Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are you a HSP? Highly sensitive person?

369 replies

HSP2022 · 01/09/2022 15:26

Apparently 20% of people are classified as a highly sensitive person.

I'm certain I fit the criteria but do any of you?

Is there a way to get absolute clarification?

Do you just accept that's how you are or have you been able to change aspects so you are not as highly sensitive to certain things?

OP posts:
LuftBalloons · 03/09/2022 12:16

Yeah @ReneBumsWombats agree with what you say. I just did one of the self-tests on the HSP website. I scored19, so you now all have to bow down to me as an Extremely Highly Sensitive Person. I am clearly so feeling and responsive that there should be a special category for me.

It’s rubbish, basically. The self-test is very bad. It’s like reading a horoscope reading or prediction.

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 11:51

ReneBumsWombats · 03/09/2022 11:44

But these people aren't talking about a sensory processing condition. Most of us are aware that those exist, often alongside conditions such as autism.

They're saying they feel and appreciate more deeply, and their only evidence appears to be a complete insensitivity to the feelings of others, an assumption that they know what others feel and can quantify it (how?) and the fact that they are less able to cope than others. The idea that a person who can cope cannot also feel is so insensitive, ignorant and offensive that I don't know where to start with it.

Nor am I convinced by the fact that someone in America wrote a self-help book for people who have a desire to define themselves this way.

Indeed. 20% of the population in the US is around 50 million people you can aim your book at.

she doesn’t appear to be associated with any clinical institute, and the main gist of her website is ‘if these catch-all traits apply to you, which they are designed to do, buy my book! Here’s a link’.

Ommommomm · 03/09/2022 11:51

Whichwhatnow · 03/09/2022 11:43

Being an empath does not mean that you're more sympathetic to others and help them in any way. It means (in my experience) that you make other's trauma or stress all about you. Example - an acquaintance breaking down and sobbing on the floor because my dog died. She didn't know my dog. But apparently she expected me to comfort her because 'I'm an empath and I feel your grief more than you do!'

I think you are confusing empath with narcissist

ReneBumsWombats · 03/09/2022 11:44

But these people aren't talking about a sensory processing condition. Most of us are aware that those exist, often alongside conditions such as autism.

They're saying they feel and appreciate more deeply, and their only evidence appears to be a complete insensitivity to the feelings of others, an assumption that they know what others feel and can quantify it (how?) and the fact that they are less able to cope than others. The idea that a person who can cope cannot also feel is so insensitive, ignorant and offensive that I don't know where to start with it.

Nor am I convinced by the fact that someone in America wrote a self-help book for people who have a desire to define themselves this way.

Whichwhatnow · 03/09/2022 11:43

HSP2022 · 01/09/2022 15:34

I don't agree.

Being an empath does not mean that you're more sympathetic to others and help them in any way. It means (in my experience) that you make other's trauma or stress all about you. Example - an acquaintance breaking down and sobbing on the floor because my dog died. She didn't know my dog. But apparently she expected me to comfort her because 'I'm an empath and I feel your grief more than you do!'

honeylulu · 03/09/2022 11:37

I think it is a real thing and I've known a few HSP including my sister. However of those, most I would not say were empaths as they are so busy being sensitive and trying to manage their feelings (or expecting others to help manage their feelings) that they don't have much capacity to think about others.

notnownorma · 03/09/2022 11:32

Eastangular2000 · 01/09/2022 15:29

It's a ridiculous made up concept for people who feel the need to consider themselves special in some way.

This. Complete with pseudo-diagnostic abbreviation label. But I guess that means we're both thoroughly insensitive, hey @Eastangular2000?

🤓

ofwarren · 03/09/2022 11:29

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 11:26

And no one is saying greater or lesser levels of sensitivity aren’t a thing. Of course they are, there are natural variations across the species. That’s normal. What’s being said is that it’s not a special trait or a condition in it’s own right.

Self reporting alone is a hugely unreliable means of diagnosing anything. Fuck, you can claim astrology is true if you base it that.

This!

ofwarren · 03/09/2022 11:28

NeedASolution · 03/09/2022 11:11

I'm surprised by the lack of balanced responses here. The concept of being 'highly sensitive' is relatively new but well-researched by Elaine Aron and related to a deeper type of sensory and cognitive processing, putting in the same ball park as other forms of neurodiversity. It hasn't been fully 'proven' because few behavioural or cognitive traits are - the body of research has to be developed over time, which is why we previously had no understanding of things like dyslexia, ADHD, etc.

Having a more easily stimulated nervous system is far from being a 'special snowflake'. Like most individual differences, it has as many disadvantages as it does advantages, but understanding it can help HSPs (and non-HSPs) play to the positives and manage the negatives. I think the concept can be particularly useful in understanding children with different temperaments, especially in learning environments.

Can people stop with saying its a neurodiversity!
Don't compare something that isn't a proven condition with actual diagnoses such as ASD and ADHD. It's offensive!
The "symptoms" people are discussing are within the variation of the normal human experience.

85% of autistic people don't/can't work
The rate of suicide in autistic people is 3 times higher than average
70% of kids with ASD are bullied due to their autism

It takes the piss to say that because someone gets upset by violence, considers that they understand art deeply and has self diagnosed themselves with HSP that they are neurodiverse.

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 11:26

And no one is saying greater or lesser levels of sensitivity aren’t a thing. Of course they are, there are natural variations across the species. That’s normal. What’s being said is that it’s not a special trait or a condition in it’s own right.

Self reporting alone is a hugely unreliable means of diagnosing anything. Fuck, you can claim astrology is true if you base it that.

whumpthereitis · 03/09/2022 11:21

NeedASolution · 03/09/2022 11:11

I'm surprised by the lack of balanced responses here. The concept of being 'highly sensitive' is relatively new but well-researched by Elaine Aron and related to a deeper type of sensory and cognitive processing, putting in the same ball park as other forms of neurodiversity. It hasn't been fully 'proven' because few behavioural or cognitive traits are - the body of research has to be developed over time, which is why we previously had no understanding of things like dyslexia, ADHD, etc.

Having a more easily stimulated nervous system is far from being a 'special snowflake'. Like most individual differences, it has as many disadvantages as it does advantages, but understanding it can help HSPs (and non-HSPs) play to the positives and manage the negatives. I think the concept can be particularly useful in understanding children with different temperaments, especially in learning environments.

It’s not that new. There’s certainly time for it to have been studied far more extensively than it has been and accepted as part of mainstream psychology if it was considered to have great merit.

it’s also worth considering the background and motivations of Elaine Aron herself. She is Jungian, and of course has a vested financial interest in pushing her theory as true. She alone does not give it any particular gravitas.

eggcustard1 · 03/09/2022 11:18

ReneBumsWombats · 03/09/2022 10:40

By "pathologised", I mean labelling it as something so unusual and far from the normal that it deserves labelling as a condition, rather than a collection of personality traits like in any other human.. And in which, over and over again, the supposed sensitivity goes only one way and is absolutely brick-like elsewhere.

It is stressed that it is a collection of common personality traits rather than a diagnosable condition. Elaine Aron suggests there are both advantages and disadvantages to having these traits.
I appreciate that some people may love a label, to somehow feel more special than everyone else. This can be irritating for others, especially if they use it as a perceived excuse for difficult behaviour. I have encountered such people.

However, other people I have encountered have quietly explored the HSP theory and then adjusted their lives to accommodate what they have learned in the hope that life won't be as tiring/difficult.
If the theory around HSP helps anyone to live a more comfortable and enjoyable life I think that is a positive.

NeedASolution · 03/09/2022 11:13

You can self-diagnose, though. Elaine Aron has a test you can find via google.

NeedASolution · 03/09/2022 11:12

Butterdishtea · 03/09/2022 10:55

My friend is a highly experiences clinical psychologist. She says it's absolutely a thing and should be factored in. However I don't think you can self diagnose.

I'm also a psychologist and agreeing with your friend.

NeedASolution · 03/09/2022 11:11

I'm surprised by the lack of balanced responses here. The concept of being 'highly sensitive' is relatively new but well-researched by Elaine Aron and related to a deeper type of sensory and cognitive processing, putting in the same ball park as other forms of neurodiversity. It hasn't been fully 'proven' because few behavioural or cognitive traits are - the body of research has to be developed over time, which is why we previously had no understanding of things like dyslexia, ADHD, etc.

Having a more easily stimulated nervous system is far from being a 'special snowflake'. Like most individual differences, it has as many disadvantages as it does advantages, but understanding it can help HSPs (and non-HSPs) play to the positives and manage the negatives. I think the concept can be particularly useful in understanding children with different temperaments, especially in learning environments.

Sonnex · 03/09/2022 11:06

I got 15 on the test and don't consider myself sensitive. If I met someone like you OP I would consider you self absorbed or self obsessed. This is just a fancy word for that isn't it?

Kanaloa · 03/09/2022 10:56

Butterdishtea · 03/09/2022 10:55

My friend is a highly experiences clinical psychologist. She says it's absolutely a thing and should be factored in. However I don't think you can self diagnose.

Self diagnose is all you can do! Unless you’re suggesting your highly experienced clinical psychologist friend diagnoses people with HSP after hearing their symptoms such as deep connection to art and finding violence disturbing.

Butterdishtea · 03/09/2022 10:56

I think it's a rather unfortunately named thing though. It sounds snowflakey.

Butterdishtea · 03/09/2022 10:55

My friend is a highly experiences clinical psychologist. She says it's absolutely a thing and should be factored in. However I don't think you can self diagnose.

LuftBalloons · 03/09/2022 10:53

And the same goes for threads by posters who identify as sensitive people or empaths. I think this attitude towards people who are more sensitive is reflected in real life too, which is really sad. I think it's partly a cultural thing here too (if you are in the UK).

I think it’s because stating one is “highly sensitive“ and using this to assert one feels MORE than others is a highly arrogant statement.

Indeed, assuming that one feels more than others is UNempathetic in the extreme, it seems to me. The aura of superiority is very obvious in posts claiming HSP.

Most MN posters are sensitive people but most of us also get on with life. And most of us don’t need to pathologise ordinary human feeling - we have personalities and don’t need some spurious pseudo-science to make us feel important.

ReneBumsWombats · 03/09/2022 10:52

I don't like loud noise or crowds either. That's why I don't go to major music festivals even though I love music. No trauma or bad experiences, just my nature.

It's never occurred to me to need an "explanation" for it, or "normalisation" or "comfort". I'm just a person who likes some things and doesn't like other things. Like everyone.

Tierne · 03/09/2022 10:47

Empath or highly sensitive seems to be to 2022 what borderline was to 2012

LuftBalloons · 03/09/2022 10:46

ReneBumsWombats · 03/09/2022 08:33

Some people have found that they can identify with a list of traits

Everyone can do that. It's called having a personality. It's not something to be pathologised.

Absolutely @ReneBumsWombats

And not having empathy, response to others, response to creativity, and revulsion at violence is a pretty good working definition of sociopathy.

Andromachehadabadday · 03/09/2022 10:41

eggcustard1 · 03/09/2022 10:35

Rather than it being pathologised, people I have encountered, that have identified with the HSP traits, have felt normalised & have been comforted to have found a likely explanation for their experiences.

But it’s not an explanation. Giving it a label doesn’t give it an explanation at all.

There could be a million reasons people don’t like loud, sudden noises. Or that they are sensitive or less able to deal with their emotions.

Slapping ‘oh I am a HSP’ explains nothing at all

ReneBumsWombats · 03/09/2022 10:40

eggcustard1 · 03/09/2022 10:35

Rather than it being pathologised, people I have encountered, that have identified with the HSP traits, have felt normalised & have been comforted to have found a likely explanation for their experiences.

By "pathologised", I mean labelling it as something so unusual and far from the normal that it deserves labelling as a condition, rather than a collection of personality traits like in any other human.. And in which, over and over again, the supposed sensitivity goes only one way and is absolutely brick-like elsewhere.