Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you raise that you thought a friends child is on the spectrum?

62 replies

Justdancers · 02/09/2022 02:20

We have a close friendship with a couple who have a little girl aged 4 (ill call her Jane). We have no children

Every since Jane was fairly little there have been behaviours that to me suggest that shes likely autistic. I have a fair ammount of experience with autistic adults due to working in a supported living but very little with children or how child development works really. I mostly knew that in an adult those behaviours eg stimming would likely be indicative of autism but wasnt sure when some stuff like being solitary play stops being the norm for that age, if that makes sense? Janes mum worked doing sensory interventions for autistic children for a while so i would assume has a good knowledge

Obviously a large part of Janes infancy was in covid so we saw less them often, and also knew that would change her social development. Each time we have seen her those things have remained and become a bit more noticeable as she hasnt been on track with other peers of her age.

We never mentioned this. Frankly we arent kid experts, Our friends are fantastic parents who seemed like they were doing an awesome job . Jane is happy, a cracking kid and we like spending time with her. It never seemed any of our buisness and thete was never a reason to

Recently Janes preschool has flagged that they feel she is autistic. Its clear this is a bombshell for them and even if they were thinking it in the back of their minds, having someone else flag it has been shocking.

We have had been emotionally supportive of them since as they try and figure out systems

Theyve told us theyve been feeling hurt that friends and family (they dont seem to include us in this) have also noticed things but not shared it with them. They feel let down by this, and like people were not being open with them.

We arent sure if our approach was the best now, we were just going with the flow, and taking their lead.

I wondered if other people would outright tell a friend if they noticed things like handflapping, sensory issues, development delays etc or if they would stay quiet?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
goldfinchonthelawn · 03/09/2022 07:31

I'm not sure. Depends how acutely the child presented and whether I thought their needs wer enot being met by parents who were blind to the situation. DS is autistic and wasn;t diagnosed until he went to secondary. Looking back, there were loads of signs but I knew nothing about autism, including that DH is on the spectrum, so for me he seemed 'normal', as does DH.

In hindsight, I wish we had known earlier. It would have made his life a lot easier and adults (teachers!) would have been kinder to him and more supportive of his evident struggles.

The nicest thing anyone said to me when he was diagnosed (I was pretty shocked) was: he is still the exact same child as he was pre-diagnosis. That's what your friends need reassuring on. Nothing at all has changed except their knowledge of how to best support their child as she grows up. But she is the exact same person they know and love and interact with. And being autistic is a very very wide spectrum, just as being neurotypical is.

My autistic DS has had really bad struggle sin the past but currently is coping in a flat on his own, cooking for himself, has a girlfriend and a big circle of genuine friends, lots of interests and looks like he;ll do well in his final year at uni. On the surface he has a lot in common with happy success NT people. Unerneath he needs a lot of support and stage by stage instructiuons on how to do or react to things NT people do without thinking.

Daisychainsandglitter · 03/09/2022 07:15

No I wouldn't. I was in a very similar situation myself a couple of months ago.
My own DD is also autistic and I've thought that my friends son is probably on the spectrum for a few years now.
The school approached this with my friend who was very upset and was asking me what I thought.
Whilst I pointed her to some information that she might find helpful and listened, I didn't give my opinion. Not that I'm qualified anyway.

FirewomanSam · 03/09/2022 00:07

I think once you have kids (I assume you are planning to, as you're ere, and hopefully that will happen for you) then I think you'll look back on this and cringe a bit.

What is OP supposed to be cringing at?

Also a hell of an assumption and a little condescending to assume that OP wants kids.

StaunchMomma · 02/09/2022 16:17

It's not a friend's job to tell them and, as you said, you are in no way qualified to make a judgement anyway.

I think once you have kids (I assume you are planning to, as you're ere, and hopefully that will happen for you) then I think you'll look back on this and cringe a bit.

Once kids hit school most find they have a barrier to something, even if it's just not being great at sports or times tables or struggling to make friends and when it is your child I think you'll see just how much you wouldn't enjoy having friends judge your child.

You did the right thing keeping out of it. Your friend is hurting. Just support her and hope that when you are going through a difficult parenting stage in the future that she'll do the same for you.

Pallisers · 02/09/2022 14:54

I think you handled it correctly.

NotLactoseFree · 02/09/2022 14:50

I think you handled it correctly. By the sounds of things, Jane is a broadly happy child and her and her family are not experiencing significant problems. Particularly impressive considering covid. And now, at the age of 4, school have flagged it and it's all moving along. If that wasn't the case, maybe you could or should have said something.

I have tried a couple of times, during conversations about nephew's challenging behaviour, to suggest that SIL consider having him assessed. it is like I have not uttered a word so I know not to push or comment further. I do worry sometimes because the behaviour is getting worse as he gets older and also due to, I suspect, some issues at home and there are hints that school have made a few comments too but that these are ignored. But what can I do? She doesn't want to hear it.

Justdancers · 02/09/2022 14:41

Hello, not a troll. Just posted this in the early hours so its taken me a while to return to it. I used a name simply because there isnt an easy abbreviation for Friends kid.
Sometimes names make more sense to me in text anyway, rather than DC etc.

Thanks all for your reponses.
Really interesting to read through.
We didnt tell them, and have tried to be a listening ear since someone else flagged it.
They dont seem to think we should have spotted it, and are completely on board with the process.

Its hard to for me to figure out when things stop being typical
eg Jane is a very solitary player and when we visit used to play around us rather than with us, thats normal in my experience for toddlers (especially lockdown ones!) so it was hard to pinpoint when those sort of things became worth a mention.

I was worried also they would think we are being critical

Its interesting to read that its often gone wrong for people, and that those recieving it have found it hard both ways

OP posts:
MyNameIsAngelicaSchuyler · 02/09/2022 13:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SkankingWombat · 02/09/2022 13:17

I think you can sound them out and then bring it up in a round-a-bout way if they are expressing concerns or having a moan about how hard they are finding things. I wouldn't suggest a specific SN unless asked point blank, and even then would heavily prefix my answer with the need for a proper assessment/I am not a doctor etc etc. I agree with the PP that because these things can be hereditary, it can be hard for the parent to see/accept because it is their 'normal' too. I first realised I was very likely ND when reading and researching for DD and realising the lists of behaviours seemed very normal and non-exceptional to me.

One of my best friend's DS has shown many Autistic traits since toddlerhood. DH and I had both noticed it quite separately but had explained it away initially as likely a parenting issue (they set strict rules but cave very easily when DS kicks off) plus boys generally being less verbal than girls and that we all have a few small quirks. Fast forward a few years: we were away with them recently, and the DS is clearly really struggling with regular huge meltdowns, as well as the parents struggling to manage his behaviour to prevent him hurting himself or others. We've helped to calm and distract him, and have employed tactics that work with our DD (who is currently being assessed for ASD and ADHD) with good effect. My DF eventually admitted how difficult she was finding it, which started a conversation. I didn't outright suggest ASD, but have suggested she speak to his school about the behaviour they are experiencing for some strategies and guidance (whose SEN radar will hopefully immediately start sounding!). I've also named some strategies to Google explaining they've really helped DD, who she knows is being assessed, and which when Googled are very clearly promoted for DCs with SEN. I would love to speak more plainly but I'm not sure if she is ready to hear it yet (at least not unless it comes from a professional), but hopefully it will plant some seeds.

Goldfishjones · 02/09/2022 11:27

Hard one. I mentioned to one friend that I saw traits in her son that are similar to those in my son who has autism in case it was worth "bearing in mind". This was during a conversation about how she was struggling with him. She shot down the suggestion sharply and we haven't discussed it since. They are still having huge difficulties with him and have not sought any support.

I mentioned the same thing to two other friends (whose children later went on to be diagnosed with autism) and the relief that poured out of them was tangible, they said it had already crossed their minds. It opened up a discussion and they regularly chat to me about it.

I wish people had not downplayed my concerns about my own son when he was younger. I would have liked someone to tell me if they suspected autism. I guess there's no right or wrong, everyone is different. I'm afraid that's not much help sorry. You did what you thought was right in those circumstances and it probably was.

BogRollBOGOF · 02/09/2022 11:25

One barrier to people recognising neurodiversity if is there is a long history of it in the family and it's culturally normal in their family.

DH accepts DS's diagnosis, but he only "sees" the obvious half. It's highly lilely that he has several autistic uncles/ siblings. Another of DS's cousins has been diagnosed. Their mum's concerns were another factor in joining the dots and seeking diagnosis for DS. They are not outliers in their family though.

shrunkenhead · 02/09/2022 11:23

Absolutely bring it up. They might be just burying their heads in the sand. Once the child gets a diagnosis they'll receive plenty of help to get them where they need to be educationally etc
If they realise other people are noticing it may push them to get the help they need.

Kanaloa · 02/09/2022 11:21

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 02/09/2022 09:14

God no- it would be seen as picking up a flaw or a negative in someone else’s child.
Not my place

I really don’t see it like that. To me picking up a flaw/negative would be saying something like ‘gosh George is really naughty isn’t he, he doesn’t listen to you at all’ about a badly behaved child. This is more (to me) like saying ‘oh George is limping a bit there, it looks like he’s hurt his leg or something.’

I still would be conflicted about whether or not to bring it up, but I wouldn’t see it as pointing out a negative.

DreamToNightmare · 02/09/2022 11:16

If they were a very good friend then absolutely I would tell them.

This did in fact happen to me a few years ago and it was difficult having the conversation with my friend but at least it meant she could start seeking assessment and support which would of course
always best for the child.

Fraaahnces · 02/09/2022 11:14

Ooops! Sent too early. Just reiterate what you said above - that this little girl has fantastic parents who are doing everything right

Hurrrrah · 02/09/2022 11:14

My brother and sister in law (who have no children or professional knowledge in this area) keep saying to my parents (not us) that they think one of our children is autistic. They keep picking up on behaviours like being really knowledgeable about things a typical 5 year old would be into, just completely normal stuff (he absolutely is not autistic!). My parents who told me about it are pissed off and my husband is really not impressed. My husband is a teacher so is very aware of the signs etc, I think it just irritates him that they are saying it behind our backs and don't want to let it drop, when we arent there my sil will say out loud "if that isnt autism I dont know what is.." when watching him play etc. Personally I would never suggest someone else's child has an issue, chances are it will not be received well.

Fraaahnces · 02/09/2022 11:13

If she brings it up with you, just tell her that you know you’re not a kid expert, and you just assumed that all kids develop at different stages and have different personalities to each other. Also that you didn’t really watch her grow up so far due to COVID.

Ohwhathaveidonenow · 02/09/2022 11:10

No. I think it's quite generally accepted that the suggestion of a neurodivergent label of any kind has to come from the person themselves, the parents (if it's a child) or possibly a teacher, unless you're specifically asked for your opinion.

Crunchingleaf · 02/09/2022 11:00

I can only speak from my own experience and say that I don’t know how I would of taken it from a friend or family member. I was concerned about DS stimming and speech delay before he was two and even when he got the diagnosis a couple years later it was still very hard to hear and was upsetting.
My mother is a primary school teacher and there have been a couple kids over the years that she suspected Autism with and the parents absolutely refused to hear it or allow child be referred for assessment. So clearly some parents are in complete denial about the possibility that their child has a development delay.
I don’t think your BU OP.

Skiphopbump · 02/09/2022 10:52

I wouldn’t want to be the first to mention it to someone but if a parent had said it had been flagged then I would probably mention I had noticed it too. If they were angry or in denial about it I would suggest going through assessment anyway to ‘rule it out’, by which time the parent will probably come round to the idea.

When DS was about 5/6 he had various professionals involved due to speech and learning difficulties. He was clearly autistic but no one wanted to say it - they were happy to talk about dyspraxia and verbal dyspraxia but also mentioned there might be ‘something else’ going on. They were relived when in a meeting I asked if they meant autism, clearly they had poor reactions in the past and no one wanted to be the first to say it!

x2boys · 02/09/2022 10:49

No i wouldn't my son is 12 and has severe autism and learning disabilities, he was diagnosed at three and a half ,I was in denial at first ,but of course I knew, it wouldn't have helped for well meaning friends to point things out, I have long since accepted the situation, and for the most part I couldn't imagine things any other way ,but it was something I had to come tonterms with.

Marvellousmadness · 02/09/2022 10:43

If it was a acquaintance or vague friend:I wouldn't have said anything

A close friend? Yeah I would have said it. For sure.

TheVanguardSix · 02/09/2022 10:35

Short answer? No.
The nursery has flagged it, seed planted. Let the rest do its thing.
Be a friend. Be loving and be accepting. That’s all you need to be.
Let her parents be the ones to say ‘Our DD is autistic’ if and when that day comes. Don’t take those words from them. Give that power to them because it’s very healing for parents be able to say that. A diagnosis can be a time of relief, bereavement, all sorts. Affirmation/acceptance is a gift the parents give to themselves on their own watch. It cannot come from others.

Madamecastafiore · 02/09/2022 10:26

I did to someone I thought I was close to. Her son was part of my sons friendship group and she kept accusing my son and another boy of bullying her son because they wouldn't play what he wanted how he wanted and he couldn't play with them all unless it was in a certain way due to his limited social ability. There were other behaviours which all pointed towards being on the spectrum, it wasn't just about how he played with the other boys.

We speak now if we bump into each other and are polite but we're no longer close. Her husband won't even look at me. Child is doing ok, still has issues socially but he isn't part of my sons friendship group anymore as I wasn't having my son accused or bullying her son when it wasn't the case.

I'd never do it again which is sad as I have a friend who thought her child had behavioural issues but someone pointed out that they may have autism and she embraced the suggestion fully and got every kind of help she could for him, she understands her child better and has adapted their lives to accommodate him and his needs and it's made a huge difference to him especially in terms of his education and abilities socially.

You're sort of damned if you do and damned if you don't. 🤷🏻‍♀️

orbitalcrisis · 02/09/2022 10:23

When my eldest was on the pathway to diagnosis a relative mentioned that she and her husband had thought that of my son. I was a little surprised they hadn't mentioned it, but wasn't annoyed, it's not something that can be easily brought up. When her son was struggling and I suggested he may have autism, she was severely pissed off with me. So I've never told her I suspect she and her husband are too!

It sounds like she is embarrassed that she didn't notice it herself so is looking for someone else to blame. Tony Atwood didn't notice it in his son so it's quite common.