Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish people would look to the future before having late in life babies?

616 replies

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 16:46

Sorry the title is a bit rubbish, but I couldn’t think of what else to put. This is not a dig at older parents at all, just this specific situation.

I’ve got 2 family members who had only children in their mid 40s. One as a couple, one as a single mum. No history of infertility in either of them (important in this context), just ‘didn’t feel ready’ before.

Anyway some years have passed, the kids are now teenagers and they’re in their late 50s/early 60s. One half of the couple has been through some health problems, and suddenly it’s like they’re all panicking about what will happen to their child should something happen to them.

To the point where I’ve received texts asking me if I would step in and house/look after their child should they be orphaned, or will I be their main family if they’re alone in the world in future.

I’m probably going to look like a cow here, but I have a chronic health issue, a toddler and am pregnant with DC2. I simply don’t have the resources to add another dependant to this household. Of course I’m happy to keep in touch with their kids as the years go on and occasionally go to see them etc, but it’s suddenly dawned on me they see me as their child’s ‘main family’ in years to come, unless of course their kids have settled down by then. I’ve had a lot of comments from other older family members about ‘not keeping in touch enough’ with these kids and ‘you might be all they have one day’.

AIBU to feel a bit annoyed and emotionally blackmailed? I feel like they spent so many years enjoying themselves before having a child, and now expect me to pick up the pieces? Totally prepared to be told IABU…

OP posts:
Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 14:30

But that’s what they think, not me.

You've said it dozens of times on this thread including the title, but now loads of people have called you out on it it's suddenly not what you think. Sure.

Wouldloveanother · 03/09/2022 14:30

@Danceswithkids you don’t understand what they’re asking of me. It’s not to be a name on a form ‘just in case’. It’s to act like a surrogate sibling in every sense of the word - the way they saw it, at 14 or so I should’ve been taking long bus journeys to go and see my 3 year old cousin on a regular basis, preferably for the whole weekend, should’ve been there every birthday and Christmas, and been available whenever summoned. All this ‘because you’re the closest thing she has to a sibling, and you might be all she has one day’.

I don’t know any young teen who spends this amount of time with a cousin so much younger, it was a wholly unreasonable expectation.

OP posts:
Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 14:26

The relatives haven't planned for anything though. They've not discussed it with anyone. We're not talking about young children anyway. It's adult children they are talking about. They want the OP to invite these people for Christmas because they won't have anyone else.

No normal person plans ahead for who will have their adult child to Christmas if they die sooner than expected. I'm sorry, that is a ridiculous stick to beat them with.

They are hoping the OP will act like family if the worst happens to them. The OP doesn't have to, it's not obligatory. It could equally (despite the OPs 'cunning plan' of having her child 10 years earlier) be the OP or her children who are unexpectedly alone one day.

I'm sure the adult kids will be fine with their own DPs/families/friends and in any case, and they will certainly be better off without the OP as she sounds thoroughly unpleasant.

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 14:23

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 14:03

Unless they don't get on with the sister, or she gets cancer or she's already died or moved to Australia yadda yadda, yadda. You can't plan for everything.

OP is repeatedly claiming that if they had had their child at 30 there would be no worry but at 40 it's terrible and irresponsible as if 10 years makes some huge difference to their chance of leaving an orphan. It's bullshit.

You can’t plan for everything, no. What you can do though is make your contingency plans with people willing to take on responsibility for your children, rather than focusing on trying to force unwilling people into it.

Wouldloveanother · 03/09/2022 14:23

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 14:03

Unless they don't get on with the sister, or she gets cancer or she's already died or moved to Australia yadda yadda, yadda. You can't plan for everything.

OP is repeatedly claiming that if they had had their child at 30 there would be no worry but at 40 it's terrible and irresponsible as if 10 years makes some huge difference to their chance of leaving an orphan. It's bullshit.

But that’s what they think, not me. It’s them endlessly going on about being older parents and how they wish they’d done in ten years earlier. It’s nothing to me, but they could’ve done that to alleviate their own worries. Or what they see as problems.

OP posts:
BadNomad · 03/09/2022 14:21

The OPs point about them having children at 30 instead of 40 is nothing to do with them dying sooner. It's that if they'd started earlier they could have had more than one child and then the children would have each other for the rest of their lives. But as it stands, there is just one child and that child will have no close family after their parents die. Hence them now trying to push a close relationship on the OP.

BadNomad · 03/09/2022 14:08

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 14:03

Unless they don't get on with the sister, or she gets cancer or she's already died or moved to Australia yadda yadda, yadda. You can't plan for everything.

OP is repeatedly claiming that if they had had their child at 30 there would be no worry but at 40 it's terrible and irresponsible as if 10 years makes some huge difference to their chance of leaving an orphan. It's bullshit.

The relatives haven't planned for anything though. They've not discussed it with anyone. We're not talking about young children anyway. It's adult children they are talking about. They want the OP to invite these people for Christmas because they won't have anyone else. They've just realised that their children as young adults won't have any other family in the world and so they're wanting the OP to be that for them. The OP has her own family and her own shit going on. She doesn't need to be befriending cousins now because her family says she must.

TeacupDrama · 03/09/2022 14:04

YABU
if you have a child in your 40's and the average age of death is approx 80 and most people are fit and well until early 70's then your child will be well over 30 when you die,

it is a completely different question about men fathering children in their 70's I do not agree with menopausal and post menopausal women being given IVF however much they pay

my father was 42 when he married and 44 when i was born and 55 when my youngest sister was born she was 42 when he died aged 98 after 2 years ill health on the other hand some die before 60 but mostly we don't know and can't predict. Should Sarah Beeny not have had children because of knowing cancer ran in her side of the family? it is really none of our business how people start their families and when,

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 14:03

BadNomad · 03/09/2022 13:53

The OP's poor orphaned child would go to her sister, like they discussed and agreed on.

Unless they don't get on with the sister, or she gets cancer or she's already died or moved to Australia yadda yadda, yadda. You can't plan for everything.

OP is repeatedly claiming that if they had had their child at 30 there would be no worry but at 40 it's terrible and irresponsible as if 10 years makes some huge difference to their chance of leaving an orphan. It's bullshit.

Totallyanonymousplease · 03/09/2022 14:03

Yabu. Everyone should have a will which states what happens to their children should they be orphaned - it’s totally normal (and indeed sensible) whatever age you are. Anyone will a with like this will have asked someone at some point.

if you can’t do it just say no - no emotional blackmail.

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 13:53

There’s really no reason why they couldn’t have had children a little bit earlier to alleviate their concerns

If you think having a child at 30 rather than 40 means you don't need to consider what happens to your kid if you die then you are delusional as well as unpleasant.

BadNomad · 03/09/2022 13:53

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 13:50

So if in the future you, DH and one of your kids die on a random car accident (it happens) will your now lone orphaned child be able to look to these people to care about them?

Let's hope they are nicer than you, eh? (Wouldn't be hard).

There's only 10 years between the age they had a kid and you are having your second, there's really no guarantee that they will die earlier in their childs life than you will.

The OP's poor orphaned child would go to her sister, like they discussed and agreed on.

Danceswithkids · 03/09/2022 13:50

So if in the future you, DH and one of your kids die on a random car accident (it happens) will your now lone orphaned child be able to look to these people to care about them?

Let's hope they are nicer than you, eh? (Wouldn't be hard).

There's only 10 years between the age they had a kid and you are having your second, there's really no guarantee that they will die earlier in their childs life than you will.

Wouldloveanother · 03/09/2022 13:17

heyitsthistle · 03/09/2022 13:08

People die at all ages. I've got my children's lives sorted, my parents and my brother will step up in our absence. Best sort it out before everyone's left in a pickle. If you can't handle it, then decline, that's okay!

I’ve got a reciprocal agreement with my sister about our kids. It would be a huge commitment but I would be happy to do it as we’ve made financial arrangements (would need bigger house etc), and I know she would do the same for my children. So it all feels very fair and respectful.

Whereas obviously there’s no chance of reciprocation with the aunts, and it does feel a bit like they’re just ‘dumping’ their worries on me and expecting me to pick up after the fact they feel guilty about their child not having a sibling or younger parents (their words, not mine, before anyone starts).

There’s really no reason why they couldn’t have had children a little bit earlier to alleviate their concerns but they wanted to have their cake and eat it and emotionally blackmail me into taking on the worries that come with that.

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 03/09/2022 13:13

Thank you @theknave
Thats exactly what I mean

OP posts:
heyitsthistle · 03/09/2022 13:08

People die at all ages. I've got my children's lives sorted, my parents and my brother will step up in our absence. Best sort it out before everyone's left in a pickle. If you can't handle it, then decline, that's okay!

theknave · 03/09/2022 12:34

Well it's good to see that the usual suspects have piled on to be offensive without actually bothering to read what the OP has posted, including the very first line of her opening post! Some people really do enjoy putting the boot in.
I could understand a bit of the hostility if OP had said she didn't even want to send a card occasionally but it's not about that, it's about relatives expecting OP to be able to pick up all the pieces and be effectively a full-time parent if they died and putting emotional blackmail on her. Totally different. The odd Christmas invite and some phone calls is a world apart from these expectations of every Christmas and very regular meet-ups. And they're expectations without them having actually had the decency to check with OP first if it's something she'd even consider. FFS.
You can make contingency plans but what you don't do is make assumptions about other people. It's not that difficult to understand (except apparently on Mumsnet)

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 11:44

TenRedThings · 03/09/2022 11:13

What goes around comes around. One day you will be old and those you supported may be there for you.

Lol, based on what she’s said I imagine she’d rather they weren’t.

TenRedThings · 03/09/2022 11:13

What goes around comes around. One day you will be old and those you supported may be there for you.

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 11:08

Fuck me, one bad title and a resulting onslaught.

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all. Asking someone if they’d be willing to have your children in the event of your passing and accepting a no (which is perfectly acceptable answer!), is different to assuming they’ll acquiesce and attempting to pressure them into it.

it’s also foolish of them. Instead of trying to twist your arm they could be refocusing and looking for alternative arrangements.

LemonDrop22 · 03/09/2022 11:04

It’s more that there’s an expectation that if they end up lone adults, I will invite them to every Christmas, regularly keep in touch, birthdays etc.as well as ‘being there for them’ as their main family member.

Fk, I think Scrooge had more warmth, kindness and generosity (even before his epiphany).

BadNomad · 03/09/2022 10:40

Aposterhasnoname · 03/09/2022 10:38

Long thread, so let me make sure I’ve got the basics right.

You have a chronic painful health condition that means you won’t be able to have relatives round at Christmas but doesn’t affect your ability to parent your own kids, or to adopt your sisters kids if it came to it. Nor does this painful condition prevent you skiing, but it is bad enough to potentially need care later in life.

You’ll be the only family these teens have, yet you have a sister, and youre worried you’ll be expected to look after them even though they are just one and three years respectively away from being adults, and there’s no reason to expel the parents to die in that time frame.

Is this about right? Cos if so, YABVU.

No. You got it wrong. Try again.

Aposterhasnoname · 03/09/2022 10:38

Long thread, so let me make sure I’ve got the basics right.

You have a chronic painful health condition that means you won’t be able to have relatives round at Christmas but doesn’t affect your ability to parent your own kids, or to adopt your sisters kids if it came to it. Nor does this painful condition prevent you skiing, but it is bad enough to potentially need care later in life.

You’ll be the only family these teens have, yet you have a sister, and youre worried you’ll be expected to look after them even though they are just one and three years respectively away from being adults, and there’s no reason to expel the parents to die in that time frame.

Is this about right? Cos if so, YABVU.

Wouldloveanother · 03/09/2022 09:55

NippyWoowoo · 03/09/2022 09:53

I did, and the hypocrisy pervades throughout.

you keep saying that your complaint is very specific, for your heading is very general.

I hope you’re not expecting your children to become your carers, btw.

Well that proves you haven’t because I’ve said repeatedly why my children won’t be my carers.

And unless I’m harassing my niece to spend an inordinate amount of time with my kid ‘in case I pop my clogs and you’re all she has’, I’m not a hypocrite am I?

OP posts:
NippyWoowoo · 03/09/2022 09:53

I did, and the hypocrisy pervades throughout.

you keep saying that your complaint is very specific, for your heading is very general.

I hope you’re not expecting your children to become your carers, btw.

Swipe left for the next trending thread