Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housing Crisis solutions

167 replies

Aslockton · 02/09/2022 18:50

I watched the Tonight programme last night which seemed to suggest the rise of 2nd home owners and airbnb is causing the lack of housing.

What's the solution? If I were in change...

  1. Prevent Landlords increasing rents by more that 2% a year (straight away)
  2. Tax all rental profits at 40% (starting next year)
  3. Rise stamp duty on non-primary residence purchases to 20% (straight away)
  4. Double council tax on 2nd homes and airbnb (straight away)
  5. Waive capital gains tax on all second property sales for 2 years. (This will encourage 2nd home owners and landlords to sell up)
  6. Make it law that tenants have to be offered the home first (if landlords sell) and the price will be determined by an independent adjudicator (like lease sales are).

Are these ideas unreasonable/ bonkers or both!!
If I had a second home, I would be tempted to sell up.

OP posts:
Namenic · 03/09/2022 08:06

None of these things would solve the essential problem - which is lack of supply. Developers sit on land for ages and build slowly to maximise the price. I guess you can tax land zoned for housing at higher rates if they are empty/unbuilt.

i don’t disagree with some of the points you have highlighted. But essentially, we need to build more housing.

Adversity · 03/09/2022 07:58

@undermilkjug I agree about the costs meaning nothing to some people. It is very hard to really get just how rich some people are for many. I have just returned to my home town and area , there are calls to stop second home owners just like Cornwall. My friend got divorced and has returned to our hometown and is working back in her old job. The local estate agent has said that 80% of homes are being sold to second home owners.

@BrieAndChilli The amount of houses occupied by one person has roughly tripled since the 1970’s and people breaking up and people living longer is a big part of the issue. I live in a road where there are eight 3 bed houses of decent size with quite big gardens all built in the 1920’s. For 15 years four of them had one person living in them.

My Dad was an immigrant to pretend that immigration doesn’t contribute to housing issues is short sighted but everyone is so desperate not to appear racist there can never be a sensible discussion.

Trainbear · 03/09/2022 07:42

Having worked for a large housing association I was astonished by the large number of properties (subsidised rent and council tax) unoccupied, but occupied on paper. Tenants away living with one (or more) parters, living with Mummie, or sofa surfing due to chaotic life styles. An investigation into this, and action would release a great number of properties.

BrieAndChilli · 03/09/2022 07:08

Another reason for less houses being available but for which nothing can be done about it is the fact that it is much more common to divorce/split up nowadays - plus it 50/50 custody has become the norm (as compared to the every other weekend stay at grandmas with dad type scenario) That means that that 1 family now needs 2 family homes so that both parents can provide a home for the kids - both family sized houses are then half empty while the kids are at the other house.
so even if the actual population hasn’t increased the amount of houses needed has .

another reason is the elderly are putting off going into care homes as they don’t want to have to sell thier homes for fees - they want to be able to pass thier property down to the kids so are hanging to thier houses longer than they used to.

air bnb has designated the rental market. If people can rent thier house out to holiday makers for triple what they would get for a long term rental to someone needing a home financially it’s a no brainier. They don’t think about the moral aspect of ruining a villlage/town for the locals. But the holiday makers/2nd homers soon complain when the lovely friendly village they bought it suddenly becomes a ghost town and the shop and pub close down die to not enough constant trade all year round.

theres a reduction in. Extended family living together. Much less common for grandma or grandad to love in.

gogohmm · 03/09/2022 07:03

You have to remember there are plenty of empty houses, they are simply either in areas people don't want to live or needing expensive refurbishment that the selling price (or rent) in that area can't cover.

Part of the solution is to ensure wealth creation is spread more evenly across the U.K. including these areas. Drive through Middlesbrough, Hartlepool etc and you see boarded up houses

OperaStation · 03/09/2022 06:58

Cottagegarden11 · 02/09/2022 19:14

I'm not against 2nd home owners, they are investing their money and given the opportunity I think alot of people would do the same. I think more affordable, alternative housing options should be considered. I love the idea of tiny houses. Where I live a 2 bed new build is around £300,000 which is crazy money for a first time buyer/single person. I think we need to think outside the box when it comes to the housing crisis.

Why would anyone want a tiny house? Our new build houses are already some of the smallest (and most expensive) in the developed world. We have famously small and pokey crappy new builds.

romdowa · 03/09/2022 06:55

I've always thought some kind of tax on derelect and vacant properties would be a big help. In my town there are so many. Over every second shop is a disused apartment, houses rotting for years lying empty.at least holiday lets are being used for some purpose. Not to mention the visual affect of these properties being abandoned.

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 06:49

lollipoprainbow · 03/09/2022 05:19

Banks to give mortgages to people that are already paying regular rental payments monthly that are twice as much a monthly mortgage payment. The fact I can't get a mortgage but have been paying rent for 9 years is bloody ludicrous.

But owning a house involves far more than just the mortgage payment. You have insurance, maintenance, repairs, decoration, new kitchen and so on.

Then there’s the fact that the bank is taking on a twenty-five year (or longer) commitment compared to a landlord taking you on for a year or two.

If you think that the right comparison is the rent versus the mortgage and don’t understand the nature of the lender’s risk then maybe you aren’t really ready to take on the responsibility of owning a house.

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 06:39

stopitstopitnow · 03/09/2022 04:53

Here's my ideas...daft though they might be

  1. Private rents should be capped at 1-2% of the mortgage paid for it...it's crazy that many people renting are paying twice as much in rent than they would for a mortgage.
  2. house prices should be capped with the cap being increased every 3 years.
  3. Any property that's been empty for x amount of years ( maybe 2) should be subject to a compulsory purchase order from LA's at 10% less than market value....this would mean that "investors" who sit on empty properties would lose money.

What would you do about the hundreds of thousands of families being made homeless if these policies were enacted?

funzeny · 03/09/2022 05:28

lollipoprainbow · 03/09/2022 05:19

Banks to give mortgages to people that are already paying regular rental payments monthly that are twice as much a monthly mortgage payment. The fact I can't get a mortgage but have been paying rent for 9 years is bloody ludicrous.

That's absolutely obscene how can any normal person aspire to own a house once they start renting it's completely horrific! But now holiday towns, third and forth houses are being bought by the rich which is destroying full areas. That's a problem. Not people renting to local people. The fact the rich in the country could buy all our businesses, houses, basically everything for play money if they want, because every politician is rich! They can use our country as a dolls play house it's sickening.
Rishi Sunaks wife is a billionaire! How can they understand us to even pretend to care

lollipoprainbow · 03/09/2022 05:19

Banks to give mortgages to people that are already paying regular rental payments monthly that are twice as much a monthly mortgage payment. The fact I can't get a mortgage but have been paying rent for 9 years is bloody ludicrous.

stopitstopitnow · 03/09/2022 04:53

Here's my ideas...daft though they might be

  1. Private rents should be capped at 1-2% of the mortgage paid for it...it's crazy that many people renting are paying twice as much in rent than they would for a mortgage.
  2. house prices should be capped with the cap being increased every 3 years.
  3. Any property that's been empty for x amount of years ( maybe 2) should be subject to a compulsory purchase order from LA's at 10% less than market value....this would mean that "investors" who sit on empty properties would lose money.
Imnotreadyforthis88 · 03/09/2022 03:04

I dont think just building more houses is the right solution. Yes we need some new houses, but there are also a lot of properties sitting empty that could be filled or old properties that could be renovated which would be quicker than building from scratch. I know this because there is an apartment in my block that's been empty for 18 months, nice inside and in an excellent area - it's such a waste.
Also, when they build houses they are building them on green spaces which I don't agree. And often the targets for new homes include tiny studio apartments when what we actually need are three bedroom houses. Everytime there's a planning application where I live it's for yet more apartments on a tiny square of land, yet we are desperate for family houses.
In my hometown they have built thousands of new houses but they haven't built a new school, doctor's surgery etc to meet the needs of the increased population. I can't see how it's going to work.

DreamOfSilence · 03/09/2022 02:19

sst1234 · 02/09/2022 21:50

Wow so much nonsense about tax here and restrictions there. While the elephant stomps around the room screaming ‘look at me’.

Housebuilding. Supply and demand.

This.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 03/09/2022 02:09

FruitPastilleNut · 02/09/2022 18:59

Waive capital gains tax on all second property sales for 2 years

I really like this idea...with the addition that any saved tax would need to be repaid if you purchased another property (that's not the primary residence) within 5 years.

Good catch.

Coffeetable123 · 03/09/2022 02:05

I think some of the OP’s suggestions are good ones. I am a LL- I have a house that I used to live in that I now let out. I’d be tempted to sell but I would have to pay tens of thousands in capital tax which I do not want to do.

EmmaH2022 · 03/09/2022 01:50

RunningSME "I believe there’s eight people going for every rental available these days and only 50% of the rental stock that was available at the beginning of 2019 so that’s where the bottleneck is."

well, I guess this is part of the issue with it being made more of a pain to be a landlord.

the price range you give for the new build houses is flats round here (Zone 5, London). The overcrowding is horrendous. I am trying to get out, but I really think eventually the Highlands will be overpopulated soon, it's bloody awful.

if you've seen the film Idiocracy, we're not far off it now.

RunningSME · 03/09/2022 01:32

EmmaH2022 · 03/09/2022 01:21

If I just walk 15 mins in any direction from my home, there are literally 100s of new homes being built. That is being echoed all over the country.

there's no shortage of house building. There's an issue with population and prices.

There’s a housing estate going up not too far from us but it is very isolated but you couldn’t walk to the shops, or schooling locally.

and yet these houses sell faster than you can view them. £350-500,000 boxes

RunningSME · 03/09/2022 01:30

I was absolutely disgusted to find out that my student daughter was renting accommodation that we were led to believe for student flats, turns out they were available to the local community as well. Being basically bedsits you can imagine the clientele.

so I really don’t feel like that’s a fair solution but I do agree there’s enough of them now no need to build any more.

as for taxing the landlord 40% profit I agree with that 100% currently the situation is that they’re taxed at 40% of the net total collect it in rent which is totally unreasonable and is what’s causing a lot of the issues I believe there’s eight people going for every rental available these days and only 50% of the rental stock that was available at the beginning of 2019 so that’s where the bottleneck is.

EmmaH2022 · 03/09/2022 01:21

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2022 23:21

It's very simple.

Build more houses. Anything else is a waste of fucking time.

When I say more, I don't mean the 5 or 10 that got built under the last government push. I mean 2 or 3 million. Like wot we did in the 1920s.

However decent affordable housing doesn't make pots of cash for Tory donors - both in and out of the UK. So it will never happen.

If I just walk 15 mins in any direction from my home, there are literally 100s of new homes being built. That is being echoed all over the country.

there's no shortage of house building. There's an issue with population and prices.

HappyChloé2 · 03/09/2022 00:46

Isaidnoalready · 03/09/2022 00:38

We need to match these two figures up there is no point building houses they need to be built in the right places clearly

Look at the responses on here though when it’s suggested to someone that moving to the North East is a better option than seeing their children made homeless.

Unfortunately people often seem to think that they have a right to be given a nice home, where they want, irrespective of their ability to pay for it.

PlanetNormal · 03/09/2022 00:46

There is no housing crisis. There is an immigration crisis.

Decades of uncontrolled mass immigration are the root cause of this situation. Millions of people were led to believe that this would change when they voted for Brexit. They were lied to. EU migration has largely been replaced by legal migration from India & China, plus illegal migration from African & Middle Eastern countries. Overall net migration to the U.K. is just as high now as it was before Brexit. When people realise that they have been betrayed by the same politicians they trusted to ‘take back control of our borders’, further political upheaval is inevitable.

MidnightMeltdown · 03/09/2022 00:45

You can’t keep punishing landlords. They enable some
to have a home to live in that they would not otherwise be able to buy.

No they don't, not really. They are stopping the government from taking responsibility. We need more council housing not more private lets.

Isaidnoalready · 03/09/2022 00:38

We need to match these two figures up there is no point building houses they need to be built in the right places clearly

Housing Crisis solutions
Housing Crisis solutions
DixonD · 03/09/2022 00:34

And where are all the renters going to live if landlords sell up? It would create another crisis, not solve it.

I get your point about second homes/holiday lets. These are a big problem.

You can’t keep punishing landlords. They enable some
to have a home to live in that they would not otherwise be able to buy.