Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think personalised pricing is unethical?

215 replies

Issummeroveralready · 01/09/2022 22:55

I already thought that using a club card to get reduced prices on food items was a little close to the mark, but tonight on TV I saw advertised that a certain supermarket is now offering personalised prices on food items when a loyalty card is used (nectar card). AIBU to think this is neoliberalism gone mad. Surely food costs what it costs. Fancy Mary getting lurpack for 5 quid and John getting it for 2 because of some known algorithm. Bonkers.

OP posts:
Kite22 · 02/09/2022 10:54

But last week I noticed Superdrug have brought in the same system. Because - for me anyway - the nice hair products I was looking at were a luxury rather than essential like food shopping this had the result of me buying nothing as I couldn't bring myself to pay the higher price for what I wanted. I know it's irrational as had the cheaper pink price not been listed below I probably wouldn't have minded the real price. Lost a sale there Superdrug.

This is it for me, too.
I am aware, in my subconscious, that the other people in my train carriage might have a better deal on their ticket price than me, but they don't have a big label on to say so, so it isn't "in your face". It is because it is so blatant and, at the moment I might be going to buy something, that it is offputting. At any shop purchase, you might think you might be able to get it online cheaper or buy it in bulk cheaper, but you accept you are paying for the convenience of it being there in front of you and you can use/eat it straight away. But seeing it in front of you next to another bag being sold at a difference price "feels" wrong, even if people who only use non emotional reasoning can't see it.

GlassofWaterAgai · 02/09/2022 10:51

I cancelled all my loyalty cards because when I signed up, it was mandatory to provide a home address etc. I didn't like the idea of a retailer having so much detailed info on me including address/date of birth plus a comprehensive understanding of my shopping habits. However, I've just signed up for the Asda loyalty scheme as it's totally digital and only requires an email address. The rewards are obviously designed to make me shop more but they are surprisingly quite good.

My view is that if I don't have to hand over big chunks of personal data and it gives me worthwhile discounts, then I'm happy to do it.

lightisnotwhite · 02/09/2022 10:50

Agreed. I have sat on the sofa with my DH comparing Easyjet pricing and his would show up as less because he hadn’t done the endless searching I had

fUNNYfACE36 · 02/09/2022 10:49

oviraptor21 · 01/09/2022 22:56

The vouchers I get sent seem personalised to my shopping habits. I guess this is an extension of the same concept.

Wait..what? I don't get any personalised vouchers!

DoraSpenlow · 02/09/2022 10:43

Veeragall · 02/09/2022 06:49

As always ageism creeps in. Older shoppers are perfectly capable of using a Clubcard.

I don't care if Tesco's know what I buy. It's no big deal. There are other options, eg Aldi, if you prefer that everyone pays the same price.

And the claim that you pay more for flights if you don't clear cookies is nonsense. It's simply not true, although many believe it is.

And the claim that you pay more for flights if you don't clear cookies is nonsense. It's simply not true, although many believe it is.

It is true that deleting cookies helps with airline ticket pricing, or at least it still was a couple of years ago.

I used to book travel when I was working. We had subsidiaries in Paris and Frankfurt and my boss used to go there regularly. I would check prices with all the airlines to see who was cheapest at that time. Very often I would go back to say BA, for example, as they were cheapest on the day and the price would have gone up since I checked half an hour before. If I went in and deleted cookies and then went back on the BA site the price would have returned to the first one I saw. This happened many, many times.

Veeragall · 02/09/2022 10:05

Loyalty schemes are optional. I don't know of any that aren't.

It's marketing. It's no different really to some stores giving discounts to NHS workers or students. Stores are free to target specific demographics or individuals as they wish, and we are free to decide where to shop.

Cheeseonbeans · 02/09/2022 09:55

rosyvalentine · 02/09/2022 09:45

I have completely stopped shopping in Tesco since they introduced this new scheme of discounting solely for Clubcard members. They are undoubtedly selling the data on to third parties. I'd be interested to know how many customers they have lost over recent months. Loyalty schemes should be optional. I don't want my personal data known to all and sundry. But why would I shop in a supermarket that's not offering me any discounts when there are plenty of others that will?

Clubcard is still optional

Also Tesco have reported higher shopper numbers over the past couple of months

rosyvalentine · 02/09/2022 09:45

I have completely stopped shopping in Tesco since they introduced this new scheme of discounting solely for Clubcard members. They are undoubtedly selling the data on to third parties. I'd be interested to know how many customers they have lost over recent months. Loyalty schemes should be optional. I don't want my personal data known to all and sundry. But why would I shop in a supermarket that's not offering me any discounts when there are plenty of others that will?

Digimoor · 02/09/2022 09:38

lemmein · 01/09/2022 23:48

The problem I have with clubcards is kids can't use them so they have to pay full price for sweets/crisps if they're not with an adult.

I don't have a problem with the cards themselves if they are accessible to everyone, but I think kids should be exempt and get the cheaper price without a card. Not a huge issue in the grand scheme of things, but unfair - if they had an upper age limit and pensioners had to pay the higher prices they'd be hell on.

Kids can use them - mine has a key fob version of the card

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 02/09/2022 09:28

Crunchymum · 02/09/2022 08:30

Sainsburys is our regular supermarket and I've not heard of this

Does it work like Tesco club clubcard prices? Or are you just talking about their vouchers they print off that offer money off xyz (two things you do use and one you don't)

I have nectar card and use the smart shop scanner while going round to skip the checkout bit. Every week you get about 10 items that you regularly buy which are discounted as long as you use the smart shop thing.

In addition if your shop would have been cheaper elsewhere they credit you with a voucher that you can use against your next shop.

To think personalised pricing is unethical?
To think personalised pricing is unethical?
Fizbosshoes · 02/09/2022 09:08

I was in my local petrol station tesco a year or so ago and a young boy was buying something. The cashier went round the store asking if anyone had a club card so the boy could buy the item/s at the reduced rate.

DogInATent · 02/09/2022 08:59

Personalised pricing/offers would be great. I'm fed up getting vouchers/deals on products I won't buy. Being gluten-free it's not very useful being offered a deal on croissants or crusty bread.

Btw, the history of the Tesco club card is interesting.

Dreamingcats · 02/09/2022 08:55

Dreamingcats · 02/09/2022 08:30

I read an article where a man had found out that his teenage daughter was pregnant because Tesco started sending her coupons for baby products and complained to Tesco that it was inappropriate. Apparently they have a list of non-pregnancy related items that early-pregnant people tend to buy more of which tips them off.

Apologies, it was Target it's a long but interesting article.
www.nytimes.com/2012/02/19/magazine/shopping-habits.html

SoupDragon · 02/09/2022 08:49

paying the higher price

it is the standard price. If there was no clubcard at all, that is the price everyone would be paying.

ChocoDoodle · 02/09/2022 08:39

Is it just Tescos you are mad at?

There was an uproar on this site when Waitrose stopped their free coffee. But they still do vouchers don't they? It's just the same, apart from it's tasteful innit?

Wafflehouse · 02/09/2022 08:34

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/09/2022 07:14

Ds 16 has been using my clubcard at the self service since they brought in clubcard prices. I use the app, he carries my card. Never been questioned.

See this is the only issue I have with it really and would’ve thought this is legally a bit tricky (hands up, I have no legal knowledge at all). Surely you can’t discriminate against a specific group of customers in this way, you have to be 18 to have a Clubcard and so anyone under 18 is automatically paying the higher price. Fair enough under 18s probably make up a small proportion of their customers but that is still discrimination.

And if I were to be really picky, using someone else’s card to gain the discounts is fraud. Not saying this to have a go at you pp but more that Tesco can’t just say use your parents card to get the discount. So not sure how Tesco can explain that they don’t discriminate against the school kid buying a meal deal or the child who’s buying a toy with their pocket money under the Clubcard prices offer.

SoupDragon · 02/09/2022 08:33

Crunchymum · 02/09/2022 08:30

Sainsburys is our regular supermarket and I've not heard of this

Does it work like Tesco club clubcard prices? Or are you just talking about their vouchers they print off that offer money off xyz (two things you do use and one you don't)

It's the Nectar card.

if you use Smart Scan you get special "nectar prices" based on things you buy. They change every week.

there are also targeted "coupons" you can add to your Nectar card giving you extra points.

Crunchymum · 02/09/2022 08:30

Sainsburys is our regular supermarket and I've not heard of this

Does it work like Tesco club clubcard prices? Or are you just talking about their vouchers they print off that offer money off xyz (two things you do use and one you don't)

Dreamingcats · 02/09/2022 08:30

BrieAndChilli · 02/09/2022 02:23

I’m trying to think what nefarious things Tesco can do with the knowledge that I buy 8 pints of milk a week and have a weakness for fruit and but chocolate?
im fully aware that this week they can deduce that I have extra people staying at my house.
i don’t mind them having that knowledge, it it means I get targeted ads then I also don’t care. I never buy anything coz I saw it in an ad anyway! Always research and compare etc
mumsnet probably knows a lot more about us than tesco!

there are different prices fro things all the time - flights, insurance, mortgage deals, genius prices on booking.com, cheaper food in cafes in attractions if you are a member, free parking if you ar a national trust member etc etc.

I read an article where a man had found out that his teenage daughter was pregnant because Tesco started sending her coupons for baby products and complained to Tesco that it was inappropriate. Apparently they have a list of non-pregnancy related items that early-pregnant people tend to buy more of which tips them off.

SoupDragon · 02/09/2022 08:29

carefullycourageous · 02/09/2022 08:24

This type of response comparing MN vs store cards just demonstrates a lack of understanding about what is being gathered and what can be sold and for what purpose.

You are happily giving away information to journalists and researchers every time you post.

apintortwo · 02/09/2022 08:29

I have to say I found it more annoying to go to a tesco the other day where I couldn't even enter the shop (and thus compare the price of anything) because you needed an app on your phone to activate a barrier to get in the shop!
I only wanted a drink so I went next door to boots

I've seen one of these and it's always empty

carefullycourageous · 02/09/2022 08:24

Lockheart · 02/09/2022 08:21

And yet many on this thread are happily posting on MN, for free.

Like you said - if you're not paying for a the product, you are the product.

Might want to delete your MN account!

This type of response comparing MN vs store cards just demonstrates a lack of understanding about what is being gathered and what can be sold and for what purpose.

luxxlisbon · 02/09/2022 08:24

I don’t see how it’s any different if you get a coupon for butter in the Mail but not in the Sun though?

carefullycourageous · 02/09/2022 08:22

Presumably the "I'm not selling my data that cheaply!" people only use cash. It is about creating a sellable data set. The data they gather through the store cards is cheap and collected in a format very easy and cheap to analyse and sell.

Lockheart · 02/09/2022 08:21

TeaAndBiscuitsAndWine · 01/09/2022 23:19

I’ve worked in privacy for decades. My first boss had a saying, “If you’re not paying for a product, then you are the product”. The money off vouchers, offers etc that are provided with loyalty cards are paid for with your personal data, which is at the very least used to try to affect your spending. Depending on the company, it may also be flogged to third parties to try to monetise you. As PPs have said, very dystopian, very Black Mirror.

And yet many on this thread are happily posting on MN, for free.

Like you said - if you're not paying for a the product, you are the product.

Might want to delete your MN account!

Swipe left for the next trending thread