Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to keep our cash.

159 replies

TarasHarp55 · 03/09/2022 09:08

What's everyone's thoughts on going digital? Yesterday on the bus was for me, a prime example of why we shouldn't. This man got on and presented his debit card to pay his fare. The card declined. The poor man was on his way to work and was saying "I've just got paid this morning, I don't understand". He had no other way of paying. The driver kept telling him to try again, the poor man getting upset. Anyway the outcome was I paid his fare because he didn't want to miss work.

It got me thinking though, is this going to get more and more common. Relying on a computer to give you your money. There's so many other problems when there's no cash too imo. I hate the thought of a cashless society.

OP posts:
EightChalk · 03/09/2022 11:12

I would rather keep cash, for four main reasons:

  1. For people who need to keep private savings, like those saving to escape an abusive relationship
  2. For giving money to homeless people
  3. To tip in restaurants etc. - I don't trust that staff get card tips
  4. In case of cards not working, system failures, and so on
orangeisthenewpuce · 03/09/2022 11:11

If cash goes then further down the line expect to be stopped from buying alcohol if you bought over your recommended units that week, no high calorie foods if you're morbidly obese etc. Having someone seeing all of your spending isn't a good idea.

gettingolderandgrumpier · 03/09/2022 11:10

I prefer card I can’t get upset about cash , in fact having to get cash out for various reasons annoys me as I find it really inconvenient. There are no cash machines near me so I either have to remember to get cash back when I go to the supermarket or cash machine at supermarket and that’s only 1-2 times a week .
finding the correct money for bus fare is annoying and the bus driver rolling his eyes at the £20 note . It’s quicker too if everyone pays by card
cash is absolutely filthy too .
im a bit umm about those that cards decline I’m sure it happens but do people not check how much they have in their account ?
I don’t care about that reason for the government wants to track us I’m really not that intesting.

LakieLady · 03/09/2022 11:08

A lot of people on low incomes find cash easier to manage. It means that they can leave enough money in their accounts to cover bills, and don't risk overspending on shopping and having DDs rejected, which incurs charges.

With cash, they draw out how much they can afford to spend each week, and have a very tangible reminder of how much of that they have left.

blebbleb · 03/09/2022 11:07

girlmom21 · 03/09/2022 11:04

On buses and trains etc you can only use the same card every 3 minutes or so as well so can't use the contactless option in the same way you would normally with cash if you were helping a stranger out

Is this the case for all buses and trains across the country? I didn't know this (but never tried).

RobertsRadio · 03/09/2022 11:05

I use cards for practically all my purchases, but I still carry cash for some of my local car parks and emergencies. I am not in favour of a cashless society being forced on people, cash has its place for many and I think there should be a choice.

girlmom21 · 03/09/2022 11:04

On buses and trains etc you can only use the same card every 3 minutes or so as well so can't use the contactless option in the same way you would normally with cash if you were helping a stranger out

Georgyporky · 03/09/2022 10:59

I think it's a mistake to rely solely on one form of payment.
I have several credit & debit cards in case one should be declined.
I carry some cash (mainly for my hairdresser).

I never use my 'phone - I've been held up too many times by people having trouble with theirs.

Lilbunnyfufu · 03/09/2022 10:58

Cash is still needed I went to Aldi and Poundland yesterday and neither of them could accept card payments has the internet in the area was down.
So many people walked out without their items has they didn't have cash to pay.

Mumspair1 · 03/09/2022 10:58

LampLighter414 · 03/09/2022 10:11

That’s fine. But why do you support card only when they could accept both?

How often do you have the exact cash or enough.

Mumspair1 · 03/09/2022 10:57

Ithinkthatisenoughnowthanks · 03/09/2022 09:59

You can choose to be a Luddite about anything. Change happens, get over it

So you have a trolley full in Sainsburys and the power goes out for half a mile around. The nearest cashpoint will pay you out the cash you need to finish your shop. Or no shopping till the power's back on?

We are living in an uncertain world. Power cuts are way more likely today than they were 6 months ago.

And how many times have these actual power cuts happened ?

Precipice · 03/09/2022 10:56

I've already heard a second hand story about banks querying transactions based not on fraud control, but on the purpose of the transaction. A friend of a friend was apparently called up by HSBC and queried as to why he was buying crypto. Criticisms of crypto mining aside, it is a legal transaction and as such none of the bank's business beyond confirming it was actually him doing so. We've already had banks expressing political views. On this basis, it's not such a jump to having certain transactions made more difficult, if not blocked completely.

I'm a young person, but unlike some young people referred to in this thread, I withdraw cash and pay almost entirely in cash throughout the money (excepting stuff like bills and rent).

Sceptre86 · 03/09/2022 10:55

My dh prefers to use Google pay or his cards. I always have cash on me. He's been in the position of trying to buy formula when his card wasn't working. It turned out the bank had cancelled it due to fraudulent activity spotted on his account. Thankfully I was waiting for him in the car and had my purse with me. Lots of people who use Google pay and the like don't even look at the amount before tapping their phone.

Tierne · 03/09/2022 10:52

Apart from the tracking thing the other reason I use cash only is to keep an eye on what I spend and companies know this. It's too easy to merrily tap away and suddenly discover you have overspent. With cash I can physically feel my money floating away and can realise "oh shit it's been a week and ive already spent X quid, need to slow down".

LampLighter414 · 03/09/2022 10:52

newbiename · 03/09/2022 10:47

How ?

Look at what they did in Canada, which we perceive to be a liberal democratic nation, to the truck protestors (no I don’t agree with what they are standing for). Suspension of bank accounts. At least with cash, if they have some or access to some they can still live their lives.

When society goes fully cashless we will be completely at the whim of governments, bans and hackers etc preventing us from making essential purchases at the click of a button. Never mind tech failures and similar uncontrollable situations.

Sparklingbrook · 03/09/2022 10:49

My DC have always liked a bank transfer for Christmas and birthdays, if they got any cash they would pay it straight into their bank accounts.

mondaytosunday · 03/09/2022 10:48

I hardly ever carry cash and I'm happy with that but as you point out there are flaws. If you use Apple Pay but you run out of battery; if your card is declined; if you use Oyster or Zip card and it runs out without anywhere to top up (and online there's a half hour delay before it works); if there is an electric outage and machines don't work.
I always tell my daughter to keep a £20 on her in case of emergency.

newbiename · 03/09/2022 10:47

LampLighter414 · 03/09/2022 09:36

Card only = control

How ?

GhostFromTheOtherSide · 03/09/2022 10:46

Some really quite unpleasant and judgemental responses on this thread.

So if you pay for things in cash you must automatically be viewed with suspicion. Be evading tax, doing drugs, generally up to no good.

Yet almost all scams are carried out using digital payment, but hey you don’t use cash so the rest of the world shouldn’t be allowed to either.

There have been several instances recently where whole banking systems have gone down meaning that people can’t make any transactions, direct debits have bounced, late payment notices have been issued, credit ratings are affected.

If you carry cash and you lose it then you’ve lost a few quid. Give your credit card number to the wrong person and you lose your life’s savings.

As for “carry more than one card,” why should I? I have a current account. I have no reason to have any more accounts, and incidentally for every account you create your credit rating temporarily goes down…

I don’t generally carry cash but that’s my choice. Although I’m considering doing so in light of the cost of living, so that I can see exactly what I’m spending and what I have left at a glance without having to log into an app.

But just because I don’t carry cash doesn’t mean that I think nobody else should.

if you don’t want to pay cash then crack on. But don’t be such a bloody snob about other people doing so. It says far more about you than it does about them.

And I bet people will be as offended at being called snobs and judgemental but think it’s perfectly ok to think as cash carriers as being drug dealers and tax evaders.

VenusStarr · 03/09/2022 10:45

I'm glad you were able to help the man.

We were on the bus a while ago and a man with 2 children got on but the driver said he couldn't buy multiple tickets on the same card. Luckily he did have some cash, but ended up paying £10 for 1 adult and 2 children for a one way journey into town. The driver couldn't give change. How can an adult not be able to pay for his children's tickets? 🙄

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 10:45

No you couldn’t say that at all because there is no equivalence. It’s actually silly. Car ownership and bank robberies are not a comparison you can make with the number of people getting paid cash in hand.

We're not talking specifically about people being paid cash-in-hand - this thread is about the existence of cash in general.

Also, whilst plenty of people do use being paid cash-in-hand as a way to evade tax, it's a false conclusion to reach that all or most do. Apart from anything, many young/casual workers who are paid CIH are very low-paid and wouldn't need to pay tax anyway.

Also, Amazon doesn't conduct a single transaction in cash, and yet they are quite well-known for their ability to, shall we say, structure their tax affairs in a way that benefits them very greatly, but which many find highly controversial.

Tierne · 03/09/2022 10:43

Oh and just to add I always make a point of withdrawing from the same machine too

LakieLady · 03/09/2022 10:42

Having spent most of my life in London, as a precaution I always kept bit of cash, some where other than my purse, in case it was lost or stolen.

When I lived in London, I worked in an area where street robbery was rife. And I had to attend evening meetings and sometimes didn't leave work until gone midnight.

I used to keep an old purse in my bag, with a £5 note, some loose change and a couple of out of date cards in it. It was the purse for handing over in the event of being mugged. The purse I actually used was squirreled away in a zip pocket in the back of my bag.

Loads of people did the same.

LondonQueen · 03/09/2022 10:42

I always have more than one card on me, then if one doesn't work you can use the other. I don't like carrying cash.

lookthisway · 03/09/2022 10:41

I agree with you OP, I think there has to be a choice. Digital gives too much power to the Government and Banking corporations, why do you think they are so keen on it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread