Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to keep our cash.

159 replies

TarasHarp55 · 03/09/2022 09:08

What's everyone's thoughts on going digital? Yesterday on the bus was for me, a prime example of why we shouldn't. This man got on and presented his debit card to pay his fare. The card declined. The poor man was on his way to work and was saying "I've just got paid this morning, I don't understand". He had no other way of paying. The driver kept telling him to try again, the poor man getting upset. Anyway the outcome was I paid his fare because he didn't want to miss work.

It got me thinking though, is this going to get more and more common. Relying on a computer to give you your money. There's so many other problems when there's no cash too imo. I hate the thought of a cashless society.

OP posts:
Tierne · 03/09/2022 12:26

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll
Using cash also prevents you from spending unnecessarily which businesses (and the state) wont find ideal.
For example you could go to the supermarket only wanting to spend £20. If you're using cash you will tot up along the way and maybe let something go at the till, because you will only take a 20 out with you.
If you're using a card it might come to £26 and you'll think "ah fuck it that's fine".

EmmaH2022 · 03/09/2022 12:26

Ooh I wish you had enabled voting

i'm horrified at this digital dystopia.

gamerchick · 03/09/2022 12:26

midgetastic · 03/09/2022 09:32

But you don't know if that was a tech fail or a guy who had no money ?

Might be a neat little trick that works often, who knows.

I don't want to become a cashless society. That wouldn't bring happy feels during power cuts or cyber attacks.

Tierne · 03/09/2022 12:24

I've never had a mortgage before so not sure but presumably if you ask a bank for a mortgage they look at your statements, and I'm assuming they would be interested in how you spend your money. Aka "oh all her free spending money goes on the pub and clothes". Or "oh she blows all her money in the first fortnight and then lives hand to mouth for the next 2 weeks". Or "she buys crypto", "she buys CBD". Or do they not care?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 12:22

....also meant to add that, whilst plenty of people do frequently check how much is in their account, a lot of folk who don't use phones or the internet for whatever reason, or just prefer not to, use the time-honoured method of knowing how much money they have available by looking at what is in their purse or wallet. They might also be relying on a benefit or other payment that has been delayed for some reason.

Neither method is better or worse or more or less valid than the other, it's just personal preference (or what works in your own circumstances).

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 12:18

im a bit umm about those that cards decline I’m sure it happens but do people not check how much they have in their account ?
I don’t care about that reason for the government wants to track us I’m really not that intesting.

Cards are frequently declined for all kinds of reasons, not just because the cardholder has insufficient funds. If I pay with a card in Morrisons (and some other places) using chip and PIN, their machines have an inherent fault with how they read the chip, meaning that they will simply decline it unless you know exactly how to bend the card right over to get the chip to read it - and hope that it doesn't snap one day. I see it happen to others as well and pass on the 'tip' that I only found out when a helpful manager told me. I've never had cash refused because of the angle at which I pass it to the cashier!

Even with contactless, on occasions when you have to insert your card and PIN for the random security check, whichever clown designed most POS systems didn't think to flash up a simple message saying something like "Additional security check: please insert your card" but rather just made it say 'declined' so that a hundred worries go through your head and you possibly also feel embarrassed. I wonder if it was the same idiot who designed websites requiring passwords to tell you in big flashing red letters that your, say 10-character password is 'incorrect' nine times, until you've entered the last character.

Also, you say you aren't interesting - just a boringly ordinary consumer - but loyalty cards beg to differ! They make millions from finding out individuals' spending patterns. Fair enough, maybe, if they just use the data to encourage you to spend more or try other products; but can you really not see a time when a future government could use similar technologies to track you and then restrict what you're allowed to do?

For example, if instead of levying the sugar tax on many products across the board at retail level, each individual were given an allowance and had to use a digital equivalent of a ration book to register it. Or alcohol, fatty foods, even just an amount considered 'officially' too much food for the size of your family.

A view or behaviour that may seem boring/ordinary/inoffensive now can become a very hot potato in a relatively short space of time. Just for one example, ordinary people are now being 'disciplined' and 're-educated' - even losing their jobs and facing persecution and violence - for calmly expressing their 'opinion' that biological women are women, biological men are men and that can't be changed, regardless of how people choose to live and present. If you'd told anybody ten years ago that this could happen in a decade's time, they'd have scoffed at you for being the looniest conspiracy nut ever.

luckylavender · 03/09/2022 12:18

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 09:20

We rely on computers to tell the weather, change lights so cars don’t crash into each other and fly planes. It’s not a reason to want to keep cash.

Cash is a way for those to evade tax, who can. People on PAYE don’t have the luxury of cash in hand. Small businesses use this way to cheat the rest of us all the time. Cash is an enabler of sinister illegal activity of all kinds. I’m sure people will be along to justify how their 80 year old parents like using cash so we should not get rid of it. Or that it helps with budgeting, which is a strange argument as the pennies are the same whether they are in coins or in a bank account.

You can choose to be a Luddite about anything. Change happens, get over it.

Goodness, what a nasty post. I don't think we should get rid of cash either.

AlviarinAesSedai · 03/09/2022 12:11

The local buses here often the machine doesn’t work, so wouldn’t matter how many cards you have! Sometimes they just let you on but mostly it’s cash or get off. Or buy the ticket off app.
Why can’t we have both?
The nearest parking to me people complain about paying 40p for one hour.

Trainbear · 03/09/2022 12:00

orangeisthenewpuce · 03/09/2022 11:11

If cash goes then further down the line expect to be stopped from buying alcohol if you bought over your recommended units that week, no high calorie foods if you're morbidly obese etc. Having someone seeing all of your spending isn't a good idea.

Yes, as in the current system in China, tied to “social credit”. Good monkeys buy healthy, spend on good things, get credit for nice things. Bad monkeys buy bad things, get account frozen, bad comrade.

gettingolderandgrumpier · 03/09/2022 11:57

orangeisthenewpuce · 03/09/2022 11:17

@gettingolderandgrumpier Absolute nonsense!! Where do you even get this from ?

How do you know it's absolute nonsense.

thats the worst defence I’ve ever heard that’s like saying if all I eat is chocolate I’ll turn into chocolate and someone saying that’s rubbish and the defence is how do you know .
ok how do you know it’s true I asked first where did you get this from ?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 11:52

The whataboutery is getting ridiculous now. Yet more false equivalence. If you don’t agree, you don’t agree, why make these irrelevant, odd comparisons.

It's quite common for people on this forum to discuss and develop their ideas and opinions together....

You were the one who clearly said that cash is bad because it can be abused or used fraudulently in a very small minority of cases. Fair enough if you don't like analogies, but I will just say that, in my personal opinion, it is foolish (and possibly dictatorial) to want to get rid of an inherently useful and efficient thing to millions of people on a regular basis, just because it is also possible to use it in a bad way.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 11:45

A friend of a friend was apparently called up by HSBC and queried as to why he was buying crypto. Criticisms of crypto mining aside, it is a legal transaction and as such none of the bank's business beyond confirming it was actually him doing so.

HSBC are really big now on, as they would see it, providing powerful security measures to prevent theft or fraud, but what effectively boils down to being stopped from free use of your own money. Having to call their call centre when you discover they've arbitrarily blocked a payment is like being a kid again and having to ask your mum if you can have some sweeties.

They also have a thing on their app where they ask you what the purpose of a transaction to a new payee is - with a list of options such as 'sending money to family or friends', 'paying a bill', 'buying goods or services' etc. - before they let it go through, then, regardless of what option you choose, a big screen flashes up to say "Warning! This may be a scam". It seems to be designed to make you think that their sophisticated algorithms have identified it as such, based on your answer, but it's basically just a 'no poo, Poirot' thing to protect themselves.

It's interesting, though, to think that the bank is making a value judgment on a legal purchase that somebody wants to make using their own money. I have no personal interest in (or knowledge of) Crypto myself, but I agree that, before too long, we could well see nannying or pure refusal to allow adults to buy perfectly legitimate things that the bank or government frown on.

Imagine if systems developed and joined up to the point where, once it's identified that you buy 15 bottles of wine each week, a message is sent to your GP to inform them that you could be at risk, who may then inform Social Services. Maybe word also gets out to your car insurer and even employer, possibly even put on a police potential anti-social-behaviour watch list. All this because you host dinner parties for 30 friends every Friday night, but apparently can't be trusted to behave like a responsible adult. People will read this and say I'm being ridiculous, but it's all very possible indeed already, should the political will to do it arise.

blebbleb · 03/09/2022 11:35

girlmom21 · 03/09/2022 11:16

@blebbleb I'm sure it's the case for all buses and trains in the Midlands. I'm not sure about elsewhere, I thought I'd heard it about London buses but I could be wrong.

It makes sense as a safety measure.

Christonabike37 · 03/09/2022 11:29

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 11:22

One is breaking the law, the other is not. In case there is any confusion, Dave is breaking the law. If you don’t care about law breaking, just come out and say it. No need for whataboutery.

The law is designed by the friends of the rich. It is not designed to help or care about dave. What these huge corporations do to cheat us out of tax is only legal because they can afford the brown envelopes.
So no I don't care that Daves extra 20 quid is illegal, I care that he's having to risk his freedom to keep his head about water.

Sparklingbrook · 03/09/2022 11:29

I have been to so many restaurants and bars where you can use an App to order and I really prefer it. The server doesn't have to keep going back and forth, no going up to queue at the bar, you can leisurely look at the menu, and no waiting for the bill at the end, just get up and leave. Convenient for me, especially when I'm on a tight time schedule.

I really do not care about being tracked by anything.

dottiedodah · 03/09/2022 11:28

I like to manage my money, and find the easiest way is to have one joint account for food shops only .Rest on card, thankfully SB still take cash so take exact amount out and try to tot up as I go round . Thing is we need choices surely .

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 11:22

Christonabike37 · 03/09/2022 11:16

smal businesses cheating everyone out of tax.
Small businesses are not the problem, Google seem to manage dodging tax just fine without charging cash-in-hand. Dave the builder doing a cash job on a Saturday is not the problem.

One is breaking the law, the other is not. In case there is any confusion, Dave is breaking the law. If you don’t care about law breaking, just come out and say it. No need for whataboutery.

Lochjeda · 03/09/2022 11:20

Absolutely agree. It's bullshit. We were away on holiday a couple of weeks ago and there was a machine on the table to order. They were useless. Items on the menu kept disappearing and the waiting staff needed to keep rebooting it. Selections just didn't work. They wouldn't take our card. Was a complete waste of time and besides that I don't want my every penny I spend being tracked by the government.

orangeisthenewpuce · 03/09/2022 11:17

@gettingolderandgrumpier Absolute nonsense!! Where do you even get this from ?

How do you know it's absolute nonsense.

viques · 03/09/2022 11:17

I was in Brussels a few years ago , on my way home from Bruges , and decided to spend the whole day in Brussels before catching the Eurostar in the evening, a mooch round the markets, a nice lunch, a visit to a museum, a wander through a chocolate shop…….. except I only had about three euros in cash on me and every damn cash terminal / shop I went to was not accepting cards from the UK, some issue with a bank server. It was a long day until I could get on the train and pay sterling.

Christonabike37 · 03/09/2022 11:16

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 09:20

We rely on computers to tell the weather, change lights so cars don’t crash into each other and fly planes. It’s not a reason to want to keep cash.

Cash is a way for those to evade tax, who can. People on PAYE don’t have the luxury of cash in hand. Small businesses use this way to cheat the rest of us all the time. Cash is an enabler of sinister illegal activity of all kinds. I’m sure people will be along to justify how their 80 year old parents like using cash so we should not get rid of it. Or that it helps with budgeting, which is a strange argument as the pennies are the same whether they are in coins or in a bank account.

You can choose to be a Luddite about anything. Change happens, get over it.

smal businesses cheating everyone out of tax.
Small businesses are not the problem, Google seem to manage dodging tax just fine without charging cash-in-hand. Dave the builder doing a cash job on a Saturday is not the problem.

girlmom21 · 03/09/2022 11:16

@blebbleb I'm sure it's the case for all buses and trains in the Midlands. I'm not sure about elsewhere, I thought I'd heard it about London buses but I could be wrong.

gettingolderandgrumpier · 03/09/2022 11:14

orangeisthenewpuce · 03/09/2022 11:11

If cash goes then further down the line expect to be stopped from buying alcohol if you bought over your recommended units that week, no high calorie foods if you're morbidly obese etc. Having someone seeing all of your spending isn't a good idea.

Absolute nonsense!! Where do you even get this from ?

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 11:14

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 10:45

No you couldn’t say that at all because there is no equivalence. It’s actually silly. Car ownership and bank robberies are not a comparison you can make with the number of people getting paid cash in hand.

We're not talking specifically about people being paid cash-in-hand - this thread is about the existence of cash in general.

Also, whilst plenty of people do use being paid cash-in-hand as a way to evade tax, it's a false conclusion to reach that all or most do. Apart from anything, many young/casual workers who are paid CIH are very low-paid and wouldn't need to pay tax anyway.

Also, Amazon doesn't conduct a single transaction in cash, and yet they are quite well-known for their ability to, shall we say, structure their tax affairs in a way that benefits them very greatly, but which many find highly controversial.

The whataboutery is getting ridiculous now. Yet more false equivalence. If you don’t agree, you don’t agree, why make these irrelevant, odd comparisons.

Metabigot · 03/09/2022 11:12

Precipice · 03/09/2022 10:56

I've already heard a second hand story about banks querying transactions based not on fraud control, but on the purpose of the transaction. A friend of a friend was apparently called up by HSBC and queried as to why he was buying crypto. Criticisms of crypto mining aside, it is a legal transaction and as such none of the bank's business beyond confirming it was actually him doing so. We've already had banks expressing political views. On this basis, it's not such a jump to having certain transactions made more difficult, if not blocked completely.

I'm a young person, but unlike some young people referred to in this thread, I withdraw cash and pay almost entirely in cash throughout the money (excepting stuff like bills and rent).

I can't buy crypto with a debit card any more even the established exchanges. Card just gets stopped and passed to fraud department. I have to do bank transfer. Ridiculous