Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents cutting me out of will

345 replies

JoshuaTree36 · 02/09/2022 08:40

HI guys

I will try and keep this brief, as I know how what it is like trying to read a wall of text but facts will be accurate

I am one of two siblings, and me and my brother are both in our 30s now and both of us have a relationship with our parents

I have worked since I left school. (I do not expect any awards for this btw lol) but it is how I expected to be. I have an inherited health condition that has made this a real struggle at times (and I don't expect sympathy either) I am happy with my life, and am married. We brought our house through blood sweat and tears same as everyone else

My brother I love dearly btw, none of this is a jibe at him. Brother has rarely worked i.e worked for short periods in-between addiction and substance issues, is twice divorced and lives alone now in a council flat in a high rise. Again, I am not having a dig at my bro, just merely painting a picture of the situation. Bro is a good person and we get on well. My Brother would give me his last penny if i needed it

Last week, out of the blue, My Mum told me that they are planning to leave their house to my Brother, in their Will as it is 'ok for me, as I own a house'.

I was shocked at this as you can imagine, and Mum asked me how I would feel. I literally was on the backfoot and said 'You do whatever you think is right' and I stand by that, as I feel that I should not be pointing out to them what to do.

Maybe my face gave me away and Mum said 'oh i can tell you are not happy ' but I insisted, this is a surprise conversation, and they need to do what they think is right so she said this is what we have decided and that was that.

My main issue is, they are doing this on the basis that I own a house (with my Husband obviously) so they assume I will be set up forever.

However, as i mentioned before I have an inherited health condition where no one that I know of, in my family (who have inherited it) has been able to continue working past age 55 due the declining issues it causes. My Brother does not have this condition, which I am grateful for truly

Plus , just because me and my husband are happy now, we could split up in two years for example, and me end up out on my ear. or stuck with mortgage i cant afford to pay

I feel properly pee'd off about this. I will not be raising this with them, and I was sworn to secrecy so my Brother does not know what he apparently, has coming to him. To top it off, it is unlikely my Brother would want to live there, as they live in quite a remote location

How would you feel? AIBU?

OP posts:
saraclara · 03/09/2022 19:35

Pupinski · 03/09/2022 19:20

Addiction is illness too. Clearly it impacts your brother greatly. From his track record it's clear he will never be able to have a mortgage of his own and your parents are concerned that he should have that most basic of needs - a roof over his head. Nobody knows what the future may bring but your brother could hit tougher times just as you could, but you'd have a head start in getting back on your feet. Be happy for your brother.

He had a council flat. That gives him a roof over his head for the rest of his life.

me109f · 03/09/2022 19:24

Your parents are being stinkers. Unless there is a good reason parents should try to treat their children reasonably equally. How divisive it is of them to be so judgemental, you have a birthright, and it is not greed, it is being recognised fairly.
I go along with all the prior comments.

Pupinski · 03/09/2022 19:20

Addiction is illness too. Clearly it impacts your brother greatly. From his track record it's clear he will never be able to have a mortgage of his own and your parents are concerned that he should have that most basic of needs - a roof over his head. Nobody knows what the future may bring but your brother could hit tougher times just as you could, but you'd have a head start in getting back on your feet. Be happy for your brother.

Bizzyone · 03/09/2022 18:49

Oops posted too soon!

Dont cut them out etc, just go back to them and explain how you feel having had time to process it and your reasons it worries you hopefully they will at least give it more consideration

CrueTrimeGal · 03/09/2022 18:48

This is a classic testing the water situation which is still shitty for you as their child. It's their responsibility to devide their estate in a way they feel is fair and helpful to both of you as their children, but it sounds as if they are playing with your emotions hoping you'll accept their plans without asking any questions. As you've said do what you want, they can now say you agreed you didn't want your share of the house. If you speak up or challenge their decision now, you look as if all you care about is the money. Point out these facts to them, and tell them you don't appreciate being put in this position, especially from them. They need to do better tbh.

Anele22 · 03/09/2022 18:48

This is appalling, for all the reasons you mention. And why should you have to bear the secret but your brother can remain in blissful ignorance? If it was me I'd definitely be telling my parents how unfair they were being.

Strangeways19 · 03/09/2022 18:47

DadBodAlready · 03/09/2022 18:41

I understand your frustrations, but look at it from your parents view.
They probably love you both dearly, but you have clearly made a success of your life and don't give them worries. Your brother on the other hand appears to be a bit of a disaster. Your parents are probably looking at the situation and are really concerned fr your brothers future, hence their decision.

I don't think throwing money at him is necessarily going to make him any different though sadly

LC84 · 03/09/2022 18:47

Dont cut them out etc!

Just ob

Strangeways19 · 03/09/2022 18:45

I think it's a shame that you weren't able to tell your mother how you felt, she asked this question but you told her what you thought. If you have a good relationships with your parents you could revisit the conversation & tell her house yesterday really feel about it.

For what it's worth I don't agree with giving children's different amounts unless said child has made it clear that they wanted nothing to do with parents. This isn't the case here. It runs the risk of setting up rivalry between siblings & I also wonder why they've not told your brother? I think this infantilizes him he is not a child who on earth would they treated him likes one?! He might have an opinion of his own

DadBodAlready · 03/09/2022 18:41

I understand your frustrations, but look at it from your parents view.
They probably love you both dearly, but you have clearly made a success of your life and don't give them worries. Your brother on the other hand appears to be a bit of a disaster. Your parents are probably looking at the situation and are really concerned fr your brothers future, hence their decision.

Chuck2015 · 03/09/2022 18:38

Very similar situation to mine a few years ago. My parent left more money to my bro but split the house between us. Because of various MH issues he now lives in the house and probably will do forever because otherwise he’d be v vulnerable. The point I’m making is that I wish my Dad had discussed the will with me because on balance I would rather my brother had the house and maybe I could have been left more of the other assets. I wish he’d discussed it with me, I wouldn’t care if it was a fair split as it would be better for me than it is now. Where will your brother go in the event of your parents death? Is he guaranteed a council flat for ever or could he ever face homelessness? i don’t think it’s fair but you do need to consider his MH and well-being long term in all this.

wentworthinmate · 03/09/2022 18:11

Your brother is going to go through that money in no time on drugs. Happened to my partners brother. Had a small drinking issue, came into money after mothers death and then drank himself into
hospital and died about 18 months later.

gardenooh · 03/09/2022 18:02

You should never show favouritism especially with money. How can you just accept that? It's outrageous. I'm sure they will be expecting old age care from you when they lose their mobility and independence, and to do chores and help them out. You are far more gracious than me

RC64 · 03/09/2022 17:57

I am going through similar to you. My mum died last month and has left everything to my eldest sister and her son. I have a life limiting condition and I'm recently divorced from a high earning man (£120k+ bonuses pa) who earns more in a month than I do in a year! I am in need of having at least 2 operations both of which are 6 months recovery and I am self employed so no sickness benefit etc.and I have been told I'll never work full time again. I lost lots of work due to having to isolate during covid because of my health issues and had to live off my savings (from divorce settlement which have nearly all gone). My eldest sister has no mortgage (luckily neither do I) and also has a second property that she rents out. She is also self-employed and is never without a good income. My other sister is the same as my eldest sister. So out of the three of us I am the 'worst' off.Please understand this isn'y me feeling sorry for myself or bitching about my two sisters that I love dearly. However, my eldest sister has looks after our mum for many years and because of this I have never had to worry about her. Personally, I think my sister and her son have both been there for my mum and I am more than happy for her to have what is essentially a small estate. If I got anything from mum it would only have been a mediocre amount. We (my sisters and I) each 'lost' a fortune when our birth father died and left all his money to our stepmother (even though she always swore to him that she would leave it all to us instead she left it to the dogs home - we're talking hundreds of thousands!). I have always taken the stance that if someone wants to leave their money to someone other than family, well that's up to them. At the end of the day it is just money. I can understand your concerns (specially having gone through the breakdown of my marriage which mum knew about) but honestly, try not to worry about the 'what if's'. None of us know what is round the corner. Your parents may change their minds. Rather than letting it fester, speak to your parents calmly and explain why you are concerned. I'm sure they'll understand. They might not change things but at least you will have voiced your opinion. Half of the time, we don't speak up and that in itself can cause lots of turmoil within ourselves. I hope this is of some help.

Bunpea · 03/09/2022 17:56

YANBU. This is very hurtful and is plan old fashioned sexism.

When you look back at it, you might also wonder about your brother (whom I hear you say you love dearly).

it’s very sad situation because it has undoubtedly made you question your relationship with your parents, and you have my sympathy.

All you can do is appeal to your parents conscience and sense of fairness, I think.

A solicitor might be able to advise about any chances of challenging the will after your parents have died, and any potential claims under the Inheritance Act.
Wishing you all the best.

Snog · 03/09/2022 17:43

I would be honest with your parents about your own worries for your future and how this has made you feel. Then they can decide if they want to change their wills or not.
This is surely the best way to honour your relationship.

Lovethesun100 · 03/09/2022 14:44

If your brother has a council flat he is probably in a more secure home situation than you are as a part owner of a property with you partner.

PetraBP · 03/09/2022 14:31

Try to carry on as normal. You’re stressing about something that might not happen for many many years.

She may even change her mind in time, especially if your DB manages to sort himself out and continues on that path.

Thatboymum · 03/09/2022 13:54

What a horrible situation to be in, I think anything around wills is always awkward and difficult to manage , I think give it a week or so and sit down and have a frank and honest convo with your mum , if she still looks at it through rose tinted glasses after hearing what you have to say so be it but don’t cut them off because of it what shitty advice from people. You say you have a good bond with your brother , maybe he would hate to have all that thrown at him and will split it equally I know I would with my sister who I love dearly I would feel terrible for her

andyetanotherschoolyear · 03/09/2022 13:29

Dragonsmother · 02/09/2022 23:07

OP you need to have an honest conversation with yourself. This will emotionally eat you up.

I am in a similar position. DB will get everything and we will get nothing.

It hurts- like really hurts. It’s not about the money but it is about never being treated as equals.

When I found out what was in our parents will I confronted them. It’s their money, their choice. But I am their daughter and should be treated equally to their son.

gosh, that's terrible. Sorry for asking but is there a cultural element that is playing a part here?

Dragonsmother · 02/09/2022 23:07

OP you need to have an honest conversation with yourself. This will emotionally eat you up.

I am in a similar position. DB will get everything and we will get nothing.

It hurts- like really hurts. It’s not about the money but it is about never being treated as equals.

When I found out what was in our parents will I confronted them. It’s their money, their choice. But I am their daughter and should be treated equally to their son.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 02/09/2022 22:39

@Howdoyoulikeyourtea That is horrible of your DM.

WinterDeWinter · 02/09/2022 22:31

TrashyPanda · 02/09/2022 18:10

Similar thing happened to my pal - mother left her (mortgage free) flat to older half-brother.

she tried to rationalise this, by saying she was married, with husband earning good wage and brother was single and drifted from job to job, with long periods of unemployment.

and then my friends marriage broke up, cos he ExH was having an affair. She hadn’t worked since before her DC were born and couldn’t afford to stay in the family home.

meanwhile, brother mortgaged the flat multiple times, and of course defaulted, so flat was repossessed. Everything my friends mum had worked so hard for all her working life was gone. And my friend was left high and dry.

there was a happy ending, as my marriage broke up a few months later and we combined out households and have been living as housemates for over 10 years.

This is like a feminist fairy tale - amazing @TrashyPanda.

And they lived happily ever after yeah motherfucker!

Caterinaballerina · 02/09/2022 22:28

Sorry if I’m repeating advice already offered, I’ve not read the whole thread but what immediately sprang to my mind is to speak to your parents and explain that as their house is not in a position you think your DB would want to live in they need to think about leaving the value of the house. A house itself cannot be split but the value of it could be. You understand they may want more provision for your DB which you’d have to think about how much you’d support that, also you could be made trustee of something for your DB.

MultiplicationBell · 02/09/2022 22:12

Dotjones · 02/09/2022 08:43

At least they've told you how they feel about you, so you can make the choice as to whether to cut them out of your life now to spare yourself the pain later.

Try going NC with them for a few months and see what their reaction is. If they keep trying to contact you, try to apologise and change the will, then maybe they just made a stupid mistake. If they don't bother to try to restart your relationship then you know they're not worth the bother.

Wow. Seriously? Emotionally black mail them into leaving something or going no contact? That's horrible advice.

If I understand correctly they aren't disinheriting op out of spite. It sounds to me as if rightly or wrongly they think that op doesn't need the house but her brother does. If the roles were reversed and they felt that op had less assets they might have made a will in op's favour.

I assume they've spent a lot of time worrying about the brother and how he'll manage his life whereas op has seemed to do well. I know op you say that you aren't in a great situation either but I guess your parents might just worry more about your brother because of his addiction issues, etc. I think you could mention to them that 1. Your brother might not want to live in the house and 2. You might also be more dependent in your fifties and then maybe the four of you can come to an arrangement that suits all of you better. E.g. maybe they can leave the house to you and any other assets to your brother or something like that. Or sell the house and split the money.

Op I genuinely don't think it's reflection of how much they care for you (at least purely going by what you have written in your post. If there is a backstory to this then I could be totally wrong of course)