Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you a HSP? Highly sensitive person?

369 replies

HSP2022 · 01/09/2022 15:26

Apparently 20% of people are classified as a highly sensitive person.

I'm certain I fit the criteria but do any of you?

Is there a way to get absolute clarification?

Do you just accept that's how you are or have you been able to change aspects so you are not as highly sensitive to certain things?

OP posts:
Ccoffee · 02/09/2022 09:46

ReneBumsWombats · 02/09/2022 08:39

I suspect a lot of the snarky comments are from people who would love to come out with 'snowflake' comments on the ADHD, autism, anxiety, depression etc threads but know they wouldn't get away with it.

Even though a lot of them have specified that their knowledge and understanding of ADHD, autism etc is precisely why they realise this one's a load of bunkum?

Sure but why not discuss that instead of snidely comments? Everyone with a diagnosis was undiagnosed at some point. They didn't magically morph from a laughable snowflake to a diagnosed person that deserves understanding when they received a diagnosis.

bringincrazyback · 02/09/2022 09:16

I suspect a lot of the snarky comments are from people who would love to come out with 'snowflake' comments on the ADHD, autism, anxiety, depression etc threads but know they wouldn't get away with it.

This. Depressingly the thread's turned into yet another example of the intolerance of some MNers to anything that's not within their own understanding or lived experience.

ReneBumsWombats · 02/09/2022 08:39

I suspect a lot of the snarky comments are from people who would love to come out with 'snowflake' comments on the ADHD, autism, anxiety, depression etc threads but know they wouldn't get away with it.

Even though a lot of them have specified that their knowledge and understanding of ADHD, autism etc is precisely why they realise this one's a load of bunkum?

Ccoffee · 02/09/2022 08:29

This thread turned into a really unhelpful pile-on. The OP wanted to start a discussion and got a ton of snarky remarks. I suspect a lot of the snarky comments are from people who would love to come out with 'snowflake' comments on the ADHD, autism, anxiety, depression etc threads but know they wouldn't get away with it.

HSP does sound like generalised pseudo-science. But instead of mocking the OP, point her towards info on neurodiversion, introversion, anxiety, trauma etc. Or if you know nothing about those, maybe you have nothing to add to the thread.

ScarlettSunset · 02/09/2022 07:44

If someone just asked me 'are you a highly sensitive person'? I'd think that yes I am. I take things to heart, sometimes get overly anxious about doing the right thing etc.

But then there was that ridiculous, claptrap definition and so nope, I'm definitely not!

Miffee · 02/09/2022 07:41

NumberTheory · 02/09/2022 04:23

Yes! Lots of evidence that there is a spectrum of sensitivity to stimuli and so some people are better at noticing some stimuli than others and (in this study) of using that information effectively.

But that isn’t the description that OP has posted. OP’s description is pop psychology at its worst, taking the inability to cope with stimuli to be a sign of being highly sensitive and associating that inability to cope with the increased ability to discern subtleties (and so to be more aware of others). But these are different responses to stimuli.

I also think these pseudo scientific pathologies serve another purpose. Introvert, empath and now HSP. Some of them have anti social behaviours in there. Having a label to stick on it means the the labelled suddenly believes that their behaviour isn't something they need to work on but rather something other people need to accommodate.

Again that line of reasoning also unmask a horrible understanding of those with genuine neurodivergence, that is that they demand society conforms to them. That is not the case at all of course.

SupDuck · 02/09/2022 07:40

Not read the full thread but I guess a few years ago I would have (privately) identified with this.
However, after a breakdown and therapy it turns out a lot was a result of complex trauma and I am neurodiverse.
So, while I’m agreeing that yes, some people are more easily startled, unable to watch violence and generally more sensitive it’s probably usually due to something else than some unique personality trait.

Miffee · 02/09/2022 07:37

Givemesunshines · 02/09/2022 00:00

For those who dont believe in hsp.. dont you believe in other non neuro typical conditions ??!!
Yes , some people, like all people, with this condition can ham it up, like anyone can , but this hsp i think is simply a different brain wiring, just like others.i am not neuro tyoical but guess what i dont use this as an excuse but acknowlwdge it amd work.to my strenghts where i can and i imagine most hsps do the same in a world that challenges them as it does many of us.

It's pseudo science. The fact you are comparing it to diagnosed neurodivergece is exactly the problem.

It's taking a random group of reactions to things, boxing them up and giving them a label. Even OP said only 4 of the 5 apply to her. It's entirely arbitrary and exists solely to get people who are self obsessed to click on it.

ofwarren · 02/09/2022 07:26

Givemesunshines · 02/09/2022 00:00

For those who dont believe in hsp.. dont you believe in other non neuro typical conditions ??!!
Yes , some people, like all people, with this condition can ham it up, like anyone can , but this hsp i think is simply a different brain wiring, just like others.i am not neuro tyoical but guess what i dont use this as an excuse but acknowlwdge it amd work.to my strenghts where i can and i imagine most hsps do the same in a world that challenges them as it does many of us.

Saying that so called HSP are ND like those of us with autism and ADHD is offensive.

Being more sensitive is not a different neurotype ffs. It's just a natural variation of typical!

Ravenpuff93 · 02/09/2022 06:21

Givemesunshines · 02/09/2022 00:00

For those who dont believe in hsp.. dont you believe in other non neuro typical conditions ??!!
Yes , some people, like all people, with this condition can ham it up, like anyone can , but this hsp i think is simply a different brain wiring, just like others.i am not neuro tyoical but guess what i dont use this as an excuse but acknowlwdge it amd work.to my strenghts where i can and i imagine most hsps do the same in a world that challenges them as it does many of us.

I believe in neurodiversity because I’ve studied it, I don’t believe in the utility of labels like these. As I mentioned previously, call yourself what you want, but don’t expect it to have any clinical relevance. I had a patient not long ago describe himself as an empath and start on how many MH professionals don’t seem to know anything about it. It was a real challenge wording “that’s because it’s a pseudoscientific term at best” in a patient centred, empathetic way.

NumberTheory · 02/09/2022 04:23

eggcustard1 · 02/09/2022 00:04

Yes! Lots of evidence that there is a spectrum of sensitivity to stimuli and so some people are better at noticing some stimuli than others and (in this study) of using that information effectively.

But that isn’t the description that OP has posted. OP’s description is pop psychology at its worst, taking the inability to cope with stimuli to be a sign of being highly sensitive and associating that inability to cope with the increased ability to discern subtleties (and so to be more aware of others). But these are different responses to stimuli.

HSP2022 · 02/09/2022 04:22

bringincrazyback · 01/09/2022 22:51

OP, ignore the shitty responses.

Some people don't seem to realise it's possible to have a personality trait without being a snowflake or a brat or thinking it makes one special.

I consider myself an HSP for all sorts of reasons. I don't consider it makes me special, I don't use it to demand special treatment, and I don't use it to excuse bad behaviour. I do, however, find it helpful to know this is a researched and documented trait that others share, and which has positive as well as negative sides.

Some people just can't seem to stand the fact that people are not all the same as them.

It's been quite an odd response to this thread. Almost as though no one believes someone like me can actually exist. You sound similar to me.

The appreciation of art thing has cropped up loads on here, but isn't something that resonates for me personally and a lot of the other traits completely overlooked.

Violence has mentioned a few times as though if you're not affected by it in the way I am, then the opposite is to enjoy it. I could explain how I'm affected by violence but to be honest I feel it's not worth it with the turn that this thread has taken.

OP posts:
bringincrazyback · 02/09/2022 00:19

Crankley · 02/09/2022 00:02

Try being less self obsessed.

It's possible to be self-aware without being self-obsessed.

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 02/09/2022 00:05

Navel gazing claptrap.

eggcustard1 · 02/09/2022 00:04

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4086365/

Crankley · 02/09/2022 00:02

Try being less self obsessed.

Givemesunshines · 02/09/2022 00:00

For those who dont believe in hsp.. dont you believe in other non neuro typical conditions ??!!
Yes , some people, like all people, with this condition can ham it up, like anyone can , but this hsp i think is simply a different brain wiring, just like others.i am not neuro tyoical but guess what i dont use this as an excuse but acknowlwdge it amd work.to my strenghts where i can and i imagine most hsps do the same in a world that challenges them as it does many of us.

eggcustard1 · 01/09/2022 23:54

Kanaloa · 01/09/2022 23:45

But what study was it? Could you link so I could have a look? How were these people determined to ‘have HSP?’ How were the subjects gathered? How did the brain scans confirm that those people, for example, appreciated art on a deeper level than the control subjects who were not considered to ‘have HSP?’

I will dig it out and link it for you......it won't be tonight though!

Bobbybobbins · 01/09/2022 23:47

I am definitely a less sensitive person and I am ok with that. I am a bit reckless, don't always allow myself time to appreciate how I feel. But I am very resilient. And I do like art!

Kanaloa · 01/09/2022 23:45

eggcustard1 · 01/09/2022 23:41

It has involved brain scans showing differences in for instance the mirror neurons that are believed to govern empathy. I did some research around this a few years ago. People considered to have HSP have physical differences in their brains.

But what study was it? Could you link so I could have a look? How were these people determined to ‘have HSP?’ How were the subjects gathered? How did the brain scans confirm that those people, for example, appreciated art on a deeper level than the control subjects who were not considered to ‘have HSP?’

Kanaloa · 01/09/2022 23:43

Eastangular2000 · 01/09/2022 23:36

This! Of course there is science around peoples physical sensitivity and reactivity. Indeed, concepts such as hyper vigilance are fairly well established, but as the pp says I would love to see the science that has detected deeper appreciation of art and music in animal species

Oh of course. I’ve seen studies where peoples reactivity and such had been measured. I have a son who is autistic so am very interested in those types of things - that’s why I was interested to know what sort of science this was. How could they measure how deeply one appreciates art? How do they set a control for that? How do they choose subjects? Because anyone who signs up for an art study will likely be very interested in art, therefore skewing the results. How do they measure who ‘hears’ the music and who ‘feels’ it? I’d be interested to know, truly, because I’d just love to see how such a study would be organised.

eggcustard1 · 01/09/2022 23:41

Kanaloa · 01/09/2022 23:34

What science? I’d be genuinely interested in science that proves how there are special HSP who can appreciate art on a deeper level? Just because I’d love to know how they measured that.

It has involved brain scans showing differences in for instance the mirror neurons that are believed to govern empathy. I did some research around this a few years ago. People considered to have HSP have physical differences in their brains.

Eastangular2000 · 01/09/2022 23:36

Kanaloa · 01/09/2022 23:34

What science? I’d be genuinely interested in science that proves how there are special HSP who can appreciate art on a deeper level? Just because I’d love to know how they measured that.

This! Of course there is science around peoples physical sensitivity and reactivity. Indeed, concepts such as hyper vigilance are fairly well established, but as the pp says I would love to see the science that has detected deeper appreciation of art and music in animal species

eggcustard1 · 01/09/2022 23:36

delete the 'I don't believe' bit in post above! 🙂

Kanaloa · 01/09/2022 23:34

eggcustard1 · 01/09/2022 23:29

There is science that demonstrates HSP brains are different in several ways. It has also been detected in many species of animals. I don't believe I know people that are HSP and the overwhelm they experience, and subsequent exhaustion through being over stimulated, is very real.

What science? I’d be genuinely interested in science that proves how there are special HSP who can appreciate art on a deeper level? Just because I’d love to know how they measured that.