Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think sister is starving herself?

166 replies

ScaryBiscuitz · 02/09/2022 15:53

Sister is living off a bowl of Shreddies and one small meal a day. The Shreddies is her lunch. Small meal for dinner.

She’s lost a lot of weight and was not overweight to start with. WIBU to tell her she’s basically starving herself?

OP posts:
Undermearmour · 02/09/2022 17:12

The problem is that MN is full of people who think its acceptable to eat less than a small child everyday. Eating disorders are a problem at any size. Anorexia is not defined by your BMI.

Have a chat with your friend and ask if she is OK. My worry would be if she's eating like this cos she couldn't afford anything more.

Fififelix · 02/09/2022 17:10

Based on pure calories which will probably be a 1000 it's very low. Doesn't sound like a balanced diet.

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 02/09/2022 17:08

Divebar2021 · 02/09/2022 16:58

Why are people so determined to argue with the OP? She’s concerned enough about her sister to make the post ….. just go with it. I can’t help but think these threads are populated by the posters I’ve seen who are stuffed on half a tin of soup.

As an aside there’s a lady at my gym who is painfully thin and wears a woolly hat to work out in. My PT says she’s there 4 times a day. I’m guessing someone’s going to argue that’s normal too.

How do you know she's concerned or that she even has a sister for that matter?

We're all anonymous on the internet, we're all different in real life and above all, we all have different valid opinions.

OhYouBadBadKitten · 02/09/2022 17:06

Don't ask her about her weight or her eating, instead check in with her mental health, in a sensitive way. Disordered eating is a sign that things are going wrong within the person. It's a symptom, not the main issue.

KassandraOfSparta · 02/09/2022 17:04

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 16:15

I don’t want to turn this into a competitive teeny tinies thread but honestly that is not eating disorder territory imo.

What part of "she has lost a lot of weight and wasn't overweight to start with" are you struggling to understand?

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 17:03

OP? Any clarification? And are you my sister?

yikesanotherbooboo · 02/09/2022 16:59

The point is that if she is eating the correct amount she won't be losing weight.
Is she now a healthy weight and steady or is she underweight and continuing to lose. If it is the latter or if she is lacking in energy or unwell or if she has ideas around food where it seems that the need to control her intake is overriding her normal instincts get some advice before talking to her.

Divebar2021 · 02/09/2022 16:58

Why are people so determined to argue with the OP? She’s concerned enough about her sister to make the post ….. just go with it. I can’t help but think these threads are populated by the posters I’ve seen who are stuffed on half a tin of soup.

As an aside there’s a lady at my gym who is painfully thin and wears a woolly hat to work out in. My PT says she’s there 4 times a day. I’m guessing someone’s going to argue that’s normal too.

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 16:55

For example, I’m making linguine this evening. I’ll have one or two large ladles of it. DH and the teenagers will have two bowls full. He’d say I’m having a small dinner. But I’m the one with a normal appetite in this house, DH is very active and has always had a crazy metabolism and the teens are, well, bottomless pits as teenagers are.

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 02/09/2022 16:54

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 16:48

Small dinner is not the same thing as restricted dinner though.

Of course it's not and MNetter's opinions on how much a 'normal' portion is, tends to vary wildly.

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 16:48

Small dinner is not the same thing as restricted dinner though.

Astounding · 02/09/2022 16:47

I don’t want to turn this into a competitive teeny tinies thread but honestly that is not eating disorder territory imo.

I think from OPs post it’s not possible to generalise. There are a lot of factors such as:

How long has she been eating like this? Does the one small meal change regularly or does it consist of more or less the same foods in the same quantity? Does she eat very slowly. Does she cut her food up into very small mouthfuls. Is there any flexibility around food . For instance if you asked her if she’d like to come to yours for dinner or go out for a meal how would she react? If you brought something you know she likes such as a pack of her favourite biscuits, chocolate etc would she have any or put it away and say she will have some later (when you’ve gone ).

whar has her appetite been like in the past ? How does her mental health seem? Any sign of anxiety , depression etc and anything very stressful she has been through or is going through still? Is she exercising more than she used to ?

I used to be anorexic in my late teens early 20s and I’d eat two small meals a day. There was absolutely nothing normal in my attitude and feelings around food at that time and if anyone had told me I was starving myself I’d have absolutely deny it. I would hide food, make excuses not to eat, say I wasn’t hungry, have to exercise if I had been pressured to eat more than I wanted. I would look into EDs, contact helplines if possible as to how best to try find out what’s going on and how to help your DS.

Josette77 · 02/09/2022 16:47

Anyone who thinks that a bowl of cereal and a restricted dinner is a normal amount needs to see a dietician.
I am recovering from anorexia and never stopped eating completely. Eating less than 1000 calories a day is not healthy. If you eat that little and don't lose weight you may have metabolism issues.

WishDragon · 02/09/2022 16:44

Pre kids that’s what I would eat, mainly because I would never be up in time to eat breakfast. I also find shreddies really filling.

What do you define as a small meal?

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 02/09/2022 16:44

If they are small and she’s losing weight quickly when not overweight to start with I think it’s a fair description…

It's too hard to tell whether the description is fair because one person's 'small meal' is another person's perfectly adequate meal.

Ditto (often) when it comes to deciding whether someone is 'skinny' or not.

Too many variables and too little information from OP at this stage, but 'starving' is a bit dramatic even if the meals were small.

goldenlillacs19 · 02/09/2022 16:41

are well aware*

goldenlillacs19 · 02/09/2022 16:40

YANBU like it's already been stated, you are well well of this issue. Nobody knows you better than yourself.

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 16:38

Also shreddies are really filling, and full of sugar, hardly the weapon of choice for someone trying to lose weight.

I love shreddies, and a bowl will fill me up for hours.

cardibach · 02/09/2022 16:38

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 02/09/2022 16:35

How on earth is she starving herself on two meals a day? Confused

If they are small and she’s losing weight quickly when not overweight to start with I think it’s a fair description…

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 02/09/2022 16:35

How on earth is she starving herself on two meals a day? Confused

shumway · 02/09/2022 16:35

So much misunderstanding about anorexia - people think you can only have it if you eat literally nothing but that's not the case at all. Anorexics do eat otherwise they'd be dead. Lots of anorexics would eat two meals a day.

IncessantNameChanger · 02/09/2022 16:31

I posted on here years ago about my friend who clearly is extremely underweight and had half a sandwich for lunch and a side of MASH as her main meal on nights out.

I don't think this is good place for advice as I was told it was normal to be under 6 stone and 5,6 and eat those meals. Because it was my friend I didn't say anything as that was firmly the advice on here. Bit harder if it's family.

My son is 5,8. Just under 8 stone and pretty skeletal to me but someone somewhere would say he is fat. If you apear healthy I don't think it's a big deal. Healthy on one person isn't healthy weight for the next person.

Like my friend, she is happy with her choice, let them get with it. Tricky one really

Heatherbell1978 · 02/09/2022 16:29

That's pretty much what I ate for about 4 years in my late teens/early 20s. Got down to about 6 stone. I had an eating disorder but I ate so it wasn't anorexia and I didn't make myself sick so not bulimia. Restricted calorie intake was what someone badged it as. I kind of got over it without any help and now in my 40s, it's a distant, shitty memory but it is something to be worried about. I didn't have a particularly empathetic family so it's just as well I kind of grew out of it.

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 16:29

Well somebody who thinks two meals a day is a starvation diet may not be the best judge of how much weight someone needs to lose.

We need more information.

melmos · 02/09/2022 16:25

I'll just grab some (low cal) 🍿