Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to keep our cash.

159 replies

TarasHarp55 · 03/09/2022 09:08

What's everyone's thoughts on going digital? Yesterday on the bus was for me, a prime example of why we shouldn't. This man got on and presented his debit card to pay his fare. The card declined. The poor man was on his way to work and was saying "I've just got paid this morning, I don't understand". He had no other way of paying. The driver kept telling him to try again, the poor man getting upset. Anyway the outcome was I paid his fare because he didn't want to miss work.

It got me thinking though, is this going to get more and more common. Relying on a computer to give you your money. There's so many other problems when there's no cash too imo. I hate the thought of a cashless society.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Badbadbunny · 12/03/2023 19:26

lightand · 12/03/2023 15:34

You can say that again.

Silicon Valley Bank anyone?
Peoples' money. Disappearing.

The ship sailed long ago.

House deeds now online, as are wills, taxes, pension entitlements, savings, health records, etc.

Fair enough to keep a moderate amount of "cash" in your house in case of short term emergencies, but, realistically, if there's any major power/computer meltdown, we're all beggared anyway!

lightand · 12/03/2023 15:34

You can say that again.

Silicon Valley Bank anyone?
Peoples' money. Disappearing.

Thelnebriati · 11/01/2023 19:52

YANBU. I'm not a Luddite, just a pragmatist. Always have a back up system because computer systems aren't infallible.

@Ifailed Did you see the news today?
Royal Mail tells people not to send post abroad due to 'cyber incident'
www.bbc.com/news/business-64231473

woodhill · 11/01/2023 19:32

MadeInChorley · 11/01/2023 12:02

Businesses should ideally accept cash and cards. But please don’t use businesses that insist on “cash only” and don’t accept any card payments.

A friend is a trustee of a charity that deals with modern slavery issues. There’s a strong link with modern slavery and tax dodging at cash only businesses. No pesky paper trail or National Insurance. You are likely supporting the exploitation of vulnerable people (often women) if you spend there.

Yes

Nail bars seem to operate like this

MadeInChorley · 11/01/2023 12:02

Businesses should ideally accept cash and cards. But please don’t use businesses that insist on “cash only” and don’t accept any card payments.

A friend is a trustee of a charity that deals with modern slavery issues. There’s a strong link with modern slavery and tax dodging at cash only businesses. No pesky paper trail or National Insurance. You are likely supporting the exploitation of vulnerable people (often women) if you spend there.

Ifailed · 11/01/2023 11:48

Apropos of nothing:
www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-64236047

AdoraBell · 11/01/2023 11:47

YANBU OP and well done for helping by paying the bus fare.

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 11:44

KimberleyClark · 11/01/2023 11:26

My Mother also had dementia and her debit card became useless to her because she couldn’t remember the PIN (and in fact denied ever having had one). This was before contactless.

We changed hers to a VERY easy to remember one (yes, don't say it, but there's so little on the card, it's worth the small risk of it being stolen and a thief being lucky enough to use the right number, even if obvious and no, it's not as obvious as 1234, but it is obvious and easy to remember for MIL). Even if it got stolen and successfully used, the amount they'd get away is less than MIL would carry on his regular "bank runs", so no difference really to what she was losing anyway!

But even so, I don't think she ever needs to use the PIN. We take her to the cash machine for present money every month or two and do it ourselves so I think that "resets" the number of uses contactless until it asks for the PIN in a shop. If we take her shopping, we do the same, we type in the PIN instead of using contactless, to "reset" the count again.

I think contactless makes things a lot easier for the elderly/confused.

KimberleyClark · 11/01/2023 11:37

I also use cash less and less, the only thing I really need it for are to pay my Avon rep and tips for my hair stylist.

Toooldtoworry · 11/01/2023 11:34

Trainbear · 03/09/2022 14:07

Yes, I’m certain this is true. The example I heard was that if you had evidence in your bank account of have taken out a payday loan (when they were a big thing) then you were considered a Bad Risk.

Also look up Biden signing the Digital currency legislation in the US.

I used to be a mortgage adviser (I specialise elsewhere now) and I had a lender decline a mortgage because the FTB living at home with parents was betting very frequently with an online betting agent.

Pay day loans were also a massive thing because it showed that you cannot manage your money effectively, same with constantly being in overdraft.

Re: Cashless society - personally I have no issue with it. I never carry cash anyway, but also I find it easier to budget and keep an eye on what I've spent online.

KimberleyClark · 11/01/2023 11:26

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 11:23

On the contrary, a debit card has been very helpful to my 83 year old MIL who suffers from dementia. She was going to the bank every week to withdraw a shed load of cash over the counter and she'd just lose it. Literally a hundred or two per week according to her bank statement. There's no way she actually spent it as she didn't go anywhere or do anything. All she needed cash for was the window cleaner, her paper bill, and the odd pint of milk or loaf of bread at her corner shop (we did her "big" shopping for her as she wasn't capable of even making a shopping list let alone going round a big store trying to find things).

We think she hid it and then lost it, i.e. put it in cereal boxes in the kitchen and then threw out the box when the corn flakes ran out without checking if there was anything in the bottom, or putting notes in clothes pockets to hide it and then washing the clothes so the notes disintegrated. When we've been helping her in the house in the past, we'd often find notes in very strange places, even a wad of them once in the microwave! She'd become paranoid about "people" coming into her house to steal her money! We also think she could have lost money on the street as she'd never put it away properly and would just glibly put it in a pocket where it's easy to fall out.

We got her a debit card, and it took a while, but we got her used to using it, and now we can see what she spends and where, and we were right, she spends hardly anything. We take her to the cash machine to withdraw cash for birthdays and Xmas, but we make her write the card and put the cash in, seal it and then take the cards away for us to distribute, so we stay in control. We also contacted her window cleaner ourselves to ask him to email us his bill and we pay electronically.

She must have lost a small fortune by farting around with cash when she really didn't need to. Now, she can hardly remember using cash at all! So much better for her.

My Mother also had dementia and her debit card became useless to her because she couldn’t remember the PIN (and in fact denied ever having had one). This was before contactless.

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 11:23

BeyondMyWits · 03/09/2022 10:24

We are living longer, many people are developing Alzheimers and other forms of dementia etc. Now is not the time to get rid of cash. Your memory regresses. MIL can no longer use a mobile phone, she gets flummoxed by machines where you just tap the card, so finds bus travel difficult now, she can't remember to take a bus pass, then doesn't know where to place it etc etc. Same in the shops. When some went cashless during covid her world shrunk again.

Nobody helps, they just think she's a stupid old woman. Some people rely on cash.

On the contrary, a debit card has been very helpful to my 83 year old MIL who suffers from dementia. She was going to the bank every week to withdraw a shed load of cash over the counter and she'd just lose it. Literally a hundred or two per week according to her bank statement. There's no way she actually spent it as she didn't go anywhere or do anything. All she needed cash for was the window cleaner, her paper bill, and the odd pint of milk or loaf of bread at her corner shop (we did her "big" shopping for her as she wasn't capable of even making a shopping list let alone going round a big store trying to find things).

We think she hid it and then lost it, i.e. put it in cereal boxes in the kitchen and then threw out the box when the corn flakes ran out without checking if there was anything in the bottom, or putting notes in clothes pockets to hide it and then washing the clothes so the notes disintegrated. When we've been helping her in the house in the past, we'd often find notes in very strange places, even a wad of them once in the microwave! She'd become paranoid about "people" coming into her house to steal her money! We also think she could have lost money on the street as she'd never put it away properly and would just glibly put it in a pocket where it's easy to fall out.

We got her a debit card, and it took a while, but we got her used to using it, and now we can see what she spends and where, and we were right, she spends hardly anything. We take her to the cash machine to withdraw cash for birthdays and Xmas, but we make her write the card and put the cash in, seal it and then take the cards away for us to distribute, so we stay in control. We also contacted her window cleaner ourselves to ask him to email us his bill and we pay electronically.

She must have lost a small fortune by farting around with cash when she really didn't need to. Now, she can hardly remember using cash at all! So much better for her.

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 11:08

Sparklingbrook · 03/09/2022 10:49

My DC have always liked a bank transfer for Christmas and birthdays, if they got any cash they would pay it straight into their bank accounts.

Yep, same here. DS (20) has absolutely no interest in cash. We gave him a couple of tenners when he started Uni as "emergency money" and he still has them in his phone case, never used!

He has two "card" accounts. One is his main account where his wages and student loans are paid into and then his rent, and other standing orders/direct debits paid out of. He never carries that card with him as it can sometimes have significant amounts of money on it. He has another account with Monzo which is his "spending money" card, with a standing order from his main account which he regards as "his budget" for spending money for grocery shopping, pubs, etc.

Any cash he gets, he gives to us and we do a transfer to his bank account and then try to spend it, which is a pain because we hardly ever need cash, even the window cleaner wants paying by BACS.

KimberleyClark · 11/01/2023 11:01

In my bus travelling days the bus company had a phone app which enabled you to buy tickets in advance and activate them as necessary. When you activated a ticket a code came up which you showed the driver. Still cashless I know but at least you already have a ticket when you board the bus.

Sparklingbrook · 11/01/2023 10:56

I was confused. This threads from Sep 22 and we also have this week’s

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4716704-to-be-sick-of-cashless-society?page=11&reply=122991782

EndlessRain1 · 11/01/2023 10:55

Bus has alwasy been problematic. I don't use them regularly anymore, but when I did I remember that bus drivers could reject notes. So you basically had to have more or less exact change or you couldn't get on. I don't see how that is giving more "choice" than a payment card.

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 10:54

@GhostFromTheOtherSide

incidentally for every account you create your credit rating temporarily goes down

No it doesn't. I check my credit rating regularly and have multiple accounts with different banks, multiple credit cards, etc. and it's never even blipped when I apply for another account.

bloodyplanes · 11/01/2023 10:53

I myself run a small business and i only accept cash!

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 10:51

sunandheatwave · 03/09/2022 10:41

I agree cards are great but technology fails and then back ups don't always work

My online shop was due this morning, and my bank card was declined. I have just been paid so have over £1k on there. Tried a credit card that was declined and I got a text for fraud. Also plenty of credit on it! So stressful, as have hungry kids at home and still waiting for a supermarket shop.

It's YOUR choice to have a delivery. You couldn't have paid by cash for your online grocery delivery anyway.

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 10:49

bloodyplanes · 03/09/2022 14:32

Going digital is also a way for the government to see everything we spend our money on. Why would you want to give the state any more involvement in your life than they already have? I purposely won't use any business that doesn't accept cash.

So you don't go to any events or attractions that are advance booking by card only?

Did you buy your last car by cash? Or holiday? Is it fun paying your monthly rent/mortgage by cash?

It's a bit hypocritical to be happy to pay for some things electronically yet force your views on smaller businesses to exercise your "right" to buy a loaf of bread or pint of milk in cash!

Badbadbunny · 11/01/2023 10:46

thegcatsmother · 03/09/2022 09:23

sst1234 I disagree. Even Sweden, a very digital payment country, has passed legislation to ensure they there is still and always will be, access to cash. Cyber attacks, power outages etc, means that non cash transactions can't be done. I always have cash on me.

Power outages mean that shops etc will close anyway. Your cash is no use if the shop is closed, is it? During storm desmond, our city had no power. Even the railway station closed and trains didn't stop and just carried on through, because there was no lighting, security, customer info screens, etc., so it was deemed at H&S risk to have passengers and staff on the station! Have you tried filling up your car at a petrol station without power - the pumps don't work!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/09/2022 22:08

You misquoted your own reference! Did you even read the article or was your statement the opposite of what you meant to write?

stopitstopitnow was quoting what a rather 'forthright' PP had presented as fact and then gave the link to an article demonstrating the exact opposite to be the actual case.

Loonancy · 03/09/2022 21:49

stopitstopitnow · 03/09/2022 13:19

Cash is an enabler of sinister illegal activity of all kinds

cashessentials.org/cashless-making-drug-dealers-lives-easier/

You misquoted your own reference! Did you even read the article or was your statement the opposite of what you meant to write?

this is what your link says…
In fact, cash only makes drug dealers’ lives harder, not easier – a revelation that is the polar opposite to what some anti-cash lawmakers and politicians are suggesting.

Loonancy · 03/09/2022 21:45

You misquoted your own reference!

this is what your link says…
In fact, cash only makes drug dealers’ lives harder, not easier – a revelation that is the polar opposite to what some anti-cash lawmakers and politicians are suggesting.

Sparklingbrook · 03/09/2022 14:48

LemonsOnSaleAgain · 03/09/2022 14:43

So are we now going to have to pay £3 on a card machine every time we want to buy The Big Issue from our local seller?

You can probably pay by direct debit and have a subscription...