Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If wholesale energy prices have risen massively, how come.....

55 replies

Rampxoxo · 02/09/2022 22:29

Energy suppliers are making humongous profits? Surely, if they are paying loads to buy energy wholesale (in order to supply us customers) , their profit margins would not be huge.
I am probably dim, but I'm not getting it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 01:51

We don’t really need to undo any neoliberal capital woo. We need log burners, and a stack of wood to get through this winter, and the government needs to properly subsidise solar power for homes electricity, upgrade those on gas to electric who can’t afford a switch and fund panels or issue loans for those unable to afford it immediately. And we probably need a war effort level of manufacturing panels as we will likely run out of those too.

Your right. It’s happened now. No ones going to do anything about it as it’s far too complicated. So we have no choice. We need to make our own energy. Fast.

Liebig · 03/09/2022 01:34

In addition, the major energy producers now are no longer private companies but national ones that aren’t subject to the approaches we may have with BP or Exxon. Gazprom and Aramco are two massively powerful gov’t entities, essentially.

Liebig · 03/09/2022 01:32

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 01:27

And when the baker auctions his 5 loaves to the one fat cat. And the other 9 perish or learn to make their own bread. The one fat cat returns to the baker and says please may I have a loaf. And the baker says well what about the other 4? I have 5. And he says well I only need 1 and I am not paying you £300 for it like last time because Ol’Mary down the road gives her spare away for 10p. The once rich baker packs up his shop and goes to live in a breadless shoe.

As I said lessons need to be learned. And I hope society and governments remember this and ensure these companies learn painful lessons too.

That would mean undoing neoliberal capitalist markets.

There are currently no major political parties in any Western nation with that as a platform.

Additionally, for this to be effective, the whole world would need to be in on it too. Can’t tell Saudi or Qatar or America that they are obligated to share our energy to the needy at any price.

The places that can’t pay go the route Sri Lanka took.

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 01:27

And when the baker auctions his 5 loaves to the one fat cat. And the other 9 perish or learn to make their own bread. The one fat cat returns to the baker and says please may I have a loaf. And the baker says well what about the other 4? I have 5. And he says well I only need 1 and I am not paying you £300 for it like last time because Ol’Mary down the road gives her spare away for 10p. The once rich baker packs up his shop and goes to live in a breadless shoe.

As I said lessons need to be learned. And I hope society and governments remember this and ensure these companies learn painful lessons too.

Liebig · 03/09/2022 01:24

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 01:18

If there’s not enough that’s what’s going to have to happen. What they don’t have to do is charge an extortionate amount for it just because they can.

Do you even know how those prices are arrived at? Do you think they have someone plugging ever bigger numbers in their sales portfolio?

That’s not how energy markets work. At all. The price is indicative of lack of supply. It’s going up because of price auctions, not because Centrica or Shell’s CEO said “hey, I feel like a new McLaren and mansion, let’s charge €1000 MWh today, yeah”.

Prices will continue to increase until demand comes in line with supply. This is basic auction market theory. If someone goes to Sotheby’s to get a rare item, and someone else really wants it, that’s what happens until one party cannot bid up the price anymore because they hit their limit. Same thing, but in a two way fashion (ignoring how arbitrage can make markets more efficient) happens on international markets for commodities.

Liebig · 03/09/2022 01:19

As for what I’m proposing, that’s what the market price signals are: for indicating rationing is required. Reduction in prices by artificial ways, say, via handouts from the state, indicate no immediate crisis and send the wrong message to people.

There are a limited number of LNG tankers. There are only so many contracts. Someone has to delegate how they get assigned. And that mechanism is markets. If you can’t afford to get the LNG to meet your needs, you either cut back what you have or do without.

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 01:18

If there’s not enough that’s what’s going to have to happen. What they don’t have to do is charge an extortionate amount for it just because they can.

Liebig · 03/09/2022 01:14

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 01:10

A philanthropic bakery would go oh shit, we need to ration. Here’s half a loaf each, for half the price you would usually pay for a full loaf.

Not oh here let’s auction all 5 loaves to the highest bidder.

But that’s what you get when we rely on foreign private companies to supply basic essentials to life.

You think this is good and an acceptable form of business for someone supplying an essential service? What are you suggesting we do with the 5 loaves?

Rationing, you say?

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 01:10

Liebig · 03/09/2022 00:52

I have five loaves of bread, but ten people need a loaf each. What would you do?

A philanthropic bakery would go oh shit, we need to ration. Here’s half a loaf each, for half the price you would usually pay for a full loaf.

Not oh here let’s auction all 5 loaves to the highest bidder.

But that’s what you get when we rely on foreign private companies to supply basic essentials to life.

You think this is good and an acceptable form of business for someone supplying an essential service? What are you suggesting we do with the 5 loaves?

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 01:02

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:51

Hang on, the people pumping oil out of the ground in Saudi Arabia are only able to do so because we live in a stable country in the UK?

How exactly are you claiming that that works?

This is how.

www.reuters.com/business/energy/oils-journey-worthless-pandemic-100-barrel-2022-02-24/

Liebig · 03/09/2022 00:56

Eeksteek · 03/09/2022 00:52

Amen. I’m seriously beginning to consider solar and a heat pump, not because it’s good fiscal sense (although it’s starting to look more and more like it) or because I’m a bit of a lentil weaver (although I am) but because it makes me sick to be funding them.

It’s rebellion. As close as I can get to a boycott without going and living in a tree and making candles out of my earwax. And not paying won’t work. Protesting won’t work (they don’t care) voting hasn’t worked. I’m left with hitting the bastards where it hurts them. In the wallet (well, the shares). I don’t want to give them another penny of mine if I can possibly help it.

Well, have fun getting your own energy then. I'm guessing most people in this thread skipped basic supply and demand models and went straight to the robbing gets part of the econ textbook.

Liebig · 03/09/2022 00:52

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 00:47

I think it’s disgraceful. These large companies who pump and distribute energy can only do so because we live in a civilised functioning productive society.

The fact the price of a barrel fell so low during COVID is testament to that.

They don’t have to increase prices, they are doing it because they can. Because without Russia’s cheap gas they have us over a barrel.

I think that’s a fucking disgrace. That in a pre WW3 scenario they all band together and rinse every citizen of this planet for all that they are worth. I don’t really know what to say tbh. In an emergency situation like a pandemic it’s ok for everyone’s civil liberties to be taken away but in an emergency situation like a global energy shortage god help us we can’t possibly touch the global energy companies and demand the charge in a reasonable way.

It’s fucked. As a country we have relied on others far too long. I think we have a lot of very painful lessons we sadly will bear the brunt of learning.

I have five loaves of bread, but ten people need a loaf each. What would you do?

Eeksteek · 03/09/2022 00:52

VirginiaWool · 02/09/2022 23:53

Lol. Of course nobody cares about npower. Npower were just crap sharks who got eaten by bigger sharks. Your average Joe on the street doesn't give a shit which supplier they have, as long as they're not getting overly fucked by it. No one ever in the history of the world woke up and said to themselves "oh I know what I'll do today : I'll treat myself to a new energy provider. What fun!"

All that people want is to be able to use the functions of their homes in the manner in which they are designed, without spending too much of their take home on it.

And when more money is demanded from them, they do not want to hear bullshit about "supply and demand" and "international markets" from an absentee government whose erstwhile cabinet has many sticky fingers in many personal international monetary pies.

Amen. I’m seriously beginning to consider solar and a heat pump, not because it’s good fiscal sense (although it’s starting to look more and more like it) or because I’m a bit of a lentil weaver (although I am) but because it makes me sick to be funding them.

It’s rebellion. As close as I can get to a boycott without going and living in a tree and making candles out of my earwax. And not paying won’t work. Protesting won’t work (they don’t care) voting hasn’t worked. I’m left with hitting the bastards where it hurts them. In the wallet (well, the shares). I don’t want to give them another penny of mine if I can possibly help it.

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:51

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 00:47

I think it’s disgraceful. These large companies who pump and distribute energy can only do so because we live in a civilised functioning productive society.

The fact the price of a barrel fell so low during COVID is testament to that.

They don’t have to increase prices, they are doing it because they can. Because without Russia’s cheap gas they have us over a barrel.

I think that’s a fucking disgrace. That in a pre WW3 scenario they all band together and rinse every citizen of this planet for all that they are worth. I don’t really know what to say tbh. In an emergency situation like a pandemic it’s ok for everyone’s civil liberties to be taken away but in an emergency situation like a global energy shortage god help us we can’t possibly touch the global energy companies and demand the charge in a reasonable way.

It’s fucked. As a country we have relied on others far too long. I think we have a lot of very painful lessons we sadly will bear the brunt of learning.

Hang on, the people pumping oil out of the ground in Saudi Arabia are only able to do so because we live in a stable country in the UK?

How exactly are you claiming that that works?

LemonSwan · 03/09/2022 00:47

I think it’s disgraceful. These large companies who pump and distribute energy can only do so because we live in a civilised functioning productive society.

The fact the price of a barrel fell so low during COVID is testament to that.

They don’t have to increase prices, they are doing it because they can. Because without Russia’s cheap gas they have us over a barrel.

I think that’s a fucking disgrace. That in a pre WW3 scenario they all band together and rinse every citizen of this planet for all that they are worth. I don’t really know what to say tbh. In an emergency situation like a pandemic it’s ok for everyone’s civil liberties to be taken away but in an emergency situation like a global energy shortage god help us we can’t possibly touch the global energy companies and demand the charge in a reasonable way.

It’s fucked. As a country we have relied on others far too long. I think we have a lot of very painful lessons we sadly will bear the brunt of learning.

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:34

worriedatthistime · 03/09/2022 00:26

@HappyChloé2 at point did they say it was all about them though did they ? But its a stark reality that many many will not be able to afford to pay
And its not always easy for companies to cut people off in certain circumstances

Which has nothing at all to do with the people planning not to pay.

Liebig · 03/09/2022 00:33

worriedatthistime · 03/09/2022 00:24

@Liebig so why the big push in electric cars when we will face all these blackouts etc and are being told to use less
Its bullshit all of it , you won't see lights being turned off and less energy used in goverment buildings and the like

The car companies stand to gain from EVs, no one said anything about this being prudent, just good business. The current ESG movement means that "green" business is the current cause du jour. That's simply another way for capitalist ventures to make money off the current trends such as environmentally aware products, think vegan food and clothing as well as electric vehicles. There is nothing "green" about these ventures.

The companies selling those products are not the ones in charge of infrastructure. The politicians cannot tell people bad things, and so it's onwards to net zero and fully electric transport and home energy by 2035, because we mandated it.

We'll ignore that no energy source has ever been fully replaced by another more diffuse and intermittent version. Going from wood to coal to oil to gas and nuclear is, naturally, easier and more progressive than going from nuclear and gas to wood.

In early 2008, were people still selling toxic mortgages to people unable to pay? Why yes, yes they were. Does anyone seriously think they have the foresight to look decades into the future to anticipate the end of the fossil fuel era?

There are very few people talking about this, because if they were to talk about plausible outcomes for the future, they would be voted out of office very quickly for suggesting people cutback on everything.

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:33

worriedatthistime · 03/09/2022 00:24

@Liebig so why the big push in electric cars when we will face all these blackouts etc and are being told to use less
Its bullshit all of it , you won't see lights being turned off and less energy used in goverment buildings and the like

Because they use far less energy per mile travelled than do internal combustion engines.

worriedatthistime · 03/09/2022 00:26

@HappyChloé2 at point did they say it was all about them though did they ? But its a stark reality that many many will not be able to afford to pay
And its not always easy for companies to cut people off in certain circumstances

worriedatthistime · 03/09/2022 00:24

@Liebig so why the big push in electric cars when we will face all these blackouts etc and are being told to use less
Its bullshit all of it , you won't see lights being turned off and less energy used in goverment buildings and the like

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:24

Wisterical · 03/09/2022 00:20

@HappyChloé2 how am I an idiot for not paying a bill that I simply don’t have the money to pay?

I mentioned those not planning to pay, not those unable to. Not everything is about you..l

Liebig · 03/09/2022 00:23

Wisterical · 03/09/2022 00:20

@HappyChloé2 how am I an idiot for not paying a bill that I simply don’t have the money to pay?

That's not remotely the same as those that have money and refuse to pay because they "feel" it's too expensive.

DustinsHat · 03/09/2022 00:22

EverythingHeadinSouth · 02/09/2022 22:42

They're selling to a global market. How do you propose regulation could fix prices globally?

I think this should be a question for Liz Truss or Rishi Sunak but oh wait they’re just as fucking useless as me, a minimum wage drone who does spreadsheets for a living.

Wisterical · 03/09/2022 00:20

@HappyChloé2 how am I an idiot for not paying a bill that I simply don’t have the money to pay?

Liebig · 03/09/2022 00:17

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:12

One thing that may reduce the likelihood of blackouts are the hundreds of thousands of idiots planning not to pay their bills.

Each one of them who gets cut off reduces the probability of cuts in supply for the rest of us.

Hilariously, likely true. People need to wake up fast about reality. This is not "price gouging" like someone selling TP on eBay during the first lockdown for £100 a roll. This is simple resource limits.

No, the gov't can not pay your bills for you so you can keep using energy as you are.

No, there is no new, immediate access energy source we can put into action to counter these shortages.

No, Ukraine surrendering or a peace being otherwise negotiated will not change Russia's mind.

Yes, it is unfair that this is happening. The universe also does not care and you are not entitled to cheap, abundant energy in a world where it is exhausted.