Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think zero hours contracts shouldn't be banned?

35 replies

sweetbill · 01/09/2022 22:16

It seems to me that zero hours contracts suit lots of people who want to work a few hours intermittently and flexibly. For example, students who are juggling academic timetables with sport and social life, who might not realistically be able to commit to regular hours, or people who want to work a few hours in addition to another job, but only when they're not too busy with other things.

So I don't understand why Labour want to ban them. Apparently Kier Starmer said at the labour conference that to raise a family people need jobs with “security and certainty”, and that Labour would ban zero hours contracts and replace them with regular contracts which actually reflect the hours normally work.. But there are plenty of jobs with non-zero hour contracts, so people do have a choice - what about the many people who aren't raising a family and are just working for extra pocket money or to top up their student loan? Why should they be penalised? Could there perhaps be a compromise where they are only banned for people working more than a certain number of hours a week?
Disclaimer: I"m a floating voter, so not coming at this from a political standpoint, but something like this would potentially influence my vote as members of my family have benefitted from the flexibility of zero hours contracts.

OP posts:
Twizbe · 01/09/2022 22:49

@Speedweed but what if you want to be able to drop that income to nothing.

For my DH his holiday job was lots of fun and paid really well. Uni was over 3 hours away so he couldn't do that job during term time. The business was a tourist attraction so needed more staff in school holidays. Students on zero hours were great for that. They didn't need to train a whole ton of new people every holiday and the students had the confidence that a job was there for them in the holidays.

KaitK · 01/09/2022 22:46

I worked as a bank nurse for a few years when I didn't really know what I wanted to do career-wise, (effectively a zero-hour contract, employed directly by the hospital Trust but no "base" and no contracted hours - I could pick and choose when and where I worked, obviously providing they had uncovered shifts). I had a few places where I regularly worked and they would sometimes text me and ask me to work shifts for them (ended up getting a permanent job in one of them). The added benefit of this was I could try different specialities and I did end up working somewhere that I would never have even considered applying for if I hadn't done shifts there already (a speciality that no-one really knows anything about and hasn't got a clue about what we do).

Like someone else said, I think it depends on what you are doing and my experience was probably very different to someone in retail or hospitality.

Llangfairpwllgwingychgogerychwyndroblllantisilio · 01/09/2022 22:46

I know so many people who have had to take these jobs because the job centre has pushed for them to. And then they're stuck being unable to afford to make rent, pay utility bills, never mind food and transport to get to the job when it wants them. Finding a better job is something they all continuously attempt, but not everyone can do, or have the qualifications for, more secure jobs.

Great for those of you needing a top up but I can't imagine anyone without more means than the people I know, being able to make zero hours work.

SquigglePigs · 01/09/2022 22:45

The problem with them is that when they work like they were designed to, they benefit both company and employees but they are heavily abused by employers who want people available at all hours at the drop of a hat but won't guarantee work if they need it.

If they aren't banned (and I don't think they should be on balance) they do need some regulation reform on them.

Speedweed · 01/09/2022 22:44

Because they are used far more widely than you describe, for jobs for which they aren't really appropriate, when those employees have no bargaining power either at the outset to say they want a fixed minimum number of hours or, when the job starts, to agree the hours when they'll be working. My understanding is that employers use them as well to evade various obligations to employees.

It's also not as simple as 'get another job', as if it's advantageous for an employer to use them for a particular type of role, then it's likely that all similar roles in the area offered by different employers will use a zero hours contract to remain competitive- it becomes a race to the bottom.

They combine the worst of all worlds, and banning them wouldn't affect anyone negatively because there are other contractual ways of achieving flexibility over hours worked.

How can you plan anything, when at any point your income could fall to zero, when that is not your choice and you had no say in that? That's why they need banning.

Twizbe · 01/09/2022 22:41

I agree with you. My DH had one for his holiday job while at uni. Meant he didn't have to faff around with leaving / being hired back when he went back to uni.

I had a perm contract with a retail business at the time. I had to transfer back and forth throughout the year. I was also on a 4 hour contract and expected to do tons of overtime. I might have got paid holidays, but only for 4 hours a week.

They can be great for lots of people but they do need some rules to ensure people aren't exploited via them.

Cuddlywuddlies · 01/09/2022 22:34

I’m in Ireland and they are banned here as such, there are several rules in place around them. There are only allowed in certain situations. see link.
www.citizensinformation.ie/en/employment/employment_rights_and_conditions/contracts_of_employment/contracts_without_specific_working_hours_zero_hours_contracts.html#lcc62d

MumW · 01/09/2022 22:34

It all depends on the contract.
A zero hours contract where you have no control over your hours but are expected to be available at all times (eg: retail) is different to a casual contract where you can say no to hours offered or can say you'll only work certain days/times (eg: bano staff/supply teacher).
The latter allows you flexibility and the option of juggling two jobs whilst the former is more like being employed full-time but without the guarantee of any actual work.

FrippEnos · 01/09/2022 22:28

I agree in principle with zero hour contracts.
But they need to have more rules and regulations put in place to ensure that employers don't take the piss.

And those that want the zero hour contracts need to realise that their need for flexibility make see them overlooked for available hours.

JaceLancs · 01/09/2022 22:23

I worked in this way when DC were younger as a lone parent I could be flexible and work extra hours during term time and 0 hours or very few during holidays
Now as a charity CEO I offer it as an option to people who don’t want regular hours if they are a student, carer, run another business, have multiple jobs, child care issues etc - we would all be disadvantaged if this is brought in

Swipe left for the next trending thread