Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housing Crisis solutions

167 replies

Aslockton · 02/09/2022 18:50

I watched the Tonight programme last night which seemed to suggest the rise of 2nd home owners and airbnb is causing the lack of housing.

What's the solution? If I were in change...

  1. Prevent Landlords increasing rents by more that 2% a year (straight away)
  2. Tax all rental profits at 40% (starting next year)
  3. Rise stamp duty on non-primary residence purchases to 20% (straight away)
  4. Double council tax on 2nd homes and airbnb (straight away)
  5. Waive capital gains tax on all second property sales for 2 years. (This will encourage 2nd home owners and landlords to sell up)
  6. Make it law that tenants have to be offered the home first (if landlords sell) and the price will be determined by an independent adjudicator (like lease sales are).

Are these ideas unreasonable/ bonkers or both!!
If I had a second home, I would be tempted to sell up.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 03/09/2022 13:32

EverythingHeadinSouth · 03/09/2022 00:10

Are you living on a different planet or just at the wind up? Even if you really are the owner of property that rents out for £5000 pcm you can't be so detached from reality (or basic arithmetic) to realise that £850 a month is not "very cheap" for the vast majority of the population, given average salaries and the number of people on NMW.

Also, if your rent is covered by Housing Benefit, it does not get increased if the LL puts the rent up.

Fancydancer1934 · 03/09/2022 13:18

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/09/2022 19:00

There is a housing crisis because the population is expanding far faster than we can supply housing. It is increasing mainly through adult immigration, not through birth and family formation, which would put less strain on the housing stock. The city where I live has seen a population increase of 8 per cent in the past ten years. The housing stock has been expanded by the endless creation of new housing estates ( but without any increase in sewerage, electric generation, ,new main roads etc) but it can’t keep up.
I expect this answer will be replied to with accusations of racism and then be removed. It is still true, though.

I think you are correct - housing isn't being created quick enough to cope with the influx. So why the OP would want to deter potential LLs from entering the market and existing ones to leave is beyond me.

pieceofpies · 03/09/2022 13:12

I would vote for you, OP @Aslockton Flowers

Thelnebriati · 03/09/2022 13:09

Selling off arable/farmland for housing is ridiculous and will bring its own problems for us later on.

The answer to the housing crisis is more social housing.

Kashmirsilver · 03/09/2022 13:04

Aslockton · 02/09/2022 18:50

I watched the Tonight programme last night which seemed to suggest the rise of 2nd home owners and airbnb is causing the lack of housing.

What's the solution? If I were in change...

  1. Prevent Landlords increasing rents by more that 2% a year (straight away)
  2. Tax all rental profits at 40% (starting next year)
  3. Rise stamp duty on non-primary residence purchases to 20% (straight away)
  4. Double council tax on 2nd homes and airbnb (straight away)
  5. Waive capital gains tax on all second property sales for 2 years. (This will encourage 2nd home owners and landlords to sell up)
  6. Make it law that tenants have to be offered the home first (if landlords sell) and the price will be determined by an independent adjudicator (like lease sales are).

Are these ideas unreasonable/ bonkers or both!!
If I had a second home, I would be tempted to sell up.

Yes.
I'd also bring in a law that states, that tenants must keep a property perfectly clean at ALL times. Any damage to the property fixtures or fittings will be charged back to the tenant at a cost of £10,000.
🙄

vivainsomnia · 03/09/2022 12:44

If you think that the right comparison is the rent versus the mortgage and don’t understand the nature of the lender’s risk then maybe you aren’t really ready to take on the responsibility of owning a house
Indeed, the lack of understanding of what being a landlord entails goes a long way explaining why they are hated so much. 1-2 % above cost of mortgage....let's see.

What I have to pay for the privilege of being a landlord:

  • 40% of the rental income going to the tax man.
  • insurance, gas certificate, electric certificate, EPC.
  • repairs, including garden maintenance (tree cutting)
  • agency fee when looking for new tenants
  • new carpets every 5 years or so
  • new kitchen/bathroom every 8-10 years
  • new boiler every 10 years or so
  • new painting every 5-7 years
  • significant repairs, roof etc...every 20-30 years.
  • savings for potential loss of rent, going to court

If anyone think that this is covered by £70-140 a month, then they are very naive or ignorant!

Breakfast0utside · 03/09/2022 11:15

"Prevent LL increasing rent by more than 2% per year"

My estate agency has recommended an increase of 5% per year. They obviously wanted their cut of the increases. I just said no & they agreed to no increases. However, not everyone can withhold the increases due to the rising costs.

It is not easy being a LL & it comes with responsibilities.

On MN it is an easy discussion to dislike LL, but you have no idea about individuals circumstances

kegofcoffee · 03/09/2022 11:14

Wibbly1008 · 02/09/2022 18:52

Some people need to rent because they can’t get mortgages, for various reasons. If there are no landlords (because it’s not worth having a second property) there can’t be any renting - could create a bigger problem in the long run

This!

If anything the solution is to make long term rentals more strictly regulated and secure, but also more worthwhile for landlords. So actually cut tax on profits, but put in caps on rental increases, make leases longer, have stricter rules on maintenance, etc. So rentals have to be secure and to a high standard, but in return it's more worthwhile for landlords.

Agreed that holiday homes should be taxed, capped per area, and let out for a minimum numbers of weeks a year.

Paq · 03/09/2022 10:58

Don't know how my 1 turned into a • 🤷🏻‍♀️

Paq · 03/09/2022 10:57
  1. Increase stock of social housing to give security to the most vulnerable.
  1. Punitive taxes on empty properties.
  1. Covenants on new builds/new housing developments in tourist/second home saturated areas (Cornwall, Lake District) that restrict use to full time residential occupancy only.

The private rental market has a place in the housing market, people will always want to rent for various reasons but agree rents should be more affordable.

Population increase has not driven up demand as much as societal changes, i.e. the massive increase in single parent families and single occupancy homes.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 03/09/2022 10:23

Porcupineintherough · 03/09/2022 09:40

@ILikeHotWaterBottles thats a developers arguement. Planning authorities should be string enough to insist that developments are either what is needed where is needed or don't happen at all. And council's themselves should be allowed and financed to build social housing - maybe using all the money raised by council house sell offs.

Our housing sector is suffering from many years of free market economy and Tory ideology. But there is no shortage of suitable housing land (and with increases flooding I think houses on hills will get more and more popular).

They won't though, again that's the problem. Councils don't give a damn, they want their back handed money from these companies. Our council 'lost' 400k, wonder where that came from and went? They do build social housing too, but not a lot and then there's the housing labelled as 'affordable'. Average salary here is 25k, even with 2 salaries you've got a max budget of 200k. All 'affordable' housing starts higher than that.

People don't want to live on hills either. You need cars to get there, some of them don't drive or find it too scary to drive there, they don't put on public transport either (I live in one of the hilly regions, you either drive or you're screwed) and it's far from everything. Most people want local facilities, good public transport and easy roads. None of which councils are doing, or at least most aren't. We just got our public transport reduced, despite them claiming in all new developments there is loads.

BrieAndChilli · 03/09/2022 09:44

With the huge rise in WFH some of the empty office building could be converted into flats.

lollipoprainbow · 03/09/2022 09:43

@HappyChloé2 thanks for your patronising response, I have zero chance of ever owning a house so you don't need to worry.

Porcupineintherough · 03/09/2022 09:40

@ILikeHotWaterBottles thats a developers arguement. Planning authorities should be string enough to insist that developments are either what is needed where is needed or don't happen at all. And council's themselves should be allowed and financed to build social housing - maybe using all the money raised by council house sell offs.

Our housing sector is suffering from many years of free market economy and Tory ideology. But there is no shortage of suitable housing land (and with increases flooding I think houses on hills will get more and more popular).

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 03/09/2022 09:09

Porcupineintherough · 03/09/2022 08:43

This is crap. There's plenty of land suitable for building if your primary aim is to provide decent housing not maximise some developers profits.

Not land they want to build on though, exactly. And they won't build anywhere that doesn't maximise their profits. Councils don't care either. Farmers are selling off land to build on. A lot of equestrian venues are being sold to build on. Pretty areas obviously. And they won't venture from that, and people won't buy from non pretty sites either. So where do we build? Just keep ruining every pretty site until all towns and cities interlink? It's getting that way already..

oviraptor21 · 03/09/2022 09:02

Same with areas around Newcastle. However I would suggest that the green fields there are not the most exciting and probably OK to build on given that we need so many more houses.

I also think there are a large number of high streets and shopping centres that are slowly dying a death and these are ripe for redevelopment for housing with amenities, supermarket, leisure and a few smaller shops. There's one near me which is currently has a planning application going through for a massive redevelopment. The resistance to it is huge but I think it's a great idea in principle - the height needs to come down and the affordable housing requirement needs to be switched to social housing and the percentage increased but it's the right idea in my opinion.

I disagree with PP that developers have a requirement for social housing. Round here they have a requirement for affordable housing which is not the same at all especially when they have very funny ideas about what affordable means.

I also think mortgages on second homes or buy to let should be banned. People can only buy a second home if they can afford it outright. Might need some thinking through the implications of that one but certainly some mechanism to disincentivise borrowing for a second home.

OperaStation · 03/09/2022 08:50

gogohmm · 03/09/2022 07:03

You have to remember there are plenty of empty houses, they are simply either in areas people don't want to live or needing expensive refurbishment that the selling price (or rent) in that area can't cover.

Part of the solution is to ensure wealth creation is spread more evenly across the U.K. including these areas. Drive through Middlesbrough, Hartlepool etc and you see boarded up houses

Drive through Middlesbrough and Hartlepool and you see endless sprawl of new housing estates. I’ve never seen anything like it. They’re all built on green fields despite both towns having huge swathes of brownfield sites and none are built with any new infrastructure (schools, doctors, shops etc). And worst of all, there is absolutely no public transport. People are ending up further and further from town centres and the services that they need any everyone has no choice but to drive everywhere. Pollution from road traffic is now the single biggest contributor to global warming. Our government, sadly, does not care and is in the pockets of the housing developers.

thefoggiest · 03/09/2022 08:46

I think it's really bad how LLs are allowed to put the rent up just like that. In France they cant just do that. In France too the tenant has first opportunity to buy and the owner is forced to accept an offer at the asking price which stops all the ridiculous over offering you see in the UK.

But I think one of the biggest issues in the UK is the attachment to living in houses, its cultural. In lots of places on the continent you have very well to do families who are very happy to live in big (glamorous!) apartments. Because the UK traditionally hasnt built big housing blocks (like the Hausmannien apartments), it means that there are practically no apartments with cachet so peoples obsession with houses continues. One of the problems with housing in the UK comes from that I reckon. For example a street in Paris might have 500 households on it, but in London because they are old victorian or georgian terraces, there are only 100 households. That means housing cant be provided upwards, it has to go outwards, meaning pushing out into the countryside. And the problem with that is that the UK is a relatively small land mass for a relatively high number of people.

Porcupineintherough · 03/09/2022 08:43

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 03/09/2022 08:13

People who say build more houses.. where? We are running out of decent land to build on. They are already building on areas that flood. Where do you suggest they build? Not everyone wants to live in the middle of nowhere up a hill, and we need to keep spots for the environment. We are losing businesses, sporting areas and farms to house building. Cool we will have everyone in a home. But we won't have anywhere to go or food to eat/sell. Great idea!

This is crap. There's plenty of land suitable for building if your primary aim is to provide decent housing not maximise some developers profits.

Breakfast0utside · 03/09/2022 08:38

My former home is up for sale
It was rented out under market rate
All repairs & certificates are up to date
The tenants have been offered first purchase, but are not in a position to buy. The tenants have been provided with plenty of notice.
I have paid all my taxes
All boxes ticked

I am one of the good LL

However, there are unscrupulous LL who do not perform repairs & do not pay taxes.

I don't see how this will solve the housing crisis

Ponoka7 · 03/09/2022 08:28

"Any property that's been empty for x amount of years ( maybe 2) should be subject to a compulsory purchase order from LA's at 10% less than market value....this would mean that "investors" who sit on empty properties would lose money."

Those who are caught up in probate should obviously be excluded. Although if a warning was given and it was a case of the executor playing God (I've been there) if might help the other beneficiaries.

We need to slow down our population growth. As said our population expansion isn't natural. We often have a lot of adults looking for housing.

VoiceaFromUranus · 03/09/2022 08:22

An axe wound. Damn this site to heck on mobile this morning.

VoiceaFromUranus · 03/09/2022 08:20

sst1234 · 02/09/2022 21:50

Wow so much nonsense about tax here and restrictions there. While the elephant stomps around the room screaming ‘look at me’.

Housebuilding. Supply and demand.

They can tax landlords into oblivion, which would cause as many problems as it "solves", but until that fairly flipping big elephant is ignored, the one that grew by what 10% in the last 40 years alone, it would be like sticking a plaster on

Notlosinganyweight · 03/09/2022 08:20

Nice ideas, but I'm not sure we need those solutions. Changes to tenants rights, people struggling to pay rent or afford holiday lets, pending changes to the law which mean landlords have to make expensive changes to properties and a deteriorating market (look at the figures for last three months, not year on year as the media use and it will show a slowing market) should put quite a few off and make them want to sell.

This time last year I hardly ever saw for sale signs on the street, but i'm seeing a lot more now. Asking prices are starting to drop, so probably actual sales values are lower.

People say there is not enough houses/supply, but it is not just dictated by number of properties, as so many factors influence someone wanting to sell and people being able to buy and what type of properties are on the market too. It's already being see elsewhere in the world.

More social housing would be good though. paying private landlords to house people on benefits or a low income doesn't make sense. It would have helped us a lot when we were on a low income.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 03/09/2022 08:13

People who say build more houses.. where? We are running out of decent land to build on. They are already building on areas that flood. Where do you suggest they build? Not everyone wants to live in the middle of nowhere up a hill, and we need to keep spots for the environment. We are losing businesses, sporting areas and farms to house building. Cool we will have everyone in a home. But we won't have anywhere to go or food to eat/sell. Great idea!