Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think sister is starving herself?

166 replies

ScaryBiscuitz · 02/09/2022 15:53

Sister is living off a bowl of Shreddies and one small meal a day. The Shreddies is her lunch. Small meal for dinner.

She’s lost a lot of weight and was not overweight to start with. WIBU to tell her she’s basically starving herself?

OP posts:
Jourdain11 · 02/09/2022 18:24

Oh my God. How are people saying that's normal? How is eating one bowl of cereal and one small meal per day going to fulfil your nutritional needs? Ugh.

I'm off to prepare my massive s

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 18:23

Yeah I’ve just realised I put too much double cream in (the whole thing not just my portion).

So 1700. Fairly normal amount I would think?

Ohdofuckofdear · 02/09/2022 18:23

To be honest I would be worried OP, that's how anorexia started for me,eating less meals and a smaller amount too eating barely anything and making myself Ill when I did eat anything(or as I called it back then giving up) It started for me when I was 7 and got worse and worse and went on actively till I was 16.

I'm 47 now and not actively anorexic anymore but I'll always have an anorexic persons brain.

I think mine wouldn't have got as bad as it did if someone,anyone had noticed sooner and tried to actually help me!

Eating Disorders in the main don't happen because of a person's weight(I was tiny before the anorexia and so were the 2 other girls I knew that were anorexic,one I met when I was 11 and the other when I was 16) anorexia for me and the 2 friends I made and so many others rears it's ugly head when you so desperately feel like you have no control over anything what so ever.

Madmax1992 · 02/09/2022 18:20

That must be an enormous portion to amount to that

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 18:03

It’s a big bowl of shreddies tbf. But a small serving of pasta (double cream though!).

That’s my point, we have no idea what a small dinner means, or whether she’s having a great big bowl of cereal.

I don’t know anyone who only eats a cup of cereal btw. We always take the little boxes of cereal with us on holiday (tradition) and laugh at the tiny portions.

Josette77 · 02/09/2022 17:58

If a bowl of shreddies and pasta get you over 2000 calories then those are large servings! A cup of shreddies is 180 calories. Most McDonald's meals aren't even 1000 calories.

Sunnyqueen · 02/09/2022 17:55

I just think someone who thinks a bowl of cereal and a small meal a day is starving themselves, probably isn't the best judge of what defines already slim and lost a lot of weight. Probably someone who was a size 12 now a size 10 ffs.

Astounding · 02/09/2022 17:52

Arabella. I hope your DD keeps up her recovery. I can relate to everything you say as it could have described my experience when I was in the grip of this awful condition. I was always so cold , even in summer my finger and toenails would be blue. Exhausted, utterly depressed and obsessed with cooking for others, keeping up the facade of not being anorexic. No periods, extra body hair , no bowel movements for weeks at a time, terrible irritable, defensive, compulsive exercising. Would look in the mirror and still not see a very thin young woman. It was going on a mini gap year and being around other people my age but being totally unable to do all the fun things they were doing, couldn’t join them to eat, that somehow turned on a switch and made me think I didn’t want to live like this. I very gradually recovered without any help (there really wasn’t much awareness of EDs in the late 70s and early 80s.).

Anorexia is so much more than whether someone is eating a bowl of shreddies and one small meal - there’s a whole pile of red flags that indicate there’s a real problem and not just someone just wanting to lose a stone and is cutting down for a while. I hope your DD keeps up her progress. I remember the absolute distress and terror my DM went through and how angry I would get with her if she suggested anything was wrong or tried to get me to eat more.

Cabsnotlint · 02/09/2022 17:52

Threeboysandadog · 02/09/2022 17:40

If she is loosing weight and is definitely now underweight now then that is a concern. Are you close to her and would she discuss your concerns with you?

I will say, when I was dieting and lost quite a bit of weight, I kept getting told I was loosing to much and was “too thin” at almost 12 stone. I do have a big frame, am solidly built and I look lighter than I am but by no stretch of the imagination was I “too thin”. This was by quite a few different people too so I think some peoples views of normal weight is skewed.

it really depends on if she is underweight or not.

Perhaps you did look too thin though. Not everyone suits that look. You yourself don't see how small your getting until you look back on pictures. It depends how much bigger you was..

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 17:48

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 02/09/2022 17:12

Some of the responses on here 🤯

A bowl of cereal and a small dinner is nowhere near enough food to keep a grown woman going, that's probably around 700-800 calories.

Easily less than half what she should be having.

Op I would be very concerned as well, I would gently broach the subject with her however be prepared to be met with denial and more denial.

Treating an ED in an adult is very difficult as part of the illness is to deny you're ill.

I’ve just put a bowl of shreddies, semi skimmed milk, and my portion of home made linguine through MyFitnessPal.

2011 calories.

Theendofnature · 02/09/2022 17:47

I think

oakleaffy · 02/09/2022 17:47

ArabellaRockerfella · 02/09/2022 17:24

My daughter has anorexia and has been ill for 3yrs now. She is beginning to show signs of recovery after lots of therapy, removal from school, medication etc. It has been the most horrific and emotional time which has devastated the whole family.
After what I have experienced myself and learnt along the way, what you describe would set alarm bells for me.
It would be especially worrying if her eating habits have changed and are accompanied by any of the following: she is low in mood, tired, exercising a lot, pouring over cookery books, following food accounts on Instagram, reading food labels meticulously, wearing baggy clothes, avoiding foods that she otherwise used to enjoy, restricting the range of foods she is eating, is always cold, has a bluish tinge to her toes and nails, is developing a fine covering of hair over her face/back/neck/arms, has become secretive about what she is eating or lying about what she has had today.
Eating disorders especially anorexia are very dangerous to a persons long term health and is the deadliest of mental health conditions. It is not about food, it goes deeper than this and needs professional intervention. You and your family should act if you truly believe she has developed an eating disorder. There are now specials services for children and young people under 18 with ED.
There is lots of advice and support on the BEAT website.
I'm happy to offer any support or advice that I can. I really wouldn't wish anorexia on any family.

I’m sorry your Daughter is affected with an ED-
They seem horribly compulsive, almost akin to an addiction to class A’s.
The physical description you gave brings tears to my eyes- One of my friends was like this at 17.
Absolutely you could be describing her.

It’s a serious and worrying condition, and must be infinitely worse these days with the Internet.

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 02/09/2022 17:41

X posted with @Threeboysandadog

x2boys · 02/09/2022 17:41

I really wouldnt post about this on here ,it's akin to asking how much alcohol is too much ..

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 02/09/2022 17:40

This shouldn’t even be that sort of discussion. It’s whether a sister is right or not to raise her concerns about some worrying weight loss or not. Not whether shreddies are a suitable lunch food.

That's true and it's not something anyone can answer as one person's idea of 'worrying weight loss' can be very different to another's.

I've read on here too many times an OP saying they still have 2 stone to lose, and yet their friend is telling them they're 'too thin' and need to stop dieting. The general consensus is that people can sometimes be jealous.

On the other hand, the OP may have a point but we'll never know.

Threeboysandadog · 02/09/2022 17:40

If she is loosing weight and is definitely now underweight now then that is a concern. Are you close to her and would she discuss your concerns with you?

I will say, when I was dieting and lost quite a bit of weight, I kept getting told I was loosing to much and was “too thin” at almost 12 stone. I do have a big frame, am solidly built and I look lighter than I am but by no stretch of the imagination was I “too thin”. This was by quite a few different people too so I think some peoples views of normal weight is skewed.

it really depends on if she is underweight or not.

oakleaffy · 02/09/2022 17:35

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 02/09/2022 16:16

You will get competitive under eating comments now

But the fact that she has lost lots of weight when not over weight in the first place is concerning

I too thought “Aaand here come the competitive eating comments”
Not a good look.
Ive never had an eating disorder- but lived alongside anorexics and couldn’t believe how mega competitive they were.

This thread won’t go well.

PurpleDaisies · 02/09/2022 17:34

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 02/09/2022 17:32

The problem is that MN is full of people who think its acceptable to eat less than a small child everyday.

But equally full of people who overeat and feed their children adult size portions.

This is why MN is not the place for this sort of discussion and never has been.

This shouldn’t even be that sort of discussion. It’s whether a sister is right or not to raise her concerns about some worrying weight loss or not. Not whether shreddies are a suitable lunch food.

MaryHoldTheCandleSteadyWhileIShaveTheChickensLeg · 02/09/2022 17:32

The problem is that MN is full of people who think its acceptable to eat less than a small child everyday.

But equally full of people who overeat and feed their children adult size portions.

This is why MN is not the place for this sort of discussion and never has been.

PurpleDaisies · 02/09/2022 17:32

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 16:38

Also shreddies are really filling, and full of sugar, hardly the weapon of choice for someone trying to lose weight.

I love shreddies, and a bowl will fill me up for hours.

This sounds like you think someone who eats shreddies every day for lunch could go possibly have an eating disorder. You really don’t know how these things can work.

My friend with eating issues ate a lot of sugary cereal Neckar it happened to be one of her “safe” foods. She just ate very little else.

Nobody can say the whether op’s sister is fine or not. What the op has said had raised some potential red flags that could be discussed in a sensitive way to try and make sure there’s nothing else going on. What’s the problem with that?

Cabsnotlint · 02/09/2022 17:29

TimeAtTheBar · 02/09/2022 16:15

I don’t want to turn this into a competitive teeny tinies thread but honestly that is not eating disorder territory imo.

Nutrition isn't about how fat/slender you are.

Eating shreddies for lunch because that's what you fancy is one thing but doing it daily is definitely unhealthy.

ArabellaRockerfella · 02/09/2022 17:24

My daughter has anorexia and has been ill for 3yrs now. She is beginning to show signs of recovery after lots of therapy, removal from school, medication etc. It has been the most horrific and emotional time which has devastated the whole family.
After what I have experienced myself and learnt along the way, what you describe would set alarm bells for me.
It would be especially worrying if her eating habits have changed and are accompanied by any of the following: she is low in mood, tired, exercising a lot, pouring over cookery books, following food accounts on Instagram, reading food labels meticulously, wearing baggy clothes, avoiding foods that she otherwise used to enjoy, restricting the range of foods she is eating, is always cold, has a bluish tinge to her toes and nails, is developing a fine covering of hair over her face/back/neck/arms, has become secretive about what she is eating or lying about what she has had today.
Eating disorders especially anorexia are very dangerous to a persons long term health and is the deadliest of mental health conditions. It is not about food, it goes deeper than this and needs professional intervention. You and your family should act if you truly believe she has developed an eating disorder. There are now specials services for children and young people under 18 with ED.
There is lots of advice and support on the BEAT website.
I'm happy to offer any support or advice that I can. I really wouldn't wish anorexia on any family.

mowly77 · 02/09/2022 17:18

😂 @melmos (Grabs own )

MissyB1 · 02/09/2022 17:18

Yep the competative under eaters piled on pretty quick! Like flies to the jam jar - except they would never eat jam of course!

OP you sound like a kind concerned sister. Don't mention her starving herself, just discreetly try and find out why this is happening if you can.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 02/09/2022 17:12

Some of the responses on here 🤯

A bowl of cereal and a small dinner is nowhere near enough food to keep a grown woman going, that's probably around 700-800 calories.

Easily less than half what she should be having.

Op I would be very concerned as well, I would gently broach the subject with her however be prepared to be met with denial and more denial.

Treating an ED in an adult is very difficult as part of the illness is to deny you're ill.