Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housing Crisis solutions

167 replies

Aslockton · 02/09/2022 18:50

I watched the Tonight programme last night which seemed to suggest the rise of 2nd home owners and airbnb is causing the lack of housing.

What's the solution? If I were in change...

  1. Prevent Landlords increasing rents by more that 2% a year (straight away)
  2. Tax all rental profits at 40% (starting next year)
  3. Rise stamp duty on non-primary residence purchases to 20% (straight away)
  4. Double council tax on 2nd homes and airbnb (straight away)
  5. Waive capital gains tax on all second property sales for 2 years. (This will encourage 2nd home owners and landlords to sell up)
  6. Make it law that tenants have to be offered the home first (if landlords sell) and the price will be determined by an independent adjudicator (like lease sales are).

Are these ideas unreasonable/ bonkers or both!!
If I had a second home, I would be tempted to sell up.

OP posts:
HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:31

EverythingHeadinSouth · 03/09/2022 00:10

Are you living on a different planet or just at the wind up? Even if you really are the owner of property that rents out for £5000 pcm you can't be so detached from reality (or basic arithmetic) to realise that £850 a month is not "very cheap" for the vast majority of the population, given average salaries and the number of people on NMW.

Of course it is. £650 per month to rent a home is very cheap. It’s affordable even for a single adult on minimum wage.

The average monthly rent in the UK is around £1,100 per year. 650 is well below the average, and so clearly can be viewed as very cheap.

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:28

XenoBitch · 03/09/2022 00:09

Of course, everyone who rents is on £100k a year. Maybe in your world. Meanwhile in the real one.....

What are you talking about? No-one’s made such a stupid claim.

Even if a couple are both on minimum wage, that’s still the best part of £40,000 per year between them. If the can’t afford £650 per month rent out of that then they need to learn to budget better. It’s certainly not an argument for capping rents.

Again, why do you think it right that rent should be based on someone’s earnings?

If I can rent a flat out for £1,000 per month, why would I instead choose to rent it to someone who can’t pay that much, rathe pr than the family who can?

sst1234 · 03/09/2022 00:24

XenoBitch · 02/09/2022 23:54

A £150pm increase is an absurd amount. Would you put up with that?

What’s that got to do with the price of fish? Or houses? You can say you don’t want to put up with something, but not sure your dislike counts for much.

Prices don’t stay static because you don’t like them to increase. It’s a case of supply and demand. If you want lower prices of anything, you need to increase supply.

EverythingHeadinSouth · 03/09/2022 00:10

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:00

Given how small either amount is it’s really not enough to be concerned about. So yes, if my rent went from ludicrously cheap to just very cheap I’d be fine with it.

My tenants are paying £5,000 per month, an amount that’s not gone up in years, but if after a few years the market rate has none up by 30% then of course it’s reasonable to increase in line with that.

Rents often work this way, sitting static for multiple years and then jumping back in line with the market.

Are you living on a different planet or just at the wind up? Even if you really are the owner of property that rents out for £5000 pcm you can't be so detached from reality (or basic arithmetic) to realise that £850 a month is not "very cheap" for the vast majority of the population, given average salaries and the number of people on NMW.

XenoBitch · 03/09/2022 00:09

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:07

No, they are on a few hundred thousand pounds per year.

The wages of the tenants should have absolutely no impact on the level of rent being charged, of course. We don’t base the amount that people pay for clothes, food, or electricity on their income, and rent works in exactly the same way.

Of course, everyone who rents is on £100k a year. Maybe in your world. Meanwhile in the real one.....

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:07

XenoBitch · 03/09/2022 00:02

£5000 a month? So your tenants are not ones on little more than minimum wage.

Someone on MW would be very concerned about a £250pm increase.

No, they are on a few hundred thousand pounds per year.

The wages of the tenants should have absolutely no impact on the level of rent being charged, of course. We don’t base the amount that people pay for clothes, food, or electricity on their income, and rent works in exactly the same way.

XenoBitch · 03/09/2022 00:02

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:00

Given how small either amount is it’s really not enough to be concerned about. So yes, if my rent went from ludicrously cheap to just very cheap I’d be fine with it.

My tenants are paying £5,000 per month, an amount that’s not gone up in years, but if after a few years the market rate has none up by 30% then of course it’s reasonable to increase in line with that.

Rents often work this way, sitting static for multiple years and then jumping back in line with the market.

£5000 a month? So your tenants are not ones on little more than minimum wage.

Someone on MW would be very concerned about a £250pm increase.

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:00

XenoBitch · 02/09/2022 23:54

A £150pm increase is an absurd amount. Would you put up with that?

Given how small either amount is it’s really not enough to be concerned about. So yes, if my rent went from ludicrously cheap to just very cheap I’d be fine with it.

My tenants are paying £5,000 per month, an amount that’s not gone up in years, but if after a few years the market rate has none up by 30% then of course it’s reasonable to increase in line with that.

Rents often work this way, sitting static for multiple years and then jumping back in line with the market.

XenoBitch · 02/09/2022 23:54

Sorry, that is £250. Maths failure.

XenoBitch · 02/09/2022 23:54

HappyChloé2 · 02/09/2022 23:50

Why not?

A £150pm increase is an absurd amount. Would you put up with that?

HappyChloé2 · 02/09/2022 23:50

XenoBitch · 02/09/2022 23:39

Agree with 1. I have a relative who saw his rent increase from £600pm to £850pm in one go. That can not be right, or even allowed.

Why not?

EverythingHeadinSouth · 02/09/2022 23:39

In my opinion, things really started to go to shit when the Thatcher government introduced right-to-buy and effectively ended large-scale council owned and operated social housing. So for me the answer is to find ways to bring that back. You don't need to target private landlords in their many guises with fees and taxes. All that will do is force them to raise their rents and the tenants will end up paying. There will always be people who don't have the option to buy. Unless you provide a viable and affordable alternative to private rents then commercial landlords will control the market.

As an aside, I don't believe right-to-buy was ever meant to be for the good of the working classes. It was introduced at the height of Thatcher's battle with the unions and I believe her logic was that a worker with a mortgage and the risk of repossession was far less likely to strike than a worker living in a home rented from invariable a labour-run council.

XenoBitch · 02/09/2022 23:39

Agree with 1. I have a relative who saw his rent increase from £600pm to £850pm in one go. That can not be right, or even allowed.

Thighdentitycrisis · 02/09/2022 23:38

if there was a real step change in our family living model and we still lived in multi generation households instead of individual households -I wonder if we will see a return to this way of living in the future

also , councils should buy back ex LA homes - got to be cheaper than building new

HappyChloé2 · 02/09/2022 23:37

GeorgeorRuth · 02/09/2022 19:37

Private rental to be capped at 2/3rds of local authority rent for equivalent sized property. Maybe a rental £ per sqft for bigger properties.

Social housing build scheme.

What would you do about the hundreds of thousands of families who’d be evicted because of this?

strugglingmum82 · 02/09/2022 23:34

Completely agree with number 2. My ex mils mother owned numerous rental properties on the Wirral and in seaside towns in north wales.

She had a huge property portfolio when she died which was passed to MILs sister (that's another story) they've all been turned into holiday lets. Vile

allboysherebutme · 02/09/2022 23:29

Same as @Allthegoodnamesarechosen

Omgwhatisthat · 02/09/2022 23:27

@sst1234

You hit the nail on the head. The abundance of cheap credit has also somewhat inflated prices but fundamentally it’s a problem of supply.

As a housing researcher and this thread is excruciating for me to read. (I clicked on this link against my better judgement.)

Unfortunately, most politicians bow to so much of this illogical nonsense despite knowing better and thus the cycle continues in perpetuity…

BattenburgSlice · 02/09/2022 23:25

I have a tenancy with (what was Council) and now a HA. I have a life long tenancy that can be transferred within that HA. I exchanged my house to a flat. I exchanged from a 3 bed house with front and back garden to a 2 bed first floor flat. The lady I exchanged with had a young boy, girl and another baby expected. I’ve had right to buy since early 90’s…I don’t believe in right to buy.

Sobaridiot · 02/09/2022 23:25

Tenants pay the council tax so doubling that doesn't help at all!

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2022 23:21

It's very simple.

Build more houses. Anything else is a waste of fucking time.

When I say more, I don't mean the 5 or 10 that got built under the last government push. I mean 2 or 3 million. Like wot we did in the 1920s.

However decent affordable housing doesn't make pots of cash for Tory donors - both in and out of the UK. So it will never happen.

Nat6999 · 02/09/2022 23:20

Bring back mortgage interest relief for people buying their home, I know it wouldn't be much but every little helps.

EmmaH2022 · 02/09/2022 23:08

Agree the biggest problem by far is population

but I'd like to see the empty offices and high street shops converted rather than build on green space.

Kendodd · 02/09/2022 23:02

The biggest issue is obviously lack of new building though. The Nimbyiam really needs to stop.

CaptainBarbosa · 02/09/2022 23:01

Genuinely think the LA's need some post war prefabs/tiny homes on some land, or as someone said some modern static caravans. Each should be well insulated and cost effective to heat.

At least as temporary accommodation whilst families await more substantial housing on the waiting lists. Or simply for small families , 2/3 bedroom prefabs/lodges.

Each site should come with a play park, dog walking area, laundry facilities, and housing/advice office 9-5.

If you were to place 3/4 of these sites in some LA's with 25-30 prefab homes/lodges on them, you'd drastically improve the housing list/housing crisis.

I was homeless with a 5 year old, if someone had offered me a little 2 bedroom lodge/prefab I'd have no issue taking it whatsoever.