Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about the number of people who think a ‘fixed’ energy tariff means the monthly price will always be the same - regardless of usage

160 replies

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 12:12

I know there are loads of threads about energy costs at the moment but I have noticed there are quite a number of people who think a fixed price tariff operates in the same way as say a monthly Netflix subscription.

With Netflix, you pay the same each month regardless of how much you watch.

With energy it is only the unit price you are fixing - your monthly bill will vary dependent on usage.

The terms ‘fix’ and ‘cap’ are causing a lot of confusion.

OP posts:
CeeJay81 · 01/09/2022 17:23

I agree plus the number of people who think that by cutting back on energy they'll be fine. When in reality even cutting back to the bare minimum won't be anywhere near enough to combat the massive rises .

Bebbanburg2507 · 01/09/2022 17:11

I've just had a conversation with a family member about the £400 energy rebate over winter and he hadn't even heard of it! He doesn't watch mainstream news, read papers or have the internet so I often forget he doesn't hear about this stuff.
On a different note, we just happened to be telling our friends that we did an overpayment on our mortgage and also switched early to get a cheaper fix for 5 years. They all couldn't understand why we did it, even though their mortgage term is coming to an end soon they aren't even thinking about rate increases. And one of the friends earns a good wage yet has never thought to overpay the mortgage! They thought it was really odd that we did an overpayment.

Bubblebubblebah · 01/09/2022 17:01

Eastangular2000 · 01/09/2022 16:54

Oh I agree re the reporting, it is dreadful!

Agreed. It should be showing units straight away AND use the words "...so the bills for average households rise...."

Davros75 · 01/09/2022 17:00

In the days of switching and going to a new contract my supplier reps thought I was crazy because I was asking for unit rates and standing charges. They obviously usually used an attractive direct debit arrangement to convince people and not mention these, which are the only figures which matter. People are the same with cars; they know the monthly cost but often have no idea how much the car was and interest are actually adding up to.

Eastangular2000 · 01/09/2022 16:54

FinanceLPlates · 01/09/2022 16:47

Just goes to show how confused I am Wink

I mean the way it is being communicated, eg

“Ofgem has announced that its price cap will rise to £3,549 from October 1 - this is up 80% from the current figure of £1,971.”

This might be (mis-)understood as “the maximum anyone will pay is £3,549 per year”, which is not at all true of course.

Oh I agree re the reporting, it is dreadful!

FinanceLPlates · 01/09/2022 16:48

Sorry that was in response to @Eastangular2000

FinanceLPlates · 01/09/2022 16:47

Just goes to show how confused I am Wink

I mean the way it is being communicated, eg

“Ofgem has announced that its price cap will rise to £3,549 from October 1 - this is up 80% from the current figure of £1,971.”

This might be (mis-)understood as “the maximum anyone will pay is £3,549 per year”, which is not at all true of course.

GreenLunchBox · 01/09/2022 15:39

ScamelaAnderson · 01/09/2022 12:22

Im now getting this. Friends who have never done a rate change for their mortgage. One still pays 7% interest on theirs. I was staggered. I literally said, you are throwing money away!

Surely they have bad credit, because most banks' SVRs are under 4% at the moment

Augend23 · 01/09/2022 15:32

I'm worried too OP - or maybe concerned is the right word if worried isn't.

I want people to be okay this winter, and I don't want people to either reject good fixes because they're "too expensive" i.e. the forecast usage is too high, or accept them and get a horrible shock when they submit a meter reading.

The same way I'm worried that some people won't be able to afford to heat their houses at all, or that more people will need food banks.

Eastangular2000 · 01/09/2022 15:26

FinanceLPlates · 01/09/2022 13:01

Agree with @Anothernamechangeplease . Also it sometimes feels like energy suppliers are almost deliberately obfuscating and offering “deals” that aren’t very transparent or easy to compare. As they’re commercial companies it’s maybe unsurprising that they use this tactic.
However I’d expect better from government regulators. Why are they using this roundabout and confusingly named “price cap” metric? In plain English, a “price cap” suggests that you won’t pay more than that. So it’s not too surprising that some people might understand it that way.
Instead, regulators should set an actual price cap on
a) maximum standing charge/day
b) maximum price for kWh

Energy companies should be forced to spell out these metrics too for any deals they offer. Consumers could then easily compare and work out their projected costs depending on usage.

Instead, regulators should set an actual price cap on
a) maximum standing charge/day
b) maximum price for kWh

This is literally exactly what the price cap is!

JP3264 · 01/09/2022 15:17

@Moonmelodies the price per unit of electricity is pegged to the price of generating it by gas, so producers of renewable electricity will be making incredible profits while gas prices are high. The regulator prioritizes keeping energy companies producing over keeping costs low for consumers.

Crunchymum · 01/09/2022 15:17

I give monthly readings, my past two annual statements have been correct so I'm pretty sure I am paying a correct monthly DD. It is just my (prior) annual amount ÷ 12 months. It is not on an estimate.

My situation has not changed at all. So whilst the unit price is going up, I'm pretty confident my usage isn't going to massively change.

I am not going to start heating empty rooms just because my DD is going up. I realise I am paying more for the same amount I am using.

TheOrigRights · 01/09/2022 15:16

@ThrallsWife those sounds like brilliant physics lessons!
I would have found that far more useful than learning how long it would take to throw a ball over the roof of my house!

RustyBear · 01/09/2022 15:15

Crikeyalmighty · 01/09/2022 12:56

@RustyBear not yet no- are you talking about the£66 a month gvt thing? Or a refund because you are so much in credit.

A refund because I'm in credit.

From our electricity account page on the SSE website:
"Your monthly payments are staying the same and we're giving you a refund
We've worked out what you need to pay to cover the cost of your energy by looking at your forecasted energy use until your next review and your account balance (excluding any reserved credit). We're giving you a refund of £223.90 from your current balance of £479.08. The reserved credit amount of £255.18 helps to smooth out any changes in usage and costs over time. We'll check your payments at your next review and let you know if anything should change."

I would have expected that with the increased price we would have used all that credit and probably a bit more by the end of next winter, so there doesn't seem much point in giving it back to us - it's not as if we'd be able to get any significant amount of interest on it over the next six months.

ThrallsWife · 01/09/2022 14:49

I teach Physics.

One of my standard lessons is taking an energy bill and analysing it with my students, as part of a cost of electricity lessons. I'd say about 50% of my students pay attention to what we are doing during that lesson (and I'm considered one of the good 'uns, before anyone chimes in with it being my methods that are at fault).

I also did a stand-alone lesson on general finances and budgeting with a class which had finished all teaching for the year. I think only one of them actually completed the (adapted to their knowledge and needs) MSE sheet, which, together with an overview of entry level salaries, gave them a good idea of what they could afford when they moved out, a few did some very basic calculations, but stopped after a while.

This is in an inner city school.

Until many parents (not all, there are a few who are reasonably clued up) stop indulging their children who want the newest iPhone (which number are we on now?) and who will deliberately smash their old phone to get the newest version (done right in front of me, repeatedly, by different students), until children get taught basic money management at home as soon as they are deemed old enough for allowances, until money actually matters to them, it makes no difference what is being taught in school.

Sadly, while we are doing our best in the classroom, until money has actual relevance to children, they won't be interested.

So the buck does stop with homes I'm afraid. My children learn budgeting, learn what they can afford and what they can't and the oldest is included in some financial decisions. The youngest is 5 and knows how to look out for prices in shops as well as how to add up their pocket money to see whether they can afford their weekly object of choice, the oldest can compare prices per unit and make a basic budget plan for a trip out.

Perhaps now is a good time to start these habits and conversations.

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 14:32

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 13:55

So if ‘worried’ isn’t the right word then what is?

People who don’t understand this are going to end up in the shit if they just use as much gas and electric as they like, thinking they charge will stay the same.

And you don’t know who doesn’t know this - it could be your friends or family

I can understand being worried if it's a friend or family member you are talking about, in that case you could teach them about it if they want to learn.

But I am not sure why you would worry about other people that you don't know.

I am assuming you are not just talking about your own friends and family here?

TheOrigRights · 01/09/2022 14:26

So I hope we are all teaching our children how it all works so future generations aren't as ignorant as we are.

Unless you've sat down and taught yourself this stuff then you won't know how it works. All these companies are notorious for making it difficult for the average person to make sense of their bills.
I know I've looked at bills which maybe say Credit or Debit and I can't work out whether I owe them money or not, because you see Debit and think, oh I'm in debt, but then you read further and see, no, you don't owe then because your DD is about to come out, or they say "don't worry if it say Debit, it averages out over the year"

Or a bill is calculated out of sync to your DD payment. You might have paid an upfront charge or pay after usage so you're not quite sure what's what (mobile phone contracts are terrible for this).

Then all the gubbins about standing charge, rates per unit etc etc.

I think a lot of people think "OK, that seems reasonable, I'll keep an eye on it and maybe look around for a better deal next year" and then get on with everything else.

I am not an unintelligent person, it took me AGES to work out that what I needed to do was NOTHING when my fixed tariff ended. They were suggesting I move to something more than 3 times what I was paying. The info was hidden deep in their website.

QuattroFromagio · 01/09/2022 14:23

Yeah I find these faux "worried for other people" threads a bit sneery too.

Just come out and say how thick you think people are if that's what you want to discuss. Or do something about if it's family and friends life worried about - make sure they understand, or check with anyone you know that might need help.

I'm perfectly mathematically literate, but until a couple of years ago, never really though about energy bills. I paid the DD each month; renewed to the tariff they recommended; realised that over the year my payments seemed to cover the usage that went up and down; and didn't think much more about it.

Only when I moved to a new place with complicated heating (district heating) and rates were much higher than I expected did I start looking into the tariff more carefully, and realising what a huge difference the balance between standing charge and unit rate made, particularly for people who lived alone. The hugely high standing charge the housing association had agreed with the energy supplier was killing me. Not that I could do anything about it, as the tariff wasn't up to me. But it made me petition a bit for the next tariff to have a lower standing charge and higher unit charge (not that pushing them had any effect, I'm sure, but the later rate was a bit more in my favour). And it made me look into that balance more in my electricity bill, where I did have some choice of tariff. So instead of just accepting the recommended tariff automatically, I tried to find one with a lower standing charge if possible. At least that way I felt I might have a little more control over that bill, even if the district heating bill will be massive tariff this winter (not subject to price cap, and no warning in advance of the new tariff - we are just waiting to find out what it could be from October, and then will have no choice but to pay it)

The point is that if you are generally paying a reasonable amount for normal usage that your DD has always covered, you really might not think much about how it works. Not because you're stupid , or Watch Love Island or whatever someone said, but because it's just not been that relevant. Mortgage rates, too. People have blackcaps about some financial things as well, and may always have been told how complicated they are, so they assume that's true.

TheNefariousOrange · 01/09/2022 14:22

I only learnt from mn last week that this is what it means. I feel gutted now as I was offered a fairly decent fixed rate in March but rejected it because I thought it would be adding 500 to my monthly bill 😳.

Moonmelodies · 01/09/2022 14:18

People on 'green' renewable electricity tariffs must be pretty happy, there's no reason for the price of wind or solar energy to increase.

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 13:55

CovertImage · 01/09/2022 13:45

Nailed it

So if ‘worried’ isn’t the right word then what is?

People who don’t understand this are going to end up in the shit if they just use as much gas and electric as they like, thinking they charge will stay the same.

And you don’t know who doesn’t know this - it could be your friends or family

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 01/09/2022 13:53

@Dotjones I've spied this with my own eyes today on twitter on a thread- several Middle aged to late middle aged people (and I'm in that bracket myself) clearly not getting that their DD is just that- an amount that should cover off the years use in theory based on expected and previous rates. It is not an 'all inclusive' any use tariff like Netflix.

CovertImage · 01/09/2022 13:45

SpringIntoChaos · 01/09/2022 13:34

Why are you 'worried'? How does other peoples lack of understanding about a subject negatively affect you?

Or...is your 'concern' merely a way to start a post showing off your own 'higher knowledge' on these things?

Yes, some people don't understand how certain things work...but you could instead (if you were genuinely 'worried' 🤦‍♀️) simply explain it, as a concept...you know, supportively!

I bloody hate faux 'worry' posts! Smacks of Mean Girls and Tinkly Laughs 😔

Nailed it

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 13:41

SpringIntoChaos · 01/09/2022 13:34

Why are you 'worried'? How does other peoples lack of understanding about a subject negatively affect you?

Or...is your 'concern' merely a way to start a post showing off your own 'higher knowledge' on these things?

Yes, some people don't understand how certain things work...but you could instead (if you were genuinely 'worried' 🤦‍♀️) simply explain it, as a concept...you know, supportively!

I bloody hate faux 'worry' posts! Smacks of Mean Girls and Tinkly Laughs 😔

I thought I did explain it as a simple concept in my OP

Not sure why people have to be so narky on here.

OP posts:
Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 13:39

Dotjones · 01/09/2022 13:33

YABU, I have never met anyone who believed that a fixed price energy deal referred to anything other than the fact that the unit price and daily charge wouldn't change for the duration of the fix. As far as I was aware I thought everyone knew that their bill would vary based on usage.

I do think however that many people seem to misunderstand the "price cap" because of the way it's reported. Media sources refer to it as a "cap of £6000 a year" or whatever. This implies that people won't be billed more than this, which is not the case. I'd think it would be much simpler if they just said a cap of £x.xx per unit and £x.xx per day for the standing charge.

Well you clearly haven’t read the energy related threads on here and other SM platforms 🤔

OP posts: