Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish people would look to the future before having late in life babies?

616 replies

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 16:46

Sorry the title is a bit rubbish, but I couldn’t think of what else to put. This is not a dig at older parents at all, just this specific situation.

I’ve got 2 family members who had only children in their mid 40s. One as a couple, one as a single mum. No history of infertility in either of them (important in this context), just ‘didn’t feel ready’ before.

Anyway some years have passed, the kids are now teenagers and they’re in their late 50s/early 60s. One half of the couple has been through some health problems, and suddenly it’s like they’re all panicking about what will happen to their child should something happen to them.

To the point where I’ve received texts asking me if I would step in and house/look after their child should they be orphaned, or will I be their main family if they’re alone in the world in future.

I’m probably going to look like a cow here, but I have a chronic health issue, a toddler and am pregnant with DC2. I simply don’t have the resources to add another dependant to this household. Of course I’m happy to keep in touch with their kids as the years go on and occasionally go to see them etc, but it’s suddenly dawned on me they see me as their child’s ‘main family’ in years to come, unless of course their kids have settled down by then. I’ve had a lot of comments from other older family members about ‘not keeping in touch enough’ with these kids and ‘you might be all they have one day’.

AIBU to feel a bit annoyed and emotionally blackmailed? I feel like they spent so many years enjoying themselves before having a child, and now expect me to pick up the pieces? Totally prepared to be told IABU…

OP posts:
Changechangychange · 02/09/2022 18:34

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 18:06

Asking me to give more than I practically can (regular 4 hour round journeys to see them when I work FT and have a toddler); that I should make every Christmas and birthday available to them (travelling to them again, of course); that I should basically be available whenever they need me to be, or my cousins want me to be. Like my only position in the family is one of ‘future surrogate parent’ for their kids.

What exactly has any of that to do with them having only children?

ReneBumsWombats · 02/09/2022 18:34

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 18:32

I doubt I would be asked if they had siblings. They’d probably assume they would spend it together if they didn’t have anyone else. No, I don’t want to centre mine and my kids Christmas plans around another relative every year - we want to go skiing, etc

So why can't you? The only reason you're even thinking about it is because of guilt tripping from people who will be dead. Their being dead is literally what will cause the situation.

Have the kids been telling you how much time they want to spend with you when their parents kick the bucket?

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 18:32

greektreacle · 02/09/2022 18:29

It’s more that there’s an expectation that if they end up lone adults, I will invite them to every Christmas, regularly keep in touch, birthdays etc.as well as ‘being there for them’ as their main family member.

Erm..... is that really such a huge hardship? To be around for a young adult or adult as a member of their family?

YABU. You disapprove of their decision to have one child, yet you also disapprove of their decision to have that child at a particular age. Are you honestly saying you'd be happier with being asked if there were two or three siblings?

I doubt I would be asked if they had siblings. They’d probably assume they would spend it together if they didn’t have anyone else. No, I don’t want to centre mine and my kids Christmas plans around another relative every year - we want to go skiing, etc

OP posts:
Onthegrid · 02/09/2022 18:32

I just don't get your angst. My DSis has a life limiting illness, but is perfectly healthy for now, if something happened to her, of course I would step in and support her DD both financially and more importantly emotionally (only child), her age in this is irrelevant as I unfortunately know plenty of people who have not lived to old age.

I had my DC in my 20s, my siblings in law and plenty of cousins had them into their 40s, we are all about the same age (Late 40s-50s), the youngest is 1 the oldest 26. Each DC has named guardians, its normal.

MintJulia · 02/09/2022 18:31

I'm in my late 50s, I may not be a suitable parent as far as the OP is concerned but I'm listed as guardian to five children under the age of ten. And unlike the OP, I wouldn't hesitate to give them all a home if the need arose.

A bucketful of love and kindness is a lot more important than some arbitrary number, thank goodness !

greywinds · 02/09/2022 18:30

I agree with @billy1966 too - any replacement parenting relationship costs money, has to come from the heart and is a big commitment. Expecting someone with small kids to travel to see them is off too.

I would never want someone to be guardian who didn't want to do it.

greektreacle · 02/09/2022 18:29

It’s more that there’s an expectation that if they end up lone adults, I will invite them to every Christmas, regularly keep in touch, birthdays etc.as well as ‘being there for them’ as their main family member.

Erm..... is that really such a huge hardship? To be around for a young adult or adult as a member of their family?

YABU. You disapprove of their decision to have one child, yet you also disapprove of their decision to have that child at a particular age. Are you honestly saying you'd be happier with being asked if there were two or three siblings?

Justwantanicepeacfulholiday · 02/09/2022 18:29

YABU to judge people on when they have babies. People can get crippling illnesses suddenly in thier 20’s and 30’s too. Many in their 60’s suffer no health issues.

You’d be entirely within your rights to say no you couldn’t help. Couldn’t say it myself mind.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/09/2022 18:28

Of course you aren’t being unreasonable. It’s just all the people who have had children late in life, or know someone who has justifying themselves by having a pop at you.
meanwhile at the school gates, they are getting upset / outraged when they are taken for their child’s grandparent.

Cyw2018 · 02/09/2022 18:28

ReneBumsWombats · 02/09/2022 18:25

One of the single parents was a lesbian too, because apparently that's relevant. Since she knew she'd never have to find a man. Or something.

Hat trick (I mmust have missed the mention of the Lesbian Mum)!!!

J0y · 02/09/2022 18:27

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 17:03

DH, obviously.

I’m not particularly concerned about ending up their guardian, as statistically it’s unlikely.

It’s more that there’s an expectation that if they end up lone adults, I will invite them to every Christmas, regularly keep in touch, birthdays etc.as well as ‘being there for them’ as their main family member.

Wouldn't you want to do this?

Your relatives don't know who you are:-/

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/09/2022 18:27

My nominated guardians for DS in my will were in their 40s when he was born, 20 years older than me. I think it's specific to your family members' situations.

billy1966 · 02/09/2022 18:26

OP,

We are those parents.

I absolutely agree with you.

We didn't give it any thought and we should have.

We certainly have thought about it since, and when friends have been diagnosed with cancer, it put the wind up me completely.

Several of my peers have left teens/early 20's behind and it has been desperately sad.

I don't think prospective parents think that far ahead.

They are all caught up in the lack of sleep, when what we didn't actually realise is the hard bit is nearly 15 years away, and yet to come.

Having teens in your 50's can be really hard at times.

We are running around after them, counselling them, supporting them, paying for them.

We love and enjoy ours but we definitely feel very tired at times.

Our friends that had children a decade earlier, are grateful, as they feel their energy levels dip with age.

Our peers without exception, share our views too.

It's a tricky one.

We loved our childfree 20's, into our 30's, they were fantastic years full of travel and wonderful experiences.

Would I swap those years? It depends on the day and whats going on, is the honest answer.

I think it is very presumptuous to think family members will step in and have an obligation to be close to your children on the off chance they will need to take them on should you die.

I can tell you that I was pleased when my eldest turned 21.

I think should they push a conversation upon you, or criticise you, you have every right to put them straight.

Bustarold · 02/09/2022 18:26

To wish people would look to the future before having babies when they have a chronic health condition

Nice, eh?

ReneBumsWombats · 02/09/2022 18:25

Cyw2018 · 02/09/2022 18:23

Dig dig dig, keep digging OP, you've now insulted parents of only children as well as older parents.

One of the single parents was a lesbian too, because apparently that's relevant. Since she knew she'd never have to find a man. Or something.

MichelleScarn · 02/09/2022 18:25

Snugglemonkey · 02/09/2022 17:26

This!!! ^

Agree, what a shitty, twatty judgy op.
Are you suggesting some kind of Logans Run op with enforced contraception for anyone over 38 and a half?

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 18:25

Yetanotheryeti · 02/09/2022 18:22

“Totally prepared to be told IABU…”

OP told resoundingly they’re unreasonable

*OP keeps on posting about how they’re not unreasonable *

in fairness OP, I think you’d be amazing as a family member to these kids if the worst should happen. You’ve just got a natural warmth x

No I’m fine with all the comments. Votes are pretty even so who knows if I will end BU or not! But most of the comments are either attacking my health condition (with zero knowledge of it) or personal insults. Nobody has actually persuaded me that I’m wrong yet.

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 18:24

Cyw2018 · 02/09/2022 18:21

The only thing your friends are be unreasonable about is their utterly appalling ability to judge your character and suitability as a guardian for their child.

I think I might start a thread to see if people think it is unreasonable for parents to knowingly bring a child into the world whilst suffering from a chronic health condition and thus setting their children up for a future as young carers.

Why would they be my carers? I have made financial provision for my own general elderly care, but I won’t need it because of my condition, it’s not ‘that’ kind of illness.

OP posts:
Cyw2018 · 02/09/2022 18:23

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 16:57

But they didn’t have ‘kids’ that’s my point. They had one child. Hence no siblings in later life, and a presumption I will step into this role.

Dig dig dig, keep digging OP, you've now insulted parents of only children as well as older parents.

Yetanotheryeti · 02/09/2022 18:22

“Totally prepared to be told IABU…”

OP told resoundingly they’re unreasonable

*OP keeps on posting about how they’re not unreasonable *

in fairness OP, I think you’d be amazing as a family member to these kids if the worst should happen. You’ve just got a natural warmth x

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 18:22

greywinds · 02/09/2022 18:19

@Wouldloveanother are they leaving you part of the life insurance? They ABU for expecting someone to take full prenatal responsibility without some compensation. I've left some money to the guardian if we die for exactly this reason.

Not that I’m aware. It was never mentioned anyway.

OP posts:
MacarenaMacarena · 02/09/2022 18:22

I agree it feels rather presumptuous of your relatives to seem to want to have their cake and eat it... I hope that they have financial plans in place in case the worst happens eg life assurance, will etc. Until my son was 20 I had a will in place for a friend whose background and ethos would have suited my son as his guardian if I died, with monthly payments from the life assurance money to make sure she would be happy to do it, and do it properly. My house would have been rented out until son finished uni. I am sorry you are living with health issues - other posters should not raise that... It is your choice to have a family that you can manage, it is a bit of an imposition that relatives assume that there is any slack for you to be their standby choice after a life of freedom themselves. Hopefully they are financially savvy and your life would not be compromised should the worst happen to your relatives.

Cyw2018 · 02/09/2022 18:21

The only thing your friends are be unreasonable about is their utterly appalling ability to judge your character and suitability as a guardian for their child.

I think I might start a thread to see if people think it is unreasonable for parents to knowingly bring a child into the world whilst suffering from a chronic health condition and thus setting their children up for a future as young carers.

DanielTheGhostGangbanger · 02/09/2022 18:20

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 18:12

Ok let me address this. Because there’s a lot of wrong assumptions there.

  1. it is very highly unlikely they will get it. About the same risk as a member of the population spontaneously developing it.
  2. they will never need to care for me. I’ve made my own arrangements for this - thanks to reading the stately home thread on MN!
  3. It doesn’t really affect my ability to parent. I don’t have mobility issues or the like.

The accusations of ageism are interesting given every other post is ableist… not to mention inaccurate…

As we don't know what your condition is, there's no way to see if your assertions are true. I find it very hard to believe that if you actually have a chronic disability it won't ever affect your ability to parent.

I accept not all conditions are passed on. But there are many disabling conditions which turn out to have a genetic component which wasn't known before.

I'm not referring about caring for you in old age. I'm referencing your disability/pain getting worse and your children becoming carers for you while they're young. It happens to tens of thousands of children all around the country - it's not an unusual consequence of having a disabled parent.

Luredbyapomegranate · 02/09/2022 18:19

Wouldloveanother · 02/09/2022 17:11

Absolutely I think that’s a very fair comment.

I think my annoyance stems from the fact they left parenthood late simply to enjoy themselves, and now expect me to pick up any potential consequences of that.

If they’d had fertility problems etc I don’t think I would be as annoyed at all. But it seems preventable - they’re also quite stressed by this, hence their messages to me.

And don’t get me wrong, if my sis and BIL (god forbid) got knocked down by a bus I would happily take DNiece and DNephew. We’ve got reciprocal arrangements to care for each other’s kids should this happen. So I don’t think that it’s selfish and uncaring.

I think my annoyance stems from the fact they left parenthood late simply to enjoy themselves, and now expect me to pick up any potential consequences of that.

Your problem OP, is that you are making it your problem. It's not.

You didn't make any reciprocal arrangements with them, you are not obligated to do anything. Just tell them very clearly that's not a role you can take on, and they need to look elsewhere.

I presume you are worrying you will be perceived as being selfish and that's why you are projecting it onto them. This is nonsense. Apart from the fact no one is obligated to take on other people's kids, you have two kids and a health condition, so it's pretty clear why you can't and won't.

Stop fretting about nothing. The kids are in their late teens. If you feel able you'll be inviting them for Christmas as young adults, not changing their nappies and worrying about them being out on a school night.

As PPs have pointed out, it is unreasonable to make generalisations out of your specific situation. It's also surprising you've done this since you have a chronic condition that causes you pain. There are a few people around who would question whether you should have kids when inevitably some aspects of your parenting would be limited by this. Of course it's none of their business, as your relative's choices are none of your business.

Swipe left for the next trending thread