Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housing Crisis solutions

167 replies

Aslockton · 02/09/2022 18:50

I watched the Tonight programme last night which seemed to suggest the rise of 2nd home owners and airbnb is causing the lack of housing.

What's the solution? If I were in change...

  1. Prevent Landlords increasing rents by more that 2% a year (straight away)
  2. Tax all rental profits at 40% (starting next year)
  3. Rise stamp duty on non-primary residence purchases to 20% (straight away)
  4. Double council tax on 2nd homes and airbnb (straight away)
  5. Waive capital gains tax on all second property sales for 2 years. (This will encourage 2nd home owners and landlords to sell up)
  6. Make it law that tenants have to be offered the home first (if landlords sell) and the price will be determined by an independent adjudicator (like lease sales are).

Are these ideas unreasonable/ bonkers or both!!
If I had a second home, I would be tempted to sell up.

OP posts:
sunstoked · 04/09/2022 07:50

@SerendipityJane that’s my point though, saying it isn’t doing it. It’s not possible to have greater equality and the rich getting richer, so they are choosing the latter option. There are plenty of ways things can be improved (look at all the ideas on this thread) it’s just it doesn’t benefit the government to do so.

funzeny · 04/09/2022 05:06

There's thousands of new houses built in my area recently, new estates with big houses worth 250k plus. We need affordable terraced houses maybe that people can afford to live in even with a few kids. The new build estates are unsuitable and unaffordable

Mammyloveswine · 04/09/2022 01:44

Stop the right to buy scheme on council Properties...

SerendipityJane · 04/09/2022 00:33

However, governments either want to address the housing crisis/increasing poverty levels and level things up, or they want to continue to line their own pockets. Can’t have it both ways.

Of course they can. They can say they are addressing the housing crisis while continuing to line their pockets. It's worked these past 30 years, why stop now.

Namenic · 03/09/2022 22:54

Immigrants help run the social care system, nhs and building trades. They also help with agricultural work. We need the brownfield sites developed. In Singapore there is a government company that builds council housing. We need something like that. And they can build hospitals too - so we won’t have v costly PFI bills.

sunstoked · 03/09/2022 22:35

It’s sad that not everyone agrees basic human needs (food/water/shelter) should be addressed before lining pockets of the rich - I’m acutely aware of the number of people who don’t agree though, and I think recent times are just serving to widen this gap. However, governments either want to address the housing crisis/increasing poverty levels and level things up, or they want to continue to line their own pockets. Can’t have it both ways.

SerendipityJane · 03/09/2022 22:09

The rich get richer and the poor are struggling for basic housing

Remember: not everyone thinks that's a bad thing. So you're pushing a stone uphill there.

woodhill · 03/09/2022 22:07

sunstoked · 03/09/2022 18:22

I think new housing being built should only be available for those who are going to occupy it rather than landlords/second home owners for a minimum period before it is offered on the open market. Where I am there are several new estates being built, as soon as they go up for sale (reasonably priced small family homes) they are snapped up, shortly after they are up for rent at extortionate prices. The rich get richer and the poor are struggling for basic housing.

Yes totally agree with that

Invernessy · 03/09/2022 21:09

Other option is people with larger houses (say four beds and above) should split them in two, three, four etc depending on the size of their house or pay capital gains on everything apart from the value of the rooms they need. Tongue in cheek but I live in a small house (2 beds and a loft, one tiny bathroom, straight into the lounge) and rent out a flat through a Crisis scheme paying 40% tax on the income and having had to deal with arrears, tenant damage etc. Many of my friends live in large houses with big gardens ripe for conversion and have decided the housing crisis is entirely my fault. They likely have pensions with funds investing in property too.

Porcupineintherough · 03/09/2022 19:13

SerendipityJane · 03/09/2022 18:21

We have developers trying to build on greenbelt land this is land used to provide food

So it's not greenbelt land, but agricultural. Which has it's own planning regime.

The greenbelt can include agricultural land.

BoffinMum · 03/09/2022 18:42

Another good policy would be to charge less tax if landlords charged locally agreed rents per square metre, on long lets (eg 5 years minimum).

BoffinMum · 03/09/2022 18:39

BTW I would start by taxing empty properties - if nobody is living there, or it’s a second home with no commercial holiday rentals above a certain level (40 weeks a year?), I would charge the owner say 25% of the market rent every year, more in places where the housing situation is critical, like the SW.

BoffinMum · 03/09/2022 18:36

Both times we have rented to someone on UC they left the property dilapidated - £6k repairs the first time and £27k the second, plus in both cases they were getting rent money from UC and did not pass it on to us, latterly because it was the pandemic and our tenant knew evictions were impossible. It is bitterly unfair to UC tenants who do behave properly, but landlords have to cover their own costs and are not there to provide a social welfare system - the Government could have chosen to fix this and prioritise social housing but it’s effectively privatised most of the rental sector.

sunstoked · 03/09/2022 18:22

I think new housing being built should only be available for those who are going to occupy it rather than landlords/second home owners for a minimum period before it is offered on the open market. Where I am there are several new estates being built, as soon as they go up for sale (reasonably priced small family homes) they are snapped up, shortly after they are up for rent at extortionate prices. The rich get richer and the poor are struggling for basic housing.

SerendipityJane · 03/09/2022 18:21

We have developers trying to build on greenbelt land this is land used to provide food

So it's not greenbelt land, but agricultural. Which has it's own planning regime.

Isaidnoalready · 03/09/2022 18:10

entropynow · 03/09/2022 17:22

Also, end nimby preciousness about the Greenbelt
Yes, it WILL affect me. Still the right thing to do, always provided that infrastructure is in place and legally enforced

We have developers trying to build on greenbelt land this is land used to provide food that we need to eat in my area we don't have much of a homeless problem around 15 total there are houses available they choose not to be accommodated but still developers want to build over our food supply we have a lot of brownfield sites they all have planning permission have had for years but nothing is being done with it they will rather use the greenbelt

Damm right we object brownfield first infrastructure first building houses for houses sake is pointless

SerendipityJane · 03/09/2022 18:07

It's hard not to suggest that the Greenbelt was designed to specifically prevent housebuilding and keep property prices (and therefore rents) artificially high.

entropynow · 03/09/2022 17:22

sst1234 · 02/09/2022 21:50

Wow so much nonsense about tax here and restrictions there. While the elephant stomps around the room screaming ‘look at me’.

Housebuilding. Supply and demand.

Also, end nimby preciousness about the Greenbelt
Yes, it WILL affect me. Still the right thing to do, always provided that infrastructure is in place and legally enforced

wakingNorbert · 03/09/2022 17:12

Corrupt Government with fingers in the corrupt housing develepor's pies.
Limited space as it is in the relatively tiny UK.

Demographic collapse is imminent as the boomers go into retirement and the working-age population is not ample enough to replace them. Immigrants needed but the infrastucture to accommodate them just isn't there.

Quality of life is set to seriously decline over the next decade in most countries globally - and the UK is one of them.

My family is made up of 5 and we live in a tiny 2 bed. I'm preparing for life to get much, much worse.

woodhill · 03/09/2022 16:57

Getoff · 02/09/2022 23:01

Perhaps I would have a wealth tax on residential property, with the proviso that any tax on rental income from a property should reduce the wealth-tax pound-for-pound, so the property is not being taxed twice.

Oh great, you mean on someones place of residence or do you mean a 2nd home

Hopefully the latter

Knittynanna · 03/09/2022 14:53

Build more social housing.

Not popular I know, but more social housing is the only easy answer I can think of. It's how we got rid of slum landlords in the past, so that there were 3 valid options for people, social housing, good rental accommodation, and ownership.

Overthisnow98 · 03/09/2022 14:21

Habitation laws which specify that properties must be lived in or rented out within 18months of purchase or pay a high financial penalty.

tiny houses on little developments made from shipping containers / prefabs or whatnot for young singles . They are small enough to be run on independent renewable sources and the all inclusive, low price to rent should allow for savings to buy a proper flat or house when they want to start a family.

yes to extra council tax on air B&B rentals but a discount or some sort of incentive to landlords who rent long term at a fair rate.
cute, comfortable little bungalows near their families for the elderly that tempt them out of family homes in the social housing sector.

RunningSME · 03/09/2022 14:21

Lykia · 03/09/2022 14:02

I wholeheartedly agree with you about societal change however I disagree with you about population increase.

I'm a landlord and I have seen first hand how immigration affects rental housing. Our population has risen by 7 million since 2005. These people need somewhere to live and basic supply and demand is at play here. Unfortunately we can't have huge population growth and cheap housing.

I became a landlord around 2005. Most of my tenants have been from Eastern Europe and they've been great tenants.

I've recently had two properties vacated and most people applying are recent immigrants from India and Nigeria. Most of the Nigerians are doing care work and the Indian people have full time jobs plus Deliveroo/Just Eat etc.

Rental increases have been insane and even I'm astounded at the going rate in some areas.

So why don't I charge below market rate. I've done this. Turns out the person renting it sub- let it out as an Air B N B. Luckily enough my neighbours informed me. That's what happens if the rent is too cheap. It will be subletted out.

It's a vicious circle. Immigration has been great for me financially, my dad was an immigrant, but not so great for the indigenous population of the UK. Especially single parents with children relying on UC/ people on low income.

New entrants to the UK are working 2 - 3 jobs to pack the money in however this is not possible for single parents with children. These sadly are the ones being left behind in the rental market.

So why don't I rent to people on UC? I have many, many times and sadly each and every time they've left the property in a state with outstanding rent. I've been burned too many times now.

This is my first hand experience of the rental market in the south east since 2005.

I agree I rented to a single parent, I’ve took photograph of the bedroom in the condition of the place and I was very tempted to send it to social services she clearly could not cope living alone. Awful as it is it’s just not my problem, she should’ve been in some sort of supported living program.

MidnightMeltdown · 03/09/2022 14:10

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2022 23:21

It's very simple.

Build more houses. Anything else is a waste of fucking time.

When I say more, I don't mean the 5 or 10 that got built under the last government push. I mean 2 or 3 million. Like wot we did in the 1920s.

However decent affordable housing doesn't make pots of cash for Tory donors - both in and out of the UK. So it will never happen.

It's really not that simple. It's not just housing we need, we need all the infrastructure to go with it including GPs and hospitals. As others have said, it's not a housing problem. It's an immigration problem.

Lykia · 03/09/2022 14:02

Paq · 03/09/2022 10:57

  1. Increase stock of social housing to give security to the most vulnerable.
  1. Punitive taxes on empty properties.
  1. Covenants on new builds/new housing developments in tourist/second home saturated areas (Cornwall, Lake District) that restrict use to full time residential occupancy only.

The private rental market has a place in the housing market, people will always want to rent for various reasons but agree rents should be more affordable.

Population increase has not driven up demand as much as societal changes, i.e. the massive increase in single parent families and single occupancy homes.

I wholeheartedly agree with you about societal change however I disagree with you about population increase.

I'm a landlord and I have seen first hand how immigration affects rental housing. Our population has risen by 7 million since 2005. These people need somewhere to live and basic supply and demand is at play here. Unfortunately we can't have huge population growth and cheap housing.

I became a landlord around 2005. Most of my tenants have been from Eastern Europe and they've been great tenants.

I've recently had two properties vacated and most people applying are recent immigrants from India and Nigeria. Most of the Nigerians are doing care work and the Indian people have full time jobs plus Deliveroo/Just Eat etc.

Rental increases have been insane and even I'm astounded at the going rate in some areas.

So why don't I charge below market rate. I've done this. Turns out the person renting it sub- let it out as an Air B N B. Luckily enough my neighbours informed me. That's what happens if the rent is too cheap. It will be subletted out.

It's a vicious circle. Immigration has been great for me financially, my dad was an immigrant, but not so great for the indigenous population of the UK. Especially single parents with children relying on UC/ people on low income.

New entrants to the UK are working 2 - 3 jobs to pack the money in however this is not possible for single parents with children. These sadly are the ones being left behind in the rental market.

So why don't I rent to people on UC? I have many, many times and sadly each and every time they've left the property in a state with outstanding rent. I've been burned too many times now.

This is my first hand experience of the rental market in the south east since 2005.