Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housing Crisis solutions

167 replies

Aslockton · 02/09/2022 18:50

I watched the Tonight programme last night which seemed to suggest the rise of 2nd home owners and airbnb is causing the lack of housing.

What's the solution? If I were in change...

  1. Prevent Landlords increasing rents by more that 2% a year (straight away)
  2. Tax all rental profits at 40% (starting next year)
  3. Rise stamp duty on non-primary residence purchases to 20% (straight away)
  4. Double council tax on 2nd homes and airbnb (straight away)
  5. Waive capital gains tax on all second property sales for 2 years. (This will encourage 2nd home owners and landlords to sell up)
  6. Make it law that tenants have to be offered the home first (if landlords sell) and the price will be determined by an independent adjudicator (like lease sales are).

Are these ideas unreasonable/ bonkers or both!!
If I had a second home, I would be tempted to sell up.

OP posts:
Getoff · 02/09/2022 23:01

Perhaps I would have a wealth tax on residential property, with the proviso that any tax on rental income from a property should reduce the wealth-tax pound-for-pound, so the property is not being taxed twice.

Kendodd · 02/09/2022 23:01

I'm a LL
I largely agree.

IncessantNameChanger · 02/09/2022 22:59

My tennants could never afford to buy the house. If they could they wouldn't be renting it. If it wasn't for the thought of making them homeless I'd get rid of it tomorrow. Not sure exactly where they move too as it a three bed semi with drive and garage I'm renting for under 1000 within 50 minutes direct line to London.

I don't think they have a countless abundance of better offers.

If I wasn't living in rented for dh work I'd had never bought it but I'm not regretting getting on the property ladder so far. If I hadn't bought it, I most definitely would be in the situation of never offording to buy today.

If there was more council housing but there isn't. Plus the days of btl being attractive and well and truly long gone.

Getoff · 02/09/2022 22:58

I would abolish all tax relief on mortgage interest for individual landlords. (Corporations could still get tax relief.)

I would make rental income on secure tenancies tax-free for corporations, hopefully encouraging large investors including insurance companies to get into the residential landlord market.

I would change the benefits system to make payments to each adult individual, rather than each household, so that who you lived with would never make a difference to what you were entitled to. This would make it more attractive for people to share housing.

Getoff · 02/09/2022 22:49

Aslockton · 02/09/2022 21:28

Yes, I have a friend who works in sales for new build flats in London. She said they are bought up by large investors who sit on them empty waiting for the market to rise. They are in no hurry to rent them out.

The idea that London newbuilds are left empty by investor-buyers was investigated by academics, at the instigation of the Mayor of London, and found to be false.

The illusion that this might be the case is caused by the fact that it can be up to two years after completion before a building is fully occupied.

It's always been obvious to me that this idea was false, as it makes no economic sense. If you own a property that no-one lives in, you are throwing away income you could have had with every month that goes by. Why would someone motivated by money do that, year after year? If it was the case that wear-and-tear outweighed rent, no-one would ever be a landlord.

mondaytosunday · 02/09/2022 22:44

Why do you think this would help? Why penalise people offering much neeeded housing? Do you think that suddenly all these renters will be in a position to buy or even want to?
How are you going to house: students? Young people just starting out? People who do not want the responsibility of home ownership? People here on secondment? People who can't or don't want or would not be able to get a mortgage?
When my husband died I invested in a small house and flat for a steady income as my kids were very small. The people I rent to are either students who stay for two/three years, or just want to rent a place they could not afford to buy.
Second homes that remain empty for 90% of the time should perhaps have sone added taxation. So should a limit on foreigners bulk purchasing flats to park their money that they leave empty.

SuperlativeOxymoron · 02/09/2022 22:35

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/09/2022 19:00

There is a housing crisis because the population is expanding far faster than we can supply housing. It is increasing mainly through adult immigration, not through birth and family formation, which would put less strain on the housing stock. The city where I live has seen a population increase of 8 per cent in the past ten years. The housing stock has been expanded by the endless creation of new housing estates ( but without any increase in sewerage, electric generation, ,new main roads etc) but it can’t keep up.
I expect this answer will be replied to with accusations of racism and then be removed. It is still true, though.

Are you in the East Midlands to East of England by any chance as that sounds very similar to the city I'm in.
Huge population boom, but mainly from commuters (not just people moving to the UK to work, but also people priced out of London) rather than childbirth.

GreenLunchBox · 02/09/2022 22:34

Wibbly1008 · 02/09/2022 18:52

Some people need to rent because they can’t get mortgages, for various reasons. If there are no landlords (because it’s not worth having a second property) there can’t be any renting - could create a bigger problem in the long run

Yep, I saw a news feature on Sky news today about the rental problems in Ireland. It said there was something like 700 properties available to rent for a population of five million

Isaidnoalready · 02/09/2022 22:32

Hammering landlords will just result in them selling up and people becoming homeless

There are houses but they are in areas with no jobs or transport too jobs so they are pretty useless

People can't afford to buy houses right now they just can't

Social housing needs a shake up no pensioner should be allowed to keep a three bed Social housing property when they live alone

Yes immigration is an issue everyone gets put in a diverse area which happens to be big cities causing more issues there

Overseas investments half my town centre is rotting its also owned by overseas and they set the rent so high its never rented it sits and rots they don't want to rent it out however it could have easily been converted into housing

Pricing caps on rent would be a great idea for example my Social housing rent is £450 pcm private is between £550 and £650 (more desirable part of my town) someone has recently converted a shop into flats one bedroom "flats" no parking tiny spaces no outdoor space etc £850 plus a month who is going to pay that? No-one can afford that? There needs to be a cap a proper LHA valuation years ago a man would come around every year and asses your rent rates for benefits purposes this needs to happen again

gogohmm · 02/09/2022 22:30

People need to be able to rent. There's many reasons you may need a shortish term rental eg moving area for job and can't sell house quick enough, temporarily relocating, divorce etc. if landlords can't make a profit they will pull out of the market meaning there will be no rentals. Also how you ever booked a self catering holiday? I've been going to Cornwall self catering for all my life.

Personally I think that all holiday rentals should be registered and capped at a certain amount in an area. Second homes that are not being let should have very high taxation. Landlords with up to 5 properties should not be punitively taxed as long as rents are fare

Caramilk · 02/09/2022 22:28

I'm not sure forcing people to sell second homes would make much difference in the long run.

The big companies that own a lot of housing would probably continue to do so, so you'd be looking at people with one or two second properties.

But if you release a lot of houses on the market, what happens?

Well initially prices would probably go down, which would be good for the people who are in the band of not being able to buy... but then can, which will be great for them, but I suspect relatively few people would be in that situation.

What would effect more of the less well off people would be that with the reduction in number of rental places the rental prices would go up, so more people would be not able to afford to rent, I suspect in far greater numbers than the ones who would be able to buy.

But also if prices go down guess what the big rental groups would think.... Whoopee, I can add to my stock.

So the people that would gain would be the big rental companies who could buy more housing and charge more rent.
The people that would lose out are the people with one property to rent, and the majority of renters.

Nat6999 · 02/09/2022 22:23

Let councils use static caravans to get their housing lists down, it would support jobs in the caravan industry as most of them are built here. Many councils have plots of land they aren't using, in Sheffield there are quite a few schools that have been closed & flattened but the land is going to waste, I live next to one that has planning permission for 65 houses & a rest home, it's been empty for 20 years, they could have it up & running in 3 months, just needs utilities laying on. The government could subsidise the purchase of the statics or allow councils to buy them VAT free. I would happily live in one instead of my flat.

Helenahandcartt · 02/09/2022 22:20

Nidan2Sandan · 02/09/2022 22:08

This already happens in most new build estates. In order to get planning permission and grants etc approx 30% of new housing estates need to be for social housing, usually under a HA.

In addition these days they're not allowed to have one end private owners and one end social housing to avoid a "getto" scenario. It's now all about mixed tenure so you could own a £500k house and your neighbour in the same house rents it from an HA for £600 a month.

It been a while since I worked in that section of social housing, but if I recall the thinking behind it was that if you were unemployed, you'd see your neighbour getting off to work every day, maybe a nice car and it would make you want to aspire to the same. We know that's nonsense but that was the govt thought process 🤨

What happens where I am:
-developer promises large percentage of social housing, gets planning permission and meets requirements. Council celebrate the partnership and sell land cheaply
-developer claims issues/ costs require less social housing. Council allow this in order to carry on
-developer stalls, claims further issues. Social housing is eventually reduced to about 5% and segregated by the time anything is built.
-council officials in time become employees of the developers or share holders

Hereward1332 · 02/09/2022 22:17

It won't solve the crisis but one change should be to tax rent at source. I have a former colleague living in a tax haven with three rental properties in London, paying virtually no tax on the income nor on any capital gain. Foreign landlords ought to pay tax at the very least, preferably they should be banned from all but super high end property.

BaileySharp · 02/09/2022 22:15

Limit 2nd homes in holiday destinations? New build estates maybe a good percentage (is 50% too much?) should be council houses to increase housing stock!

Porcupineintherough · 02/09/2022 22:15

How about - building some more housing? It's the only thing that will get prices to fall and provide homes. More social housing needs to be built too.

Nidan2Sandan · 02/09/2022 22:08

OddBoots · 02/09/2022 19:56

I don't know enough to know if it would work but in the same way there is a requirement for a certain number of 'affordable housing' dwellings to be built on a new development there could also be a requirement that a percentage of the houses should be social housing that go straight to the LA (or HA) upon completion, possibly wiht the cost being shared by local and/or national government. I realise this will put the prices of the purchased houses up but it spreads the social housing out as well as increasing the amount of it.

We defiantly need more social housing now so many landlords are selling up and we know now that building big estates of it causes problems.

This already happens in most new build estates. In order to get planning permission and grants etc approx 30% of new housing estates need to be for social housing, usually under a HA.

In addition these days they're not allowed to have one end private owners and one end social housing to avoid a "getto" scenario. It's now all about mixed tenure so you could own a £500k house and your neighbour in the same house rents it from an HA for £600 a month.

It been a while since I worked in that section of social housing, but if I recall the thinking behind it was that if you were unemployed, you'd see your neighbour getting off to work every day, maybe a nice car and it would make you want to aspire to the same. We know that's nonsense but that was the govt thought process 🤨

oviraptor21 · 02/09/2022 22:04

No need for hammering private landlords but regulations around ensuring properties are habitable and repairs etc are attended to quickly need to be improved and there need to be penalties for landlords who ignore the regulations and councils who fail to enforce them.

Helenahandcartt · 02/09/2022 22:02

Where I am in London the crisis is the rental sector. Some estate agents have left the market there is so little. People are offering a year up front even. Many people go for each property and rent prices are climbing higher and higher. Some people need to ent and taking away the market isn’t helping the , they won’t be buying if the market falls a little.

I don’t have a broader sense of the whole country, but the issue here is affordable housing. Either rental or to buy. Flats are being built at a crazy rate, but so little of it is affordable. Both in for rent and sale it’s the one bed flats and small properties that are inflated, the 2-3 beds often aren’t much more. The fanciest ones are often even empty once built!

for me what needs to be done

-some socially planned housing. Somewhere between estates of detached houses/ fancy flats and high rise. Large areas with social developers to make practical housing. What is being built needs to change. What is built needs to be better joined up and planned, like the new towns where

-selling a second property needs to be easier tax wise, buying one needs to have more barriers

-shared ownership needs to become a social model, between council owned and private sales. Not for profit

oviraptor21 · 02/09/2022 22:01

Stripyhoglets1 · 02/09/2022 20:05

Abolishing the right to buy is essential too

And this

oviraptor21 · 02/09/2022 22:01

OddBoots · 02/09/2022 19:56

I don't know enough to know if it would work but in the same way there is a requirement for a certain number of 'affordable housing' dwellings to be built on a new development there could also be a requirement that a percentage of the houses should be social housing that go straight to the LA (or HA) upon completion, possibly wiht the cost being shared by local and/or national government. I realise this will put the prices of the purchased houses up but it spreads the social housing out as well as increasing the amount of it.

We defiantly need more social housing now so many landlords are selling up and we know now that building big estates of it causes problems.

This

sst1234 · 02/09/2022 21:50

Wow so much nonsense about tax here and restrictions there. While the elephant stomps around the room screaming ‘look at me’.

Housebuilding. Supply and demand.

PureBlackVoid · 02/09/2022 21:42

I don’t know how much of a dent it would make but I’ve always thought properties bought through RTB shouldn’t be allowed to be rented at private market rates, even if they are sold on. They should be let through Council, who for a fee can act as the managing agent (lower fee than private companies), sort the maintenance etc. Landlord still responsible for big jobs such as kitchen upgrades. There could be tiers, or some sort of thresholds for which properties can be let to those on the housing register, and those ‘open to all’ (my council has two separate lists, not sure if it’s the same for all). Rent amount should be on par with social housing rates, again maybe tiers for type/condition of property.

People can still make use of RTB, Councils can still get use of some properties they’ve sold off, landlords and tenants get some form of security in different ways, compared to general private let. Most councils have a ‘lettable standard’ for example which applies to more than just gas safety and electric testing.

I’m sure there are issues with this idea but I think if councils had a finger in the pie, they would also be more proactive to help both tenants and landlords where there is non payment of rent, ASB, or crap landlords.

Aslockton · 02/09/2022 21:28

Yes, I have a friend who works in sales for new build flats in London. She said they are bought up by large investors who sit on them empty waiting for the market to rise. They are in no hurry to rent them out.

OP posts: