Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP asking the same question every day. AIBU to ignore him?

418 replies

BabyBear101 · 02/09/2022 19:39

I've posted on here before about part one of this issue so some people might recognise it.

Basically, DP used to give me a hard time whenever I got home late from work. I finish at 4pm and live about 15 minutes from work. He used to get the hump and quiz me whenever I was home later than 4.20pm. He has the sort of job when he can down tools bang on finishing time and if a job isn't done then it's "someone else's problem". My job isn't like that. If I don't finish a task then it's still waiting for me the next morning. Plus I like to have a gossip with my colleagues sometimes after work 🤷‍♀️ anyway after months of this, I explained all this to him and he reluctantly agreed to cut it out.

A few months on though I noticed he would text me near the end of my working day saying "are you going to be home sharp today?" I didn't think much of it at the time but then he started sending it earlier and earlier until one day he sent it at 10am! I snapped. He huffed. Stopped for 2 weeks. Now doing it again.

I'm now ignoring him when he texts. I can tell it's annoying him because he sent the same message "will you be home sharp today?" twice in the space of an hour.

AIBU? I'm a grown woman and can plan my work day however I please.

OP posts:
CheapBeersFilledwithCrocodileTears · 03/09/2022 01:47

BabyBear101 · 02/09/2022 19:47

We don't have children so no reason for me to be home bang on 4.15pm.

Because his job is leave bang on x time, he doesn't understand why I don't.

You have two issues. 1. As multiple PP have said, is he always this controlling? AND 2. What the fuck is going on that he feels he needs to police when you enter your own home? There are tons of men with jobs that finish at X time married to women who DON’T finish at exact times, and somehow they understand it.

So either he’s a controlling arsehole, or he’s so stupid he should drown when it rains. Which is it?

Kennykenkencat · 03/09/2022 01:30

But would you grill someone if they were 5 minutes late or they asked at the beginning of the day and expected you to stick to your answer without any flexibility

What about if you fancy not getting back straight away after work and want to go to look around the shops or go for coffee

Texting to say you will be late, would you expect to be asked in detail exactly why you were late.

FictionalCharacter · 03/09/2022 01:30

“I am the "breadwinner" and he has already admitted he's intimidated by my job.”
That’s a really unhealthy attitude for him to have. I do wonder if he’s a bit resentful of you having the kind of job you do because it makes him feel less important in your life. Not only do you bring in more money and have more responsibility than he does, you spend more time at work than you need to (in his eyes) - so you’re giving your work attention that he’d like you to be giving him instead. Hence the following you around talking. It’s like “you’ve spent all that unnecessary time at work, now give me some attention!”
So not necessarily controlling, but maybe needy because he resents you not having a job more like his.

user29 · 03/09/2022 01:25

I dont think its unreasonable to want a rough idea of when your partner is going to be home. I would vertainly text if i was going o be late. Not controlling , its jsut normal manners and communication

Novum · 03/09/2022 01:17

Doesn't have any interests or any means of entertaining himself when alone at home?

In your shoes I'd be tempted to block texts from him during working hours.

Kennykenkencat · 03/09/2022 00:58

He sounds like a very boring person.

No friends, no interests or hobbies, no real conversation because he hasn’t done anything of interest and only does the bare minimum that he is paid for

What on earth does he find to talk about when he hasn’t done anything.

No job is for life and I would worry that with the attitude he has towards work he will at some stage find himself unemployed and won’t be eager to get his CV together and be proactive in finding another job because he isn’t being paid for the work.

Can I ask do his parents have a similar attitude

pawkins · 03/09/2022 00:52

Novum · 03/09/2022 00:39

Seriously, how could he not understand that? How difficult is it to work out the concept that, when people pay you to do a job, they expect you to do the job?

A lot of people don't understand this.
A friend of mine is self employed in a desk job and worked from home. Her DP is self employed in a service type/sales job. He never understands why she gives herself timed breaks and works to a strict timetable every day. He fully expects her to close her laptop whenever he wants to go out for lunch (which is when he is having a slow sales day). He's the same with holidays. When he wants to go on holiday, he closes his business. She has regular clients so she can't do this. There is no understanding there because he has never been worked for anyone else. He's flexible and easy going and she is a planner.

ThePumpkinPatch · 03/09/2022 00:40

@Smineusername Autistic people are not toddlers, HTH

Novum · 03/09/2022 00:39

BabyBear101 · 02/09/2022 21:18

When covid started, I worked from home but had to go back after 3 weeks as he was constantly hovering around during my calls, chatting constantly and asking can I take an hour off to go for a walk? He was bored and didn't understand I needed to work.

Seriously, how could he not understand that? How difficult is it to work out the concept that, when people pay you to do a job, they expect you to do the job?

pawkins · 03/09/2022 00:36

BabyBear101 · 02/09/2022 21:32

When I asked him he said "you're paid until 4. You should leave at 4".

My DH is similar about finishing bang on time as otherwise work is getting its 'pound of flesh'. My parents used also say to 'walk out' the minute the clock struck 5pm. I always thought it was because my parents were self employed that they had no idea that people 'in jobs' didn't 'walk out' the door on the dot.

DH earns a high salary and seems to come and go as he pleases. I earn peanuts and always seem to be doing more hours than I'm paid to do. He keeps saying that my job is 'transactional' and I should only work the exact time I'm being paid to work. I think there are two reasons - firstly DH has a different work mindset. He sees himself as an asset to the company and values the contribution he makes to the company whereas I am completely dispensable and can be replaced immediately so I am always 'proving' myself to my employers. Secondly DH was far worse than me as he worked every evening after the kids went to bed including weekend. His whole team was made redundant out of the blue and he felt very hard done by when he realised he was .just a number' and he changed his behaviour as his career progressed.

YANBU OP. The texts do sound a bit controlling though I presume he isn't asking because he is planning on cooking and you eating together before he goes to work? It might be just easier to say from now on you will be home half an hour later than when you usually are and see if that stops it?

HarryBlaster · 03/09/2022 00:30

It does sound controlling. It sounds terribly suffocating. It also sounds like he needs a new job and / or interests.

Octomore · 03/09/2022 00:28

abblie · 02/09/2022 23:09

My reply would be I only answer to my father and you are not him

Wtaf? Your father?!? What about your own agency as an autonomous adult?

ToGanymedeAndTitan · 03/09/2022 00:15

Not read all the thread, but jeez, that'd drive me bonkers .
YANBU (although YABU for putting up with it, I'd seriously go out for a walk or a glass of wine in a pub after work if DH started doing all that crap on me!

WtoB · 03/09/2022 00:12

Is he on the spectrum?

bloodyunicorns · 03/09/2022 00:09

Urgh. Is he very stupid and hard of understanding? No? Then presumably he know that you can't leave at 4pm, because things crop up, and that he has to leave you to take calls etc during Covid. He sounds like a needy, selfish idiot.

CockingASnook · 03/09/2022 00:05

He sounds like the sort of person who really needs order and a system in their life. Zero flexibility. I know a few colleagues like this but I'm the opposite. Used to happily stay at work until midnight to get the job done not because I was being paid. He also has quite an us-and-them attitude to employment, which I don't. My job is to complete X tasks not just be present from 9-5. I would offer two thoughts: one, there's nothing suspicious going on with him, he just doesn't understand. Two, it will get worse with age. Better to draw a firm line under this behaviour now.

deeperthanallroses · 03/09/2022 00:01

@ADHDkillingme that seems totally different to me. When you are home and exhausted with young babies your partner is the cavalry to give you a break- you depend on their arrival and he owes that time to his family. No one owes an adult partner every moment of their day. I’ve felt like you do and of course it’s normal to ask sometimes when they will be home even past that stage - I check when I have evening meetings or the baby is being really difficult while I’m trying to prep dinner or I wanted to go for a run.
op, I know you think it sounds dramatic but I would not could not be in your relationship. Just the texting about being home would have me tense every day waiting for it and I’d erupt into a fury on receiving it tbh. My replies would be very rude. In the early days they’d have been ‘we talked about this’ and they’d go up from there.
but the whole complete incomprehension- I just couldn’t look at him to be honest. I mean, what part of I cannot just take a walk for an hour do you understand? What part of I’m working and you need to STOP TALKING? what part of I can’t leave on 4? I must have said it several thousand times by now - have you TRIED to understand? Do you think I’m your clone? Am I as tall as you? Do I do everything exactly the same as you? Do you think I secretly work for your company in the exact same job? Do you recognise that a fireman had a different job from a teacher? Do you recognise they won’t work identical hours? Do you think a garbage man can pause the truck on morning rounds, with someone’s bin hanging in mid air, and wander off for a walk and chat? When you’re in a cafe and the waiter is walking towards you with your coffee, can they just dump it in the nearest surface instead and go for a chat? I couldn’t cope with the incomprehension in a partner. When I didn’t have children I’d be home between 7:30 and midnight, I had enough of an issue in the early days wiht dh getting home and relaxing and ready to jump on me as I walked in the door to ask how was your day etc. we had to discuss that he’s had his downtime, I am an introvert and I need to be able to walk in my door without this. I cannot imagine living through your scenario and not thinking this man is completely incompatible with everyone else on the planet.

SleepingAgent · 02/09/2022 23:55

billy1966 · 02/09/2022 20:26

So you married a man just like your parents?

Controlling.

You are still with him?

He's not going to change.

If you are silly enough to have children with him, THEN his really Controlling nature will come out.

He will think you are stuck and that he can ramp up his behaviour.

Can you not see how abnormal and totly fxxk up it is for him to be at work but texting you about your finishing time?

He's a controlling freak and you better wake up and cop on and see what is going on right in front of you.

You have an absolutely shit future ahead of you if you don't.

Just adding to the chorus of "controlling arse, dump and run" as per above!

Wheresthebeach · 02/09/2022 23:52

Can you imagine how bad he’d be if you had kids with him?
time to give this relationship some serious thought - massively controlling and irritating

Marvellousmadness · 02/09/2022 23:42

He either is
controlling
Abusive
Or extremely needy

Neither are great

But ignoring him???
No op

SET HIM STRAIGHT ONCE AND FOR ALL

Tell him to stop messaging you everyday
Tell him you work until work is done and this may vary everyday
Tell him he needs to stop harassing you with his messages as you will NOT be responding to them anymore and that his behaviour is bordering on Abusive and definitely is controlling and that you aren't having it no more. BACK OFF

And leave him stunned.let him digest it
And when he Does text you again. You ignore him and give him hell again. And eventually you just give him a deadline if he doesn't listen and leave him and his bizarre behaviour

Brigante9 · 02/09/2022 23:38

Jesus, this would drive me nuts! Have you told him to stop messaging constantly? If he's on night shift, how is he messaging from like 10 am. I'd be tempted to respond with 'Be home when I finish' and ignore all other messages.

CookieCoo · 02/09/2022 23:36

I’d be snappy in your shoes!!

“Stop nagging me, I’ll be home when I get home, I might fancy popping to the shop or having a coffee with a friend. Stop nagging, I’m not a child, I’m not accounting for my time!!” And repeat.

6coffeesbefore9am · 02/09/2022 23:28

You were told the first time he was controlling and to end the relationship. The advice is the same.

Thighdentitycrisis · 02/09/2022 23:26

@DanielTheGhostGangbanger
beat me to it!

kateandme · 02/09/2022 23:26

ADHDkillingme · 02/09/2022 23:13

@CoolerThanIceCream Yes I understand that and like I said I’ve never even really given it much thought until now. I’ve just checked and I did it twice this working week. One was after 5 one day asking how long he was going to be till he was home (at that time it’s definitely meal prep related) and another asking if he thought he would be having a half day today.

We do text on and off throughout the day some days anyway - not really conversation just random statements tbh.

Sadly we are both lacking in outside parties in our lives and we are quite an insular couple/family so we are pretty tragic in that type of way anyway Blush

Your seems to be an emotionally triggered response luv. Add to that this is a very real symptomatic behaviour of adhd so please don’t beat yourself up about it. The reasons you do it might seem completely irrational to some but in your case at least from the gist I’ve read it doesn’t seem the controlling way AT ALL.
there no might be technique’s you can do to make you feel calmer and more able to jot ask the questions though,and more able to sit with that feeling that make you text and need to no what happening all the time.