Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think personalised pricing is unethical?

215 replies

Issummeroveralready · 01/09/2022 22:55

I already thought that using a club card to get reduced prices on food items was a little close to the mark, but tonight on TV I saw advertised that a certain supermarket is now offering personalised prices on food items when a loyalty card is used (nectar card). AIBU to think this is neoliberalism gone mad. Surely food costs what it costs. Fancy Mary getting lurpack for 5 quid and John getting it for 2 because of some known algorithm. Bonkers.

OP posts:
Tuilpmouse · 02/09/2022 18:45

@Issummeroveralready

Yes. This is what I was talking about really. Data specific personalisation... The clubcard is a blanket discount. However I have no idea what algorithms sainsburys are using. They should make it clear?

The algorithms will be changing all the time depending on the products they are pushing, and they'd be broadcasting their retail strategy to competitors.

Most people really don't care if a supermarket knows they purchased hobnobs/orange juice/basil or whatever, and have no problem offering that information in exchange for better deals.... Why should your frankly irrational distain for this stop this... If you don't like it, don't get a loyalty card.

Also, Supermarkets owe you nothing... If they want to trade information for lower prices from wiling customers, why shouldn't they.

Elleherd · 02/09/2022 17:53

Issummeroveralready · 02/09/2022 11:23

The "higher value" a customer you are the better the deals they send you also. So it's another poor tax really.

Yes it feels very divisive and tip of the iceberg. What next? Cheaper pints at the pub if you look pretty and they want you there more often to "sell" the establishment for them? Outlandish but not too many steps away!

Didn't that ship sailed ages back?
Free entry and/or happy hour prices for young women. Who where of course the bait to get the lads in and spending earlier.

Issummeroveralready · 02/09/2022 17:05

But that isn't what your OP was about. You were objecting to people getting what is the equivalent of an electronic discount coupon

Yes it was. I should know. I wrote it after watching the saisburys ad. It was about their new personalised prices. Hint is in the thread title.

OP posts:
SoupDragon · 02/09/2022 16:55

Issummeroveralready · 02/09/2022 16:22

The Sainsbury card seems a bit different to me , ‘personalisation’ is much more data specific than a straight open to everyone who can manage to sign up or remember to bring their card with them. I don’t expect to find out more because I don’t like Sainsbury’s social policies and I haven’t got a smart phone.

Yes. This is what I was talking about really. Data specific personalisation... The clubcard is a blanket discount. However I have no idea what algorithms sainsburys are using. They should make it clear?

But that isn't what your OP was about. You were objecting to people getting what is the equivalent of an electronic discount coupon.

Getting discounts on what you buy the most has been done for years. They aren't using an "algorithm" as such, they just look at what you're buying. My Nectar prices are all things I usually buy. The "extra points" offers are also usually things I buy with the very rare oddity. The algorithm appears to be "she bought this, give her some money off it"

woodhill · 02/09/2022 16:31

I like the "freebies" that clubcard gives you. It's always been useful

woodhill · 02/09/2022 16:27

It was like that in the USA . I remember shopping in Win Dixie and Walgreens and using loyalty cards

Issummeroveralready · 02/09/2022 16:22

The Sainsbury card seems a bit different to me , ‘personalisation’ is much more data specific than a straight open to everyone who can manage to sign up or remember to bring their card with them. I don’t expect to find out more because I don’t like Sainsbury’s social policies and I haven’t got a smart phone.

Yes. This is what I was talking about really. Data specific personalisation... The clubcard is a blanket discount. However I have no idea what algorithms sainsburys are using. They should make it clear?

OP posts:
GloucesterBBQ · 02/09/2022 16:21

Yeah they kinda do tell you what they do with your data.
www.tesco.com/help/privacy-and-cookies/privacy-centre/tesco-and-your-data/your-data-journey/

It's the law (GDPR) you are in complete control of your data. If you don't want a company to have it you can ask to have it erased.

GloucesterBBQ · 02/09/2022 16:14

I'm not sure if you are annoyed that someone (or you) might end up paying a different price than someone else without you knowing. Take for example gas and electric, it's all the same stuff regardless of your supplier. We all pay a different price depending on what tariff we are on and what supplier. In turn, this is linked to if we bothered to switch or fix etc. There is plenty of opportunities to acquire different/cheaper prices dependent on how hard you look. In fact, in most cases, the cheaper prices are only available because others are overpaying.

lightisnotwhite · 02/09/2022 15:45

jay55 · 02/09/2022 14:11

When I was at uni in the late 90s I had several lecturers who wouldn't use loyalty cards that had recently come in. They were all database and encryption specialists and would lecture us on the direction gathering of personal data was going.
They were all totally on the nose.

Ok so they might know that security is one the sketchy side but what can anyone really do with the information? Names and addresses are easy to search up. Aside from credit cards how useful is the weekly shop to anyone?
More likely its their political leanings rather than any knowledge of wrong doing.

Georgeskitchen · 02/09/2022 15:13

yawn 🥱 😫 just get yourself a f*ing loyalty card.
Why wouldn't you, to get lower prices.
Yes they have your data but its not like there gonna send a hit man round to off you, is it?

Aria999 · 02/09/2022 15:01

It's a bit like giving student discounts.

You want to sell extra stuff to people who can't afford full price, without giving the lower price to people who can afford the regular price.

ouch321 · 02/09/2022 14:44

I sell my data all the time to various companies.

I'm not buying or doing anything shameful so why would I be fearful of it?

I don't care in the slightest if i see adverts that are tailored to my buying history. Could introduce me to a yummy new product or whatever.

Don't shop at Tesco if it bothers you that much or go and pay the higher price. There is no attempt to force you into signing up for a Clubcard.

Wishyfishy · 02/09/2022 14:38

I get better prices on certain products that I buy a lot using the self scanner and my and Nectar card, is that the personalised prices you’d not agree with?
I honestly think it’s win-win.. I get money off, they get the data they want. We all know that loyalty cards work to their benefit too.. this way, I get actually benefits (I save usually £4 or so per shop.. better than any other loyalty scheme).

Bubblebubblebah · 02/09/2022 14:33

I happily sell company my shopping data if it is used for deciding on what to stock in shops I regularly visit as well🤷🏻
Fucking asda should do that. Everything for sushi bar wasabi. WHO DOESN'T STOCK WASABI WITH SUSHI STUFF. Asda, that's who.

Bubblebubblebah · 02/09/2022 14:27

Personalised pricing/offers would be great. I'm fed up getting vouchers/deals on products I won't buy. Being gluten-free it's not very useful being offered a deal on croissants or crusty bread.

I would love that. I don't need 30% off hobnobs, but I would love 30 or even 15% off tomatoes!

Porcupineintherough · 02/09/2022 14:25

jay55 · 02/09/2022 14:11

When I was at uni in the late 90s I had several lecturers who wouldn't use loyalty cards that had recently come in. They were all database and encryption specialists and would lecture us on the direction gathering of personal data was going.
They were all totally on the nose.

Why were they? I volunteer care less if Tesco want to track what I buy, it's not a secret. Very happy to exchange that info for cashback.

SoupDragon · 02/09/2022 14:24

What about "staff discounts" they are discriminatory to those who can't get a job there.

SoupDragon · 02/09/2022 14:23

Wafflehouse · 02/09/2022 13:42

Bollocks, some kids save their money for big toys and have birthday money to spend. I don’t buy all they toys my kids have, they’re expected to buy their own if they want a box of Lego outside of Christmas and birthdays. My son is old enough to get himself to Tesco and buy his own Lego if he wants, why should he miss out on the discounted price because he isn’t old enough to use the scheme?

For the same reason he can't get the "blue light" discount. Or shop in Costco. Or the many other ways discounts are offered to only some people.

Veeragall · 02/09/2022 14:20

I don't get the paranoia about personal data. Most people's name, address, date of birth can be found easily on the internet. It's hardly secret info. I don't care if Tesco know what I buy in their shops if they want to give me discount on those products in future. My bank and credit card provider know where I shop regularly and can block my card instantly if they see an unusual transaction which might be fraudulent. That works for me.

A friend recently told me she wasn't providing her bank account details to the council in case they stole her money. She was being asked for sort code and account number so they could pay her the council tax rebate. I pointed out they're on her cheque book. She wasn't convinced....

jay55 · 02/09/2022 14:11

When I was at uni in the late 90s I had several lecturers who wouldn't use loyalty cards that had recently come in. They were all database and encryption specialists and would lecture us on the direction gathering of personal data was going.
They were all totally on the nose.

liveforsummer · 02/09/2022 14:00

Are club card vouchers tailored? I assumed they were just general as my last ones were for nappies and baby food my dc are 9 and 12 😆

Porcupineintherough · 02/09/2022 13:52

If you don't want to sell your data then you are free not to have a club card. Why you think you should be paid for your data without providing it is beyond me.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 02/09/2022 13:45

French supermarkets have had the ‘members’ schemes for at least fifteen years. They used to offer money back for a certain number of points ( so many, not very attractive) ’ or redeeming points against a catalogue of stuff ( also not very exciting).
A lot of shoppers didn’t seem to have/ use the cards; then Carrefour and LeClerc introduced thé special offer with the card type scheme. Suddenly, everyone in the queue seemed to have one! We were always surprised that no British store did it.
Now Tesco do. The card is free. You don’t actually have to tell the truth about your age or sex, though your address will be useful if you want a delivery. I have checked the non club card prices against Waitrose and Aldi ( though difficult because a lot of Aldi products are not really straight comparison). Nope, not more expensive as far as we could see. The Club card prices are usually because Tesco have negotiated a deal with a manufacturer, or because they are on seasonal fresh produce which they can buy more cheaply because it is in Season.
The Sainsbury card seems a bit different to me , ‘personalisation’ is much more data specific than a straight open to everyone who can manage to sign up or remember to bring their card with them. I don’t expect to find out more because I don’t like Sainsbury’s social policies and I haven’t got a smart phone.

Wafflehouse · 02/09/2022 13:42

Bollocks, some kids save their money for big toys and have birthday money to spend. I don’t buy all they toys my kids have, they’re expected to buy their own if they want a box of Lego outside of Christmas and birthdays. My son is old enough to get himself to Tesco and buy his own Lego if he wants, why should he miss out on the discounted price because he isn’t old enough to use the scheme?

Swipe left for the next trending thread