Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to keep our cash.

159 replies

TarasHarp55 · 03/09/2022 09:08

What's everyone's thoughts on going digital? Yesterday on the bus was for me, a prime example of why we shouldn't. This man got on and presented his debit card to pay his fare. The card declined. The poor man was on his way to work and was saying "I've just got paid this morning, I don't understand". He had no other way of paying. The driver kept telling him to try again, the poor man getting upset. Anyway the outcome was I paid his fare because he didn't want to miss work.

It got me thinking though, is this going to get more and more common. Relying on a computer to give you your money. There's so many other problems when there's no cash too imo. I hate the thought of a cashless society.

OP posts:
sunandheatwave · 03/09/2022 10:41

I agree cards are great but technology fails and then back ups don't always work

My online shop was due this morning, and my bank card was declined. I have just been paid so have over £1k on there. Tried a credit card that was declined and I got a text for fraud. Also plenty of credit on it! So stressful, as have hungry kids at home and still waiting for a supermarket shop.

Beachbreak2411 · 03/09/2022 10:40

My card often gets declined even when plenty of money in account. I like to always have a bit of cash on me for this reason. Especially when trying to get transport somewhere!!

Seemslikeaniceday · 03/09/2022 10:40

To add, you cannot replace the genuinely surprised and delighted look on my step-nephews face when he opened the hand made gift card and saw the £50 note I had placed in it. There is no way £50 appearing in his bank account would have had the same reaction.

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 10:39

AKnitterofThings · 03/09/2022 10:09

@sst1234 Gosh there is some snobbery around about using cash. I use cash therefore I must be into drug peddling or human trafficking and tax dodging!
I hate this digitalised world. How long before the banking chip is in our fingers? It is already being trialled. How long before our steak dinner is declined because we bought too much meat last week?

You should be more worried about carbon credits as that really is a threat.

Sparklingbrook · 03/09/2022 10:37

Has anyone actually said that we will definitely be a cashless society though? At the moment there are a few things/places that you can't use cash for. But no cash at all, anywhere-when's that happening? Confused

Seemslikeaniceday · 03/09/2022 10:37

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 09:20

We rely on computers to tell the weather, change lights so cars don’t crash into each other and fly planes. It’s not a reason to want to keep cash.

Cash is a way for those to evade tax, who can. People on PAYE don’t have the luxury of cash in hand. Small businesses use this way to cheat the rest of us all the time. Cash is an enabler of sinister illegal activity of all kinds. I’m sure people will be along to justify how their 80 year old parents like using cash so we should not get rid of it. Or that it helps with budgeting, which is a strange argument as the pennies are the same whether they are in coins or in a bank account.

You can choose to be a Luddite about anything. Change happens, get over it.

The one issue, I have never found an acceptable (to me) digital solution for is gifting money to loved ones e.g. weddings, Christmas, birthdays. Really interested in how you do this digitally without spoiling the surprise and asking for bank account details?

Paying straight into a bank account to me feels like it devalues the present.

blebbleb · 03/09/2022 10:36

I oh our cleaner in cash, and the local car boot still takes cash. Also any purchases and sales on Facebook marketplace are in cash. I'm all for keeping cash! Agree with another poster, finding a voucher on your phone can be such a pain. Especially if there's limited signal! Most of my store cards are on phones which are reliant on signal and battery. At least if you have cash it's reliable.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 10:36

Each time I asked if I could pay cash my 15 year old groaned and said I was so embarrassing.

I think it's part of the conditioning that has been going on for several decades now, but is being ramped up now more than ever. Once you take it as a given that cash is bad/unnecessary/archaic and that payment cards are the way forward, the blurring between debit and credit cards/payments intensifies and it's one more step to encouraging people not to actively think about whether they are funding things with their own money or using debt to buy them.

Klarna and PayPal credit are part of it too, now - the way you're offered the choice to pay now or borrow and pay later, even on the most frivolous and inexpensive purchases. I'm not saying they're 100% bad things, depending on your circumstances and choices, but banks and other lending institutions know that cards/digital/online payments give them a huge potential advantage to exploit and rinse you in a way that cash simply shuts that door on them from the start.

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 10:33

Bishbashboss · 03/09/2022 10:17

Go to Scarborough. I saw a sign near there in Filey at a coffee shop saying “Cash only. Help us keep it a cash society”.

I’m sure that that is their motivation. Cough, cough

Tierne · 03/09/2022 10:33

A cashless society is a death sentence for the homeless.

It was bad enough when people stopped using phone boxes so there were no stray coins to collect.

People stopped using paper tickets in the Tube or train so there are no physical tickets the homeless can collect at the end of the day and use.

Now you see them begging for change but nobody has any to give.

At the start of the month I withdraw all the cash for my everyday spending. I dont want the bank to see how I spend my money not because I have anything to hide but because I dont consider it any of their business to know what I buy and where I am.

LakieLady · 03/09/2022 10:32

user1471499545 · 03/09/2022 10:12

Paying cash was the only way a friend of mine who was in a domestic abuse situation could survive. She didn't want her partner knowing what she was spending her money on, the abuse got worse if he found she was taking the children out for ice cream or fun stuff. She couldn't buy anything without him know on their joint account and he used to find her cards and destroy them if she opened a bank account of her own He was a controlling arsehole obviously, but she needed cash to survive. I wonder if there are any similar scenarios.

Yes.

A former client of mine built her "escape fund" by getting cashback every time she went shopping. Her abusive ex never queried why she was spending more and more in the supermarkets.

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 10:29

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 09:46

Cash is a way for those to evade tax, who can.

You could just as easily say that cars are a way for people to get away from bank robberies, using that as justification for banning them; or that nobody should be allowed to cut bread or prepare vegetables because a minority of people use knives to hurt and kill other people. That seems quite a one-sided view, suggesting that individuals probably can't be trusted whereas banks and governments always can!

I'm firmly in the camp of wanting to keep the choice. Of course, modern society necessitates cards and online payments, and they're very often the best/only/most practical way, but there is still a place for cash.

I hate car park machines that force you to pay online, call a number or download an app (often charging you extra for the 'privilege' of paying them). Great as an option for those who prefer it, but I just want to stick a quid in, take a ticket and get on with my day.

Also, as in the OP, if I have coins or notes, I have a guaranteed currency to make payments and I'm not dependent on a bank's systems not going down or having mobile reception. Scammers/muggers can't rob me of cash without my knowing (unless I'm asleep).

I'm not saying that they would/will, but the idea that somebody in a bank (or a hacker) could accidentally (or deliberately) press a button or a computer could glitch and render me unable to pay for/buy anything until it's all (hopefully) resolved, maybe days or weeks later, is not the most comforting thought. Effectively, every time you make a payment digitally, you're asking your bank for their permission to allow you to do so. Although they shouldn't decline it if your account is in credit, they easily can at any time, if they want to.

No you couldn’t say that at all because there is no equivalence. It’s actually silly. Car ownership and bank robberies are not a comparison you can make with the number of people getting paid cash in hand.

LakieLady · 03/09/2022 10:26

hewouldwouldnthe · 03/09/2022 10:11

I always have a backup credit card in case something happens with my debit card. never have cash anyway

But if the network was down, you wouldn't be able to use your credit card, either.

A couple of streets near me had no landline/internet for several days a couple of years ago. Unfortunately, it included the streets where our local convenience store is, so the owner couldn't take card payments. He was a lovely man, and was more than happy to let people have credit if they didn't have cash on them (needless to say, a few never paid their tab ) but a lot of businesses wouldn't. That would cause real problems if it continued, the next nearest shop is nearly 2 miles away and there's no public transport after 5.30.

After that, I always make sure I have £100 or so in cash for immediate needs, just in case.

The new owners of that shop won't let people pay by card for energy top-ups, they have to pay for them in cash. I asked them why, and they told me that the tiny amount they make on each top-up is less than the cost of processing the transaction, so they were losing money on every one. Anyone with a prepayment meter living here will need cash if they're to avoid a long walk.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 10:25

The sign said it was for OUR convenience

Yes, you see that kind of gaslighting a lot. Very Orwellian.

Like that now infamous quote from the WEF, where they claim we will soon own nothing and we will like it - is that in the sense of it will genuinely make us happier and we will want to choose to adapt, or the other understanding of 'you will like it' i.e. tough crap if you don't, you don't get any other choice.

BeyondMyWits · 03/09/2022 10:24

We are living longer, many people are developing Alzheimers and other forms of dementia etc. Now is not the time to get rid of cash. Your memory regresses. MIL can no longer use a mobile phone, she gets flummoxed by machines where you just tap the card, so finds bus travel difficult now, she can't remember to take a bus pass, then doesn't know where to place it etc etc. Same in the shops. When some went cashless during covid her world shrunk again.

Nobody helps, they just think she's a stupid old woman. Some people rely on cash.

Metabigot · 03/09/2022 10:23

Yes, I had my purse and phone stolen a few day's before a trip to London this year. Had to take a wad of cash someone lent me as couldn't access anything and all cards cancelled.

A few places wouldn't accept cash, they lost my business that weekend ! Luckily I always checked before I committed to any purchase.

SeeSeaC · 03/09/2022 10:23

What absolute bollocks @sst1234 I take cash out at the beginning of the month at that's all i spend
I want to know down to the last penny what I have in my account

Kitkatcatflap · 03/09/2022 10:21

I live in Sweden, our local supermarkets both take cash but I noticed how hard it was to pay with cash in the city chains. Buying back to school stuff was a challenge - H&M, Bix Box, Gina Tricot, Glitter and sports shop were card payments only. Each time I asked if I could pay cash my 15 year old groaned and said I was so embarrassing.

Having spent most of my life in London, as a precaution I always kept bit of cash, some where other than my purse, in case it was lost or stolen. It was never stolen or lost but there have been incidences where my card hasn't work, their system was down and I have had to use cash., So I dislike not having the choice.

Sparklingbrook · 03/09/2022 10:20

I recently had exactly this problem - no card transactions for a couple of hours

Was that to do with the banking system rather than a power cut? if the tills were working to take cash payments?

justaladyLOL · 03/09/2022 10:19

Was in a car park - lady in her 80s does not own a mobile was only pay by phone
I paid for her
The sign said it was for OUR convenience

sneak · 03/09/2022 10:18

We absolutely should not give up cash.
That would allow central banks to enforce negative interest rates on our savings to control inflation and encourage us to spend instead of save
www.bankofengland.co.uk/knowledgebank/what-are-negative-interest-rates

Bishbashboss · 03/09/2022 10:17

Go to Scarborough. I saw a sign near there in Filey at a coffee shop saying “Cash only. Help us keep it a cash society”.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 10:17

Soon it will be oh you can't buy xyz as we can see that you've already spent XXX on this and therefore we're cutting you off.

People will tell you how ridiculous and paranoid you're being.... until it happens and then becomes the accepted norm.

They're already talking about rationing gas and electricity, which could easily be done with smart meters. Never mind whether you're heating a massive swimming pool or charging your electric wheelchair - if you've used your 'quota', you're not allowed any more and a computer algorithm can just cut you off.

user1471462428 · 03/09/2022 10:16

Actually the drug dealer I know gets his clients to pay by card, he has a business account and pretends to buy and sell musical instruments.

Delabruche · 03/09/2022 10:15

Sparklingbrook · 03/09/2022 10:01

So you have a trolley full in Sainsburys and the power goes out for half a mile around. The nearest cashpoint will pay you out the cash you need to finish your shop. Or no shopping till the power's back on?

Supermarkets have back up generators. But cashpoints need power too.

They might have generators for freezers but I recently had exactly this problem - no card transactions for a couple of hours.