ds secondary school had people from the chairty oddballs in last year talking to the children about the importance of checking yourself and not being ashamed. Hopefully the culture can change.

whatonearthh · 03/09/2022 17:28

I haven't read all the responses OP but I note you said your family has problems with boundaries but it is for you to reinforce those boundaries.

The school do not need to know the reason for the operation and nor should they ask. If extended family need to know he is having an op then you should be able to simply say he needs a minor op but don't wish to share the details then rebut any further questions. You shouldn't have to tell out right lies to protect your sons privacy and you are doing much to teach him about healthy boundaries.

DreamToNightmare · 03/09/2022 17:20

For all of you who are saying there is no shame in it etc, of course there isn't, but this doesn't mean that people won't take the piss and why would you want to expose him to that, particularly if the poor kid winds up with one testicle?

My son “wound up” up with one testicle and I can assure you he isn’t a “poor kid” because of it.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 03/09/2022 17:09

stillsmilingtoday · 03/09/2022 16:18

Haven't read the thread but were once in exactly the same situation at you. School doesn't need to know anything beyond he's having a minor operation and needs to be off games for a week or whatever your consultant recommends. Relatives don't need to know. FGS. There is such a thing as privacy and discretion!!!

Unfortunately, while it may be an undescended testicle it is also possible that there isn't anything viable so what there is might need to be removed and then he will have one testicle (still fine re having kids in later life), this is what happened to our DS, they couldn't tell until they did the operation.

For all of you who are saying there is no shame in it etc, of course there isn't, but this doesn't mean that people won't take the piss and why would you want to expose him to that, particularly if the poor kid winds up with one testicle? Have you ever met a bunch of 14 yo boys? My son's consultant told us of the teenage boy who told everyone and never lived it down, and eventually came to him requesting a cosmetic insert. Yes of course he shouldn't be ashamed of it but people don't need to know.

We've kept it quiet (even from his siblings), it's his thing to tell people, if he wants to, in later life. We even asked him if he had one leg or one arm would be prefer people to know or not know? And he said he'd prefer people to not know. And obviously we had the conversation about there would be nothing wrong with having one arm etc, but he decided not to speak about it anyway. He's a very happy and energetic boy, I can't see that he has been affected by it at all, he's too young to be interested in thinking or worrying about his privates! But at least when this time comes (as I'm sure it will), he will be in control of who knows what about it, he won't have moved up to senior school with a bunch of other kids who think it funny to banter about it. This isn't to say that teachers will let it slip, just a thought on what might happen if you go down the path of less discretion. In any case hopefully the operation will be a success and he won't have the same result as our DS.

Still, I would just tell the school the restrictions and advice that your consultant gives you re daily activities that should be curtailed. Good luck with the operation xx

Howay man, please read upthread to the poster who put this perfectly. THIS IS THE REASON MEN DO NOT GET MEDICAL HELP WHEN THEY NEED IT. Its ingrained by parents like you needing to keep things 'private'.

Sirzy · 03/09/2022 17:06

Teachers shouldn’t be deciding, but them having a rough idea of what the procedure has been helps them know when their is a potential problem afterwards. If when he is back at school he isn’t comfy sitting on the carpet, or he gets hit by a ball and says it hurts the teacher will know why and be able to respond appropriately.

when someone is in loco parentis it really is useful for them to have a basic idea of what’s happening.

ancientgran · 03/09/2022 17:01

saraclara · 03/09/2022 16:57

Which is why teachers, who are used to common surgeries like the OP's sons, will have been through

Are we (the general 'We') fuck.

Talk about a little learning being a dangerous thing. You have SUCH a high opinion of yourself.
As teachers, when a child returns to school after an illness or surgery, we do as we are told, by the parents and/or doctor. We do not go deciding what we think best based on the name of an operation. For goodness sake, have some humility. So much depends on how it went and the patient themselves. Only the doctor and parents know that, and we follow their instructions. Anything else is dangerous arrogance.

Absolutely. You only have to read about CS on here, one mum will say she was up and about within a day and another will say she wasn't back to normal for months. People heal differently, operations for the same condition can vary. No way should teachers be deciding what a child should or shouldn't be doing. They need to do what the parent/doctor says.

saraclara · 03/09/2022 16:57

Which is why teachers, who are used to common surgeries like the OP's sons, will have been through

Are we (the general 'We') fuck.

Talk about a little learning being a dangerous thing. You have SUCH a high opinion of yourself.
As teachers, when a child returns to school after an illness or surgery, we do as we are told, by the parents and/or doctor. We do not go deciding what we think best based on the name of an operation. For goodness sake, have some humility. So much depends on how it went and the patient themselves. Only the doctor and parents know that, and we follow their instructions. Anything else is dangerous arrogance.

ancientgran · 03/09/2022 16:52

knittingaddict · 03/09/2022 13:14

No, I want to send the message that the genitals are a normal part of the body and that where medical issues are concerned there is no need to pretend it's something else. I'm not suggesting it's announced by town crier, but the school at least need to know. I see no reason to keep it from close family members either.

His privacy should still be respected regardless of what the operation is. One of my sons had an operation when he was younger than the OPs son, if anyone asked him about it he said he was going to be bionic (the six million dollar man was big at the time) and that was the information he was happy to share. I never felt the need to disclose anything else. His operation was on his head so nothing to do with genitals.

JaneBrowning · 03/09/2022 16:49

My mum also told two of her friends about it. Who then, god knows why, asked me about it multiple times! Hugely mortifying.

Mortifying?

What a sheltered life you have led @WellTidy if having adult friends of your mum know you had constipation.

MN is a weird and wonderful insight into all kinds of people!

JaneBrowning · 03/09/2022 16:47

No. They are not medically qualified to assess what can and cannot be done based on a particular procedure. Non-medical professionals trying to make those judgements is how people get injured, because they are not competent to assess.They just need to be told what can and cannot be done. Then act on that information

I despair at the lack of critical thinking here.

No one has said the teacher will assess him.

Where's that comment come from?

As a former and very experienced teacher, across all age groups, I'd want to know what op a 7 year old had.

I would not expect to make a decision on his after-care but would expect the parent to share the dr's advice.

If it's 'delicate' most adults will work out it's either his scrotum/ testicles or penis.

As for the poster who said she was outed by a letter in the register for being off school for severe constipation! You're still thinking about this, decades later?

1 A teacher ought not to hand over a register containing confidential info.

2 A pupil ought not to read it.

3 You ought to get over being embarrassed by constipation!