Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish people would look to the future before having late in life babies?

616 replies

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 16:46

Sorry the title is a bit rubbish, but I couldn’t think of what else to put. This is not a dig at older parents at all, just this specific situation.

I’ve got 2 family members who had only children in their mid 40s. One as a couple, one as a single mum. No history of infertility in either of them (important in this context), just ‘didn’t feel ready’ before.

Anyway some years have passed, the kids are now teenagers and they’re in their late 50s/early 60s. One half of the couple has been through some health problems, and suddenly it’s like they’re all panicking about what will happen to their child should something happen to them.

To the point where I’ve received texts asking me if I would step in and house/look after their child should they be orphaned, or will I be their main family if they’re alone in the world in future.

I’m probably going to look like a cow here, but I have a chronic health issue, a toddler and am pregnant with DC2. I simply don’t have the resources to add another dependant to this household. Of course I’m happy to keep in touch with their kids as the years go on and occasionally go to see them etc, but it’s suddenly dawned on me they see me as their child’s ‘main family’ in years to come, unless of course their kids have settled down by then. I’ve had a lot of comments from other older family members about ‘not keeping in touch enough’ with these kids and ‘you might be all they have one day’.

AIBU to feel a bit annoyed and emotionally blackmailed? I feel like they spent so many years enjoying themselves before having a child, and now expect me to pick up the pieces? Totally prepared to be told IABU…

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 03/09/2022 09:50

NippyWoowoo · 03/09/2022 09:49

Have you asked someone to be legal guardians to your kids? Maybe that person feels you shouldn’t have had children and put them in the position, knowing of your health condition 🥴

Have you read my posts? Do you actually know what I’m objecting to?

OP posts:
NippyWoowoo · 03/09/2022 09:49

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 16:55

I didn’t say people who have kids in their 40s are selfish, nor do I think it. I think I should’ve worded the title ‘AIBU to not want to be legal guardians to my relatives’ maybe. Sorry for any offence caused by the title.

Have you asked someone to be legal guardians to your kids? Maybe that person feels you shouldn’t have had children and put them in the position, knowing of your health condition 🥴

Arbesque · 03/09/2022 09:44

My brother is in his late 50s and had never asked anyone to be on standby to take in his 2 teenagers should anything happen to him.

Anyone can get a serious health scare at any age, it isn't typical in your 50s.

I agree people who manipulate nature to have babies in their 60s are selfish. There is a high possibility they will become ill or even die before their child is independent.

ivfbabymomma1 · 03/09/2022 09:18

I'm 34 and an only child and I don't feel the need to have a sibling to get me through anything that will eventually happen to my parents. (Some people might but don't assume you NEED a sibling)

fanjosaysi · 03/09/2022 08:56

IAMNOTTHEONE2022 · 03/09/2022 08:42

I am in absolute awe of anyone who was financially, socially and emotionally ready to have children before the age of 30. I expect a large amount of it comes down to luck…

Nope, not luck. Just being savvy. I had multiple children by early 20s. I worked my arse off, was independent, and loved being a mum!

We all mature at different rates, just because you weren't ready, doesn't mean you need to project that shit on everyone else..

Right, I mean 30? It doesn't take til the age of 30 to get a job/career. Many people are married in their mid-late 20s. Don't know what socially ready even means. People project so much here. Not even before 25, it's before 30 now😂

Not everyone wants to be that age to start a family, not everyone's life is ruined by having a family. People do things at different times in their life.

C8H10N4O2 · 03/09/2022 08:48

YANBU @Wouldloveanother. I'm with @LicoricePizza

Your OP clearly states that you are talking about your specific situation.

Apparently these days on MN any post about a family situation requires a big glittery ticker statement that you fully support the right of all people to do all things and then a reminder every ten posts that you are talking about one specific dysfunctional family situation. You should also have zero expectation that people will try to think outside their own situation instead of projecting their own circumstances.

Here though the issue is less about the age they chose to have children than having children on the assumption that some random relative will do a chunk of your parenting for you.

Everyone should have a plan for their children if the worst happens, for most of us that will involve family but not all families are like that. Its completely unreasonable to lay that expectation on another person unless they actively want to take that role.

I'm bemused by posters who think that we all have obligations to drive cross country to seem someone solely because we share some genetic makeup and posters who apparently think lesbians didn't have children by donor as recently as the 80s and 90s.

IAMNOTTHEONE2022 · 03/09/2022 08:42

I am in absolute awe of anyone who was financially, socially and emotionally ready to have children before the age of 30. I expect a large amount of it comes down to luck…

Nope, not luck. Just being savvy. I had multiple children by early 20s. I worked my arse off, was independent, and loved being a mum!

We all mature at different rates, just because you weren't ready, doesn't mean you need to project that shit on everyone else..

IAMNOTTHEONE2022 · 03/09/2022 08:33

I think it's selfish for them to expect you to mop up after them. And you can say NO!

However, I really don't think it's for you to keep tabs on their unprotected sex lives..or how many children they decide to have. Bit weird, tbh.

Wouldloveanother · 03/09/2022 08:11

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 03/09/2022 06:48

Lucky for you that life turned out as you planned it. Some of us wanted children when a lot younger but only now having them due to infertility.

I hope you aren't expecting your children to look after you if your condition worsens?

Someone else lacking in reading comprehension skills…

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 03/09/2022 08:07

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 03/09/2022 07:30

Why mention it if irrelevant?

God knows, wish I hadn’t 😂 it’s become the main focus of the thread, ‘proving’ I’m not well enough to be having a baby to refute a point I haven’t even made 😂

OP posts:
BadNomad · 03/09/2022 07:34

MyBrilliantFriend · 03/09/2022 07:24

Of course they are your responsibility but if you’re dead you can’t do much about that - hence surely part of responsible parenting is sorting out guardians etc (& the financial arrangements that go with that) just in case the worst happens. This isn’t the same as expecting grandma to do childcare at all.

I didn't say it was the same. I'm saying there are people who think as soon as they have children they are entitled to other people's time. If you don't plan these things before birth you need to sort them out after, but you can't ever assume someone else will do it. No one asked the OP if she will become the significant adult in these children's lives. They're just assuming she will.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 03/09/2022 07:30

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 19:23

its interesting, the votes are so different from the responses. It seems like a lot of people secretly agree but don’t want to incur the wrath of the posters on this thread! Not sure what to make of that.

My health condition is practically irrelevant -
the AIBU is about pressuring younger relatives to take on the burden of your decisions. Not AIBU to have kids in anything less than perfect circumstances. But you’ve all replied like it’s the latter.

Why mention it if irrelevant?

MyBrilliantFriend · 03/09/2022 07:24

BadNomad · 03/09/2022 05:50

You should never have mentioned age in your post because that's all people will read and get mortally offended over. Would have been better to say something like -

"Are my relatives CFs to assume I will take over the welfare of their children if something should happen to them in the future?"

The answer would be yes. It is their responsibility to ensure their children will be taken care of, but they can't just pass that on to whoever they feel like. You see it all the time on MN, women having children then getting into a flap because grandma won't give up her part-time job or holidays to do permanent childcare. Your children are your responsibility.

Of course they are your responsibility but if you’re dead you can’t do much about that - hence surely part of responsible parenting is sorting out guardians etc (& the financial arrangements that go with that) just in case the worst happens. This isn’t the same as expecting grandma to do childcare at all.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 03/09/2022 06:48

Lucky for you that life turned out as you planned it. Some of us wanted children when a lot younger but only now having them due to infertility.

I hope you aren't expecting your children to look after you if your condition worsens?

Shoxfordian · 03/09/2022 06:36

Yanbu in your circumstances but you need to draw better boundaries with your family to stop them pressuring you all the time

BadNomad · 03/09/2022 05:50

You should never have mentioned age in your post because that's all people will read and get mortally offended over. Would have been better to say something like -

"Are my relatives CFs to assume I will take over the welfare of their children if something should happen to them in the future?"

The answer would be yes. It is their responsibility to ensure their children will be taken care of, but they can't just pass that on to whoever they feel like. You see it all the time on MN, women having children then getting into a flap because grandma won't give up her part-time job or holidays to do permanent childcare. Your children are your responsibility.

Aprilx · 03/09/2022 05:50

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 17:11

Absolutely I think that’s a very fair comment.

I think my annoyance stems from the fact they left parenthood late simply to enjoy themselves, and now expect me to pick up any potential consequences of that.

If they’d had fertility problems etc I don’t think I would be as annoyed at all. But it seems preventable - they’re also quite stressed by this, hence their messages to me.

And don’t get me wrong, if my sis and BIL (god forbid) got knocked down by a bus I would happily take DNiece and DNephew. We’ve got reciprocal arrangements to care for each other’s kids should this happen. So I don’t think that it’s selfish and uncaring.

I am 53 and childless not through choice. I can assure you that nobody in my family knows I had fertility problems and neither will any friends. They will think I chose to enjoy travel and a nice life. Do you see where I am coming from? And no woman chooses to wait until she is forty before trying for children, it is not exactly a secret that it gets harder. But for some that is the reality.

lookluv · 03/09/2022 05:44

Op 4 miscarriages and 1st DC arrived after we had given up age 39 second quickly followed at 41.

Neither planned on the pill but after years of trying much loved.

Not all of us get a choice

autienotnaughty · 03/09/2022 05:25

Everyone with children should have a will and appoint guardians for their kids regardless of age. They are not being unreasonable to ask but equally you can say no.

stayinghometoday · 03/09/2022 05:19

It's not always a choice. I wanted children in my mid twenties, only had my miracle baby at 41 (after many losses and many years of fertility treatments). I exercise every day and eat very healthy. I don't drink or smoke or even drink coffee. My lifestyle is a lot healthier than most people that have kids younger. I do this on purpose to be there for my child as long as possible.

Please don't have anymore children with your mind set. If you already begrudge a potential lonely person a potential christmas meal in future (great christmas spirit there) then we really don't need those genes in the gene pool. (Shit comment to read, right? Now think about yours)

NumptiesIncorporated · 03/09/2022 05:02

I'm so confused.

I was in my twenties when I had my kids, and also thought about what would happen to them if I was no longer around.

Isn't that a normal thing to do, regardless of age?

Moancup · 03/09/2022 04:27

This has morphed from the OP being a surrogate parent to the OP being a surrogate sibling.

OP you haven’t engaged with the posters questioning whether the cousins even feel this way themselves, and the very likely scenario that they will have their own lives as adults.

Your grandparents (the irony that aged grandparents are still on the scene) and aunts sound batshit. So batshit they would probably act like this in any event. You also sound batshit though. Your level of obsession with an imagined future scenario isn’t healthy.

alphons · 03/09/2022 03:01

OP, I don’t even think this is necessarily about these aunts being older parents (by choice or otherwise). Nor about late-ish motherhood having been a lifestyle choice for them.

It’s the presumption. Anyone who presumes that you will take on a burden that haven’t ever intimated you will take on is out of order.

Obviously there are presumptions between spouses which have to be made for life to go on. But on MN even presumptions between adult children and their parents are considered out of order (see the billion threads about grandparents having to “earn” the right to care in old age by providing childcare to grandchildren 🙄). Presumptions between aunts/nieces are even more preposterous.

This is all about your grandparents’ and aunts’ neuroses and worries. These are theirs. Not yours. You must always do the right thing by your conscience but that needn’t be indulging other people’s stresses. Be straight with these people so they can make other plans. If ww3 breaks out - well, that’s on them.

MangyInseam · 03/09/2022 02:21

I do think a lot of people don't think, before they have kids, what might happen if they die when the kids are younger. It's not always older parents, with small families a lot of people don't have close relatives these days, especially of the right age.

Not that I think this should stop people from having kids but it is something to think about. Just because someone is a relative doesn't mean they will be able to step up in the way you might want them too.

MangyInseam · 03/09/2022 02:16

Op, I remember my mother saying something similar once.

She has three kids, two in her twenties, one mid-thirties, and spent lots of time and energy bringing us up. As an older lady, she has her kids and grand-kids around her.

Her siblings made different choices, and in the end that has affected the kind of support they have wanted/needed from the extended family. One of her brothers is severely disabled and that was always in the cards, but I know that at times my mum has felt her other siblings didn't want the faff of kids and settling down until much later or at all, but expect that she, as the settled one, will give a lot of support. Which often she is happy to do but sometimes she feels a little put upon.

Swipe left for the next trending thread