Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP asking the same question every day. AIBU to ignore him?

418 replies

BabyBear101 · 02/09/2022 19:39

I've posted on here before about part one of this issue so some people might recognise it.

Basically, DP used to give me a hard time whenever I got home late from work. I finish at 4pm and live about 15 minutes from work. He used to get the hump and quiz me whenever I was home later than 4.20pm. He has the sort of job when he can down tools bang on finishing time and if a job isn't done then it's "someone else's problem". My job isn't like that. If I don't finish a task then it's still waiting for me the next morning. Plus I like to have a gossip with my colleagues sometimes after work 🤷‍♀️ anyway after months of this, I explained all this to him and he reluctantly agreed to cut it out.

A few months on though I noticed he would text me near the end of my working day saying "are you going to be home sharp today?" I didn't think much of it at the time but then he started sending it earlier and earlier until one day he sent it at 10am! I snapped. He huffed. Stopped for 2 weeks. Now doing it again.

I'm now ignoring him when he texts. I can tell it's annoying him because he sent the same message "will you be home sharp today?" twice in the space of an hour.

AIBU? I'm a grown woman and can plan my work day however I please.

OP posts:
PuzzledObserver · 03/09/2022 08:38

Mobiles are both a blessing and a curse. Back in the days before mobile phones, people went off to work and had no communication all day till they got home. Barring emergencies, when of course it would be acceptable to ring the other’s workplace.

Meanwhile, OP - as a manager, working longer than your contracted hours is par for the course, as is the need to be able to concentrate on your work responsibilities without constantly being interrupted by texts. He needs to understand this and stop fighting it. This is the job you have chosen and are doing well in.

If it is indeed boredom causing him to text you, how about a conversation in which you tell him it’s not possible to predict what time you will be leaving because you never know what’s going to come up. So instead of him texting every day to ask you, you come to an agreement that if you’re not able to leave by (say) 4.30, that you text him and say “running late”, and then when you’re ready to leave, “on my way.”

That way, he will know that you will be home by 4.45, unless you have texted him. And the days when you walk through the door at 4.20 will be a nice surprise!

JaneBrowning · 03/09/2022 08:36

Hurrrrah · 03/09/2022 06:48

Posted too soon, it's a normal thing to do to me. We exchange a few messages a day, usually practical messages about our children or food etc but I will ask what time you home. I must be a monster!

Maybe read the whole thread @Hurrrrah You are having a complete empathy-pass. Missed the point and tone completely.

This is not about practical stuff like childcare.

The OP has no kids.

Fairislefandango · 03/09/2022 08:36

How can you hope to 'nip this in the bud'? In a way it's not the actual behaviours so much which should cause you to question staying in the relationship (annoying and needy/controlling as they are), it's the underlying attitudes which cause the behaviours.

The fact that he needs to know where you are and who you're with at all times, is intimidated by your job and promotion, and is too ignorant to understand that not all jobs work like his are all red flags imo.

Waterfallgirl · 03/09/2022 08:34

It IS controlling - it is impacting on your life - if you are looking at the clock at 3.45 in the afternoon and feeling uneasy. That is just awful and sad.

Even putting up with his views on when you should finish work must be hard, it’s your job - and as a manager you might have to stay much longer sometimes and maybe career progression will mean more flexibility is needed as time goes on. What will he do then? Keep texting you more,? Put pressure on you the leave your job? Not take promotions?

The texting during the day asking you when you are finishing is also controlling.

Kashmirsilver · 03/09/2022 08:28

Why don't you ask him why?
Some posters have alluded to differing views on work. I've always worked to rule, overtime only if begged, forced. I've had my own business since 2006, I have very clear boundaries between business and my personal life. Work is only a vehicle to earn an income, nothing more nothing less. If a particular set of works is going to be intrusive I formulate a strategy so this isn't too for too long.

As for DP, we rarely communicate during the day, she has a long commute on office days, so we might talk in the morning. On the return journey, she just sends a text telling me she's set off (The commute can be up to 180 mins traffic-dependent). Then she'll arrive home when she gets home. There are no conversations.
We both like to end the day, with food, and a catch-up.

We do both discuss if any particular time periods are going to be extended or intrusive work-wise. Socializing, we both give estimates I think that's normal and respectful, nothing wrong with I'll be home soon like an hr or so notice.

LicoricePizza · 03/09/2022 08:23

Is he generally a very insular homebody type of person?

Maybe you should get him to address what’s truly bothering him because if he’s u happy, anxious, bored etc he cannot project it onto you being the remedy IMO.

Lcb123 · 03/09/2022 08:18

thats more than an annoying question - to me that sounds controlling and paranoid.

astuz · 03/09/2022 08:06

A friend of mine was married to a man who was like this. He wasn't directly controlling, but he effectively controlled everything she did by constantly texting her whenever she wasn't home. She caved into it all, and by the end, she was pretty much housebound, then piled on weight, making her even more housebound, and this is a friend who loves the outdoors and adventures. You are right that you need to nip it in the bud. In fact, I would purposely make plans to go for a coffee with work colleagues, or go to the gym or something after work, a couple of nights a week, to make it quite clear that your life is your own. Arrange to do something with friends or family at the weekend as well - you need to keep doing this until he realises that you are not responsible for his social life, boredom levels etc. And strongly encourage him to take up a hobby, so you both have something that you do away from each other.

I've had to do this myself recently, because I enjoy walking and the cinema, DH would prefer to stay at home. For years, I would cajole him into coming with me, but I've realised he's much happier just staying at home, and I can go to the cinema with friends or on my own, and I've joined a walking group for the walking. Your partner needs to have a similar change of his state of mind.

hopeishere · 03/09/2022 08:05

Does he work out of the house? It partly sounds like a misunderstanding about the world of work.

Phoning you when you had a big meeting is very annoying. My manager's husband phones her every Monday during our team meeting. And she always answers!!

velvetvixen · 03/09/2022 08:03

I found myself watching the clock at my 3.45pm meeting yesterday and feeling a bit uneasy.

So your working life is being impacted. Your social life is being impacted. All because of this man. Is it all actually worth having him around I wonder.

MintJulia · 03/09/2022 07:59

I'd reply every time, 'no idea, you know how my job is'.

Until eventually I'd snap and send 'No idea, but I'm a grown woman and I don't need help getting home. Thanks.'

BabyBear101 · 03/09/2022 07:49

Kennykenkencat · 03/09/2022 00:58

He sounds like a very boring person.

No friends, no interests or hobbies, no real conversation because he hasn’t done anything of interest and only does the bare minimum that he is paid for

What on earth does he find to talk about when he hasn’t done anything.

No job is for life and I would worry that with the attitude he has towards work he will at some stage find himself unemployed and won’t be eager to get his CV together and be proactive in finding another job because he isn’t being paid for the work.

Can I ask do his parents have a similar attitude

Interesting that you asked about his parents. His mum is a nurse and he has said the same about her before when she's running late.

I've heard him say to his dad "she [mum] finishes at 2, how come she didn't get home till after 4?". His dad looked incredulous.

OP posts:
Shelby2010 · 03/09/2022 07:49

Hurrrrah · 03/09/2022 06:48

Posted too soon, it's a normal thing to do to me. We exchange a few messages a day, usually practical messages about our children or food etc but I will ask what time you home. I must be a monster!

I think it’s normal to ask/say what time you’ll be home if it tends to vary. Or the person might be going somewhere else before going home (drink, shops, gym etc).

Not so much if you’re checking whether someone will be in at 4.30 rather than 4.15 because they had a chat with a colleague on the way out, or stayed to finish an email. Which isn’t something you could even predict at 10am!

BabyBear101 · 03/09/2022 07:42

Morning all, thank you for your messages! Definitely food for thought.

Just to reiterate he doesn't quiz me any more when I get home late. Like I said in my OP, he stopped that when I had a go at him.

It's just the daily "Will you be home sharp today?" messages that I have a gripe with. I used to answer "don't know", but now I completely ignore them (until yesterday when he asked twice in an hour).

Even though I don't get quizzed anymore, it's like what a pp said, it's that expectation that I should be home when I said I would. I found myself watching the clock at my 3.45pm meeting yesterday and feeling a bit uneasy. I guess kind of like reverse psychology.

OP posts:
Shelby2010 · 03/09/2022 07:40

Another thing to try is to give him a job every time he texts….
-Are you going to be home sharpish?
-Don’t know. But I’ll definitely be back by 5pm. Can you peel some potatoes for tea?
-So what time will you be back?
-Don’t know. Can you hoover the lounge if you’re not busy?

Might put him off, and if not hopefully you’ll come home to find all the jobs done! Also reset his expectations that you will be home by 5pm (unless other plans) not 4.20pm. So you are only ‘late’ if it’s after 5pm.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 03/09/2022 07:22

user29 · 03/09/2022 01:25

I dont think its unreasonable to want a rough idea of when your partner is going to be home. I would vertainly text if i was going o be late. Not controlling , its jsut normal manners and communication

You've not read the whole thread, have you?

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 03/09/2022 06:54

mjf981 · 03/09/2022 02:45

He's bored and lonely and maybe a bit insecure about your job.
Talk to him again. Say he is being needy and suffocating and to back down. It certainly doesn't warrant LTB yet despite the MN pile on that always happens with these threads..

I can never understand what's wrong with LTB. If somebody isn't right for you, why would you stay with them? There is absolutely no moral advantage in being a martyr.

Hurrrrah · 03/09/2022 06:48

Posted too soon, it's a normal thing to do to me. We exchange a few messages a day, usually practical messages about our children or food etc but I will ask what time you home. I must be a monster!

Hurrrrah · 03/09/2022 06:46

I message my husband most days to ask when he's going to be home from work, I wfh and my parents look after our children so it isn't a childcare thing. I just like knowing when he'll be back, I like him! I'm not controlling, it's a no

speakout · 03/09/2022 06:25

autienotnaughty · 03/09/2022 05:17

Either he's controlling and expects you to be where he wants you, or he's an anxious person who finds it hard not knowing what's happening or possibly he's bored/lonely. Are you his social life or does he have friends and family he sees independently from you. I'd probably say I don't have time to chat at work and then don't engage except maybe at lunch time.

It may be the case that this guy is anxious bored/lonely.
But that's up to him to sort out.
My OH technically finished work at 5.30- and works a 20 minute drive away. He is rarely home before 7.30.
He usually gets home somewhere between 6 and 8 pm.
But this irregularity is normal- him or I would never text or call- I don't really need to know when he will be home.

autienotnaughty · 03/09/2022 05:17

Either he's controlling and expects you to be where he wants you, or he's an anxious person who finds it hard not knowing what's happening or possibly he's bored/lonely. Are you his social life or does he have friends and family he sees independently from you. I'd probably say I don't have time to chat at work and then don't engage except maybe at lunch time.

CoolerThanIceCream · 03/09/2022 03:21

mjf981 · 03/09/2022 02:45

He's bored and lonely and maybe a bit insecure about your job.
Talk to him again. Say he is being needy and suffocating and to back down. It certainly doesn't warrant LTB yet despite the MN pile on that always happens with these threads..

No, it doesn’t warrant LTB - if you believe ‘any man is better than no man’.

But … they’re not married, they don’t have kids, and she’s the main earner. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Why wouldn’t you move on in these circumstances?

There are, literally, billions of men on earth - why settle for such an annoying, clingy, needy, pathetic sub-standard one?

Not saying this applies to you necessarily, but I really do get a vibe that the anti-LTB brigade somehow think they’re morally superior - but all I think is you’re clearly in the camp that thinks any man is better than no man, and that’s not a place I’d ever want to be.

BadNomad · 03/09/2022 03:20

Well, as someone with autism, I am not offended by people suggesting this because this "neediness" is quite familiar to me. It's to do with routine and expectations. Change in routine = anxiety. If you know someone finishes work at a specific time, and it takes them 15 minutes to get home, but then when they don't get home at that time, it causes anxiety. So it is very possible that he is asking if she's going to be late home so he will know not to expect her to be home "on time". In that case, the motive isn't to control or keep tabs on her, it is just him trying to manage his anxiety. And I'm the same about start and finish times 😬I had a job once that started at 9am, but you had to be there by 8:45 to do handover. It made me crazy. I still don't understand why they didn't make 8:45 the start time. I begrudged not getting paid for those 15 mins. If the job starts at 9am then that's the time I should start! Anyway...

But that doesn't make it any less annoying for the OP. Her DP needs to find a better way to cope with uncertainty other than harass her by text every day.

mjf981 · 03/09/2022 02:45

He's bored and lonely and maybe a bit insecure about your job.
Talk to him again. Say he is being needy and suffocating and to back down. It certainly doesn't warrant LTB yet despite the MN pile on that always happens with these threads..

FetchezLaVache · 03/09/2022 02:02

Sometimes just the same message "hi gorgeous" every hour if I don't reply

Fucking hell. That would cause my lady parts to fuse permanently closed.

I was going to post in the chap's favour, pointing out that as he works nights, his time with the OP is limited and he probably just looks forward to spending as much time as he can with her before starting work, but then I read the post about how she couldn't work from home during Covid for the annoyance of the man and changed my mind.