Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Separate bedrooms = happy marriage?

181 replies

DreamToNightmare · 03/09/2022 07:52

For the last week I have been sleeping in our eldest son’s room (sofa bed) and Good Lord, I have been sleeping so soundly!!

Normally I’m disturbed by my husband’s snoring, his fidgeting, his getting up for a wee twice a night and feeling chilly because he likes the bedroom window open a little at night.

It’s been like heaven this last week not having to deal with that!

This morning he joked about me preferring to share a room with our son than him and I laughed it off when inside I was thinking “Hell yes I do” 😂

Im due to move back to our bedroom tonight and feeling a bit disappointed because this set-up is glorious.

Last night, once the children were asleep, me and DH went to our room, we watched the latest episode of a series we are watching amongst chatting about our days, then we had sex, then we said our goodnights and then I left and went to my sofa bed, read a few chapters of my book before then settling down and getting a wonderful sleep.

My husband has bought me up a cup of tea in bed this morning and now he’s downstairs dealing with the children and their breakfasts etc.

Its bliss and I could certainly get used to this.

I’m sure having separate rooms in the unspoken rule of happy marriages 😂

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 10/09/2022 11:34

I like sleeping with my DP and tbh I would find it a bit depressing if we rarely slept together: for me this is a really important of being in a relationship. But I do love sleeping on my own a couple of days a week (and occasionally still sleep with DD).

My partner and I don't live together though and I think the key to a harmonious relationship is not living together. I wouldn't move in with a man again.Two separate homes with a shared bedroom in each is the way to go.

AloysiusBear · 10/09/2022 11:22

I hate sleeping alone!!

I get no sleep when DH is away. I like the closeness and also he keeps me warm in bed 😁

gamerchick · 10/09/2022 11:14

Sidonien · 10/09/2022 09:10

Like what? Stop snoring, drink less so you're not getting up in the night etc?

Well yes, I would seek medical attention for snoring as it's not healthy for the snorer either, particularly if accompanied by apnea. Losing weight can help. There are other interventions that can be tried. Yes, I would change some habits around drinking if it helped solve the problem.

A lot of people talked about lights/tv on or off disturbing them - this is just down to behaviour change - compromise and communication.

Many issues could be resolved by a bigger and better mattress, as I said above. My DH and I used to annoy each other turning over because our old mattress bounced us around a lot. With our new mattress this is almost totally eliminated - each side stays still when the other moves. Separate duvets or Twin beds could help further. It just depends how important it is to you or your partner to remain together overnight. Talking about what exactly it is that disturbs them. Is it light? Noise? Bed movement? And looking at ways to mitigate that.

If it was important to my spouse I would try everything possible before the nuclear option of separate bedrooms. I understand in some couples both partners are equally happy to sleep alone. But I am particularly talking about situations where one side is very upset by the prospect and where it is a threat to the stability of the marriage.

So in the meantime, while getting to the bottom of the issue. It's a case of grit your teeth because the person is trying?

Separate bedrooms is not the 'nuclear option', it's that sort of thinking that makes it sound strange to those of us who have solid marriages but don't get disturbed by their spouse.

MrsMacnair · 10/09/2022 10:50

We have had our own rooms for 10+ years and tbh it’s made our marriage stronger. Dh is a snorer and an insomniac (but a selfish one at that!) and I was constantly getting disturbed through the night. He’s also early to bed and early to rise whereas I’m a night owl.

He felt rejected at first, until I said I’d come back in to the shared bed but the minute he woke me up with his faffing or snoring that was it. It was only when he made a conscious effort ‘not’ to wake me he realised how much activity he does overnight and how bad it was for me trying to sleep through it!
He now admits it was the best thing we did and we are both a lot happier.

We are just not compatible for sleep!

Xtraincome · 10/09/2022 09:26

DH sleeps in the spare 4 nights a week as I am a fidget and i would hate to make his 5am start for his 12 hour shift worse- along with 2 DDs making there way in every night it's just going sense.

It means at the weekend, for me and DH, it's sex and sleep in the same bed and it works so well. We are lucky to have a spare room though.

Sidonien · 10/09/2022 09:10

Like what? Stop snoring, drink less so you're not getting up in the night etc?

Well yes, I would seek medical attention for snoring as it's not healthy for the snorer either, particularly if accompanied by apnea. Losing weight can help. There are other interventions that can be tried. Yes, I would change some habits around drinking if it helped solve the problem.

A lot of people talked about lights/tv on or off disturbing them - this is just down to behaviour change - compromise and communication.

Many issues could be resolved by a bigger and better mattress, as I said above. My DH and I used to annoy each other turning over because our old mattress bounced us around a lot. With our new mattress this is almost totally eliminated - each side stays still when the other moves. Separate duvets or Twin beds could help further. It just depends how important it is to you or your partner to remain together overnight. Talking about what exactly it is that disturbs them. Is it light? Noise? Bed movement? And looking at ways to mitigate that.

If it was important to my spouse I would try everything possible before the nuclear option of separate bedrooms. I understand in some couples both partners are equally happy to sleep alone. But I am particularly talking about situations where one side is very upset by the prospect and where it is a threat to the stability of the marriage.

mogsrus · 09/09/2022 23:08

Been doing it for yrs. both get a perfect nights sleep. Double beds are only for convenience

SurreyHillsinspring · 09/09/2022 23:02

EmptyHouse0822 · 08/09/2022 16:05

Yeah but over night you should be there to support your partner.People don't just sleep.They have panic attacks,sleep walking,partner upset because they can't sleep,

I imagine a tiny, tiny, percentage of adults suffer in this manner. And I’m sure that in those circumstances then the couple would bed share if one was so dependent on the other.

But those aren’t the kind of circumstances we are talking about…..we are talking adults who are able to sleep independently.

Reminded me of your post tonite,the title of the thread being..Seperate beds=Happy marriage?,in our case definitely not.We bed share because we want to not because we are of the small percentage that rely on each other because of illness,we just happen to suffer from much more common complaints than you think,weirdly overnight.
Tonight my DW woke up with alot of expletives shouting about pain in both her legs.Half asleep I said get up and walk it off.It worked until she tripped over the dog,I ended up rubbing her back 🙂her sitting down in shock.
Then an hour later,no joke ,she started hiccupping while asleep ,usual light snoring aswell really freaked me out so I woke her up.
Anyway apologies for digging the thread up again,I sincerely hope the op gets what she wants🙂

Amboseli · 08/09/2022 17:43

Your DH sounds very controlling. Mine was the same, tried to stop me sleeping separately. I went ahead and did it anyway and 5+ years later we both prefer it.

Just do it!

TeeBee · 08/09/2022 17:30

Separate houses even better.

sleepymum50 · 08/09/2022 17:17

I’m menopausal, sleep badly and often wake up with a headache.

My husband snores like a train. I would have happily slept separately, but my husband “liked having me there” . He slept with earplugs in but rubbished my suggestion that he snored loudly, and always threw back that I snored as well.

Then I overheard him talking to his mates about their hotel bookings for a cycling trip. They had all agreed that they wouldn’t share rooms because their snoring was too loud.

I know for a fact that a couple of the other wives had the same problem as me.

So there you go ladies, it’s true that your husbands snore loudly, but it doesn’t matter because you are only wives. It’s only men who mustnt be disturbed by someone else’s snoring.

We no longer share a room and I don’t get the morning headaches very often.

SurreyHillsinspring · 08/09/2022 17:00

EmptyHouse0822 · 08/09/2022 16:11

It would be interesting if you asked your partner deep down if they're happy with the arrangement

And if he isn’t happy then what? The OP should move back into a joint room, suffer, shut up and be a good little wife?

Sorry forgot about the op just meant generally with partners on here..not necessarily husbands.

gamerchick · 08/09/2022 16:58

And I Swear anyone waking me up because they want sex or because they can't sleep would get told in no uncertain terms Hmm

Bubblebubblebah · 08/09/2022 16:57

EmptyHouse0822 · 08/09/2022 16:11

It would be interesting if you asked your partner deep down if they're happy with the arrangement

And if he isn’t happy then what? The OP should move back into a joint room, suffer, shut up and be a good little wife?

Then you find compromise like few nights over the weekend etc.
It doesn't work if one is unhappy. Either both happy or both somewhat unhappy🙈

SurreyHillsinspring · 08/09/2022 16:57

Ragwort · 08/09/2022 16:44

I've been married over 30 years and never had a panic attack or needed my DH to rub my back at night Hmm. That level of intensity & co-dependency would horrify me ... but each to their own ...

Tough cookie I is not.A panic attack is really frightening and painful and especially bad when over your heart.The worst one I had lasted half an hour and I was really glad my wife was there because I really thought it was a heart attack.The wife has a different type that she after a couple of years still finds difficult to deal with.She also suffers acid reflux.Bad ass people that don't suffer anything ,well I wish we were one of them.

gamerchick · 08/09/2022 16:57

SurreyHillsinspring · 08/09/2022 12:56

Yeah but over night you should be there to support your partner.People don't just sleep.They have panic attacks,sleep walking,partner upset because they can't sleep,I could go on.Both of us have suffered all of these and most of the time your other half's there for you to help calm you down ,talk you back to sleep ,rub your back.All stuff that needs immediate attention .I didn't want to veer onto middle of the night activities(men on sex threads).But not all of it starts before you go to sleep,it can happen over night at anytime.
Shame a man couldn't come on and back me up.My wife snores in my ear,ALOT,the duvet gets pulled off me but I wouldn't dream of resorting to seperate beds...just my opinion.

That world is not my world. So what you're saying is alien to me. I've never needed my bloke to rub my back or whatever else in the middle of the night.

Ragwort · 08/09/2022 16:44

I've been married over 30 years and never had a panic attack or needed my DH to rub my back at night Hmm. That level of intensity & co-dependency would horrify me ... but each to their own ...

EmptyHouse0822 · 08/09/2022 16:11

It would be interesting if you asked your partner deep down if they're happy with the arrangement

And if he isn’t happy then what? The OP should move back into a joint room, suffer, shut up and be a good little wife?

DreamToNightmare · 08/09/2022 16:08

AmberGer · 08/09/2022 14:05

My Mom used to sleep in my bedroom. I hated it. I never had any privacy and left home as soon as I was able to.

Blimey!!!

What age were you until she left your room?

Thankfully my son is only 8 so he loves having me in there. I couldn’t imagine sharing with him in this manner when he is about 10 though….I think that would be my cut off.

OP posts:
EmptyHouse0822 · 08/09/2022 16:05

Yeah but over night you should be there to support your partner.People don't just sleep.They have panic attacks,sleep walking,partner upset because they can't sleep,

I imagine a tiny, tiny, percentage of adults suffer in this manner. And I’m sure that in those circumstances then the couple would bed share if one was so dependent on the other.

But those aren’t the kind of circumstances we are talking about…..we are talking adults who are able to sleep independently.

Bubblebubblebah · 08/09/2022 15:11

SurreyHillsinspring · 08/09/2022 15:04

Separate houses anyone?

Nah. Mine does the floor cleaning and I don't like it so same house works for me😂

SurreyHillsinspring · 08/09/2022 15:04

Separate houses anyone?

SurreyHillsinspring · 08/09/2022 14:48

FriendOfDorothyGale · 08/09/2022 14:28

Why would a husband/wife not want to cuddle up to a partner in a nice warm bed after a long day at work

Menopausal sweats, snoring, insomnia, fidgeting, shift working. Lots of reasons.

Me and my husband have been together over 20 years, but soon as peri hit, that was it. He was a snorer anyway, which was always a bug bear.

I have to swap sides on the bed and flip over the covers sometimes when I am having a bad night with the menopause.

Works for us and I'm not sure people know, but I'll let the naysayers into a little secret......you don't only have to have sex in bed! I know - whodathunkit!

Some people may lose intimacy, but it's not always the case as many, many people have stated on here.

Good luck with that if you have kids..unless you have an en suite I suppose. I'm not going there🙂
Yea window flung open ,dog hates it because no fur coat and I'm freezing.Still no seperate beds happening anytime soon here.
It would be interesting if you asked your partner deep down if they're happy with the arrangement

Bubblebubblebah · 08/09/2022 14:44

pimlicoanna · 08/09/2022 14:14

I think the key is separate bathrooms!

Oooh yeah actually 😂 we got two toilets for 2 people so yeah!

FriendOfDorothyGale · 08/09/2022 14:28

Why would a husband/wife not want to cuddle up to a partner in a nice warm bed after a long day at work

Menopausal sweats, snoring, insomnia, fidgeting, shift working. Lots of reasons.

Me and my husband have been together over 20 years, but soon as peri hit, that was it. He was a snorer anyway, which was always a bug bear.

I have to swap sides on the bed and flip over the covers sometimes when I am having a bad night with the menopause.

Works for us and I'm not sure people know, but I'll let the naysayers into a little secret......you don't only have to have sex in bed! I know - whodathunkit!

Some people may lose intimacy, but it's not always the case as many, many people have stated on here.