Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Break up over text. Why do people do it?

59 replies

ellie09 · 03/09/2022 06:17

OK so me and my partner broke up yesterday.

Im not really that upset about it, only the fact it was done via text AGAIN

I had this happen to me before while at work and it happened again. I think I hate the fact a text comes through when you're in work and it takes you by surprise.

Anyhow, he says we can chat but I don't really know what there is to chat about?

AIBU to expect that in an actual relationship that you don't break up via text message and that the least you can do is do it face to face and offer an explanation?

It seems that any relationship I have had has ended this way and its not even as if I am that young either?! It just gives off teenage vibes to me and not someone in their 30s

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jalapenita · 07/09/2022 12:31

I personally prefer it. Gives you chance to reflect and make a dignified response with emotions whirling

netflixandnaps · 07/09/2022 12:20

@SandyY2K

Because I loved him and wanted him to love me too! Sadly he didn't and in the end I did have enough.

LizaSimpson · 04/09/2022 08:27

It really depends on the situation. It's not mh preferred method of breaking up with someone but with my ex if I broke up with him, he'd come to my house, cry and beg etc and I was only 21 so I'd end up taking him back everytime.

This went on for months until I went abroad with my grandma and I broke up with him via text from the airport which gave me a week to work through my emotions so when he came to my house when I got home to propose I was able to say no.

ellie09 · 04/09/2022 08:24

He came by last night and it actually went better than I thought.

He said because I was his first long term relationship (yes you're hearing this right - at 31 he's only had one other girlfriend that lasted 3 months) that he wasn't sure if the "comfortable" feeling is normal or not, but that he had just lost interest in me in a romantic sense. It seems he is more interested in locking himself in his spare room 24/7 playing games with his mate. And he can get on with that if he wants.

I wanted to have my side known to. So I told him that I agreed with splitting up and its the right thing to do. I said I felt that I wasn't emotionally fulfilled in the relationship (he has frequently said he has a numb feeling and has no emotion, so no anger, no happiness and he told me he could probably never love anyone and yes this should have been a red flag). I said I deserve someone who is going to love me and want me, especially after a year together.

We were actually friends for a few years before getting together and we have seen each other through some pretty hectic life events. He said he still sees me as one of his good friends and he hopes that even though the relationship is over, that it doesn't need to ruin the friendship we had before.

I told him that I could see us being friends again but to give me some space the next few weeks to process the end of the relationship and accept it and then I will contact him when I feel ready to reach out again. We have tickets to a comedy show at the end of October ( we are going with a group) and he says he would still like me to go, if I want.

I told him ill see how I feel once I digest everything and give him my answer.

OP posts:
ellie09 · 03/09/2022 18:25

J0y · 03/09/2022 17:22

Good luck!
Serene face.

Think "I'm relieved I'm relieved I'm relieved"

I know, the break up that hurt me so much, he snagged me the day before. Could he not have faked a headache!!! I felt used as well as rejected

Is it weird that the last couple of hours I'm starting to feel quite sad? Maybe its the thought of getting everything back that that's it essentially 'done'

Probably just a normal phase of breaking up but my self esteem at the moment is literally zero, so definitely need to not break composure later on!

OP posts:
J0y · 03/09/2022 17:22

Good luck!
Serene face.

Think "I'm relieved I'm relieved I'm relieved"

I know, the break up that hurt me so much, he snagged me the day before. Could he not have faked a headache!!! I felt used as well as rejected

ellie09 · 03/09/2022 15:46

Thanks all I will update on how it goes

OP posts:
SandyY2K · 03/09/2022 11:51

*@netflixandnaps

My ex dumped me over text every other week for 4 years! Literally killed me every time.

And you kept taking him back. Why?

He showed you who he was and you allowed him to treat you like this for 4 years ! That's on you, not him. People treat you how you let them.

TheFlyingFox · 03/09/2022 11:41

At least you're getting your stuff dropped off in person. I got the text breakup (a particularly short, abrupt text at that), followed a few days later to find my belongings dumped in my front garden, when he knew I'd be out at work (he didn't work...)

Found out he had been cheating on me and had a marriage lined up!

Its amazing how these men can have sex with you quite happily one day, not say a word and then break up with you the next.

I think they want women who run around after them, or at least pretend to.

ellie09 · 03/09/2022 11:35

OrigamiOwls · 03/09/2022 08:57

I am thinking this, probably just let him speak but don't provide a response. Just accept what says, get my stuff and show him the door

He's broken up with you by text, after a year. You don't own him the opportunity to see you. He either wants to salve his conscience "yes I dumped her by text but I did visit her the next day to check she was ok", or he wants to delight in your misery as he believes you'll be heartbroken.

He's done what he's done. He doesn't automatically get to control the break up. You don't owe him your time and you don't need to listen to what he has to say. Just tell him to leave the stuff on the doorstep. Don't get engaged with him any further.

Yeah I think you're right - anything said won't change anything anyhow I don't believe as I have always said I would never grovel or beg for anyone back. I'd never want someone who didn't want me

OP posts:
Sanpellogrino99 · 03/09/2022 09:01

Qwerkie · 03/09/2022 06:27

I had a relationship where the last time I was with him we had sex he knew I didn’t want - coerced into it basically. I ended it by text as soon as I was away from him. People have their reasons for not wanting to do it face to face or to pick up the phone. It’s not necessarily cowardly. I bet if he told people I’d done it by text they’d have thought I was pretty harsh too

This is the only time I broke up with someone by text too. He told everyone ‘I broke up with him by text’; but conviently left out he cohersed me into sex on the Friday, threw me out his flat on the Saturday morning and did not text me the entire weekend. I broke up with him by text on the Monday.

OrigamiOwls · 03/09/2022 08:57

I am thinking this, probably just let him speak but don't provide a response. Just accept what says, get my stuff and show him the door

He's broken up with you by text, after a year. You don't own him the opportunity to see you. He either wants to salve his conscience "yes I dumped her by text but I did visit her the next day to check she was ok", or he wants to delight in your misery as he believes you'll be heartbroken.

He's done what he's done. He doesn't automatically get to control the break up. You don't owe him your time and you don't need to listen to what he has to say. Just tell him to leave the stuff on the doorstep. Don't get engaged with him any further.

MyEasterEggs · 03/09/2022 08:46

Curious myself 😂 but if you haven’t had much of a conversation the last year (alarm bells!) I wonder how much you’re going to get now 🤔

IrishladyNE · 03/09/2022 08:44

I fell the same as I work full time and have a LO, I had a male friend that I would go to gig with but he suddenly started demanding more of time. Sometimes I just wanted to stay in and watch Netflix . The last time I met him we were talking to a group of guys, he acted like a spoilt time because one of them was showing me attention. He made it so comfortable that I went home.

He messaged me drunk a week later saying he had feelings. I just said not happening but he was being really needy and giving me the ick. I had to cut him off and I don’t miss spending time with him at all.

Then met a guy online making last minute demands, I have a child it doesn’t work that way so told him straight too. I don’t have the bandwidth for it my life never stops and unless someone can be happy with dating a few times a week I’m out.

ellie09 · 03/09/2022 08:37

lowmoodadvice · 03/09/2022 08:29

He’s a jerk OP
forgetball the people trying to justify it in other totally unrelated circumstances
pls don’t feel like you need to answer the door
keep cool calm - you’ll get over this and move on just fine

Yeah I see sense with people in volatile relationships but this most definitely was not one

Sitting wondering what the hell is wrong with me to be honest, probably the depression part of the break up.

I thought I was a pretty sweet deal, having a career, a house, pretty laid back in relationships, pay for all my own shit, not clingy etc but clearly not for most men, lol

OP posts:
lowmoodadvice · 03/09/2022 08:29

He’s a jerk OP
forgetball the people trying to justify it in other totally unrelated circumstances
pls don’t feel like you need to answer the door
keep cool calm - you’ll get over this and move on just fine

netflixandnaps · 03/09/2022 08:20

It's pathetic, so gutless!!!! A phone call at the least.......

My ex dumped me over text every other week for 4 years! Literally killed me every time. He was a narcissistic so he loved that power and enjoyed knowing he was hurting me.

RainbowsMoonbeams · 03/09/2022 08:17

ellie09

You are not wrong - fair enough of you have been on just a few dates. But a year in? Just bad form.

You are better off without someone who thinks this is acceptable behaviour. 💐

ellie09 · 03/09/2022 08:16

AuntieStella · 03/09/2022 08:10

I think you need a mate round when he calls to drop off stuff.

If you don't want to see him at all, she answers the door because you've just 'popped out'

Or if you're prepared to hear him out, then the presence of a third party will at least keep it civil. If you do choose this, remember you do not need to engage in discussion, or rise to anything he says. Simply note that he has spoken, and then say goodbye and point him to the exit

I am thinking this, probably just let him speak but don't provide a response. Just accept what says, get my stuff and show him the door.

I am getting far too old for this childish nonsense. Safe to say this will be my last relationship for a while, because I am done with men lol

OP posts:
Albgo · 03/09/2022 08:16

I broke up with a partner of a year and a half via text. We had quite a volatile relationship and every time I did something he didn't like he'd give me the silent treatment. We didn't live together, so this took the form of him ignoring my texts and calls for multiple days. When he treated me horribly on my birthday and then blanked me for a week I texted to end the relationship. I've never felt bad about it or that he deserved my time and effort travelling to do it.

I've also been broken up with face to face after a five year relationship. He drove over an hour to see me to tell me he'd been cheating on me for six months and was leaving me for her. I think he thought he gained cosmic points for doing it in person. I resented that he got to see how much he broke me and would have much preferred a phone call or text.

raindon · 03/09/2022 08:11

ellie09 · 03/09/2022 08:02

Its the curiosity of knowing what will say as he didn't have much to say the whole year, lol

Ha! Yes it must be a bit like..you want to talk now?

AuntieStella · 03/09/2022 08:10

I think you need a mate round when he calls to drop off stuff.

If you don't want to see him at all, she answers the door because you've just 'popped out'

Or if you're prepared to hear him out, then the presence of a third party will at least keep it civil. If you do choose this, remember you do not need to engage in discussion, or rise to anything he says. Simply note that he has spoken, and then say goodbye and point him to the exit

ellie09 · 03/09/2022 08:02

MyEasterEggs · 03/09/2022 07:47

I’d be honest with him and say you agree it’s for the best (especially as he chose to end the relationship via text like a teenager…) then let him grab him stuff. No further talking, no anger, no letting him ease his conscience since he doesn’t appear to have one anyway. Certainly no backbone! You’ve dodged a bullet OP!

Its the curiosity of knowing what will say as he didn't have much to say the whole year, lol

OP posts:
MyEasterEggs · 03/09/2022 07:47

I’d be honest with him and say you agree it’s for the best (especially as he chose to end the relationship via text like a teenager…) then let him grab him stuff. No further talking, no anger, no letting him ease his conscience since he doesn’t appear to have one anyway. Certainly no backbone! You’ve dodged a bullet OP!

ellie09 · 03/09/2022 07:33

I know, I am quite an emotional person so I would fear that I would.make myself look more upset than I actually am

Its no big loss to me as already mentioned, but you do naturally have the mourning stage in any break up I suppose

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread