Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you raise that you thought a friends child is on the spectrum?

62 replies

Justdancers · 02/09/2022 02:20

We have a close friendship with a couple who have a little girl aged 4 (ill call her Jane). We have no children

Every since Jane was fairly little there have been behaviours that to me suggest that shes likely autistic. I have a fair ammount of experience with autistic adults due to working in a supported living but very little with children or how child development works really. I mostly knew that in an adult those behaviours eg stimming would likely be indicative of autism but wasnt sure when some stuff like being solitary play stops being the norm for that age, if that makes sense? Janes mum worked doing sensory interventions for autistic children for a while so i would assume has a good knowledge

Obviously a large part of Janes infancy was in covid so we saw less them often, and also knew that would change her social development. Each time we have seen her those things have remained and become a bit more noticeable as she hasnt been on track with other peers of her age.

We never mentioned this. Frankly we arent kid experts, Our friends are fantastic parents who seemed like they were doing an awesome job . Jane is happy, a cracking kid and we like spending time with her. It never seemed any of our buisness and thete was never a reason to

Recently Janes preschool has flagged that they feel she is autistic. Its clear this is a bombshell for them and even if they were thinking it in the back of their minds, having someone else flag it has been shocking.

We have had been emotionally supportive of them since as they try and figure out systems

Theyve told us theyve been feeling hurt that friends and family (they dont seem to include us in this) have also noticed things but not shared it with them. They feel let down by this, and like people were not being open with them.

We arent sure if our approach was the best now, we were just going with the flow, and taking their lead.

I wondered if other people would outright tell a friend if they noticed things like handflapping, sensory issues, development delays etc or if they would stay quiet?

OP posts:
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 02/09/2022 09:14

God no- it would be seen as picking up a flaw or a negative in someone else’s child.
Not my place

FirewomanSam · 02/09/2022 09:12

I had a similar situation with my SIL and her son and I think you really have to wait until the parents are ready to hear it. It’s so tricky. In my nephew’s case we all had our suspicions from when he was very very small (things like no eye contact, almost never smiling, an impressive but alarming obsession with numbers and counting things…) but she could only see her clever little boy and claimed that the reason he never played with other children at nursery was because he was ‘too advanced’ for them. People would tentatively ask if she was worried about his development and she’d just say no, he’s so clever and good at all these different thing, why would she be worried? She didn’t want to hear it and would get quite defensive.

But one day it was like a lightswitch and she decided to ask his nursery about it, at which point they apparently had a whole heap of info ready to give her. It was like they’d been waiting for her to bring it up. Then she was finally ready to hear from friends and family, but that would never have gone down well if people had pushed it before then.

pennysarah · 02/09/2022 09:00

Also it helps if someone is talking positively about being autistic, I think it makes people more likely to embrace the idea/possibility. Talking about it in hushed tones with fear /dread (or avoiding talking about it) doesn't help anyone.

pennysarah · 02/09/2022 08:54

I would say something if an appropriate moment presented itself. But obviously I can't diagnose and several conditions can present similarly/ with overlapping traits. I would point out traits, could say that my children on the spectrum did/struggled with XYZ. No point in avoiding the topic if you can help/educate etc. I now have lots of knowledge on SEN and felt most lost before I started educating myself - I would help someone on that journey if I could.

Like someone else said I would never dismiss a concern- that's what happens too often. If a parent publicly questions if their child is neurodivergent in some way then chances are they are.

faw2009 · 02/09/2022 08:40

Yes I wouldn't say anything either. I was upset when a teacher mentioned it to me for DS1, and DH didn't want to know. Friends and family didn't seem surprised when I told them! Many families don't want a diagnosis as they believe it will hold their kid back in adult life.

Maybe not surprising your friend didn't notice any signs. Didn't Tony Atwood (expert on Aspergers) not realise his own son was autistic?

Diverseopinions · 02/09/2022 08:36

I don't see how you can say something. If the parents say something to you first, you can say: 'Oh, ok. Perhaps' , and read the relevant chapter or article which they show you.

The notion of 'otherness' will be upsetting, if that is how it will come across. Perhaps a conversation could go well, but there is a risk that it might not. The autistic child will have traits and features and a personality, like any neuro-typical child, and it will be hard for a friend to put across that they have noticed differences, without making it seem that they think the autistic child is very different. Autistic children are often very affectionate and interested in people, in spite of social difficulties, and pointing out 'abnormal' social behaviour can come across as suggesting that the child isn't friendly or loving.
My son was diagnosed with ASD by the health professionals aged 4, although it was suggested by a private practioner at an earlier she. The nursery talked sensitively about it and encouraged our efforts to investigate further. They had pertinent examples of difficulties to refer to - that my son was having - and they were trained educationalists. When I mentioned the possibility first, friends listened, and talked about the very positive traits, such as being smiley and interested in people.

A really close friend could talk it through with parents, but not easy to suggest it, when the parents don't seem to be considering the possibility.

BruisedSkies · 02/09/2022 08:31

I have a friend whose 6 year old doesn’t make eye contact, doesn’t interact much with other kids, doesn’t talk when spoken to. Think the child said about 10 words to me in 2 years. I’ve not said anything because it’s not my place and also not everyone wants a diagnosis. I can understand that though.

Daftasabroom · 02/09/2022 08:28

@Justdancers I have an autistic son. I would suggest that if you are asked by your friends "do you think DD is autistic?" to answer "possibly, but you would need to seek a diagnosis". But don't initiate that conversation.

Choconut · 02/09/2022 08:19

I don't think this is one that you could win tbh.

BogRollBOGOF · 02/09/2022 08:17

I strongly suspect my friend's child is autistic for a multitude of reasons but have never said anything direct because their parents aren't ready to handle it including the logistics of investigating and then managing with places like school.

The topic comes up because one of my DCs is autistic. There's an opening there if they want to take it up. From my experience with DS there's lots of subtlties I notice like selective eye contact (I only realised with DS when the consultant pointed it out; he only directly looks at "safe people"). He'll share interests with the group of children but either do things on his own (very much like toddler side by side play) or in a very fixed way. His speech is a little "off" and he'll tend to monologue, or struggle to slot with conversation age appropriately. He's very sensory with play and food. The really tricky bit is when the children have had a spat and I can't openly explain to mine that it was an autustic reaction to a trigger rather than being awkward. With one of mine having a rigid viewpoint of the world this happens a lot!

DS1 had a phase of awful meltdowns, his record being 4 hours and that was the push that I needed to join the dots up. I recognised a few scattered traits over the years but nothing seemed strong/ clear enough to push to investigate. When he was diagnosed, I was still stunned, partly through shock that I'd been believed and someone else took it seriously. Even with diagnosis, his primary school never saw through the masking and truely saw the autism. For children that "function" adequately on the surface, different people will see it differently and even without stereotypes and fear of what autism means for life, it's very difficult to broach the subject sensitively if a parent isn't seeing it or accepting that they're seeing it.

If the friends ever open up with suspicions, I'll be supportive but it needs to come from them first. You can't make people see it before they're ready.

locke360 · 02/09/2022 08:16

I think I would say something only if the parent raised concerns first. If they were talking to me about the child's development and saying she was a bit behind etc., I might say that I had worked with children with autism and maybe it's something to consider, I've noticed that she does X which is quite common in the autistic children I've seen etc.

Even then, I'd only say it if I had a professional background/ personal experience to back me up so could speak with some authority on the subject.

I certainly wouldn't raise it out of the blue without the parents mentioning any concerns to begin with. They would be the ones to initiate it.

I don't think you did anything wrong by not voicing your concerns - I think the parents are just worried/ upset but hopefully they will get the help they need now.

Chdjdn · 02/09/2022 08:10

No I wouldn’t unless someone asked my opinion; I’ve seen people do this and it go very wrong and if someone is very much in denial then it’s not going to go well

sandgrown · 02/09/2022 08:10

My son has just been diagnosed at age 20. A very observant teacher suggested he may have ADHD/ASD when he was15 and the process has taken this long . I feel so guilty I didn’t notice anything . I think I would have been grateful if someone had suggested he may be ND when I was struggling with his behaviour.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 02/09/2022 08:08

I would only suggest it if my friend was actually speaking to me about their child’s behaviour and asking for my opinion.

I think they’re probably just feeling some hard emotions as it’s taken them by surprise for autism to be suggested.

FredrikaPeri · 02/09/2022 08:07

This reply has been deleted

Deleted for troll hunting.

Why would a "troll" post about this? 🤔

Anothernamechangeplease · 02/09/2022 08:05

I would add that I had a longstanding thought that my best friend's dd was on the autistic spectrum, but chose not to say anything for years as I didn't think friend was ready to hear it. I eventually shared my thoughts when friend confided in me that she thought her other daughter was potentially on the spectrum - something that I hadn't ever considered, though it made sense when she said it. At that point, my friend was ready to hear the suggestion and found it helpful, but I don't think the time would have been right before.

Another friend of mine did say something to a third mutual friend about her ds potentially being on the spectrum. I believe that he very likely was on the spectrum, but the suggestion was very badly received and sadly it was the end of their friendship. I since lost touch with the mother of the potentially autistic child too, so I don't know if he was ever diagnosed in the end. The friend who suggested autism to the mum was an incredibly kind person and I'm sure that she was only trying to help, but sometimes people will only hear what you're saying when they're ready to listen.

DiscoBadgers · 02/09/2022 08:02

Given that the mother has significant expertise in this area, no I wouldn’t expect anyone else to say anything. People don’t want to hear that their children have SEN so it likely wouldn’t have made a difference if you had. I say this as a SEN parent.

Scepticalwotsits · 02/09/2022 08:00

I’m not a professional so I wouldn’t. If I was asked about my opinion if they were not sure if they should take their DC to a professional my response would be diplomatic along the lines of if you are thinking my about it you have a reason for that, so take them.

I wouldn’t though pass an unsolicited comment

Anothernamechangeplease · 02/09/2022 07:57

autienotnaughty · 02/09/2022 03:51

I would say if I felt parent was struggling. Otherwise I'd wait til asked.

This.

In your case, OP, I think there is no good that can come of saying something now. The school has already recommended that it's looked into, so hopefully it will be properly investigated. And your friends have already been upset by the idea that others have had hidden suspicions that they have chosen not to share. I understand that you feel bad because you're doing the same, but there is no benefit to anyone in telling them that now.

If you feel bad not saying anything, then I would tell a bit of a white lie and say that you had never really thought about it previously, but now they've mentioned it as a possibility, you've noticed that dc does xxx behaviour, which could potentially be linked to autism. That way, you're sharing your observations with them but not making it look like you've been sitting on them for ages without bothering to say anything.

georgarina · 02/09/2022 07:54

^When their child goes to school this/next year it will be flagged anyway.

georgarina · 02/09/2022 07:52

If they mentioned concerns, I would. If they didn't, I wouldn't.

ElegantlyTouched · 02/09/2022 07:49

I did, and it worked out OK, but I wouldn't recommend it. In my case my friend was convinced but no one else could see it.

BigYellowElephant · 02/09/2022 07:23

My exs son is on the spectrum (I'm 99% sure). I'm a teacher and worked with lots of SEN kids and he's got very clear traits. He didn't go to nursery and has already changed primary school once (he's 6) so I feel like the chance hasn't been there for them to flag it up. When his mum changed his school she just said his teacher was being horrible about him and I assumed she meant that she'd said he was likely autistic and shared this (in a nice way) with my ex. Well he hit the absolute ROOF, was furious with me for suggesting it as were his whole family. He still brings it up now and I'm sure when his new school flag it up I'll never get an apology or any recognition for trying to help. Next time I'll just keep my mouth shut.

Jennybeans401 · 02/09/2022 07:11

I think I'd keep my opinions to myself if I were you. Unless the parents have come yo you for advice or you are in the role of paediatrician I think it's very bad form to diagnose other people's dcs. The child is young too. As a friend you should support and listen.

Msloverlover · 02/09/2022 07:00

I did tell my very best friend that I had suspicions her ds was over a few wines. Woke up with absolute DREAD the next day feeling I had probably overstepped my mark. (For background, I’m a teacher and she has had no contact with autism before.)

She never voiced this to me though and has always continued the conversation and uses me as a sounding board re his progress. He started school last year and they clocked something was up almost immediately. Looks like it is ASD.

Overall I think she appreciated me telling her as it gave her a heads up and she felt prepared when school raised it. BUT I genuinely feel it could have gone either way and was a massive gamble (that I only took because I was a bit pished!). As it has turned out (it is rapidly becoming more obvious that he has ASD) I would have talked to her at some point, but perhaps not that early on.