Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about the number of people who think a ‘fixed’ energy tariff means the monthly price will always be the same - regardless of usage

160 replies

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 12:12

I know there are loads of threads about energy costs at the moment but I have noticed there are quite a number of people who think a fixed price tariff operates in the same way as say a monthly Netflix subscription.

With Netflix, you pay the same each month regardless of how much you watch.

With energy it is only the unit price you are fixing - your monthly bill will vary dependent on usage.

The terms ‘fix’ and ‘cap’ are causing a lot of confusion.

OP posts:
MrsLargeEmbodied · 01/09/2022 20:12

i normally go with what the energy company suggest.
they can work it out for me
i go with it.
i dont get into debt and if i do they certainly notice and email me to increase

Bubblebubblebah · 01/09/2022 20:09

YellowStar76 · 01/09/2022 19:48

I have a very hard time deciphering information that revolves around numbers. Like some others have said it's a confidence thing (for me anyway), I just don't believe I have the mental capacity to understand it so I avoid doing it if I can help it. I just pay each month what my supplier suggests my DD should be based on my projected usage.

This is literally me in a nutshell!

At the end of the day you can just think if it like going shopping, because the basic of it can be that simple. If you manage shop for food without spending accidental 5k, you have enough mental capacity for this. Nothing scary.

You know how much what in shop costs when you are buying it all the time, can work out if it's good value and if the shop charged you kind of right at the end.
This is basically the same. You look at the goods just instead of veg and fruit it's kwh of gas and kwh of electric. Does your provider charge good price or do others charge less? You can see (well not now annoyingly) it on comparison sites easily.

You look at you meter to see how much you used, like you would check a fridge when finding out what you need to add to shopping list. That's how you know your usage and if the DD is grossly overestimated or just little bit to cover usage movements. Or if it's underestimated. It can also tell you if your consumption is high or low. So again, if it's high you make decisions to see if you can use less, like you would make decision about what food can you eat less because you are eating a lot and it's costing lots of money. Eg, ease up on steak/tumble dryer 5x a week.

I know this may not be the main analogy, but tldr is the first paragraph. Imagine if so many people refused to go shopping because they don't understand food price etc. That wouldn't happen, yet it is not much more different in needs of mental power.

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 20:05

Eeksteek · 01/09/2022 19:19

It’s worrying. But understandable. So many things are subscription based theses days, and it IS worded and publicised in a way that sounds like the payment is capped.

You don’t have to be stupid to be misled. Especially if you are very used to capped services.

I do totally agree.

I initially was surprised that quite a lot of people don’t understand how this works but, when you do stand back and think about it, it is easy to see where misunderstanding comes from, given the terminology used like ‘fix’ and ‘cap’ and how other subscription services work.

That’s really my point on this thread - you don’t know what you don’t know.

There’s a lot of stuff I know nothing about but I do know how utility bills work - but we have no idea who doesn’t and it could have quite significant repercussions.

And please don’t think I’m being patronising - that really isn’t my intention.

OP posts:
HotStickyMess · 01/09/2022 20:04

Catell · 01/09/2022 19:54

OK, I've seen a lot of people call a lot of people derogatory names over this matter, which is a little unfair. These are unprecedented times for a lot of people regarding the price hikes etc. I've always handled my own bills and whenever I've been on a fixed tariff in the past, that's what I've paid on a monthly basis, regardless of usage and have never accumulated debt as a result. I fixed mine again when all the rumours bout price hikes started a while ago and think I got a good deal up until December 2023 - see attached email I recently got from Scottishpower confirming the details.
If I'm reading these messages correctly, are you now saying I'm wrong to assume I'm going to pay the same amount up until that date and/or I won't have accumulated debt once this deal ends?

No, that’s not how fixed rates work. Your price per kWh is fixed so if you carry on using electricity & gas as you have previously then the cost will stay about the same. However, if you increase usage you will
pay more and if you reduce usage your cost will drop accordingly

RichardMarxisinnocent · 01/09/2022 20:03

Catell · 01/09/2022 19:54

OK, I've seen a lot of people call a lot of people derogatory names over this matter, which is a little unfair. These are unprecedented times for a lot of people regarding the price hikes etc. I've always handled my own bills and whenever I've been on a fixed tariff in the past, that's what I've paid on a monthly basis, regardless of usage and have never accumulated debt as a result. I fixed mine again when all the rumours bout price hikes started a while ago and think I got a good deal up until December 2023 - see attached email I recently got from Scottishpower confirming the details.
If I'm reading these messages correctly, are you now saying I'm wrong to assume I'm going to pay the same amount up until that date and/or I won't have accumulated debt once this deal ends?

As long as your actual usage isn't more than what they estimate you will use (which is how they decide your direct debit) you shouldn't accumulate debt. Your account online should show you some sort of prediction for your actual bill for the next few months and an indication of whether your DD will cover it. You should currently be in credit i.e. have paid more over the summer months than you actually used, as it's this credit which adds to your DD to pay for the higher usage in the winter.

BrownTableMat · 01/09/2022 19:59

MrsLargeEmbodied · 01/09/2022 19:50

i joined that group @Snazzysausage
i was so shocked yesterday that there were so many posts from people who were washing all bedding and curtains before the price rise
or is it me, am i the only one to think that is barmy and unecessary?

I think it’s a very good idea. I’m certainly going to wash all my curtains (they need it and haven’t been done in, cough, some time) before the end of September.

Catell · 01/09/2022 19:57

SpringIntoChaos · 01/09/2022 13:34

Why are you 'worried'? How does other peoples lack of understanding about a subject negatively affect you?

Or...is your 'concern' merely a way to start a post showing off your own 'higher knowledge' on these things?

Yes, some people don't understand how certain things work...but you could instead (if you were genuinely 'worried' 🤦‍♀️) simply explain it, as a concept...you know, supportively!

I bloody hate faux 'worry' posts! Smacks of Mean Girls and Tinkly Laughs 😔

This Grin

Catell · 01/09/2022 19:54

OK, I've seen a lot of people call a lot of people derogatory names over this matter, which is a little unfair. These are unprecedented times for a lot of people regarding the price hikes etc. I've always handled my own bills and whenever I've been on a fixed tariff in the past, that's what I've paid on a monthly basis, regardless of usage and have never accumulated debt as a result. I fixed mine again when all the rumours bout price hikes started a while ago and think I got a good deal up until December 2023 - see attached email I recently got from Scottishpower confirming the details.
If I'm reading these messages correctly, are you now saying I'm wrong to assume I'm going to pay the same amount up until that date and/or I won't have accumulated debt once this deal ends?

To be worried about the number of people who think a ‘fixed’ energy tariff means the monthly price will always be the same - regardless of usage
RichardMarxisinnocent · 01/09/2022 19:53

Crikeyalmighty · 01/09/2022 17:41

I am actually quite shocked if I'm honest at how little some people were paying- !! Even in a 1 bed flat I've seen people saying they were paying £70 dual fuel- seems really low to me- I think that's part of the shock. I was paying £230 before we went abroad for 20 months , now back and paying £280 but a way better insulated house.

I'm in a one bed flat paying a dual fuel DD of £53 a month, which is expected to cover my actual usage pretty much spot on. I'm on a 2 year fixed rate which ends August 2023, so luckily fixed just before prices really started rising. My previous DD on a fixed rate was something like £35 a month.

I'm not sure why you were shocked? A well insulated one bed flat, especially on a upper floor, isn't going to cost huge amounts to heat, if only one person lives there there's likely to be less use of the washing machine/electric shower/lighting/phone and laptop chargers etc, and if the person is also on a cheapish fix their bills can absolutely be pretty low.

GeorgeorRuth · 01/09/2022 19:52

To be honest I'm not particularly good with financial things. Even though I'm firmly middle aged and keep on top of bills I do struggle to understand some of them. I came from a family that didn't discuss 'adult matters' in front of the children. The meter man read meters and you got a bill.
When my own were young we didn't hide anything financial but were on poverty wages so there was little to understand eg, pay rent, pay CT, pay electric ( key meter) etc..what's left buys food if you are lucky.

I think that the jargon used is unnecessary. Although I didn't think it meant fixed DDs, I struggled to understand the bills. It needs to be plain and simple.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 01/09/2022 19:51

and all these posts from people who have had their dd's icnreased already and money taken
are they trolls?

MrsLargeEmbodied · 01/09/2022 19:50

i joined that group @Snazzysausage
i was so shocked yesterday that there were so many posts from people who were washing all bedding and curtains before the price rise
or is it me, am i the only one to think that is barmy and unecessary?

YellowStar76 · 01/09/2022 19:48

I have a very hard time deciphering information that revolves around numbers. Like some others have said it's a confidence thing (for me anyway), I just don't believe I have the mental capacity to understand it so I avoid doing it if I can help it. I just pay each month what my supplier suggests my DD should be based on my projected usage.

This is literally me in a nutshell!

Snazzysausage · 01/09/2022 19:48

Afterfire · 01/09/2022 12:28

Yanbu.

I am on this group - it has 80k members and the amount of daily posts from people who do not understand this is staggering.

www.facebook.com/groups/966754150512356/?ref=sharewww.facebook.com/groups/966754150512356/?ref=share&exp=9594

That's the one I'm in and I agree it's baffling how many people don't know how to work out their energy usage. More than one recently still didn't seem to get that being on a fixed tariff wouldn't protect them from paying more than their current DD if they use more energy.

YellowStar76 · 01/09/2022 19:44

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 19:15

The monthly DD is based on your average prior usage.

It is essentially calculated by

  • Looking at your annual usage
  • Multiplying your annual unit usage by the fixed rates
  • Adding in the daily standing charges
  • Dividing the total by 12 to reach a monthly payment amount

This is why accounts go into credit in the summer months, when your usage is lower than the monthly payment.

But in the winter your actual usage cost will be higher than monthly payment so the account credit balance gets eaten up.

Fixing your unit and standing charge costs only guarantees the cost you pay per unit and the daily standing charge - if you then leave the heating on 24/7 your usage will shoot up and your DD will not be high enough because you are using more units than the DD calculation was based on.

So you’ll go into debt until you either increase your DD or drastically cut your usage.

Hope that makes sense.

Ahh yes I get what you mean thank you OP.

If you’re in debt because your DD isn’t matching your usage (say your using way more energy then what you’re actually paying for) does your energy provider not contact you to let you know?

Sorry for the dumb questions but I’ve always rented and my rent has included bills. I’ve been in my flat for a year now and this is the first time I’ve actually had to pay for gas and electric and I’m just realising that I don’t know so much

Bubblebubblebah · 01/09/2022 19:39

I really hope that if anything comes out of this shitstorm it will be people looking at MSE, citizens advice because and similar website and take more interest in what it is they are paying every month.

BorgQueen · 01/09/2022 19:37

I’ve also seen people who think that, because their fix is at a higher rate than the price cap rates, they will not have to pay more than the price cap rates and are very disgruntled to find out No, they pay whatever their fixed rate is.

I do think however, that fixes shouldn’t be able to charge more than 25% above the cap,
once the cap is known.

NewerCurtains · 01/09/2022 19:26

YANBU. I had this exact discussion at work in our lunch break today and two of my colleagues didn't know. They thought that because they'd 'fixed' their DDs at a certain amount that this basically meant unlimited usage. Robust discussion followed but I'm really glad they now know!

ThankYouSir · 01/09/2022 19:24

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 18:47

But you don’t know who doesn’t know.

Most people don’t really talk about finances, even with friends and family.

True, and of course it's not the sort of thing you just ask someone about.

Like I said I do understand being worried about those you know personally and care about, I kind of went off on a tangent, I appreciate it was not the main point of your post.

I am not that clued up on utility bills, I have a very hard time deciphering information that revolves around numbers. Like some others have said it's a confidence thing (for me anyway), I just don't believe I have the mental capacity to understand it so I avoid doing it if I can help it. I just pay each month what my supplier suggests my DD should be based on my projected usage.

They did put my DD up to £195 per month (for reference I live in a small 1 bedroom house alone and it's all electric, no gas supply), when I looked online at their calculation it actually came out at £155.00 per month so I changed it to that amount instead. I am actually in credit by a bit so hopefully that will help.

If it doesn't I'm building a firepit in the middle of my living room and my landlord will just have to accept it😂

Eeksteek · 01/09/2022 19:19

It’s worrying. But understandable. So many things are subscription based theses days, and it IS worded and publicised in a way that sounds like the payment is capped.

You don’t have to be stupid to be misled. Especially if you are very used to capped services.

Bubblebubblebah · 01/09/2022 19:17

YellowStar76 · 01/09/2022 19:06

Can someone explain in simple terms as I’m sure I’m one of the people who think like this lol.

My DD is the same every month and I even got a £39 month old refund because I paid too much gas??? I never check my account because I don’t know what anything means tbh

That means your DD was ever so slightly overestimating your use (which imho is absolutely correct). You used less than they thought you will.

Butterflyfluff · 01/09/2022 19:15

YellowStar76 · 01/09/2022 19:06

Can someone explain in simple terms as I’m sure I’m one of the people who think like this lol.

My DD is the same every month and I even got a £39 month old refund because I paid too much gas??? I never check my account because I don’t know what anything means tbh

The monthly DD is based on your average prior usage.

It is essentially calculated by

  • Looking at your annual usage
  • Multiplying your annual unit usage by the fixed rates
  • Adding in the daily standing charges
  • Dividing the total by 12 to reach a monthly payment amount

This is why accounts go into credit in the summer months, when your usage is lower than the monthly payment.

But in the winter your actual usage cost will be higher than monthly payment so the account credit balance gets eaten up.

Fixing your unit and standing charge costs only guarantees the cost you pay per unit and the daily standing charge - if you then leave the heating on 24/7 your usage will shoot up and your DD will not be high enough because you are using more units than the DD calculation was based on.

So you’ll go into debt until you either increase your DD or drastically cut your usage.

Hope that makes sense.

OP posts:
YellowStar76 · 01/09/2022 19:06

Can someone explain in simple terms as I’m sure I’m one of the people who think like this lol.

My DD is the same every month and I even got a £39 month old refund because I paid too much gas??? I never check my account because I don’t know what anything means tbh

WavePlant · 01/09/2022 18:56

Oh this in spades!
so many people posting that they won’t accept the recommended rate increase as they won’t pay more, not realising it’s a unit rate increase. I think the government should do an announcement that the price cap is per unit and the amount quoted is a national average for example.

bellac11 · 01/09/2022 18:51

HRTQueen · 01/09/2022 12:51

My mum is finding it all so overwhelming as are people I work with nothing to do with their reading or language abilities it’s how people process information

when you are worried trying to take on more information can be difficult and many are extremely worried

at the moment we are absolutely bombarded with information

I think the sneery comments on here are unkind

Totally agree and also its not even about how people process information necessarily, the information given out in the media and by fuel companies is deliberately misleading, vague and missing information

Its no wonder people dont really understand

People dont even understand their unit costs on here, they post talking about their monthly payment