Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to keep our cash.

159 replies

TarasHarp55 · 03/09/2022 09:08

What's everyone's thoughts on going digital? Yesterday on the bus was for me, a prime example of why we shouldn't. This man got on and presented his debit card to pay his fare. The card declined. The poor man was on his way to work and was saying "I've just got paid this morning, I don't understand". He had no other way of paying. The driver kept telling him to try again, the poor man getting upset. Anyway the outcome was I paid his fare because he didn't want to miss work.

It got me thinking though, is this going to get more and more common. Relying on a computer to give you your money. There's so many other problems when there's no cash too imo. I hate the thought of a cashless society.

OP posts:
LemonsOnSaleAgain · 03/09/2022 14:43

So are we now going to have to pay £3 on a card machine every time we want to buy The Big Issue from our local seller?

woodhill · 03/09/2022 14:42

Yes I think I still have his books

He was very interesting

Tbh his predictions aren't that wrong in some ways

You know like the spying on people in their homes i.e. your mobile phone listening in etc

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 14:39

Ooh, I remember Barry Smith. He used to show an advert that he'd found somewhere of a big empty wallet opened out to look like a mouth and with a sinister-looking face, with a slogan saying something like "Welcome to the future".

I recall he cited a quote from Henry Kissinger: “Control oil and you control nations; control food and you control the people.” Barry died 20 years ago, but I wonder what he'd have to say about the state of the world now....?

bloodyplanes · 03/09/2022 14:32

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 09:20

We rely on computers to tell the weather, change lights so cars don’t crash into each other and fly planes. It’s not a reason to want to keep cash.

Cash is a way for those to evade tax, who can. People on PAYE don’t have the luxury of cash in hand. Small businesses use this way to cheat the rest of us all the time. Cash is an enabler of sinister illegal activity of all kinds. I’m sure people will be along to justify how their 80 year old parents like using cash so we should not get rid of it. Or that it helps with budgeting, which is a strange argument as the pennies are the same whether they are in coins or in a bank account.

You can choose to be a Luddite about anything. Change happens, get over it.

Going digital is also a way for the government to see everything we spend our money on. Why would you want to give the state any more involvement in your life than they already have? I purposely won't use any business that doesn't accept cash.

Trainbear · 03/09/2022 14:07

Tierne · 03/09/2022 12:24

I've never had a mortgage before so not sure but presumably if you ask a bank for a mortgage they look at your statements, and I'm assuming they would be interested in how you spend your money. Aka "oh all her free spending money goes on the pub and clothes". Or "oh she blows all her money in the first fortnight and then lives hand to mouth for the next 2 weeks". Or "she buys crypto", "she buys CBD". Or do they not care?

Yes, I’m certain this is true. The example I heard was that if you had evidence in your bank account of have taken out a payday loan (when they were a big thing) then you were considered a Bad Risk.

Also look up Biden signing the Digital currency legislation in the US.

Pava22 · 03/09/2022 14:01

Keep the cash!

What If you are in an abusive relationship and trying to squirrel money away to get away and don't want your abuser tracking it.

What if you want to give some pocket money to a child to spend in the shops.

What If you ran out of money on your card from an unsuspected bill and you would have normally had spare cash for emergencies but now you can't do this.

Applying for a mortgage and being scrutinised for every small purchase made, coffee, gifts etc that shouldn't effect you unless really unaffordable.

teaching children to control money. They learn through seeing the money go. Numbers on a screen doesnt teach them this.

These are just the first few things that pop into my head.

woodhill · 03/09/2022 13:50

Keep using cash

It's quite sinister to not have a choice

Barry Smith, a Christian preacher in the late 80s talked a lot about how cash will cancel and then your every move can be tracked plus controlling food which is another topic and everything becoming increasingly expensive

Ponoka7 · 03/09/2022 13:44

I went to buy Euros for my DD, she's grabbing all the hours that she can before her holiday. Because I don't have a in-date passport and don't drive it took me four days to get what she needed. In the post office I had to get the cash out first, to pay in cash. Not all of us have passports, drivers licences etc. I do worry about the homeless etc. As for a bit of tax evasion from window cleaners etc, the tax and rent owed by businesses is on a massive scale, so I don't care about 'the little people' getting away with stuff.
What happens when our government pisses off the people who own the tech? Russians were stranded on holiday with no access to finances, when Russia invaded the Ukraine.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 13:31

I think the problem is more to do with transactions on buses. I tried to pay for 5 bus tickets but could only pay for my own. My daughters and friends had to each pay their own . It was a shambles.

What idiot ever dreamed up that idea? Presumably some rich oaf who never has to use public transport themselves. Actually putting in a system to prevent parents paying for their children, couples paying together or whatever.

Probably the same person who designed the taps in public toilet basins that force you to twist your elbow in awkwardly in a vain attempt to wash your hands properly under running water. As opposed to the person who designed the taps that give you 10-15 seconds' water with one press - genius!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 13:26

Post-lockdown, I've experienced a number of businesses saying cash only (as well as one or two saying card only). More commonly, I've been to places where they either have a sign or make it clear that they prefer cash if possible - especially takeaways. I don't know what changed - maybe they previously had a mixture, but lockdown meant that everybody got used to paying by contactless only? I always ask in small businesses if they have a preference and a surprising amount almost bite your hand off for cash.

Just after lockdown, our local Chinese takeaway started offering a discount for cash, but they soon stopped. I politely declined the discount as it made no difference to me and businesses were only just emerging again from very tough times; but I'm guessing that it may have worked against them, with card-using customers angry at what they saw as being charged extra. Or wasn't there a law that prevented charging extra for card payments, which a cash discount was probably considered the equivalent to?

I know that certain people will say it's so they can avoid their taxes, but as somebody whose parents ran a small business (and only ever accepted cash or cheque - right up to the end of the last millennium, when they retired), it saves on double bank charges if you don't have to pay in cheques/process card payments and then withdraw the money again. Nothing untoward or illegal if the figures all go through the books, but when a lot of your takings in your own small business are effectively your wages, you can see how nobody would want to have to pay a charge to receive their wages and then another one to spend them.

stopitstopitnow · 03/09/2022 13:19

Cash is an enabler of sinister illegal activity of all kinds

cashessentials.org/cashless-making-drug-dealers-lives-easier/

user68901 · 03/09/2022 13:14

I think the problem is more to do with transactions on buses. I tried to pay for 5 bus tickets but could only pay for my own. My daughters and friends had to each pay their own . It was a shambles.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 03/09/2022 13:08

No one is forcing cash out of society but businesses are free to decide their own payment terms. They'll accept cash as long as it is more beneficial to do so than to not.

Bus companies for example don't really like cash because accepting it adds time to the overall journey length (counting out change at each stop), creates additional work (had to be counted/balanced manually) and increases the likelihood of drivers/buses being attacked.

It also means they have to keep a store of physical cash somewhere at their depots to maintain floats which increases the risk if break ins there too.

They'll have assessed whether the number of customers paying by cash justifies the added risk, cost, and time. Which is probably why many have moved to a exact change only or card payment method.

If you don't want businesses being able to do that then you need to allow more government intervention into the market but considering how much this county loves the Tories I can't see anyone going for it.

Notlosinganyweight · 03/09/2022 13:08

EmeraldShamrock1 · 03/09/2022 09:53

It's ridiculous removing cash from society.

Agreed

Ottercave · 03/09/2022 13:06

My mum’s in her 70’s and has mild dementia. She can still go out on her own but used to get confused using her debit card to buy things. My brother now takes out cash for her every monday and she uses that to buy things. She finds doing it that way more familiar for her as that’s how it was done when she was growing up. She can keep track easier on whst she dpends as well.

On another note. I went to pay for something with my debit card the other day and the machine declined payment as I was using the wrong pin except I wasn’t. Luckily DH was with me and could pay. Used my card in the next shop using the same correct pin and the payment went through.

Cashless doesn’t always work perfectly.

nannybeach · 03/09/2022 13:01

I have a lot of elderly neighbours without smart phone,we visit a lot of private gardens open for charity like the local Hospital and Hospice,you pay cash, for entry,tea and cake and plants. Did my weekly shop last week,card machine asked for pin number, cashier said it had been doing that all morning. Put in card, started typing pin, didn't even get to press enter, before it said the pin number was incorrect and my card was now blocked. DH always has his wallet... nope, not this day. He took my card to the nearest cash point. Pin number worked fine and card wasn't blocked!

Gazelda · 03/09/2022 12:57

My DD learned budgeting by keeping track of her pocket money and piggy bank.

A learning disabled person I know can go into a coffee shop, order and pay for his drink using cash. He doesn't have the capacity to do this function using card or app, so his independence would be curtailed if he were unable to use cash.

UseOfWeapons · 03/09/2022 12:50

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 09:46

Cash is a way for those to evade tax, who can.

You could just as easily say that cars are a way for people to get away from bank robberies, using that as justification for banning them; or that nobody should be allowed to cut bread or prepare vegetables because a minority of people use knives to hurt and kill other people. That seems quite a one-sided view, suggesting that individuals probably can't be trusted whereas banks and governments always can!

I'm firmly in the camp of wanting to keep the choice. Of course, modern society necessitates cards and online payments, and they're very often the best/only/most practical way, but there is still a place for cash.

I hate car park machines that force you to pay online, call a number or download an app (often charging you extra for the 'privilege' of paying them). Great as an option for those who prefer it, but I just want to stick a quid in, take a ticket and get on with my day.

Also, as in the OP, if I have coins or notes, I have a guaranteed currency to make payments and I'm not dependent on a bank's systems not going down or having mobile reception. Scammers/muggers can't rob me of cash without my knowing (unless I'm asleep).

I'm not saying that they would/will, but the idea that somebody in a bank (or a hacker) could accidentally (or deliberately) press a button or a computer could glitch and render me unable to pay for/buy anything until it's all (hopefully) resolved, maybe days or weeks later, is not the most comforting thought. Effectively, every time you make a payment digitally, you're asking your bank for their permission to allow you to do so. Although they shouldn't decline it if your account is in credit, they easily can at any time, if they want to.

Absolutely this. I prefer to have the choice, I’ve always got some cash on me, or in the house. Why should choice be taken away? Lack of choice is a step back for progress. There are other ways to prevent tax avoidance, or money laundering. If anyone watched the documentary on BBC 2 a couple of years ago, about ‘Big Finance’, you’d know it’s more common for the latter to occur digitally.

PinkiOcelot · 03/09/2022 12:49

You are definitely not being unreasonable. I would hate a cashless society!

TooBored1 · 03/09/2022 12:48

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 09:20

We rely on computers to tell the weather, change lights so cars don’t crash into each other and fly planes. It’s not a reason to want to keep cash.

Cash is a way for those to evade tax, who can. People on PAYE don’t have the luxury of cash in hand. Small businesses use this way to cheat the rest of us all the time. Cash is an enabler of sinister illegal activity of all kinds. I’m sure people will be along to justify how their 80 year old parents like using cash so we should not get rid of it. Or that it helps with budgeting, which is a strange argument as the pennies are the same whether they are in coins or in a bank account.

You can choose to be a Luddite about anything. Change happens, get over it.

Surely it's about choice though? And getting yourself out if a hole sometimes? I mean, who hasn't had to dive down the back of the sofa at some point, just to scrape together enough for that bus fare or pint of milk.

More worryingly, it's also about excluding some parts of society. People shouldn't be forced to adopt new technology if they don't want to, especially when there is a cost to it.

Not everyone has access to the newest smartphone or bank account. What happens if you only have one account and your card is stolen? Can you not get on the bus or even have a wee in public?

unbreakbroken · 03/09/2022 12:39

I like card. It's convenient. It's safer. It's easy.

I don't overpay on buses due to not having exact change.

I don't lose coins down the back of the sofa.

I don't have to carry a purse when a fully charged phone will do.

I can keep track of my expenses and analyse my actual vs budget.

However, I'm very aware that whilst card is a brilliant solution for the majority of people, it excludes some, and that is a very real problem.

No one has to convince me that card is a great idea for me. But we need to find ways of making it work for everyone if we are to adopt it full-time.

TenRedThings · 03/09/2022 12:38

Cash will be supplemented for vouchers and our suppression and repression will be complete

Bouledeneige · 03/09/2022 12:36

I live in London and I'm not sure you can pay for public transport with cash at all. Certainly not the tube. I don't recall ever seeing someone use cash.

I do also carry a credit card as well as debit and phone - so that's 3 ways to pay. Never had a problem overseas or at home. Only need cash for the nail bar.

And my bank app is very helpful for making instaneous transfers to friends and families. My DD has just been given a small inheritance by cheque and it's a real pain for her to pay it in at a branch as she wants to split it between accounts.

But I do understand that more people are turning to cash now during the cost of living crisis as a means to manage their budgets. That makes sense.

Surely rather than bandying around insults it's live and let live?

Sparklingbrook · 03/09/2022 12:32

For example you could go to the supermarket only wanting to spend £20. If you're using cash you will tot up along the way and maybe let something go at the till, because you will only take a 20 out with you.

This is where using the hand held scanners and scanning as you shop is brilliant. it tots the total up as you scan things and you can see before you get to pay what the total is. You can still pay by cash or card at the tills.

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 12:27

luckylavender · 03/09/2022 12:18

Goodness, what a nasty post. I don't think we should get rid of cash either.

Only nasty? Please go full house with the other OTT descriptives like vile, sickening, disgusting.

Maybe report it to 101 just to be in safe side.