Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think personalised pricing is unethical?

215 replies

Issummeroveralready · 01/09/2022 22:55

I already thought that using a club card to get reduced prices on food items was a little close to the mark, but tonight on TV I saw advertised that a certain supermarket is now offering personalised prices on food items when a loyalty card is used (nectar card). AIBU to think this is neoliberalism gone mad. Surely food costs what it costs. Fancy Mary getting lurpack for 5 quid and John getting it for 2 because of some known algorithm. Bonkers.

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 03/09/2022 08:12

Tesco was akways more expensive than asda though..the discount is basically price match, like they would do in most shops with aldi.

Magnanimouse · 03/09/2022 08:09

Tesco aren't bumping up the price for those not using a Clubcard, but they discount some prices for those that do.

Quick look at Tesco's current branded clubcard offers.

Pringles, £2 reduced to £1.65 with a clubcard. £1.65 Asda.
Diet Coke £9, reduced to £7 clubcard. £7.50 Sainsburys.
Gordon's Gin 1litre, £21 reduced to £17. £17 Sainsburys.
Fridge Raiders Slow Roasted Chicken Bites 6. £2.80 reduced to £2.25. £2.00 Sainsburys.

and so on.

This is not a discount for clubcard users, who are paying the same prices they would in another store up the road. This is an excess charge for non clubcard users.

lightisnotwhite · 03/09/2022 07:56

@liveforsummer that was a reply to someone else about using data for nefarious purposes.
Of course the data is useful for sales and marketing.

To the person that said the pre Clubcard price was artificially high, I disagree. On the things I buy it was always the same as other local stores. However it’s impossible to tell now. Things seem to go up by 10p every week or so

liveforsummer · 03/09/2022 07:38

Ok so they might know that security is one the sketchy side but what can anyone really do with the information? Names and addresses are easy to search up. Aside from credit cards how useful is the weekly shop to anyone?

Well it's useful to someone as I have an app that pays me for uploading my receipts every time I shop. It's useful for market research I assume

liveforsummer · 03/09/2022 07:35

Magnanimouse · 02/09/2022 19:48

Tesco seem to be over-pricing some items for those customers who don't have a clubcard, and the reduction is back to the normal prices you could buy it elsewhere.

I don't mind Tesco offering me discounts for letting them access my data; I object to them trying to push me into getting a clubcard by over-pricing things. It makes me less likely to pop in for odds and ends (not a regular Tesco customer, so a standard voucher model of clubcard isn't really worth it).

Surely it's worth it just to access the cheaper prices. Although the points will add up over time and you found still save a few extra quid. It's not like you need to carry any extra - just the app in your phone

Wishyfishy · 03/09/2022 02:01

lightisnotwhite · 02/09/2022 15:45

Ok so they might know that security is one the sketchy side but what can anyone really do with the information? Names and addresses are easy to search up. Aside from credit cards how useful is the weekly shop to anyone?
More likely its their political leanings rather than any knowledge of wrong doing.

Well yes this. I assume it’s “if someone frequently buys x, they are also likely to buy y” or “will switch between brands and happily buy the cheapest available on x, but is loyal to one brand for y”.. or even “will buy x every time regardless of whether the price moves up or down until the price hits £3”.. and then all that data is gathered together and they know what items to place near other ones and what prices they can ask for…?

This isn’t data I’m worried about people having plus I didn’t think it’s about me - they want to add my data to everyone else’s… I can see it’s fairly valuable data so I just want paying for it. I’m now better at utilising these offers and this is one of a few reasons why I’m not spending more on my shopping than a year ago, so I’m satisfied with that.

I can see the point about checkout staff and see that some people want to not use self scanners out of principle. I don’t happen to feel like that and I don’t think my job is to retain staff in jobs that maybe aren’t needed in the future - much in the same way that I use internet banking rather than visit my local bank branch which as a result of people like me, has now shut…

Aria999 · 03/09/2022 01:58

Flatmountains · 02/09/2022 23:10

Thing about the target example, isn't personal information a lot less protected in the States than here?

Yes it is.

You get a mortgage, you spend the next 6 months answering spam calls from people who want to sell you a mortgage.

Unless you live in California where you get specific exemptions but it's still not as good.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 02/09/2022 23:31

Georgeskitchen · 02/09/2022 15:13

yawn 🥱 😫 just get yourself a f*ing loyalty card.
Why wouldn't you, to get lower prices.
Yes they have your data but its not like there gonna send a hit man round to off you, is it?

Yeah! That one there, she buys total yogurt every week, off with her head

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 02/09/2022 23:29

whenwillthemadnessend · 01/09/2022 22:59

Agree. I hate the Tesco's scheme. It's should be a blanket price. End off.

Why? Why shouldn't loyalty be rewarded?

Bubblebubblebah · 02/09/2022 23:27

I am an immigrant. I believe my data are safet eith Tesco than with Home Office 😂
freemovement.org.uk/personal-data-breaches-by-the-home-office-soar-to-over-4000-last-year/

Flatmountains · 02/09/2022 23:10

Thing about the target example, isn't personal information a lot less protected in the States than here?

apintortwo · 02/09/2022 22:18

Once they have signed up enough people to reduce/eradicate the manned tills then the offers will most probably dwindle away

This

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 02/09/2022 21:38

Veeragall · 02/09/2022 20:06

@HyacinthKylie I've just received nearly £60 of Boots points for buying an electrical product through Boots when there was an offer on. That's £60 to spend on toiletries which will keep me going for a long time. Well worth it!

Just because not many people seem to know this, did you know that boots sell appliances like washing machines, all fulfilled through AO but you get advantage points on your purchase which add up real quick when you're spend several hundred pounds on a new fridge (or whatever).

www.bootskitchenappliances.com/

SheeWeee · 02/09/2022 20:53

Issummeroveralready · 02/09/2022 19:27

Is it "fair"... No, but then I thought most people grew out of naive childish concept that everything in life could or should be fair in the sense of everything being the same for everyone during childhood. Clearly I was wrong..

Things can be fair and equitable. Just look at Finland. We've just chosen a different (worse path) of the financialisation of everyday life. It's a shame.

Hate to tell you petal, but Finland has supermarket loyalty cards too.

mondaytosunday · 02/09/2022 20:18

Oh for goodness sakes do none of you read the Ts and Cs of Tesco and similar companies? It's all written out how they use your data! They aren't hiding anything!
It's naive in the extreme not to think just about any social media or internet based or credit card use does not involve data collection. Even Mumsnet targets ads to you depending on the data you provide (ads you click on, subject searches you make). They use Google Analytics. They even keep a record of your PMs.
It's up to you to review these conditions and agree, or not.
Tesco aren't bumping up the price for those not using a Clubcard, but they discount some prices for those that do. I use it primarily for air miles, and I'm happy with them knowing I prefer Diet Coke over Pepsi.

00100001 · 02/09/2022 20:15

Tesco don't "owe" anybody anything.

If they want to offer these discounts via clubcard... They can.

Why do they have to care about the 12yo that can't get that discount on a pack of biscuits?

It's not as if the discounts are on essential items that haven't got cheaper alternatives anyway. Like... But a pack of value Chocolate Digestives for 45p, instead of the discounted branded ones at £1 instead of £1.50.

It really isn't a compulsory purchase....

00100001 · 02/09/2022 20:12

carefullycourageous · 02/09/2022 08:17

I am willing to share the data I put here yes, but I am not willing to sell my whole life data for that low price.

No one can be 'no data' unless off grid and outside society, but there is a sliding scale and I made my decision which is personal to me.

The value of big data is enormous, for a good reason.

But you're not selling your whole life data by using a clubcard... You're selling some anonymous demographic data....that's it.

You're selling similar data to Mumsnet tbh. They will know where in the country you are roughly, what device you're using, your email address, how long you stay on the site, where you were before the site, probably the browser you're using etc not wildly different to the data collected on clubcards.

(and if you've filled it in MN have the following personal information, your sex, age, postcode and if you have kids or are expecting.)

edwinbear · 02/09/2022 20:11

It really doesn’t bother me in the slightest if Sainsburys know I buy a lot of dried mango if it means I get 75p off every time I do.

Veeragall · 02/09/2022 20:06

@HyacinthKylie I've just received nearly £60 of Boots points for buying an electrical product through Boots when there was an offer on. That's £60 to spend on toiletries which will keep me going for a long time. Well worth it!

HyacinthKylie · 02/09/2022 19:49

I studied marketing as part of my business degree, and I actually chose Boots Advantage card as one of my projects (This was what 14 years ago?). Anyway, I wasn't so much concerned about the data (although back then that was more of a concern for me than now), but I was concerned at the level of manipulation involved, as I saw it (I have since been diagnosed with autism - which may be relevant). I just wanted to pay a fair price, for an item I want/need. I believe those offers that some stores do, that layer with each other - You know, a 3 for 2, alongside a 10% off, alongside a free gift if you spend x amount, alongside points offers. They are purposefully confusing and mean you overspend (and overbuy). And if you are anything like my mum you end up with a bathroom heaving with products and no money in the bank!!!

I've avoided cards ever since, and I think I am better off for it. I dread the day when the information is so valuable they are everywhere!

Magnanimouse · 02/09/2022 19:48

Tesco seem to be over-pricing some items for those customers who don't have a clubcard, and the reduction is back to the normal prices you could buy it elsewhere.

I don't mind Tesco offering me discounts for letting them access my data; I object to them trying to push me into getting a clubcard by over-pricing things. It makes me less likely to pop in for odds and ends (not a regular Tesco customer, so a standard voucher model of clubcard isn't really worth it).

Bubblebubblebah · 02/09/2022 19:43

Issummeroveralready · 02/09/2022 19:27

Is it "fair"... No, but then I thought most people grew out of naive childish concept that everything in life could or should be fair in the sense of everything being the same for everyone during childhood. Clearly I was wrong..

Things can be fair and equitable. Just look at Finland. We've just chosen a different (worse path) of the financialisation of everyday life. It's a shame.

'sup

www.expat-finland.com/shopping_in_finland/loyalty_cards.html

Issummeroveralready · 02/09/2022 19:27

Is it "fair"... No, but then I thought most people grew out of naive childish concept that everything in life could or should be fair in the sense of everything being the same for everyone during childhood. Clearly I was wrong..

Things can be fair and equitable. Just look at Finland. We've just chosen a different (worse path) of the financialisation of everyday life. It's a shame.

OP posts:
Tuilpmouse · 02/09/2022 19:20

Wafflehouse · 02/09/2022 13:42

Bollocks, some kids save their money for big toys and have birthday money to spend. I don’t buy all they toys my kids have, they’re expected to buy their own if they want a box of Lego outside of Christmas and birthdays. My son is old enough to get himself to Tesco and buy his own Lego if he wants, why should he miss out on the discounted price because he isn’t old enough to use the scheme?

Why? Because he's not deemed old enough to consent to his personal data being used by a big corporation...

Is it "fair"... No, but then I thought most people grew out of naive childish concept that everything in life could or should be fair in the sense of everything being the same for everyone during childhood. Clearly I was wrong...

I suppose you think it's also unfair they won't hire your young children so they can earn the money to buy things from the supermarket...

Tuilpmouse · 02/09/2022 18:48

@Issummeroveralready

What you really seem to be wanting is communism. Highly regulated prices with nothing such as bulk discounts that might favour people who aren't so poor they can't buy in bulk.

Swipe left for the next trending thread