Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I pay for the damage I caused?

395 replies

GogglesM · 01/09/2022 21:14

18 months ago, whilst reversing out of my boyfriend's drive, I accidentally scraped his car with my own. I was, of course, mortified and I offered at the time to go through my insurance and make a claim, or to pay to repair it privately. He told me not to worry about it and it hasn't been mentioned since.

My boyfriends car is on finance and he is now giving it back to the dealership and he is hoping to use his car to negotiate a deal on a new car. He recently got all of the scrapes repaired (including the one I caused) and it cost him just shy of £1,000. There was no mention of me paying anything towards this until after he had got the bill and had already paid. He is now asking me for a contribution of £300 towards the cost, for the scrape I caused. I've said that I'm happy to go through the insurance, but, even though I did offer cash 18 months ago, I now cannot afford to pay privately for the repair due to the cost of living. My boyfriend doesn't want to go through the insurance as he has had to make a claim recently and he worries it will affect his excess and future insurance costs. He's also said it is a lot of hassle to go through the insurance.

I do also find it a little odd to be asking for the money 18 months on, but that's by the by, and I haven't said that to him. Our relationship has moved on to the point where we will be buying a house together soon and it is serious. There's also a large wage disparity between us, I earn a modest wage with a benefit top up and he earns over £100k. That's not to say I shouldn't pay for damage I have caused, it's just the whole situation feels a bit off to me, especially to be asking for the money now so long after the incident.

What would you do in this situation?

OP posts:
Fraaahnces · 04/09/2022 01:04

Gambling problem? Big earners can get into trouble with online gambling too.

Augustmummy · 03/09/2022 22:25

has he lost his job without telling you or something? Why does he suddenly need the £300 - seems odd

FinallyHere · 03/09/2022 20:59

@llizzie

Have you read any of OP's posts?

OP offered to pay through insurance at the time. He refused.

Eighteen months later, he has had all the dings on his car repaired before returning it at end of lease.

The bill for all the damage is £1k.

No breakdown of the costs is available.

He has arbitrarily decided that OP's share is £300, having refused her offer to have it fixed, eighteen months ago.

HTH

llizzie · 03/09/2022 18:10

Have you both actually been approved for a mortgage, or are you just talking about it?

A mortgage lender would want to go into both your finances if the house will be in both your names.

llizzie · 03/09/2022 17:51

I would not like to say if you are reasonable or unreasonable, because I do not know what the law is and if it is still possible to take you to court after 18 months. The County Court office would tell you that. If time has run out, then there is no reason why he should make you pay up just for £300. It depends on your finances at the moment. It could be you are ''spoiling the ship for a pennyworth of tar'' sort of thing. If you pay the £300, chances are you will benefit another time by the same amount or more. It is up to you whether you want to spend your life together with him. Only you know how you feel. It needs a lot of thinking about. He is better off than you financially: perhaps he is not. Why give his car back to the dealership? Is he strapped for cash and making trade in the reason? Why not sell privately, since it should not make such a difference, and if the scratch has been repaired he stands to get a better deal. It is strange though, to buy a new car at this time of year when the cost of living has shot up.

It is as good as it gets. It does not get better when you marry or move in with him. If that is something you both want, you have to be very cautious, because it might be what you will have for the rest of your life together.
The fact that he earns more than you should not be an issue, because unless his employment is safe, he could lose it. He will also have to pay more income tax than you, and NI which could even things up. He may be making this £300 an excuse for leaving you.

Energydrink · 03/09/2022 15:15

Pay him back in instalments. It doesn’t matter about his salary!

The accident was your fault. Just as your circumstances have changed, so has his. He would now like to sell

BettyJDavies · 03/09/2022 15:01

Blokes a twat, you should be thankful you have found out now.

Debjam1963 · 03/09/2022 14:49

Bin this fella. Too many red flags there. You really need to get out of that relationship now...

LondonMrsA · 03/09/2022 14:14

If he is aware of the disparity between your respective incomes, then I think he is being mean. Don’t move in with a mean man. And certainly don’t marry him.

HarrietsweetHarriet · 03/09/2022 14:11

I'm sorry to say it, OP, but if he is quibbling over £300 especially on his salary, you'd be well advised to end this relationship now.

fatchilli123 · 03/09/2022 14:09

Run please run 😬

AnnieSnap · 03/09/2022 14:09

I really hope the OP returns to share her thoughts on our replies

antikkiti · 03/09/2022 13:10

Fairylightsongs · 01/09/2022 22:02

Um yes she’s even written it in the op. He needs to hand it back so needs to get it repaired.he didn’t wish to claim on insurance as it would affect his claims. He’s paying 700 of the damage she caused.he’s only asking her for 300.

That's not how I read it. She said he had a number of bodywork repairs attended to, not just the damage she caused. She didn't cause £1,000 worth of damage!

RachaelN · 03/09/2022 13:02

What a weird thing for him to ask now when he said not to worry about it. I would very much reconsider being in a relationship with this person.

Hanstarlucky · 03/09/2022 12:21

How bad is the scrape? Is it on the bumper or the paint work? Is it deep?

where has he plucked the amount of 300 from? Has he had a quote for just the scrape?

to be honest you offered at the time, and he declined, I would seriously consider the prospect of what buying a house would bring in terms of what happens if the boiler broke etc

personally I would in the politest way tell him to F off

Upsidedownagain · 03/09/2022 11:27

Would put me off him massively. People who move in together generally share finances, to a degree at least. This doesn't bode well.

You offered at the time and he made his decision then not to get the repair. He now regrets it - well that is the chance he took. It's his hard luck.

But your good luck that he has raised this red flag BEFORE you move in with him.

wentworthinmate · 03/09/2022 10:49

I haven’t read entire thread but he wants £300 from you when he earns over £100k?? WTAF. It’s a firm no from me and a review of the relationship!

UnicornsDoExist · 03/09/2022 10:49

Be careful buying a house with him, I think I’d slow things down for a bit, be 100% sure you know what you’re getting in to with this guy

impossible · 03/09/2022 10:08

DontBlameMe79 · 03/09/2022 09:29

As he’s on 100k a year, her benefits are going to be inconsequential to him. If she moves ahead, OP needs to make sure she has access to his resources, otherwise what’s the point. The 300 is neither here nor there.

Yes, that's what I mean. OPs benefits are not inconsequential to her so she needs to be sure he will be sharing his resources.

DontBlameMe79 · 03/09/2022 10:04

AlexandriasWindmill · 03/09/2022 09:52

No. It's the first sign of an abusive relationship with flags about manipulation, gaslighting and financial abuse.

Exactly!

EleanorShellstrop28 · 03/09/2022 09:58

No way would I pay!

I also wouldn’t move in with someone who had your boyfriends attitude.

cloudchaos · 03/09/2022 09:57

If you're going to move in with him then you need to be able to communicate openly with him.

I would tell him that you feel it's a bit off to be asking now for the money when you offered 18 months ago and he said no. It gives the impression he could ask for money back at any time, e.g. cost for meals etc. Also explain you had the money then and don't now. I would also use the example that you're not keeping tally, e.g. didn't ask for fuel he's used over the past 18months and with the fact you're moving in together you hoped you were a team.

Depending on his response I'd decide my next move. If he insists, for me I would pay it because I would hate to feel like he was going to feel I took advantage (I might deduct the recent petrol usage) but then end the relationship.

If he changes his tune I would monitor how he is and stall a little on the house purchase, and encourage more open conversations regarding finance and the future from now on.

I've treated exes much better than he is treating his supposedly long term partner.

AlexandriasWindmill · 03/09/2022 09:52

DontBlameMe79 · 03/09/2022 08:45

BTW - this is another form of shit testing 😄😄

No. It's the first sign of an abusive relationship with flags about manipulation, gaslighting and financial abuse.

anon666 · 03/09/2022 09:37

I know everyone has concluded this guy is a tosser, and I get why.

But I would give it one last try to let him redeem himself.

Is it possible that he just doesn't see money as an issue and is blind to it? Not being sexist but men can be very dim and naive sometimes. He might have decided that this is a logical thing to do and not really considered the impact on you.

He might just be thinking logically and apportioning the cost out on the basis that you had offered to go through the insurance.

If you explain, no, I can't afford not to go through the insurance but yes I understand that it would cost us more in insurance premiums, he might be more flexible.

However, I would question whether he is ready to have a genuine partnership yet, including financial. He sounds like he's not yet understood what's involved in terms of mutual trust and commitment.

PepperRed · 03/09/2022 09:36

Thatboymum

Do not agree that OP thinks she is entitled. She has made it plain that she offered to pay at the time or go thru' insurance. He caused the problem by not accepting either. They cannot go thru' insurance [usually one month is deadline for reporting accident in most policies and as others pointed out - no damage now] Something has made him change his mind. Agree with others that this is not about the £300. Needs careful thought about the relationship.