Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents cutting me out of will

345 replies

JoshuaTree36 · 02/09/2022 08:40

HI guys

I will try and keep this brief, as I know how what it is like trying to read a wall of text but facts will be accurate

I am one of two siblings, and me and my brother are both in our 30s now and both of us have a relationship with our parents

I have worked since I left school. (I do not expect any awards for this btw lol) but it is how I expected to be. I have an inherited health condition that has made this a real struggle at times (and I don't expect sympathy either) I am happy with my life, and am married. We brought our house through blood sweat and tears same as everyone else

My brother I love dearly btw, none of this is a jibe at him. Brother has rarely worked i.e worked for short periods in-between addiction and substance issues, is twice divorced and lives alone now in a council flat in a high rise. Again, I am not having a dig at my bro, just merely painting a picture of the situation. Bro is a good person and we get on well. My Brother would give me his last penny if i needed it

Last week, out of the blue, My Mum told me that they are planning to leave their house to my Brother, in their Will as it is 'ok for me, as I own a house'.

I was shocked at this as you can imagine, and Mum asked me how I would feel. I literally was on the backfoot and said 'You do whatever you think is right' and I stand by that, as I feel that I should not be pointing out to them what to do.

Maybe my face gave me away and Mum said 'oh i can tell you are not happy ' but I insisted, this is a surprise conversation, and they need to do what they think is right so she said this is what we have decided and that was that.

My main issue is, they are doing this on the basis that I own a house (with my Husband obviously) so they assume I will be set up forever.

However, as i mentioned before I have an inherited health condition where no one that I know of, in my family (who have inherited it) has been able to continue working past age 55 due the declining issues it causes. My Brother does not have this condition, which I am grateful for truly

Plus , just because me and my husband are happy now, we could split up in two years for example, and me end up out on my ear. or stuck with mortgage i cant afford to pay

I feel properly pee'd off about this. I will not be raising this with them, and I was sworn to secrecy so my Brother does not know what he apparently, has coming to him. To top it off, it is unlikely my Brother would want to live there, as they live in quite a remote location

How would you feel? AIBU?

OP posts:
Harmonypuss · 04/09/2022 01:04

It's your parents' house/money and it's up to them what they do with it. They could choose to donate it to the local dogs' home, give it to a homeless charity, sell it and spend the cash all themselves, etc.

IT'S NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS - THEY OWE YOU NOTHING!

bluetongue · 04/09/2022 00:25

My parents helped me with a deposit for a house (I did vaguely suggest it) and not my sister as she is in a different financial situation. My sister doesn’t know about it.

I absolutely don’t expect different treatment in their will though and would be fine if they left my sister a bit more due to the house deposit situation.

MyMumSaysALot · 04/09/2022 00:23

If you love your children equally, you treat them equally.
This should be glaringly obvious to you, @JoshuaTree36 no matter what justification your mother gave you.
It might be uncomfortable, but I’d certainly bring that to their attention. There’s no way I’d let it slide. I’d explode at some point. Your parents are being very unreasonable. Btw - do they know about your brother’s “habits?”

My brother was fantastically successful and very wealthy. My sister was married to a very wealthy man. And I was barely limping along on very limited funds. Still, my parents split their will in three equal parts. I didn’t see that as being unfair to me — in fact, I didn’t think about it at all.

eastegg · 03/09/2022 23:52

Just realised my latest post reads as if I am longtompot. I am not! Just someone else who should have read all the OP’s posts first.

eastegg · 03/09/2022 23:49

Ok, hands up, I should have read the OP’s posts before I posted. Seems like the mum is a lot more toxic than I thought from the original info.

longtompot · 03/09/2022 23:43

RealityTV · 03/09/2022 19:36

@JoshuaTree36, are you serious right now?

  1. You are a married woman with a husband!
  2. You HAVE a home already!
  3. You have health issues, but your brother does too!
  4. Your brother doesn't have a home and is living on welfare.
For you to be upset about this is ridiculous! Your brother is clearly in a position where he is struggling! You actually said you wouldn't have a problem if they gave it to charity, so why do you have a problem with them giving their home to your brother? He CLEARLY has not had the life you have had. He has issues, likely both mental and physical, that have left him in a precarious position in life. By the time your parents pass, he may be better, but right now he isn't better.

In addition to all of that, you lied to your mother! If you really had an issue with this, why not say something when she asked. You should have been honest and said you felt that was unfair to you (I think it isn't) or you should have asked what YOU were going to inherit, since that is important to you.

Let me tell you something. Sometimes, as a parent, you can tell that one child is weaker than the other. You may feel responsible for this and try to do things to help the weaker child. This may make the child who is not weaker feel hurt because they feel the parents are paying more attention to the weaker child. Your parents looked at the two of you and felt that you would be able to make it over your brother. You have a husband. You haven't been addicted. You are doing well. You may have some health issues, but you are still thriving. Don't make everything about your issues. Look at the bigger picture, like your parents are trying to do. Your husband is your support system. Your brother doesn't have that support system. Instead of feeling salty about the house, talk to them and ask them about their bank accounts and other investments. They can also take out life insurance policies and give you that instead of the house. I see nothing wrong with what your parents did as long as there is something also in their estate or a life insurance policy for you. However, I wouldn't have done what they did. If your brother is an addict, without a substantial job, how is he going to pay the taxes on the property? I don't know how it is in the UK, but in the US, if you don't pay taxes, the government will take your property! How did your parents plan for the taxes to be paid? Instead of being mad, THINK your way through this and then sit down and talk with them about life insurance, taxes and the house. Don't get mad and talk about this reasonably. Your parents just want what is best for you, their stronger child, and your brother, their emotionally weaker child! The fact that your mother even brought it up to you should tell you that!

I think you might want to read all of the ops posts about what the relationship is like with her parents

eastegg · 03/09/2022 23:39

Sorry I didn’t phrase some of that very well. I mean the parents’ decision is open to criticism, but to say it ‘shows what they think of the OP’ is too much.

eastegg · 03/09/2022 23:37

Dotjones · 02/09/2022 08:43

At least they've told you how they feel about you, so you can make the choice as to whether to cut them out of your life now to spare yourself the pain later.

Try going NC with them for a few months and see what their reaction is. If they keep trying to contact you, try to apologise and change the will, then maybe they just made a stupid mistake. If they don't bother to try to restart your relationship then you know they're not worth the bother.

So emotionally blackmail them into changing their will? I think that’s a bit harsh. And I don’t think it shows that the OP means nothing to them, as you’re suggesting. It’s open to criticism, but that’s too much, and terribly insensitive to the OP.

I don’t really have any answers OP but I think you’re handling it well, and also you and your brother have done well to maintain a good relationship despite what must have been considerable hurdles. I think if you maintain that, things are more likely to come good in the end.

Blacksheepcat · 03/09/2022 23:19

I can never understand how parents can not treat their children equally. You are not being unreasonable but your parents are.

Mrseds · 03/09/2022 23:17

That is a bit shitty, my dads wife doesn’t like me and I the same to her, so when he told me his will which favours her and her children I was gobsmacked, so I told him I would contest it if it wasn’t made fair. May seem harsh but I don’t really care 😂😂

Pinkfluff76 · 03/09/2022 22:29

You need to talk to your parents. Your mum asked and you didn’t tell her how you feel properly. It’s very unfair.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 03/09/2022 21:16

You should talk to them and say it’s unfair - which it is. ESP considering your health condition.

NippySweetie16 · 03/09/2022 20:51

Written out. Sorry!

NippySweetie16 · 03/09/2022 20:50

Where are you? In Scotland children can't be written put - they are entitled to share 1/3 of the value of the estate.

NickyChavan · 03/09/2022 20:40

I would say to your Mum and Dad, i have thought about what we discussed and i am hurt, and then state your own health etc situation. Then ask them what will be your inheritance eg, life insurance, savings etc. Maybe they see the house as only one part of it. If you plan to have children you could ask them to give him lifetime living in the house but upon brothers passing it reverts to you or equally split between any kids you and brother have. Also explain to them selling their house he could maybe buy a smaller property and then you can still be included.

Queenohmean · 03/09/2022 20:29

Your parents are enabling your brother's addictions. This is bullshit. He may give you the impression that he'd give you his last dime, this is also bullshit. Addicts are out for number one, and that doesn't include you. I would consult an attorney ASAP. (As an American, I am unfamiliar with the term council flat - gov't assistance? nevertheless, this does not put a damper on my suspicions.) I believe he's emotionally manipulated your parents into this 'decision.' Why else would your mother ask how you feel about it? Her son is feeling you out to test how likely you are to bring legal action against him. Jesus Christ, you're a woman, and you're sickness is bonafide. Your fears for the future are not at all outlandish. Divorce, death, anything can happen at any time (hell, he could be taken out by a drunk driver). If your bro doesn't work, how does he afford his drugs? He's dealing maybe?

VladmirsPoutine · 03/09/2022 20:27

I would tell your mother exactly how you feel. It's not fair. Things like this can and do create such bad will and break entire families.

Suerossi · 03/09/2022 20:21

My mother passed at an old age, my father 35 years ago. Complicated situation but house was being left to niece and nephew as eldest brother bought her council house but got 50% free because of years she’d lived there. He died 20 years ago. One of my two remaining brothers took great delight in telling me 3 days before she died that she’d changed her will a few years ago to include my two siblings and leave me out. He was smirking when he told me. I know he orchestrated it because he was always sly and sneaky and bullied her with his views, but it hurt that she never told me. I didn’t need her money but I would have felt better if she’d told me so always wonder now if she wanted it that way herself. I know it’s hard to deal with and it was too late for me to say something to her and I wasn’t giving my brother the satisfaction of a reaction which he really wanted. But I agree with others you should be honest with both your parents together. It sounds like your family dynamics might come from previous generations, like alcoholism, addiction is addiction. Controllers marry passive partners and the children grow up being another generation to suffer. Your mother and father may well be the product of parents affected by this. It causes all kinds of unhealthy behaviour and just gets passed down, learned behaviour. I had a brother who died of alcoholism and a brother who is an alcoholic and I’d swear it runs down my mother’s side even if the specific addiction skips a generation, the ‘isms’ persist. I guess what I mean is you can’t change people but you can tell them how you feel. Honesty can be a powerful tool and it can free you from the awful feeling of resentment.

BigMommafromBolton · 03/09/2022 20:15

This is just patently unfair.

My parents did something similar, and cut out a sibling. It caused so many repercussions and such bad feeling between the remaining children. Your parents are just setting you both up for years of tension once the will comes to fruition. I’d explain that to them now, and hopefully they will have a rethink.

fetchacloth · 03/09/2022 20:15

I'm in a similar situation OP and you have my full sympathy and understanding with this.
For my mum it was a pragmatic decision but when she passes it's going cause simmering resentment with me and my other brother who inherit nothing.
I feel really bad posting this but am speaking out as I'm sure OP aren't alone with this situation.

qtpa2t · 03/09/2022 20:04

Yeah I would also feel really hurt by this. You handled it with such grace and like a truly good person. Maybe if you did ever end up in that situation your brother would take you in :)

JT12 · 03/09/2022 19:53

Actually I reread the thread and it seems as if you do have issues with your family. I would still speak to them about this even if it is just to assert your emotions n the situation. Let them know how it makes you feel and if this has no impact then you have no option but to rethink your relationship with them moving forwards. If your mum truly doesn’t care about your feelings you can let her know that you no longer have the energy to invest in the relationship- invest your emotional energy in your own family unit and close friends

mynameisbrian · 03/09/2022 19:49

Well i think your mum is lying. I think her telling you this and smirking at your reaction and then telling you not to tell your brother leads to me to her wanting drama. She wants you to tell your brother.

She will either suggest your a liar or your being greedy.

Personally any parent who thinks telling a sibling they are getting nothing whilst their drug addict son gets everything would be enough for me to climb out of the fog and go NC.

It wouldn't be due to lack of inheritance or entitlement it would be due to the smug satisfaction your mother displayed when seeing you were upset,

Step way and let her get on with it. All you can hope for is that she dies first and your dad changes the will

JT12 · 03/09/2022 19:37

I think you should speak to them. If you have a good relationship with your parents (which it sounds like you do) I am sure they are not trying to hurt you and truly believe that they are doing the right thing in trying to save the most vulnerable of their children, your brother. I think if you explain your feelings they will understand. If you listen to most of the advice on here you will damage your relationship with your parents and your brother. I hope you resolve the issue

RealityTV · 03/09/2022 19:36

@JoshuaTree36, are you serious right now?

  1. You are a married woman with a husband!
  2. You HAVE a home already!
  3. You have health issues, but your brother does too!
  4. Your brother doesn't have a home and is living on welfare.
For you to be upset about this is ridiculous! Your brother is clearly in a position where he is struggling! You actually said you wouldn't have a problem if they gave it to charity, so why do you have a problem with them giving their home to your brother? He CLEARLY has not had the life you have had. He has issues, likely both mental and physical, that have left him in a precarious position in life. By the time your parents pass, he may be better, but right now he isn't better.

In addition to all of that, you lied to your mother! If you really had an issue with this, why not say something when she asked. You should have been honest and said you felt that was unfair to you (I think it isn't) or you should have asked what YOU were going to inherit, since that is important to you.

Let me tell you something. Sometimes, as a parent, you can tell that one child is weaker than the other. You may feel responsible for this and try to do things to help the weaker child. This may make the child who is not weaker feel hurt because they feel the parents are paying more attention to the weaker child. Your parents looked at the two of you and felt that you would be able to make it over your brother. You have a husband. You haven't been addicted. You are doing well. You may have some health issues, but you are still thriving. Don't make everything about your issues. Look at the bigger picture, like your parents are trying to do. Your husband is your support system. Your brother doesn't have that support system. Instead of feeling salty about the house, talk to them and ask them about their bank accounts and other investments. They can also take out life insurance policies and give you that instead of the house. I see nothing wrong with what your parents did as long as there is something also in their estate or a life insurance policy for you. However, I wouldn't have done what they did. If your brother is an addict, without a substantial job, how is he going to pay the taxes on the property? I don't know how it is in the UK, but in the US, if you don't pay taxes, the government will take your property! How did your parents plan for the taxes to be paid? Instead of being mad, THINK your way through this and then sit down and talk with them about life insurance, taxes and the house. Don't get mad and talk about this reasonably. Your parents just want what is best for you, their stronger child, and your brother, their emotionally weaker child! The fact that your mother even brought it up to you should tell you that!

Swipe left for the next trending thread