Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think zero hours contracts shouldn't be banned?

35 replies

sweetbill · 01/09/2022 22:16

It seems to me that zero hours contracts suit lots of people who want to work a few hours intermittently and flexibly. For example, students who are juggling academic timetables with sport and social life, who might not realistically be able to commit to regular hours, or people who want to work a few hours in addition to another job, but only when they're not too busy with other things.

So I don't understand why Labour want to ban them. Apparently Kier Starmer said at the labour conference that to raise a family people need jobs with “security and certainty”, and that Labour would ban zero hours contracts and replace them with regular contracts which actually reflect the hours normally work.. But there are plenty of jobs with non-zero hour contracts, so people do have a choice - what about the many people who aren't raising a family and are just working for extra pocket money or to top up their student loan? Why should they be penalised? Could there perhaps be a compromise where they are only banned for people working more than a certain number of hours a week?
Disclaimer: I"m a floating voter, so not coming at this from a political standpoint, but something like this would potentially influence my vote as members of my family have benefitted from the flexibility of zero hours contracts.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kite22 · 02/09/2022 11:04

Exactly @fpurplea
It really, really isn't just people who are students who need, or like zero hour contracts (though of course it does suit so many of them).
One place my ds worked had

  • parents who wanted school hours / term time working and the hours they didn't like were really popular with 6th formers and students
  • two people who had medical conditions that were fine for a while then flared up and they didn't want to work at those time
  • carers who wanted to work but also needed times when they didn't work either for appointments or for when the person they were caring for needed them more
  • people that travelled - they'd work for a few months then go off somewhere, travelling for 6 weeks or 3 months
  • outdoor folk (It was an outdoor shop) where they would regularly want to go off into the mountains for 5 days or a week - more than regular AL would allow - but then be happy to work longer hours when they were at home (and of course bring first hand knowledge to the sales team, having used a lot of the equipment themselves)
  • someone who like to work the Winter and go off and teach sailing in the Summer
  • someone who used to work the Summer and go off and work in a ski resort in the Winter
  • someone who worked around their partner's odd shifts

There are millions of people who don't want to work 9 - 5 x 5 days a week x 46 or 47 weeks a year. Zero hours contracts works for all sorts of reasons when well done .

Yes there are those that abuse it. Equally there are those that abuse all sorts of employment laws, or the spirit of those laws.

fpurplea · 02/09/2022 00:39

People have such blinkered viewpoints about ZHCs, it's not all about Sports Direct et al. They don't need banning. They need tighter regulating, mostly by actually enforcing the existing employment laws around them. Exploitative ZHCs should absolutely be regulated out of existence. But for some industries / companies / individuals, ZHCs are literally the only workable solution.

16 years in the entertainment industry. HMRC forced one of the companies I work for to make us all PAYE on ZHC rather than freelance contractors when they changed the rules around 2007. We get by law holiday pay, sick pay, maternity pay, pension scheme enrollment, safetywear allowance, furlough etc. No exclusivity, free to say no to shifts. You work when and where the gigs are, so hours are all over the place, but busy times are broadly seasonal, so you budget for the lean months by working like crazy during silly season and working for other companies. This company is the absolute model of ZHCs used in exactly the spirit they should be, at great cost to the business. Blanket ban them, then there is no viable, legal solution for them to employ staff, ironically leaving the field open to all the companies currently flouting the law and exploiting their staff by claiming they are are self employed.

HotPenguin · 02/09/2022 00:05

You can't get a rental contract or a mortgage with a zero hours contract. Might be ok for a student but not for the vast majority of people.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 01/09/2022 23:59

There are at least two types of zero hours contracts. One is mutually beneficial and the other's exploitative. We do need to ban the exploitative one but allow the other. Maybe making accepting a zero hours contract isn't compulsory if you're on benefits would be a start.

Florenz · 01/09/2022 23:44

The NMW for zero hours jobs should be higher than it is for jobs with F/T hours.

cawfeee · 01/09/2022 23:40

I have a zero hours contract at the moment, I just give my availability each week and work those hours, if I want more hours I will get them. The flexibility works for me.
Its like a previous poster said, it people needing a fixed amount of hours and salary working them that struggle with them.
They shouldn't be forced onto people people claiming benefits and maybe some legislation could be brought in to enable people to opt in or out of them.

lunchablefan200 · 01/09/2022 23:28

Because they don’t always offer flexibility. I have said no to extra shifts etc and then get punished by being given no hours for weeks.

N4mechanged · 01/09/2022 23:27

Name changed for this. I work in a company that uses these a lot. We work primarily with government clients. Government procurement is fucked without them. One of the main ways government has 'saved' money on their pwn spend in the last 15 years is by making people redundant then rehiring them through suppliers using 0 hr contracts. Keir Starmer can promise till the cows come home, I don't believe he will follow through for a second, the price to central government will be too high.

As a business we'd be quite happy to offer more stability and employ people but the terms of our contracts with govt often make this impossible (or would make us so uncompetitive that we might as well not bother tendering).

We try to offer as long term and stable hours as we can, and we never penalise people for not being available by the way.

Isaidnoalready · 01/09/2022 23:17

They are massively abused so imagine getting a job zero hours your assured you don't need to do weekends and of course school hours is perfect for the company they have loads of people who do just early and just lates you will fit in fine first rota comes in weekends and evenings you say I can't do that its too late the rota is done but I can't physically do those hours your childcare isn't our issue your hours are there you need to do them you think zero hours means you can say no so you do that and suddenly you don't get any more calls for work your effectively fired without actually being fired

Fucking useless

Hawkins001 · 01/09/2022 23:11

LarryTrotter · 01/09/2022 22:58

Tell me you're privileged without telling me you're privileged.

And your point is ?

carefullycourageous · 01/09/2022 23:08

thismorningisnottoday · 01/09/2022 23:07

They are extremely exploitative.

The 'flexibility' is usually only for the employers.

Ever worked on a zero-hours contract and declined a couple of shifts?? They often 'punish' you by giving you zero hours.

Ditto anyone who makes any kind of complaint.

Been there.

Precisely.

There are too many people who want people treated this way, it seems.

thismorningisnottoday · 01/09/2022 23:07

They are extremely exploitative.

The 'flexibility' is usually only for the employers.

Ever worked on a zero-hours contract and declined a couple of shifts?? They often 'punish' you by giving you zero hours.

Ditto anyone who makes any kind of complaint.

Been there.

Kite22 · 01/09/2022 23:04

I agree with you OP.

It is ridiculous to ban a really sensible, practical, flexible and helpful way of employing people which benefits both employers and employees, because there are a number of employers who abuse it.

Try looking at bringing in regulations that curtail the poor practices.
That said, there are employer and Managers who are really poor employers or managers whatever the contract.

Sledgehammer and nut come to mind.
It is back to the looking at a situation in one place and assuming it is the same all over, when it clearly isn't.

Mumofsend · 01/09/2022 23:01

They are used by far too many employers to demand 7 days a week, 12 hours a day (or more) complete flexibility. For a minority they work well, for the majority they leave them vulnerable and not actually able to refuse shifts. If I refused a shift at a well known pub chain, I had my hours slashed in return. It's a nightmare for childcare.

carefullycourageous · 01/09/2022 23:00

Twizbe · 01/09/2022 22:55

@carefullycourageous but then you lose length of service which can be very important in terms of employment protections.

You can also find yourself in a cycle of fire and rehire during which contract terms can be changed without consultation.

You don't get employment protection on zero hours anyway, really, because they can just give you zero hours. I don't see how fire and rehire is a risk when it is zero hours anyway. They can just not fire and rehire.

Honestly the unions have been fighting this for years, I think we all know work was better in the 'olden days', these contracts are exploitative.

Merryoldgoat · 01/09/2022 22:59

They will end up being unpopular after the Brazel V Harpur ruling for holiday pay soon as if an employer wants to avoid paying masses of holiday pay they’ll have to terminate and rehire all the time which is a massive administrative burden.

LarryTrotter · 01/09/2022 22:58

Tell me you're privileged without telling me you're privileged.

whenwillthemadnessend · 01/09/2022 22:57

My dd has one and it's shit.

Ok she is a sixth former and doesn't have bills but she has been offer 3 shifts in 5 weeks now and her employers seem to just dish out shifts to the favoured ones.

She is going for more interviews again

Not worth the hassle.

Twizbe · 01/09/2022 22:55

@carefullycourageous but then you lose length of service which can be very important in terms of employment protections.

You can also find yourself in a cycle of fire and rehire during which contract terms can be changed without consultation.

TamSamLam · 01/09/2022 22:55

They work really well for a lot of employers and employees. I would jump for the chance of 0 hours where I am now.

I had a job where management forced the department to get rid of them (looked bad on the books), all the 0 hours staff left rather than apply to go permanent, they were good and experienced staff who worked mostly regular hours but needed flexibility.

The problem isn't the contract, the problem is people who need a fixed hours contract working those jobs. The solution is already there in the right to request flexible working, those regulations would cover requesting less flexible working.

Friars23 · 01/09/2022 22:53

I expect far more employees are served badly by the rise of zero contract employment than those who find it helpful, so I would support banning them. However, if there is a way to pass legislation that means they can remain for the minority who do find them beneficial then of course may that happen.

carefullycourageous · 01/09/2022 22:52

effectively a zero-hour contract, employed directly by the hospital Trust but no "base" and no contracted hours - I could pick and choose when and where I worked, obviously providing they had uncovered shifts This is NOT what would be banned.

Slartibartfast42 · 01/09/2022 22:51

MumW · 01/09/2022 22:34

It all depends on the contract.
A zero hours contract where you have no control over your hours but are expected to be available at all times (eg: retail) is different to a casual contract where you can say no to hours offered or can say you'll only work certain days/times (eg: bano staff/supply teacher).
The latter allows you flexibility and the option of juggling two jobs whilst the former is more like being employed full-time but without the guarantee of any actual work.

This.

I've worked both above examples and they are very different. Currently working a zero hour and the flexibility to work more or less hours on whichever days I choose suits my current circumstances.
But I have previously worked retail where I was expected to be available all day every day for the few hours they threw my way at short notice with no option ever to say I'm not available so not possible to take on another job to try to increase my earnings.
That type of zero hour should be banned.

carefullycourageous · 01/09/2022 22:51

Twizbe · 01/09/2022 22:49

@Speedweed but what if you want to be able to drop that income to nothing.

For my DH his holiday job was lots of fun and paid really well. Uni was over 3 hours away so he couldn't do that job during term time. The business was a tourist attraction so needed more staff in school holidays. Students on zero hours were great for that. They didn't need to train a whole ton of new people every holiday and the students had the confidence that a job was there for them in the holidays.

They'll just recontract. It is really not complicated.

carefullycourageous · 01/09/2022 22:50

There will be some circs they are allowed, it is just about not being able to demand exclusivity without guaranteeing pay. Agencies/bank staff will still exist. Casual work is important in the economy.

But companies will not be able to rip people off.

Why would you be in favour of companies exploiting workers?

Swipe left for the next trending thread