Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you ever regret throwing things out?

59 replies

beebopper6 · 02/09/2022 10:04

Have you ever gotten rid of something in a fit of decluttering then regretted it ever since?

I really need to do a gigantic declutter but find it so hard to let go of even small things in case I'll need them again later!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BogRollBOGOF · 02/09/2022 15:55

I grew up with a hoarder and my bedroom was filled with other family members' stuff that I couldn't get rid of even if they moved out 15 years earlier and hadn't thought twice about it. DM was a war child and had been bombed out, so there was definitely a trauma and cultural response there. The problem was that I wasn't taught how to tidy and declutter and everything is sentimental/ potentially valuable.

I am naturally hoardy and sentimental but I've found Marie Kondo very helpful in evaluating what to clear out.

Sentiment can lie to us too. I kind of regret the purge of most of my Ladybird books, but most were out-dated, tatty hand-me-downs and the reality is that my DCs were never going to appreciate them. There was more joy in starting afresh and having space for books that they appreciated. Peter and Jane remain in print, and it was nicer having the fresh set.

Start with obviously out-dated worn out, functional stuff that can be replaced if needed.

It's better to consider the environmental toll at purchase than disposal. I only sell on things with clear value such as redundant furniture. For me the aggro of selling small stuff is not worthwhile for a few quid. I either charity shop or bin.

TheOriginalClownfish · 02/09/2022 15:34

I'm a minimalist at heart so the joy of a ruthless clear out makes my heart sing.

But I've also become much more aware of consumerism and feel terribly guilty at the idea of sending loads of shite to landfill so my aim is to buy as little as possible, as sustainably as possible and I rarely buy something 'just because'.

I regret donating a fabulous maxi coat I bought in the early 90s. The lining was torn and I should have just replaced the lining instead of sending it to the charity shop. I adored that coat and not seen anything nearly as gorgeous or hard-wearing since. I console myself that someone out there is snuggled up in it somewhere.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/09/2022 14:19

Yes! When i moved bedrooms after loft extension I threw away 1. Clothes I then wanted and 2. Loads of old photos from when I was young, without photographing them on my phone or anything.

Don’t know why I did that!

lljkk · 02/09/2022 14:16

i decided that if I only had to buy 1/3 of it back, I still benefited from the 2/3 being gone. In reality, I've bought back maybe one item every 4 years in last 16 years. I always try to give away or reduce or sell instead of binning, it's the waste that annoys me rather than the new expense.

i sold a musical instrument once for a fraction of its true value. That still stings.

TeacupDrama · 02/09/2022 14:16

I think yes you might use it agan but if you didn't have it is there something else you would use instead? or could you manage without it, just because you might use it doesn't mean it needs to be kept, ie if your potato peeler broke and you had given away the spare it would take minutes to order a new one or put it in supermarket shop next time or you could use a vegetable knife to peel them.
how much money and time would it cost to replace? if the answer is 5 minutes and £5 ( the potato peeler) it is different to £800 and maybe 4 weeks ( The extending aluminium ladder to reach gutters)
if you haven't worn something there is normally a reason it doesn't fit or its scratchy or the cut doesn't suit you I had a lovely cream linen blend skirt then when decluttering I found it washed it and wore it, then I ended up with a rash over my legs then I relaised i had stopped wearing it as it had a metallic sheen and somehow the metallic threads had broken and were scratching my legs it was beautiful but I know I will never wear it again as it hurts so off it went to charity as I wasn't going to line it or wear a long petticoat under it

EmeraldShamrock1 · 02/09/2022 14:15

Rarely not enough to stop me decluttering regularly.

I grew up in a home that was cluttered it was chaotic and impossible to find things I'm determined to be the opposite although I have attention issues and I need a strict routine to keep my home in order in comparison to people who are naturally tidy.

It's a battle that I enjoy winning.

DD has the same attention issues as my DM and I so who knows if she'll allow her future become a cluttered unorganised environment she shows all the traits.

I do talk to her about how hard it was for me as a DC living in a chaotic home and hoping if she has DC in the future she'll learn so they can avoid the stress.

CornedBeef451 · 02/09/2022 14:07

@Alphabet1spaghetti2 ooh, I haven't checked the bin bag place! I'll have a look next time I make a cup of tea.

I checked the cat stuff box and the cat food place, I'm going to have to think more laterally!

MatildaTheCat · 02/09/2022 14:01

I’m a tidy type. DH not so much and often leaves his Mail lying around for weeks. Which I then bin, obviously checking first that they are unimportant.

unfortunately I may have been a bit hasty the day I binned 4 new Chelsea season tickets.

To be fair I only regret this because he still mentions it when he wants to justify his messy ways.

Houselamp · 02/09/2022 13:58

Never, I grew up with hoarders, who were hoarders because of trauma and that made it impossible to ever throw out anything.
I was so excited as an adult to throw things away- I still get a thrill from my tidy home with space in the cupboards and clear surfaces. To be fair I also do not buy much so there is not many things to dispose of but as soon as something is gone I no longer think about it, and it is so relaxing to only own things that I need.

Elleherd · 02/09/2022 13:42

Yes. I tried to just be really tough about it and wholesale chuck out stuff that I didn't want to get rid of. but thought I should.
It caused both financial and psychological problems, though I didn't see the psychological impact till later.

But I now accept that despite being tidy and clean the reason I find letting go of stuff so hard is because I am actually a hoarder whether I like it or not.

It's hard to stand up and say, but I have a problem, and it wont be properly fixed by me pretending otherwise or
trying to just randomly throw out the symptoms.

So I'm doing work on myself and what the attachments and decision making issues are really about, while I de-clutter, and this time I'm doing much better at letting go of stuff without negative consequences.

I've Dm'd a link to something you might find useful.

bombombo · 02/09/2022 12:40

Yes 🙈 I'm a thrower outer and DH is a hoarder. I won't let him have the satisfaction of knowing I should've kept something I threw out though 😂

musicviking1 · 02/09/2022 12:39

All the time, I was ruthless in my early 20s and chucked out lots of my childhood school reports, books, etc and then when I had children wished I had kept it all to look back on. However, I feel so much better when I declutter, "stuff" everywhere gets me down.

OohThatCat · 02/09/2022 12:28

I regret getting rid of my original Gameboy and 80's My Little Ponies, I genuinely loved those toys!

viques · 02/09/2022 12:23

My Bill Gibb pink crepe wrap around skirt, didn’t actually throw it out but donated it to a charity shop. Why Viques, why?

Lilyhatesjaz · 02/09/2022 12:22

The coffee grinder. I ended up buying another one when I accidentally bought unground beans during the lock down

VeronicaBeccabunga · 02/09/2022 12:20

I keep a sort of 'halfway house' box in the spare room for discarded clothes and books [mostly paperbacks bought in charity shops for something to read] so I can retrieve stuff if I have second thoughts.
If the box is full and I honestly can't remember what's in there then off it goes.

Shortkiwi · 02/09/2022 12:18

I bought a pair of vintage Levi jeans in London in the 80s. Had a special red seam or something 😂 Got rid of them in a house move. Only item of clothing I regret giving away, would love them now.

Fink · 02/09/2022 12:15

Loads of stuff I regret getting rid of:
Children's books

Clothes - I always end up thinking 'I'll wear X today' only to realise I donated x to the charity shop because I hadn't worn it for ages. One day I'll learn that I will always want to wear it again sometime if I liked it in the first place.

Shoes and handbags - the worst was a pair of shoes I hadn't worn for 3 years, and then 6 months after getting rid of them they would have been perfect to go with a bridesmaid's outfit but instead I had to buy new, that was an expensive mistake

Loads of kitchen equipment (I didn't want to get rid of that, was persuaded to, none of the replacement stuff is as good as the old things)

Children's toys and clothes. I should have kept at least a few baby things as keepsakes, but we had no space at the time. I really regret those most of all.

DelurkingAJ · 02/09/2022 12:14

junglejane66 · 02/09/2022 11:55

I've taken to ebay to buy old board games I used to have and they no longer make. You can get some in good condition for £20-£30
Anyone for a game of 'scoop'?

Indeed…but I had probably 40 games, some of which are going for rather more than £30. It just seems such a shame!

prettyteapotsplease · 02/09/2022 12:12

I do regret throwing things out because for one thing, you sometimes give it little thought and can't remember what it was that you've chucked and can't remember if it's still at the back of a cupboard, then waste time searching for said item. I'm more careful/reluctant to get rid these days.

Knittingnanny2 · 02/09/2022 12:12

I got rid of everything child related 20 years ago apart from a few special toys and books the grown up children said they would like to keep
Ive had to rebuy some of the stuff for grandchild care! I could easily have just stored more in the attic.
But at least the charities have had donations and money from me!
Most stuff is replaceable though.

SudocremOnEverything · 02/09/2022 12:08

Sometimes. I can be a bit overzealous in decluttering sometimes!

But mostly getting rid of stuff I never use turns out to be a good idea.

ThisIsAddiction · 02/09/2022 12:08

Yes, all my vinyl from the 80's. I'd got everything on CD so figured they were cluttering.

I really regret that now.

autienotnaughty · 02/09/2022 12:08

I got rid of some childhood classic books my mum got me. I rarely looked at them but regret getting rid.

Jellycatrabbit · 02/09/2022 12:06

I'm on a major declutter and have got rid of 2,500 items since last June. There's so much easy stuff that I haven't had to make any hard decisions yet and therefore haven't missed anything. Just start with easy stuff (outgrown kids clothes is my easy) and see how you go.

I did have regrets about a lovely dress I missed- then I remembered that it wasn't decluttered, it went in the rag bag when it fell apart.

100% recommend A Slob comes Clean for this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread